How disappointing. The corned beef was bland and like something from the grocery store. Also had the pastrami, so bland. The fries were so so. Service was good, only reason for 2 stars. Simons deli and restaurant is so much better than here. read more

I ordered a pastrami reuben Regular size should be called under 3 year old all you could taste is the bread but dried out meat Potatoe pancakes were pretty good read more

Mediocre at best. So disappointed in my Reuben sandwich. Today we had a group gathered for a special occasion luncheon. The chat among us was: "We should have gone to Simon's down the street for Reuben's". We won't be returning. Bland, overpriced and woman's bathroom was out of soap. read more

Slyman's Tavern - Independence - Bars Near Me - Independence, Ohio

Friendly service even through the craziness of St Patrick's Day. LOVE their corn beef and now they have gluten free bread!! Not a fan of drinking wine out of a plastic glass but I suspect dishwasher was busy. Of course we'll be back. read more

Slyman's Tavern - Independence - Bars Near Me - Independence, Ohio

Hostess-Good Servers-Great Bartender-Superb Food-INCREDIBLE If you go thru the Cleveland area and don't get some corned beef at Slymans you are doing yourself a disservice! Above anywhere in NY, and any place we have tried, Slymans is much MUCH BETTER!!! I can't explain, but...you will thank me! I challenge anyone to find better. We live in Florida and always save one meal for our corned beef, when we visit up north. Yummers!!! read more

See all

Best corned beef around. Very tender stacked high sandwiches. That is definitely their specialty along with pastramis. The burgers are good. The chicken fingers are average. The fries are ok. They have a good size restaurant to eat in or you can do take out. Service is good and quick. Casual atmosphere. read more

The best corned beef Reubens ever - piled high and delicious. Service was quick and attentive. read more

Met friends for dinner and was pleasantly surprised how large it was inside. Service was great, as was the food. Given I ordered the knife and fork corned beef, I was thinking it would be chunks of corned beef, instead of thin sandwich slices. As can be imagined though, it still was tender and delicious. read more

Food is good. Service is good. Potions are awesome. Pricey, but worth it they don't skimp on portions.

If you are in Cleveland, Slyman's is a must. I was never a corned beef person until a good friend of mine took me there for the first time. After that I was sold. At the location the atmosphere was somewhat low key and seemed to cater to business men & women. Good beer selection and portion sizes we just right. Service was good and quick enough for our shortened schedule. Next up I will likely try the rueben but it's hard not to get the corned beef sandwich. read more

Best sandwiches ever!!! I come into town and have to go in for a sandwich. Great service!

Corned beef sandwich was excellent as usual. The service was great. We will be back!

All these low stars?!?! How in the whole world do you make a bad sandwich? at a deli at that!!!!!! I'm calling out all these restaurants in business with nasty customer service and nasty food. Although the CS here was fine, the food is unnecessarily bad. Like, its only a sandwich. Where can i find a good corn beef/pastrami with melted swiss, thousand island, saurkraut on an everything bagel? Like why haven't a deli came up with that here in cleveland? i have to drive to NY for a good sandwich. WOW. I'm annoyed with Cleveland nasty, lazy food. read more

Loved the sandwich! Quick service and my kids even enjoyed the food and atmosphere. My husband isn't normally a corned beef guy, but loved it! read more

OH 02-2024 Slyman's Tavern in Independence near Cleveland Ohio, Tony and I had dinner. It is located in shopping center near our hotel. We were greeted and seated immediately. The waitress and hostess were both extremely nice. Loved the atmosphere of the restaurant. We were escorted into the second room. Tony and I looked over the menu while she took our drink order of Halk cut Iced Tea with Lemon and PBR in a can. We went with the original Slyman's Corned Beef Light (which means baseball Size vrs regular which is softball size) with kraft, grilled onions and toasted bread! Awesome!!! I also ordered for us to share an order of pierogies and potato pancakes...oh everything was delicious and we shared it all!! The horseradish was fresh! Everything was delicious absolutely highly recommend and would eat here again!!! I wish I lived near by to eat here more often!!! The sides of applesauce was just large enough to tease me!!! read more

See all

I went in for lunch because I had other business in the plaza and I decided to get a Reuben. It arrived VERY quickly, too quickly as a matter of fact. My sandwich had seemingly been assembled from what I would say were "premanufactured" pieces and not really made on a grill as a complete entity. Nothing seemed to be hot. The bread was limp and cool. I know I get better Reubens at other local places and they come out hot and obviously cooked right then and there and the ingredients have a chance to work with each other in the cooking process. This sandwich also had the just faintest wisp of sauerkraut, but not enough to assert a presence. I expected much more for a $22 sandwich. It was overrated, overhyped, and overpriced. I remember getting a $26 omelette at the Peppermill in Las Vegas and I knew they were at least trying to be impressive at that price point. The service was lackluster in both its frequency and attention and my bill was incorrect when it arrived. I'm not sure if I could blame a general disinterest or cognitive insufficiency as the reason for my experience. I've not been to the one on St. Clair, but I don't see a reason to return to the one in Independence. Boy, I miss Corky and Lenny's. read more

This place was mediocre. The service and people were great. The ambience included knats, otherwise it would have been a great sports bar atmosphere. The food: We ordered mushrooms, classic corned beef, fish sandwich, and potatoe pancakes. The corned beef was served cold, then was offered to put it in the microwave. The potatoe pancakes were bland, the most flavor came from the sour cream. On the other hand, the fish sandwich was really good and cooked well. The mushrooms were really good, but was a very small portion. The drinks: I had a peach sangria, which was delicious! This place clearly has a knat problem, which I found to be strange, in the middle of winter. My husband killed two while we were eating. Lo and behold, I go to the ladies room and spotted at least five of them. This was very disheartening. I don't live in the area, however, I definitely would not recommend. read more

See all

Only one room in the restaurant had heat. The other rooms were cold. The outside air temp was 23. The corned beef sandwich which they boast about was flavorless and dry. Portion size was ok. The onion rings were were not worth the money. They were commercially purchased and just warmed up. Service was slow. I've eaten in delis across the country and Slymans doesn't come close others including several in Northeast Ohio. read more

The corned beef on my reuben was like corned beef lunch meat and the sandwich definitely wasn't hot, in fact it came much too quick after ordering, as if it was already made and the meat was definitely on the slimy side. The sandwiches were also not as big as they used to be for the price increase. Total disappointment as we were looking forward to the excellent corned beef Slymans is known for. No issues with the service, our waitress was friendly. Not sure what they did different to the corned beef but we won't be going back. read more

Stopped in to Slyman's on a friend's recommendation while taking a quick daytrip to Cleveland. We didn't realize the original location closed at 2:30pm but thankfully we checked before driving over and then were able to locate the Tavern location which was basically equidistant from where we already were. For our table of two adults and two toddlers we got a pastrami reuben, a corned beef dry, and then fried pickles to share. Everything tasted great and was freshly prepared. The dipping sauce for the pickles had a nice zip to it and the bark on the pastrami had a nice peppering. Our server was friendly and the waits for food were very reasonable. All-in-all a great experience and well worth stopping in for! read more

Slyman's Tavern - Independence - Menu - Bars Near Me - Independence, Ohio

Best Corned Beef Sandwich in the country. Always outstanding. Always. ///:///:////////////::://///////////::://////// read more

Slyman's Tavern - Independence - Corned Beef Sandwich w Swiss - Bars Near Me - Independence, Ohio

It's not fast food, but it is great food. Took 15-20 minutes after I ordered it in-house for my Reuben. read more

Slyman's Tavern - Independence - Reuben - Bars Near Me - Independence, Ohio

I had the opportunity to eat at Slyman's Tavern, Independence, OH restaurant in Independence yesterday. I was completely disappointed. I ordered the Tavern favorite "BLT" the lettuce was one small decrepit piece the tomato was so small you could hardly see it the bacon was perfect but the rye bread was the butt end of the loaf. I complained to the waitress, she apologized and brought me out 2 pieces of grilled rye (on one side only). She did remove 1/2 of the sandwich price but still... Very poor food for being a Tavern favorite. I have pictures. Not happy. Second and last time I'm back unless they can explain how this sandwich made it out of the kitchen. David read more

See all

I don't understand the fascination with this place. The food is incredibly overrated. The corn beef sandwiches were humongous but very very dry and the fries were so bad they shouldn't even serve them. However, the inside is very clean and pretty. They have a nice bar, we had a server name Yvonne, who was great, but the food will never bring me back here. read more

A Cleveland Masterpiece. The best possible sandwich you can get. I went to the Original downtown years ago and this one keeps the name strong. I've dreamt of this for months before coming here. As good as it looks, it's a 1000% better. Everything is full of flavor and tastes stellar. You wouldn't be disappointed with anything you order here though. It's worth the trip to Cleveland! read more

Slyman's Tavern - Independence - Large Cornbeef Sandwich with Pickle and Fries - Bars Near Me - Independence, Ohio

The corned beef was good but not as good as Vienna deli downtown. The side dishes were absolutely bad. Potato salad was beyond bland and fries are frozen crinkle cut. Portions are great and priced accordingly. Not a repeat for me. read more

Came here because of Guy fieri. It's not the original but close enough. We are not local. Got the Reuben balls app..... oh my. Crunchy Reubenesque spheres! Got the corned beef Reuben style...wow! You gotta share it. It's too big for one person. The meat is butter.... Literally melts in your mouth. No knife needed. Meat so good no sauce needed. Yea thousand island kicks it up read more

Slyman's Tavern - Independence - Reuben Poppers Corned Beef Sandwich - Bars Near Me - Independence, Ohio

Was in town at Clinic and met here from local recommendations. The cheese burger was excellent. My friend had corn beef it was excellent as well. Onion rings were amazing. Service excellent. read more

We got the New Yorker version of a Reuben sandwich, which is pastrami and corned beef. Over stuffed and delicious as usual The sliced dill pickle spears were nice and fresh and flavorful, and the sauces were all good although I do not think the spicy sauce that comes with the fried pickle appetizer was spicy at all . You taste a lot of smoke flavor and it's very good but "spicy " definitely not. The ranch dressing that comes with the fried mushroom appetizer, complemented it perfectly . It was balanced and not overly herbal. The hot chocolate was good and came in a normal sized coffee cup, not a fishbowl . If you want a glass of water, you need to ask for one. Prices are reasonable for the quality of food you are getting and the pleasant Tavern ambience. There is a happy hour for four of the different appetizers only where they are five dollars apiece and that is worth considering if you'd like to share different things around the table. The restaurant was clean inside and out and so were the bathrooms. They got really busy shortly after the 5 o'clock crowd started coming in, so we were lucky. We got there around 4:30. No complaints in the server was very attentive. Be aware that half of the seating is that tall barstool with the back kind of thing with the taller table. Fortunately, they have some regular tables that we were able to use as Seniors. That's pretty much a necessity. Same if you have a handicap. They had a cute little valentine's decorated Christmas tree. A comfortable place. I do wish the seats were padded, but except for the back of the bench seats you are out of luck there. read more

See all

Slyman's is great, but come on, the shrinkflation is real. I got a regular hamburger (no cheese) on UberEats and it was $15. I was expecting a big juicy burger at that price, but got something more resembling a slider. Tiniest, saddest burger I've gotten at that price point. The two stars are for flavor. read more

Food is fast and excellent service is excellent the interior is Very inviting wheel chair accessible I ordered in the parking lot my order only took 10 min they will tex you when it's ready read more

See all

Cool hangout spot. Pretzel was super good and so was the mozzarella sticks. Corned beef sandwich was ok. read more

See all

Totally disappointed, the pastrami sandwich was a total waist of 20 bucks! My wife loved her corned beef sandwich and my son liked his New York, fries and mushrooms were mediocre at best. Service was amazing for sure. read more

got the LITE corned beef reuben and, as you can see, it is still plenty of food! The corned beef was less salty than other places/what I am used to, but I didn't mind it! I wish I had taken the time to truly taste the reuben aspects of the sandwich, but I was too busy wolfing it all down! The bread is good, thick, and definitely quality. I try to stick to lower carb foods, but this was worth the carbs! The atmosphere was great too. Our waiter was attentive and the place was packed, which was a good sign. But we were able to get a table immediately. read more

Slyman's Tavern - Independence - LITE corned beef reuben sandwich with horseradish, thousand island dressing, and a dill pickle. - Bars Near Me - Independence, Ohio

Ordered the 1/2 corned beef - sooooo delicious, and loaded fries which had corned beef, cheese sauce, and green onion! Delicious! Also had some fun drinks which were good but I can't remember what they were! They must have been strong! LOL read more

Slyman's Tavern - Independence - Bars Near Me - Independence, Ohio

See all

#Gluten free bread available so that scores points for me. Had the lite corned beef sandwich which was delicious. Served with horseradish, 1000 island dressing and a pickle. Restaurant is very cute and packed. Bar area was hopping. Our waitress was very good and food delivered on time. Would recommend. read more

Let me start this one with "I used to love you." What has happened to this place? I would argue it's never been as good as the flagship downtown, but it has delivered consistently for years...until the last several times. Specifically my last two visits have been epic fails. First off, the beer. WTF, Slymans? Your taps are BAD. Every tap beer we've tried has been Flat. Just a Cardinal Sin for a tavern. And this isn't a day or a week thing, this is Months! Shame on you. And the food? Well, I've already noted the chintzy decision to stop putting Slymans Fries on the Happy Hour selection. We ordered them yesterday at full price ($13.50!) and they were soggy with corned beef that was clearly scraps. My southwest chicken salad was unappealing, with lettuce and toppings that looked and tasted near expiration. Again, Shame. The sandwiches were okay, but they are clearly not worth NY prices (well over 20 bucks). Reubens in particular lack the proper grilling and the melty cheese. Twice in a row we've been seated in the "I don't care" section, way in the back, with zero ambience, despite plenty of room in the main areas. This place has been like a fighter who has been knocked down a lot, and barely stays on its feet. Yesterday was the knockout blow: I will never return. read more

Our waitress was amazing, real perky personality and smiled the whole time. Gave us recommendations as it was our first time and made the kids feel included. However, when I ordered the roast beef I was expecting it to be as good as the reviews stated, I was disappointed with it being dry and flavorless. The wife's tuna melt was above average. read more

I have heard great things about Slyman's, but only got the chance to try their food today. I work in Independence, Ohio, and we ordered an office dinner from Slyman's to eat during a quarterly meeting this evening. I ordered the New Yorker sandwich with swiss cheese on grilled rye. I can honestly say that this was the MOST amazing deli sandwich I've ever had! The sandwich was so thick (literally 4 inches) that I had a problem eating it politely in front of my coworkers. Wow, it was amazing!!! Delivered on time... and plenty of pickles! Highly recommend Slyman's. Can't wait to visit in person! read more

Ordered the corned beef sandwich (American Miss) and it didn't disappoint! So much meat and super lean cuts. Also loved the fried pickles (+ sauce) and potato pancakes (+ apple sauce and sour cream). Service was great, but looked a bit slower for to-go orders and there was an automatic 20% gratuity charge for parties 6+. read more