The original and semi sweet chocolate chip cookies are my favorite!!!! I love how the cookies are consistently the same. The cookies are soft and the frosting is plentiful. The sugar cookies are soft sugar cookies. The chocolate chip cookies have an ample amount of chips in them. read more

See all

Smart cookie makes an amazing cookie. I've been going here since high school and love how they taste so homemade.

Smart cookies are the best cookies anywhere. My family found out about them in 2008. we have been going there since then. We even ordered the mini sugar cookies for my daughter's wedding reception 10 yrs. ago. I sincerely hope that you bring them back. read more

I have been going to smart cookie for years it's the very best cookies!! I am so sad why are you closed?!?! Are you going to reopen a different location? read more

My wife and I come here often to get some of their cookies. Man are they good! My favorite is their chocolate peppermint cookie. I love the added texture of chocolate chips in their chocolate cookie and the peppermint frosting really goes well with the chocolate! My wife loves their classic vanilla (sugar cookie). Sometimes they even do fun designs, like leprechauns and clovers for St. Patrick's!!! Their chocolate chip cookies, toffee cookies, and cookie sandwiches with Leatherby's ice cream in the middle are exceptional as well. They have many great things to choose from; I've always enjoyed the cookies I've bought here! read more

Smart Cookie Company - Two classic vanilla and one peppermint chocolate cookies - Desserts Near Me - American Fork, Utah

Smart Cookie had the best sugar cookies hands down! All of their cookies are amazing! Much better than all the other pop up cookie places around for sure!!! read more

I haven't been here in a while and I was really disappointed. First of all, came in about 7pm on a Saturday night and there were probably 10 cookies to choose from. We bought 4 and they tasted like they were two days old. The cookies were dry and had an old taste to them. I've had day-olds that were better. My husband and I were both surprised because we've never had a cookie here we didn't like. So I'm not sure what the deal is. Maybe trying to cut waste? read more

Well I've heard that this place has good cookies. Tried my first one (chocolate chip) at the Ship & Sip place in American Fork. It was a good cookie. Tonight I was craving for a semi sweet chocolate chip cookie, and since other places don't have semi sweet chocolate chip cookie as part of their regular menu, I decided to come to this location for the first time and try their semi sweet chocolate chip cookie. Maybe it was the time of night we showed up (7:30ish) but I was not impressed with this cookie at all. The dough/cookie part of the cookie looked like a light pale color, with big holes in the texture. It was more crunchy than I'd like, maybe because it's been sitting on the cookie sheet display for a while. There was no appearance or taste of any "gooey-ness" pin the cookie at all, which means it wasn't fresh. We also tried the lemon drop cookie - frosting was way too sweet and overpowering. The M&M cookie, well it was just alright. The milk chocolate toffee was just ok - had better. Yes, each cookie (without frosting topping) was just over a dollar (maybe $1.15 per cookie), which was a pretty good cost for a cookie. But then again, you get what you pay for. They were pretty to look at though! read more

See all

Best cookies around! We've tried all that we can find and always come back to Smart Cookie, just sad the other location closed.

My wife and I snuck in here and grabbed a couple cookies and a shake before our movie. They got the counter was kind enough to give us an extra bag so we could wrap are delicious Red Velvet iced cookie up and stick in my pocket. It was tasty. It was a little harder than I would like, I wondered how delicious is Cookie must be when it's fresh. We also got a cookies and cream shake which was awesome. I love the fact that they put the cookie in the actual shake machine. So the end of your shaky of us pleasant surprise of cookie chunks. We will definitely be back for more read more

Smart Cookie Company - Desserts Near Me - American Fork, Utah

Gross cookies and the store smelled really bad. The ice cream scoops they use to scoop your ice cream we're sitting in a bucket of nasty rancid looking water. I took one bite of the cookie I bought and wouldn't finish it. I preferred my bag of chips ahoy over these. read more

We got ice cream and cookies here one day. It was good. Lots of parking available. The girl working there was very nice and worked and quickly as she could to fulfill our order. read more

Just popped in for 2 sugar cookies. I'm always greeted right away at Smart Cookie. Plenty of cookie varieties. You can even make an ice cream cookie sandwich. I almost always just stick to the delicious sugar cookies! read more

See all

Smart Cookie is a great place for dessert, especially if you're on campus at BYU. Go get it after eating at J Dawg's or Nina's. The ice cream and the cookies are fabulous, and prices are great. They even have shakes and Italian soda. It's a very nice establishment as well. I'm very impressed every time. read more

Just visiting Utah and got a recommendation to try Smart Cookie. Shop was cute and clean. I got 4 non-frosted cookies and 4 frosted cookies. Both were delicious. The chocolate chip walnut is my favorite. Only recommendation to Smart cookie is to make an 8 pack sampler pack where you can get 4 frosted and 4 Non-frosted. This way you can get the best both of worlds and a discounted per cookie rate. read more

Place was empty and dark upon arrival I almost thought it was closed. Prices were fair for ice cream but a little pricey for cookies. Due to Covid there was not a place to sit in or outside. Also they do not have public restrooms. Ice cream was pretty bland I am not sure what brand they carry/sell. We tried a chocolate chip which was soft on the middle crispy on the edges. Chocolate chip cookie with my favorite of all of the things we ordered. We also ordered a almond one, cookie itself was very bland almost just like flour but the frosting was yummy. We were driving through we are not from the area. read more

This place is good, but not amazing. I was hoping for a fresh cookie and got one that had been sitting out. Prior to ordering I asked if they came warm (I've been spoiled by competitors) and was told yes. Then the cookie went onto the microwave. I was disappointed. I also wasn't totally happy with the flavor. It was good, I would go again if someone asked me to, but nothing I'd crave. read more

I've loved this place since my college days around 2005 (can't remember which year they opened). Having recently moved back to Utah, I had to take my young children so they could experience it as well. The service was great, portions of ice cream were HUGE, and overall it was a good experience. The one thing that would have really been nice, would have been an option for a smaller ice cream sandwich, one that a 3 or 5 year old could handle. Since my son and I were getting our own ice cream sandwiches, my two daughters wouldn't settle for JUST ice cream or JUST a cookie. They had to have both, too, and that seemed fair enough. I figured a sugar cookie and a kids ice cream would be perfect for them. Well, the cookies were roughly twice what they could eat in a sitting, and the ice cream was probably three times as much as they could eat. My son and I had an equally difficult time eating the ice cream sandwiches, and had to resort to eating just some of the ice cream and saving the entire cookies for later. I honestly don't think they made them that big at Smart Cookie 10-15 years ago. It's hard to complain about getting TOO much for your money, but I couldn't enjoy the ice cream sandwich the way I wanted to and had to deconstruct it, and we also ended up throwing a lot of ice cream away. It was a tasty treat, but also a little bit of a bummer. Edited to add (in response to the business owner's comment), I took the star away because I'd like to see a smaller portion item at a lower price. Sure, you get great value for what you're getting, but what if my 3 year old wants to choose her own flavors for an ice cream sandwich? She literally couldn't get her mouth around it. A kid size ice cream sandwich for a couple of dollars would be fantastic, and wouldn't leave my younger children feeling left out. I'm also trying to watch my weight, but wanted a few bites without sharing my kids' horrible flavor choices lol. I have a hard time throwing food away, but ended up throwing away about half of my order read more

I love cookies. If you saw me, you would know that I know cookies. I really like these cookies - both frosted and not. However, they are frequently out of cookies. If you offer to wait for more to be made, they just say no. I feel that if you have three hours before closing time, you ought to make up some cookies!!! read more

Fact. You won't find a better sugar cookie in Utah. I've tried a lot and Smart Cookie is BY FAR the best sugar cookie I've ever had. (Don't tell my mom). I don't enjoy chocolate chip or sugar cookies from the other cookie or drink shops. Their toffee? Chocolate chip cookie is fantastic, too. I like that one with pecan? Ice cream. read more

If you want a sugar cookie you'll dream about afterwards, I highly recommend Smart Cookie sugar cookies. They are just so perfect. The thickness, the frosting, and the taste all come together to make the best cookie. In my humble opinion these cookies trump every other cookie I've ever tried. read more

Okay don't get me wrong I love smart cookie. the cookies are usually pretty impressive, but lately the last four or FIVE times I have stopped by they are bare for cookie choices from the day, leaving only maybe 3 or 4 kinds of cookies to pick from and it's only 6 or 7 PM! (This includes the Ice cream too) the ice cream choices are very limited and the last ice cream scoops we got were very freezer burnt. The last concert or complaint I have is the employees, I know that customer service can be stressful and difficult but the last few times the girls are very un-eager to serve the customers, they side eye each other as to see who's "turn" it is to help; when asking when there will be new cookies they just say they aren't baking them at the moment. I don't like to think I am someone who complains but this has been a consistent disappointment. This restaurant seems to be going down hill. read more

5 stars for their frosted sugar cookies. I don't love their other cookies but my husband will get an ice cream sandwich every now and then with them and likes the sandwiches. My daughter got a snickerdoodle and wouldn't eat it. I don't think the unfrosted cookies are great alone. Stick to their sugar cookies :) They're the best sugar cookies I've ever had! read more

We love smart cookie! I purchased a dozen of their flower cookies with vanilla cream cheese frosting and they were absolutely delicious. Such a hit at her birthday party! I cut the cookies in half, because a little goes a long way! They are so rich and so so delicious. I will come here again and again! read more

Smart Cookie Company - Desserts Near Me - American Fork, Utah

I wanted to love this place because of all the raving reviews, but it fell short. The cookies were hard and dry probably some of the worst ones I have had. You could barely bite through them. The ice cream was okay, but nothing crazy. There are so many option around, so unfortunately I will probably not give them another chance. read more

I like the sugar cookie. Really yummy great balance of cookie and frosting. Tried new cookies too. Fun little hard for my liking. I like soft cookies. I would just get the sugar cookie next time read more

Smart Cookie Company - Sugar, peanut butter and white chocolate chip - Desserts Near Me - American Fork, Utah

They make a killer ice cream sandwich here. You choose your two cookies and your ice cream. Their prices are definitely a reflection of their start as a student hangout near BYU: it's less than $3 for a GIGANTIC ice cream sandwich. You can't beat their prices. I'm a sugar cookie fan, and their sugar cookies are above-par. They have a very good selection of cookies with some fun flavors. read more

Doesn't get any better then their sugar cookies. My kids beg for them. read more

I was shocked the first time I came to Smart Cookie. I expected to pay $5 for my ice-cream sandwich treat, but they only charged ~$3! Dryer's ice-cream between two, fresh cookies. Yum! I love the white-chocolate macademia cookies with strawberry ice-cream, and cookies-n-cream ice-cream with fudge-mint cookies. I also love just stopping by to pick up 3 cookies (chocolate fudge, peanut butter, and other) and a chocolate mile for ~$3. I consider it a great bargain for a fatty, pick-me-up. Just a note, these butter- and sugar-infused cookies don't keep for more than a day or two, so don't bother trying to stock up. They're terrible once they sugar and fat starts to separate. read more

I can't even go in this store without buying every kind of cookie here, I seriously try and avoid it but i can't help but go here. Their frosted sugar cookies are thee best sugar cookie! Other favorite include the red velvet, lemon, triple chocolate chip and milk chocolate toffee. read more

Double Chocolate Fudge Cookie with Cool Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream filling; Praise Jesus! Cheap, delicious ice cream treats sent directly from the precious clouds above for all the people in Utah to enjoy. read more

I've only had these cookies brought in. So I haven't been to the shop, my disclaimer. I've had the vanilla and chocolate frosted sugar cookies. Both we equally delicious. The texture is exactly what I love in a sugar cookie, super soft and moist. The frosting was a little too sour cream flavored for my liking and a little thick. So I just wiped it off some and it was then perfect. Make an awesome cookie. Ate it too fast for a picture. read more

I love smart cookie. There cookies are so awesome! I'm not really a sugar cookie fan but I'm a fan of theres. The frosting is what does it for me. I've tried very few other cookies because I like the sugar cookie so much. The other cookies I have tried have been good also. I also love there frozen hot chocolate! So yummy! Only thing is the frozen hot chocolate isn't always consistent. Meaning sometimes it doesn't taste like the time before when I got it. It's usual good though, think only once it had too much chocolate. It is true though there service could use some work. Young girls always working there, sometimes friendly at the counter when your paying but when you first walk in they just stare and no welcome to smart cookie or anything. If I was there manger I would be telling them to greet customers when they come in because looks better. Besides that there service doesn't take away from there excellent cookies! Update: I have to bring smart cookie down a star. Friday night we went in to get cookie, my husband wanted Italian ice and I wanted my frozen hot chocolate. As we were about to order they told me they were out of ice... What? Do they not have a ice maker and it's Friday night and it was the busiest night I've seen it there and they have no ice. read more

I'm proud to say that we made it through just about the entire menu in one visit and left feeling a little sick but it was definitely worth it! The ice cream sandwiches were really soooo delicious! Some of the best ice cream sandwiched between two fresh baked cookies for a great price..I couldn't ask for more. We also ordered a cinnamon frosting sugar cookie which tasted even better than it looked. The frosting was a cream cheese frosting which I loved because it was just the right amount of sweet! After we finished our ice cream sandwiches and cookies, we were feeling crazy and decided to go back and order a root beer float and a frozen hot chocolate. They were both amazing. Honestly this place is a new favorite for me! read more

I went to the one in Salt Lake (or was it Sandy? I don't get Utah's layout), and it's the best, and only, cookie place I've been too. It'd be best even if I went to the others. YOU HAVE to have a chocolate chip toffee cookie! You just do! The only bad thing is their sugar cookies. Great frosting, crappy cookie. read more

I love the chocolate chip and toffee varieties here (perfectly crisp around the edges and soft in the center), but the sugar cookies have too much frosting in my opinion. Even better if you get an ice cream sandwich and the price is pretty reasonable. read more

See all

Cookies are good and ice cream is pretty decent. There is not very much seating so plan on grabbing it to go if there are other people there. read more

Wow their cookies are delicious. I had the frosted cookie and it was amazing. My wife had the cookie ice cream sandwich which was also super yummy. Don't ask them for a cup of coffee tho as they will look down their nose at you. Oh well you gotta push those religious folks every once in while and let them know it's ok to have a cup of coffee with a delicious cookie! Thanks guys read more

I'm a bit of a cookie snob, so every time we head to Utah, I scope out a new bakery to try. This time we were in American Fork for a wedding, so we decided to try Smart Cookie. First of all, the cookies were pretty overpriced. I had read good things about Smart Cookie, so we forked out the money for 8 cookies. We got a mix of frosted and unfrosted (which are cheaper). The vanilla cookies were my favorite. The frosting is very good, but the cookies are nearly raw in the middle. I like my cookies to be baked all the way through, so I couldn't stomach the middle of the cookie. The lemon cookie was very similar. It seems like they underbake the cookies so they will remain soft. The red velvet, on the other hand, was rock hard. We only ate a few bites of that one. Again, the frosting was very good, but it all had a similar theme. I believe they are cream cheese based frostings. The unfrosted cookies were wholly unremarkable. We ordered one mint fudge, and it tainted the rest of the cookies. Everything had a mint taste. The toffee tasted like plain chocolate chip, and we couldn't find any peanut butter flavor in the peanut butter chocolate. We were pretty unimpressed with the unfrosted cookies. Smart Cookie was decent, but not worth the money. We've had better elsewhere in Utah, so we won't be back. read more

We have been wanting to try this place for a few months but haven't made our way here. We walked in on a Saturday at 8:30pm and they were low and out of most of their cookies. We were hoping to get ice cream sandwiches but they had empty cartons in the case and not a lot of selection. It was disappointing because it closes at 11 and they should have product left and stocked, especially because of how slow business was. Bummer. read more