A lovely ice cream shop with tons of options and very happy employees ready to let you taste test as many flavors as you want. I also learned that they are a main source for other ice cream shops and businesses around Indiana. If you enjoy lemon flavored desserts and chocolate, definitely try LemOreo! Unfortunately for those with allergies, they are NOT an allergen-free facility. read more

Sundae's Ice Cream & Coffee - Inside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

4.9.26 staff pleasant as always! Thurs night, weather getting warmer, perfect night for ice cream. They were fairly busy but not as packed as I've seen it. Tonight I had a taste of the honey lavendar (delicious and tempting!) Bunt I went for a baby cone of stickey chocolate. And hubs had a double cup of mint chocolate chip. #yum #ReviewsByRL read more

Sundae's Ice Cream & Coffee - 4.9.26 stickey chocolate #yum #ReviewsByRL - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Yes!!! What a remarkable surprise!!! Drove by that strip mall several times then I was looking for a special homemade sorbet!!! they answer all your questions help you know what ingredients are in their homemade products very transparent company. The store was very simple clean you came to get what you wanted and it was very open concept! All homemade ice cream creams, and sorbet!! well worth your trip read more

If you're looking for the perfect Friday night ice cream spot--this is it! I had a single scoop of the Black Raspberry Cheesecake and it was bursting with flavor. My husband opted for the same flavor but in a milkshake, and it did not disappoint. Since moving to the area, we've been on the lookout for a go-to homemade ice cream shop, and I think we've officially found it! It was busy (as expected on a Friday night), but the line moved quickly and the staff was friendly and efficient. Great atmosphere, amazing ice cream--absolutely no complaints! read more

Sundae's Ice Cream & Coffee - Black Raspberry Cheesecake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Stopped by randomly but wasn't disappointed. The young ladies greeted us when we entered and were attentive. I was shocked to see they also had coffee/roaster. I only tried and purchased a kids sized cup as I was about to get on the road. Turkish Coffee and it was AMAZING!! Will stop back in next time I'm in the area. read more

Sundae's Ice Cream & Coffee - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

If you see my previous reviews, then you know, I'm a big fan of Handels Ice Cream. I love the flavors and the consistency of the product. But now I have a new favorite in town. Sundays is amazing! The flavors are unique and they have a fresh, flavorful and deliciously smooth texture. Everything they make is made in house from their ice cream to their coffee beans, which are roasted on site. They have free samples so I would encourage you to go in and sample some of the options they have. If you're like me, then a couple of samples in and you'll be ready to enjoy the amazing flavors they offer. Only ice cream didn't make you use up a bunch of calories for the day, I could see myself eating here every day of the week. read more

Sundae's Ice Cream & Coffee - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Oooooooo I had the graham central station ice cream scoop. It was amazing. Creamy, flavorful, just the right amount of graham cracker. I'll definitely go back and try another flavor. The store was clean, and servers were friendly. You can ask for samples. read more

Sundae's Ice Cream & Coffee - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We had the pleasure of having Sundays ice cream today and it was the best cream I could ever have. We had Vanilla. The service was great everyone was friendly. It's cute inside and has a bench outside for when it gets warmer. I would highly recommend! read more

Sundae's Ice Cream & Coffee - Made this with my vanilla - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Hands down best ice cream in Indy that I've had so far. And bonus it's super close to my house. Their sundaes are so big and you get so many toppings. I try to get everyone hooked on it when they come to my house. I'm like "hey have you been to sundaes? I love the black raspberry cheesecake flavor and so does my daughter. We took her there to get ice cream for my birthday when she was just a week old. Love this spot. Services typically pretty quick and the smell of the place is fantastic. read more

They have SO many flavors to choose from. Youcan see them making ice cream in the back. There's an area to sit inside.

I've been going to Sundae's since I was a kid, and it's still one of my favorite spots! Graham Central Station and Wild Mountain Blackberry are my go to flavors. A must try!! However, they have over 30 ice cream flavors and post the list on their IG story daily. I also love the family owned atmosphere here-- it's super warm and inviting, and you can tell they really care about their staff and customers. If you're looking for amazing ice cream and a great neighborhood vibe, Sundae's is the place! read more

Great ice cream and coffee beans! Friendly service. Wish you made more Espresso Chip and mocha almond fudge ice cream though!

My favorite ice cream shop! Love most flavors I've tried, but they change often. The people who work there are friendly and will let you try before you decide. We have enjoyed the banana cream pie, French silk pie, graham central station, raspberry cheesecake, blackberry cheesecake and blue moon flavors. Most people don't know that a lot of fancy restaurants in Indy actually serve sundae's ice cream. Great little shop. Highly recommend! read more

This is one of our newly found favorite places! Love that it is locally owned with awesome and ever changing flavor rotations. The service is always friendly and fast. My husband and I really like their 1-scoop sundae options. read more

This is by far the best ice cream place in the area! Highly recommend the smores cup, it is huge and super delicious! If you like ice cream you will love this place, feels like home when you get inside read more

Sundae's Ice Cream & Coffee - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The ice cream was fine. I was hoping for something a little bit better since they make the ice cream on-site. The ice cream brownie sundae seemed a little expensive at $8 (2 scoops of ice cream, a warm brownie and whipped cream). The staff was A+. They were terrific. read more

Absolutely the best ice cream in Central Indiana! Plus, owners truly care about their customers, staff and ingredient quality when making product. I would encourage anyone that appreciates " dialed in " ice cream recipes to make the drive. Personally, it's 51 miles round trip for us and totally worth the road trip! read more

I am a big ice cream fan...like since before I was born ice cream fan...my mom...who doesn't like ice cream ... would crave ice cream when she was pregnant with me...so, I think that says something-lol! Environment When you walk in, you are greeted with the mixture of ice cream smells and coffee smells...the aroma is wonderful! Beyond the smells...there is the traditional setup of coolers that contains various flavors of ice cream...a menu board written in chalk...a few pictures to show what their unique sundaes are .... I recommend their Reese's mountain...it is sooooooo good! Then, you see bags of various coffee blends. One other thing is that there isn't seating inside (this saddens me...but, still worth coming to get their homemade ice cream!! Food My two favorites are the Reese's mountain sundae AND the milkshake made with chocolate peanut butter brownie ice cream... If you don't know what you want...they will let you sample the ones that catch your intrigue the most! Staff and service Every staff member we have encountered is always super patient while we drool over the various flavors to make sure we select the ones we really want...and they do it with a pleasant disposition! So...if you want to supper local and enjoy ice cream...go!!! read more

Sundae's Ice Cream & Coffee - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This is probably my favorite place to get ice cream - their flavors are the best! The service is always great - they let you try as many samples as you would like! Current favorite is the Cookie Monster flavor, but I love classic butter pecan as well! read more

We Love Sundaes! We have been going here for over 20 years and they have always been wonderful.

Stopped by on a whim and wasn't disappointed. The young ladies greeted us warmly and were very attentive. I was surprised to see they also roast coffee! I grabbed a kid-sized Turkish coffee since I was heading out, and it was amazing! I'll definitely stop by again next time I'm in the area. read more

My daughter and grandkids favorite neighborhood ice cream shop. I went once with them and it was yummy! read more

The Graham Central Station ice cream flavor was phenomenal. I could eat 100 pounds of it. I like it a lot. Awesome people too. Chase served me ice cream and he was awesome. read more

Sundaes is the #1 ice cream place in the Indy area! Nobody beats them. Their workers are always so nice and friendly. You never have to wait very long either. All of their ice cream is amazing but the lemon oreo is the best! read more

Sundae's Ice Cream & Coffee - Caramel cinnamon toast crunch - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Best damn ice cream & sorbet in Indy. I'm a little embarrassed by how often we're here. The sundaes are great, the ice cream flavors are original and unique and their sorbets are fresh & interesting. Check their Insta for daily flavors! read more

Sundae's Ice Cream & Coffee - Daily Menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Once again The BooBesties FunDay Terrific think about IT Taco Tuesday DateDay ends with Ice Cream!!! Very YummyLicious!!! read more

Sundae's Ice Cream & Coffee - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Sundae's ice cream is a staple in our house hold! All year, every season, any reason, I'm going to Sundae's!!!! Their flavor selection is expansive! You can get regular chocolate or vanilla, all the way to inventions like cereal ice cream or cotton candy! There are also yogurt options! I always go for the graham central station. It's a vanilla base with this amazing creation of cinnamon-sugar/graham cracker/chocolate goodness woven in. If you've never had this, get it! They have an assortment of brownie sundaes and shakes as well. And if you're a coffee drinker, check out their huge wall of coffee with dozens of choices from across the globe! read more

Sundae's Ice Cream & Coffee - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This was incredible. I went on a date and immediately fell in love... with the ice cream. Sundae's will remind you of any local ice cream place - full of nostalgia and charm, they deliver on quality and service. I got the fruity pebble sundae and sampled a few of their ice cream flavors, all of which were delicious! Their ice cream is very soft, creamy, and fluffy, which sets it apart from the dense ice cream you might typically get at a bad shop. 10/10 recommend! read more

Sundae's Ice Cream & Coffee - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Best ice cream in Indy without a doubt!! Always love to bring friends from out of town and it's a hit every time!

Great ice fresh. Always fresh. Wonderful personnel. Clean areas.Nice inside and outside seating.

Best ice cream in Indy. Service is always fast and friendly. Theirs Sundaes are the best, they do not skimp on the fudge or Carmel toppings.

I came here during COVID. They place is setup to get you in safely, let you order and then you gotta leave. The ice cream flavors are all clearly marked (there are a lot of flavors). I had Turkish coffee - the absolute best coffee ice cream ever! I also tried (from my kids) mint chocolate chip and cookies and cream. All the textures were melt in your mouth without any ice crystals (no icy ice cream here). I went back later and ordered gallons... they are gone... I will be back. read more

Two words Graham Central!! That is one of my favs I was so excited to se that they had it. They were very patient and let me try a lot of different flavor. I will definitely be back when I am in the area read more

Amazing! Prices beat a lot of the others. Service was exceptional. We did come in the later part of the evening so understandably (we are tired too) Got a Reese's sundae it was outstanding. Partner got a double scoop of butter pecan. He said it's by far the best he's had! Will absolutely be back. Building was extremely clean and it's very cute for the building! read more

This is Indy best ice cream shop by far. The workers are always good and you get your ice cream very fast. It also has items of history that you can look at while you're in the line. read more

So I just learned about Sundae's - I know, I'm super late! But I was at Livery and one of the desserts came with a scoop of Graham Central Station. It was so good we had to know where it came from So today was the day we visited Sundae's and I got my first scoop of Graham Central Station and I regretted not getting a double! Even better than I remember. They have tons of other amazing flavors- we also tried macadamia nut and it was delicious (9/10 for my husband). Looks like they have an awesome coffee bar if you want that! We'll be back next time we're on this side of town. read more

See all

You cannot go wrong with this ice cream shop. It's been around for years and there are no bad flavors. Everything is good from the Coffee to the Graham central station. This is one of the few places I will venture outside of my normal flavor profile to try something new! read more

Sundae's Ice Cream & Coffee - It doesn't photograph so well in a cup but this is the Cookie Monster and Black raspberry cheesecake. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Everyone & Everything was absolutely a great come again experience. Building's display scenery was ten times vibe expectations & while staff's attitude was very appreciating during it. Ice cream & food services are top tier quality & expectations. read more

It was a beautiful day in Indy and the warmest it has been since mid-November. So, with the sun shining brightly I decided to head out for some ice cream after my work day ended. I also decided it was a great chance to snag my Yelp review for the day as I continue my quest to write at least one Yelp review every day of 2021. Sundae's Ice Cream & Coffee is a strip center ice cream and coffee joint that has been around the Northside of Indy since 1995. Winner of several awards for best local ice cream, Sundae's offers homemade craft ice cream and coffee roasting. Located at the Southern tip of Geist, it's ideally situated to attract the Geist/Northside residential crowd. Sundae's actually provides their ice cream to restaurants throughout the Midwest, a sure sign that they're ice cream is the real deal. They offer quite a few flavors - they have 32 rotating flavors. They also have seasonal flavors, sorbets, and yogurts. With coffee, they have non-flavored and flavored options and it looked like you could buy most of them either by the half-pound or pound with prices quite reasonable. They are taking the pandemic seriously (Thank you!) - masks are required, social distancing is expected and they have a line beautifully organized. It might take just a wee bit more time, but it keeps folks safe. The employees are super friendly and helpful. Right now, they've removed their tables - there are two benches in front of the store that allow for eating on-site or outside. It didn't seem like folks cared because business was definitely fairly brisk. I ordered a "single" cup of cookies n' cream in a cup. You can get a child's size or a double. I found the pricing surprisingly reasonable as I paid just a bit over $3. The ice cream was delicious and the cookies were both bits and some actual chunks. it was quite nice. I'd contemplated getting some coffee to go, but decided I would save that for another visit. It's obviously hard to get the full flavor of a place like Sundae's when you're getting it to go, but the prices are good, the ice cream is awesome, and the employees are warm and hospitable. The process for serving works well and the line moved briskly. I'll definitely return as it's actually not far from my home. I look forward to a day, hopefully in the near future, when we can all relax inside again and life gains some semblance of normalcy. Until then, I'll support local and be grateful for those who continue to serve up quality products, great customer service, and who take the pandemic seriously without losing their flair! read more

We came right before a long line formed so I guess that's a great sign that this place is popular! My only negative thing during the pandemic is that there are marked spots to stand/wait and it was hard to view all the options they have on their menu because of how the line was formed. With that said, we all just got ice cream and nothing fancy. I ordered a scoop of banana cream pie and chocolate peanut butter brownie and it was phenomenal. From the quick glance I got of the menu, they have a lot of fun stuff like floats, sundaes, and milkshakes. Can't wait to come back and try some more stuff out when things are normal again. read more

See all