We were really excited about booking a whale watching tour outside the busier Victoria area. We specifically chose a more intimate experience in Alert Bay because we thought the secluded setting would make the longer drive from Victoria worthwhile and give us a more up-close experience.
Unfortunately, that wasn't really the case.
Sea Smoke had a friendly, knowledgeable crew, a new and comfortable boat, and the overall process was smooth. Our main criticism was simply how far away we remained from the wildlife.
Other whale-watching boats, tour boats, and even research vessels were consistently much closer to the whales than we were. I completely understand the importance of maintaining a respectful distance from wildlife, but the distance we maintained felt excessive compared with the other vessels operating in the same area. In the end, we spent much of the experience watching the whales through binoculars and even then it was too far.
What was particularly disappointing was that the photos and videos on TripAdvisor, Google, etc. gave the impression of much closer wildlife encounters. That simply wasn't our experience.
We chose Alert Bay specifically because we were willing to make the extra effort for what we hoped would be a more intimate and memorable experience. Had we known beforehand that the viewing would be from such a distance, we likely would have booked elsewhere. Especially since they advertise their new electric motor so much.
I hope Sea Smoke takes this feedback constructively.Everyone (12 people on our boat felt the same) The crew was nice and the boat was excellent unfortunately, for us, the distance from the wildlife made the experience fall short of what we were expecting from a whale-watching tour. read more