Our experience at the Vestal Red Lobter was unexpectedly dismally unpleasant. We have gone annually for years to this favorite Red Lobster restaurant in Vestal for birthday celebration lobster, looking forward to it as a special occasion and traveling quite a bit to get there. We usually are very happy in general, with good memories, at this and any other Red Lobster we have visited over the years. Unfortunately, our evening overall at this Vestal Red Lobster was very subpar, disappointing, and overall unpleasant, leading us to wonder if we want to go back to this or any other Red Lobster Restaurant. The problems were continual and numerous. We had to wait about 20 minutes for a table, although when we finally were seated, there were many tables sitting empty. We quickly assessed that this was due to not enough wait staff, and we subsequently waited long periods of time between getting menus, getting drinks, getting appetizers, etc. All the food we received was cold. We had to ask several times for bisquits (which finally came late with the entrees) as well as additional napkins. The very worst part of the evening was my steamed Maine Lobster, which was black and spotted when served, with no redness to the shell. I immediately knew something was wrong and commented right away that I was surprised to have been served this, and that this was not how a healthy lobster should look after steam cooking. The legs and tail were limp, and the interior flesh was mushy with lots of stagnant water inside the shell. I sent the lobster back, and after about 30 minutes received another lobster where the shell was slightly red in spots but still mainly black spotted with mushy flesh. There was lots of off-tasting water inside the shell. I thought maybe the lobster was dead or sick before cooking. The manager tried to tell us several times (insistently) that is the way their Rock lobsters look (although I ordered a Maine lobster and know the difference). My best guess is that the live lobsters at this restaurant suffered from lobster shell disease, which would result in the black spotting, mushy flesh quality, and internal wateriness. Sometimes lobsters in tank with this disease contract other infections that make them sick and eventually die (and can also make people sick eating them). A good restaurant would discard diseased and dead product, not try to serve it, and at top dollar. The restaurant compted the meal for me, but I was struck by the fact that Red Lobster serves diseased food product (and at a premium price), of obvious poor quality, and which may feasibly cause foodborne illness. The management was prepared to explain away the issue with nonsense. We also guessed that the crab was also a lower grade but served at a higher grade premium price. My companion had a mix of crab legs, and found that the meatiest part of the king crab legs were cut off, and there was thread-like think meat inside the remaining legs on his plate. The waitress quickly said that she would get us replacement crab legs, and that the "skinny" legs had been a problem with other customers. The other issues we had seemed pale in comparison, but included lobster bisque that looked and tasted like American cheese soup, and skimpy entree sides with high upcharges. Our waitress was helpful and pleasant, which was the only positive experience we had that night. Red Lobster used to be a wonderful place for a special meal, with good quality food, great service, and good memories. In the past we didn't mind paying a premium price for the experience. Unfortunately Red Lobster has changed for the worst, and not only will we not be returning to this Vestal Red Lobster, we are rethinking going to any other Red Lobster restaurant. read more