This was the largest "small" pizza I have ever seen. The girl that waited on us was so helpful when we told her it was our first time there. The restaurant was clean and very busy. We will be back. read more

The pizza is amazing! The closest thing to New York pizza I have had since moving to Florida.The waitress very attentive the service was perfect. read more

I finally made it to Sky's Pizza Pie! I called in my order for a large 1/2 pepperoni and pineapple and 1/2 beef and onion along with a slice of cheese pizza. The person taking the order was professional, polite, and helpful. I was told it would be about 30 minutes. I showed up, paid, and waited a couple minutes to pick up my fresh and hot pizza! This gave me a chance to glance around the dining room. It seemed clean and comfortable with a good amount of seating for patrons wishing to dine in. As far as the pizza goes... the size is awesome! The price is right! The pizza could definitely use a little more cheese and toppings. It wasn't nearly as satisfying as it would be if it were just a little more cheesy with a little more meat and other toppings. I'm sure we'll be back! This initial experience was certainly worth a return visit. read more

Overall, a great lunch option in Pensacola. It's a self seated time of day. We sat at the bar, were greeted right away, and served quickly. We were in and out in about 20 minutes. The vibes are very laid back and casual making Sky's a great option for groups of all ages. In addition to having daily specials, they also have Happy Hour, Everyday, 1600-1900, offering $4 house wine and discounts on beer. 01-29-2025 read more

See all

Update: We've been coming here for a few years since moving here and it's been our go-to. Lately a few friends have said it seems off. We always try and drop-in when in that area. We went last week and something is def off. Our pizza was over cooked and we also asked for extra cheese which it didn't seem like we got at all. Our friends ordered it last night and they said the same thing! Please bring back the yummy pizza read more

Sky's Pizza Pie - Huge pizza and great price - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

See all

UPDATE: Thank you so much for improving the quality of the toppings. The "ham" has much improved. We still are looking for the blue cheese/Gorgonzola cheese upgrade, however we are thrilled the quality of the ham has improved. We ordered the usual 24 inch Pizza with "Ham & bacon" & we found the ham is much better quality & has a much better flavor. Staff has also improved, now much more efficient & engaging service. There was also a lovely lady running around cracking the whip, keeping things running smoothly. The pizza dough here is light & airy. You can see the air holes in the dough & how light it is. The pizza dough is very thin & light. We love the dough! We still hope to see the real blue cheese/Gorgonzola cheese upgrade & then, we can work on that 5th star. Added to moi Pirate'cola hometown fave restaurant lists, and where are the treasures list. Well Done! Will Return! read more

See all

I love the different size of pies you can get. The crust was extremely thin, which I loved. I'm from Brooklyn so I'm gonna be a little biased the sauce could use some help. But overall, a decent pizza spot read more

This might be the best pizza I've ever had. We live in MS and try to make it to Sky's anytime we are in Pensacola. The pizzas are humongous and delicious. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable. Great place! read more

This place is ok, the crust was kinda soggy, pizza took about 40mins to arrive at out table, sauce had minimal flavor, and the pizza didn't have enough cheese. If you are in Pensacola maybe find somewhere else to get pizza (a frozen pizza would be about the same price and better tasting)... it was a 5/10 average pizza with slow service and low atmosphere (you are given paper plates to eat your pizza on). Also, there isn't a lot of parking. read more

Sky's Pizza Pie - Soggy paper plate after one slice. - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

We had the meatball one topping pizza for the lunch special for Thursday. The crust was crisp and the pizza was delicious. Sky Pizza is always great. Service was good as well. Best pizza on that side of town. read more

Sky's Pizza Pie - Meatball pizza. 1 topping Thursday special. - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

I was so anxious to try the meatball parm- a staple in NYC where I'm from . So Sky pizza has fabulous pizza but this sandwich was awful. The meatballs were 100% tasteless and surprisingly the tomato sauce was very bland, and the provolone cheese, you could barely taste. The sub roll was totally forgettable. Ironically perhaps, Subway meatballs, been eating for years, is 1000% better than thisl Really should have returned it. Disappointed. read more

Restaurant was packed during dinner time so I had high expectations that were definitely met! We ordered a 24in veggie pizza to go and it was enough to feed the entire family for dinner. Very tasty, for sure one of the best pizza places in Pensacola. Seems like it would've been a fun vibe to eat in the restaurant as well! read more

Sky's Pizza Pie - 24in Veggie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

NY style pizza in Pensacola. Beer and pizza. Could the Founding Fathers be happier? New York has fallen. Florida raises the revolutionary flag for pizza! read more

Sky's Pizza Pie - Apparently this is a biblical citation from the book of Cheese, 24:7 - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

I just wanted to try the mac & cheese bites && I paid $10 for this the girl at the front was very nice but this is ridiculous. i tried one of them, it taste good but just the fact that this is all I get for what I paid is a turnoff I won't be buying them again they need to increase the portion or lower the price read more

Sky's Pizza Pie - Mac & cheese bites - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

The pizza was delicious and plentiful, a real good value. The service was spot on,always kept drink full. Avery nice place to eat at that is clean and family friendly. read more

Side salad and pizza were great! Service was quick and friendly. As far as ambiance it's more of a pizza dive bar.

Finally!! After almost three years living here we finally tried and found the BEST Pizza ! I wish every pizza shop would come eat here to find out how to make pizza! Great job!! read more

Sky's Pizza Pie - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

See all

Delicious New York style pizza, one of Pensacola pizza gems Liked the fact the crust was thin crunchy & the slices large and foldable just like a true New York pie, only wish there was more cheese to experience that gooey cheese pull, overall the toppings were plenty & fresh, would recommend trying them out read more

Sky's Pizza Pie - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

See all

Some of the best pizza in town in my opinion. The service is great and the restaurant is a good size with outdoor space too. Decent prices for great food! The fried ravioli is a favorite of ours as well. read more

Greatest NY style pizza around. I would highly recommend. Always have good service. Love the pizza garlic knots and meatball sub.

One of my favorite local pizza places. Great place to meet friends. Servers are always friendly and attentive. read more

See all

Stopped by for the first time on a Friday night for a pickup order. Online ordering was easy. Pick up time was 35 minutes because they were busy. Ordered the 24 inch margherita pizza. It was huge! The chicken portion was perfect! Some restaurants only top with a small portion of protein. Pizza was hot and fresh. Service was great and restaurant was clean. I'll be back to try the lasagna pie. read more

See all

my calzone was cooked to perfection..marinara sauce is smooth and so tasty..i absolutely recomend eating here. pizzas are huge and beer is ice cold..mmmm.love this place!! read more

Sky's Pizza Pie - Grandkids having summer fun and my beautiful husband to be - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

Get the calzone! The veggie one is mind blowing!! Love this place. Staff are really hard working people

Outstanding pizza , we ordered two large pizzas for a small party , very good quality with good value

Great pizza and the best toppings! This is my go-to pizza place in pensacola! And be prepared- they are freakin'hugeeeeee!! *pizza was bigger than the top of my stove!!! read more

SO GOOD!!! The white garlic sauce pizza is THE BEST. The Meat Amore was also very good read more

See all

Absolutely the biggest pizza I have ever seen the taste was awesome and price was great will definitely be back. Service was great. I called before I picked up. The place was packed. read more

Sky's Pizza Pie - Hawaiian pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

Great NY style pizza ! Best in town. Fast, friendly, and cordial staff. Always polite and professional.

We've been here many times when we're in town. Recent visit was not the best. Something has changed regarding the pizza. It was over cooked (slightly burnt crust) and paper thin crust. Now, we did not complain at the time, but it definitely wasn't the pie we were used to getting. We're hoping this was a one off and we will be back....one more chance. read more

Sky's Pizza is my family's FAVORITE pizza joint in all of Pensacola. There's just something about their pizzas that set them above the rest. Our favorite dishes are the fried ravioli, the Queen B, and the Bianca (my absolute favorite). Not only is their food phenomenal, but their service is also always spot on. Our beers were never empty and our server was super kind and helpful. And just to top it all off, the vibes in there are always amazing as well. Every table you see seems like they're having a good time. It really feels like a place that genuinely cares about their guests and their food. We have been back probably a dozen times and I guarantee we will be back a dozen more. read more

New to the area and always hoping we can find pizza similar to "back home." Skys pizza pie didn't disappoint! We ordered a super large (the size of a monster truck wheel!) pepperoni w/ extra cheese for delivery and it arrived super hot and delicious!! If you're into NY style pizza, this may be your new favorite! SO GOOD!! Thankful we're in their delivery zone! read more

Best pizza in Pensacola! Thin pepperoni is amazing. I would give it a 5 star, but it was a flop deduction. I ended up throwing it in my oven to get it a little crispier. Next time I'm asking for extra crispy. read more

Sky's Pizza Pie - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

See all

Great pizza, great service, and fair price! My only complaint is they did not have a desert pizza. If you added a brigadeiro with Nutella pizza, you would be the talk of the town! read more

PHENOMENAL PIZZA!!!! Rarely will I drive more than 10-15 minutes to pick up food but I drive the 30 minutes each way to get Sky's 3-4 times per month!!! Can't wait for the location in Pace to open!!! read more

Best NY pizza we've ever had . But be warned the box will not fit in your fridge . So you must eat it all which is totally doable ! Great place ! And they opened up a pace location too read more

I ordered a take out pizza last night while waiting for the first time in about 3 years. it's not the same sauce and quality ing it once was. Truthfully, it's the worse pizza I've ever had. never going back. read more

The pizza and wings from this place are awesome ! We get it to go all the time,when we go to see our grandchildren in Pace,Florida. They got us started on it. They always have it hot and ready and it's always good. The people are always friendly and helpful. This is a great place to grab some food for your family or friends and have a party at home. Try it !! read more

After a 2 hour appointment we decided on pizza. We were greeted shortly after entering the building and was told to pick a seat any seat so we did. After a few minutes we had to ask if we had a server and the waitress who was asked yelled across restaurant to the lady that should had already checked with us. It turns out the server I had been watching since we sat at table and I had made eye contact with many times finally came to our table waited on us. The garlic balls were just that (balls of bread). Pizza was ok. It took us almost an hour to get our pizza after ordering. Now that's a ridiculous wait. Especially when the place was not busy and all the business was coming from pick up orders. I don't see the big deal about this place. I know the service could improve tremendously. Won't be back to this restaurant. read more

Sky's Pizza Pie - Bianca Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

See all

Service was great. Food was outstanding. One of cleanest and nicest pizzerias I've ever been to. Pizza was the best I've have in the panhandle. Highly recommend. read more