The ambiance of this restaurant is so sexy and classy, without being pretentious. The service was immaculate, I came around 7pm on a Thursday. The food is to die for, I tried the Suprema Burger it was decadent, and flavorful all while still being light. It comes with brussel sprouts instead of French fries. I loved it, I would come back again read more

See all

Good village staple . Packed spot w nyc crowds you'd expect. Nice people watching and all the young and recent college grads. Nice open kitchen design. Dark and Italian accents. Food was good. Burger is a really good one ! Super solid and worth the try. Caesar salad a base hit. Mushroom flatbread was good too. Make reservations it gets really packed . Service from hostesses to servers is rushed. They clearly want to get you in and out . read more

See all

Incredible service! We had a charcuterie board, mushroom pasta, pistachio pesto pasta and beef tips. Kind of loud. We had 3 really great desserts, crème brûlée, pistachio cake -& tiramisu. yummy read more

We have lots of fond memories of the space when it was a popular jazz club Sweet Basil. For years we've driven by and wondered about the food. We finally made a reservation on Halloween and were seated in the window where we had a perfect view of some pretty clever costumes. The space feels completely different and much larger than before. There's an entrance on Bleeker street, a pizza oven and bathrooms downstairs. About the food- we started with cocktails, ordered bone marrow topped with steak tartare, we ordered braised octopus and the veal chop. Service was great and so was the food. People rave about their burgers and pasta - we'll have to return and try them. read more

See all

I saw the Short Rib Fettuccine while I was browsing Restaurant Week menus maybe a year ago and have had this restaurant on my list ever since. It was a bit of the letdown. The short rib was perfectly cooked and flavorful, but the pasta was plain and unflavored. Mixing in the short rib didn't do much for the flavor. The staff was attentive, especially when the rain started pouring. They acted promptly to keep the rain out of the restaurant. The restaurant was loud, but that wasn't necessarily a bad thing. It was a vibe when our section of the restaurant started singing to the music. read more

Suprema Provisions - Short Rib Fettuccine - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Came for date night with my wife one Friday evening. Very good and love the pastas. Tough to get a seat so need to make a res in advance. Service was very kinda. Would certainly come back for the cacio e pepe! read more

Suprema Provisions - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Went for the NYC summer restaurant week dinner for $45. Had a really good lobster pasta and tiramisu. What was weird, was that on a hot day they kept the doors and windows opened and couldn't keep the restaurant cool. Of course, they had to close doors/windows later on. D'uh read more

Suprema Provisions - Interior - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

My best friend and I decided to catch up over dinner at Suprema Provisions, and it was definitely a great choice for a Friday night. From the moment I arrived, the atmosphere was welcoming. I got there a little early and took a seat at the bar, where I enjoyed a delicious sunflower-powered drink, which was very refreshing and delish and not strong with liquor. The bartender was super courteous and attentive, checking in to make sure I was comfortable and if I needed anything. Once my friend arrived and we were seated, our waitress continued the excellent service. She was incredibly attentive, providing recommendations and helping us navigate the menu. She gave us a great rundown of what was popular and what she personally enjoyed, which really helped us decide on our meal. We started with a cheese board--because who doesn't love a good cheese board for a chat? It was a perfect choice. The atmosphere was chill at first but quickly became lively as the night went on. This spot is definitely a happening place on West 4th, surrounded by tons of dining options. People were constantly walking by and deciding to come in, which says a lot about its popularity. Overall, I highly recommend Suprema Provisions--the food is tasty, the service is excellent, and the vibe is just right. Whether you're catching up with a friend or just looking for a great meal in the area, it's definitely worth a visit! read more

See all

The tuna tartare got so much lemon juice its started cooking the tuna? Literally sour gummies as this point. And the chips that comes with is regular store bought chips? Also got the burger with the side of brussels sprouts. The brussels sprouts r so chewy not in a good way. The roasted beet was good, would recommend that. The service is really good. Very friendly staff read more

Outdoor seating was a major vibe in the summer. Great people watching walking on the sidewalk in the heart of west village. The owner was really sweet and attentive to us during restaurant week. A really good dog says hi to the restaurant a lot. The cacio e Pepe was hollow noodles which was interesting. The flavor was good. The shrimp was fine. The burger was also okay. Not as amazing as I expected. The tiramisu was and panacotta were good but average. Nothing really stood out here other than the service and ambiance. Inside was pretty big too and spacious. read more

See all

The short rib pasta did not disappoint!! The truffle deviled eggs were great also. Service was pretty good, they were sure to get me out in time to make it to the show I was headed to. read more

Suprema Provisions - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Some of the best espresso martinis in NYC. Good for group (lots to share) or solo. Staff is helpful. Can get a bit loud at night but comes with evening dining territory read more

Honestly overpriced. The food was good. The drinks are good. But you can't substitute or take things away from your order which is weird? I asked for penne vodka with chicken and the waitress replied "we don't do that." Ok. Anyway the drinks are $17-$20 each. It's good but def overpriced. The other restaurants around here are packed with long waits and this was the only empty one. I can understand why. read more

Suprema Provisions - Cesar salad - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

My friend and I split a pasta and salad - a perfect amount of food to not feel overly full! We also got the truffled devil eggs - came with 1.5 eggs. Sooo delish! The staff was also very nice and quick to pour wine, assist. Dim lighting for a moody NYC spot. Will definitely be going back to try the suprema burger and short rib fettuccine!! read more

Suprema Provisions - Burrata Carbonara and Suprema Caesar - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

My co-workers and I came here for dinner on a Thursday. the place itself isn't super big, I do recommend making a reservation in a advance because it did get pretty busy throughout the night. They do have a bar area inside with seating throughout the whole place. It was pretty dark in there. The service was amazing - all the staff was super attentive and accomondating. The menu itself was pretty large - I definitely think that you can find something for everyone. We decided to get a bunch of items to share since there was so many of us: -Cheeseboard: pretty good, you really cannot go wrong and the brie was so soft and delicious -truffle deviled egg: it was not bad but nothing special would pass on this -ricotta crostini: absolutely delicious. Mildly sweet and so creamy - highly recommend -Tuna Tartare Ciotola: Not a huge fan of tuna tartare so this was just MID to me; would also pass on this -Mushroom Crostini: Also delicious I think I liked the ricotta one more but this was equally as good -Short Rib Fettuccine: I think this was my favorite pasta dish - the noodles were cooked to perfection and the flavors were so good -Seafood Pasta: Pass on this; the mussels had sand in them and there was way too much seafood in this dish (if you love seafood you would probs like this more than I did) -Braised Octopus: Also not a huge fan - would pass on this as well Overall - some of the dishes were hit or miss but the ones that were good, were really good but the other ones were very meh in my books. But A+ for the service here. read more

We passed this place walking by and decided to try this for dinner. Glad we did! Service was very attentive and friendly. Had great conversations with several staff members. Great apps and wine. Loved our charcuterie board. The food was delicious and the dessert was fantastic. Loved the vibe and ambience! read more

See all

Burger was probably one of the best burgers I've ever had! Tuna tartar was also delicious as well as the cocktails read more

See all

The salumi and cheese plate was nice, but the rest of the dishes were average, over salted. The black polenta "puck" with the octopus was unappetizing. The music was so loud (and bad) it was hard to talk. Service was indifferent. And, it was pretty expensive. I don't be back, sorry. read more

Suprema Provisions - Salumi & Formaggi - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Lucky enough to try this place for the first time during restaurant week in NYC. The prefixed menu offered a three course assortment with with is three choices for appetizers, main courses, and desserts. Our party of four selected of variety so we could all try as many as possible. There wasn't a single option that we did not love. Appetizers included Truffle, deviled eggs, Cristini with whipped ricotta, honey, and toasted nuts, and a grilled artichoke. Service was amazing, and we were constantly approached for added water, asking about more cocktails and questioned on if we were satisfied with the food. For the main courses, there were five options we were able to try four of them, including, cace e pepe , a wonderful fettuccine with braised short ribs, a burrata pasta with pancetta, and an amazing grilled sirloin burger with a toasted brioche bun. read more

See all

Place is so vibey, and when i got there at 7.30ish it wasnt that crowded, love sort of having my own space and not packed like a sarden. East river rickey cocktail was soo refreshing, and the special menu Clam was yesss! I will come back! read more

What a pleasant surprise. I did not have reservations. It was a last-minute decision to eat there and what a good decision it was. The atmosphere was outstanding. The food was great and the service was exceptional. The menu is somewhat limited, but the three of us that ate there were all exceptionally pleased with what we got and we all got different things. read more

Host was rude and denied us a table when place was not full and said we needed reservation, did the reservation in front of her and was force to give me a table for the exact time we came in. Only came in for the burger and it came out with barely any seasoning. Place looked nice. read more

Suprema Provisions - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Could've been so much better. In walking in and seeing the food at other tables, thought it would be amazing. The beef tartare on bone marrow was very tasty - a must honestly. My burger wasn't bad but both the burger and Brussels sprouts lacked flavour and the size was too small. The burger had too much cheese to the point it was on the table and Brussels sprouts were over-charred. Fries were great. Service was friendly. Ambiance had a great buzz. Bathroom wasn't clean. This restaurant had potential but needs more generous portions and stronger flavours. read more

Suprema Provisions - The Suprema Burger - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

I came here for Winter Restaurant Week 2023 with my partner, so I got to try a lot of the different menu items! The vibe inside is nice but the chairs aren't haha. Ricotta crostini: 9/10 These were delicious! I got the nuts on the side. The whipped ricotta was so fluffy and creamy. I loved the hint of truffle, the sweetness of the honey, and the extra earthiness from the mint. Such a great combination! My only qualm was there could have been one more piece of bread with the same amount of ricotta because the portion of ricotta largely outweighed the bread. Artichokes: 8/10 The flavor of these is very unique. They only give you three. To me they tasted a bit too oily, but they were still good. Uni carbonara: 5/10 I was SO disappointed in this dish. This was one of my soul reasons for wanting to come here and the uni was not present. The carbonara was way too cheesy I couldn't even finish it it was so dense. There was no umami flavor whatsoever that should come from having uni. Completely a mislabeling of a dish so they can charge more. The carbonara again was fine but too heavy. Short rib fettuccine: 9/10 Yum! Definitely a great dish! I wish there was more fettuccine because I loved it with the short rib sauce. The short rib falls off the bone and super soft, juicy, and flavorful! Tiramisu: 8/10 The tiramisu serving is a good size and it's very good! A little too moist with some of the cake layers but overall very decent tiramisu. Chocolate olive oil cake: 8/10 Very interesting tidbit but they add savory creme fraise on top of the cake and it does not taste good. It honestly is weird to have with the sweet cake and then the salt crystals. The cake itself was good and moist. Very chocolatey too! Overall I really enjoyed my time at Suprema. It's a nice vibe and the food is good and pretty reasonably priced. I thought the restaurant week deal was great! I highly recommend coming here for that. The food comes out so quickly too! read more

See all

Penne Rosa, with gluten free pasta, sauce is a perfect blend of spicy and sweet. Delicious. I recommend it! read more

Suprema Provisions - Penne Rosa, gluten free pasta! Perfect blend of sweet and spicy - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Went here for restaurant week with two of my girlfriends. Busy restaurant. Lots of different options - from pastas to burgers to tuna tartar - something for everyone. I went with the Cesar salad for app, suprema burger for my main and chocolate olive oil cake for dessert. Cesar salad was nothing special, the suprema burger was solid - nice and juicy with a fondue-like cheese and some crispy Brussels were a nice lighter side than classic French fries. Chocolate olive oil cake was really good. My friends got the tuna tartar which they said was good but thought the apples were a weird touch. Overall, good vibe & solid food read more

See all

Great bar for chilling and gathering with some friends. Really reasonable prices, and the service was great

I had planned to try the burger on a friend's recommendation. When I got to the restaurant it wasn't busy at all and there were over half the tables available at 9PM. The hostess wouldn't seat me until my friend arrived which was strange considering how slow it was on a Tuesday night. I decide to run to the restroom to wash my hands and kill a few minutes but was told by the hostess I couldn't use the restroom until I was seated. But I couldn't be seated without my party. I said that's absurd and she responded she doesn't make the rules and I said that's ridiculous and left. If a restaurant doesn't value its customers I won't give them my money. I would love to have tried the burger but I couldn't get past the poor treatment. read more

Excellent spot in the West Village. I absolutely love the space and the relaxed vibe. I came here for a vendor dinner and was impressed with the whole experience. Service was exceptional and our server provided great recommendations. I ordered an espresso martini, old fashioned. and shared some appetizers with my guests. I tried the ricotta crostini and truffle deviled eggs. The crostini had a nice contrast of textures between the crunchy hazelnuts the creamy ricotta. The truffle honey was subtle and a nice touch. The truffle devilled eggs was light and had a perfect hint of truffle. I ordered the meatballs & bone marrow for my main course. The serving portion was decent and nicely plated and served with a plate of crostini. The meatballs were tender and the bone marrow added to the decadence. The marinara was delicious and I wish I had more bread to soak up the sauce. What a fantastic dinner experience. Definitely coming back to try their pastas. read more

See all

Went here for restaurant week 2024 and was very impressed. The deal included an appetizer, entree and dessert. Ended up getting the artichokes, burger and crème brûlée. Absolutely delicious and great service! read more

See all

Food wasn't good, service was ok, 4 meals way too pricey. . I wouldn't recommend. Maybe to come in from the cold but that's it.

I'm not big on Restaurant Week (AKA Culinary Choose Your Adventure), but a friend wanted to try Suprema, and I'm a sucker for being told what to do. Our experience started weird. Really weird. A junkie at the table next to us was having it out with the staff. The NYPD came and sort of took him away, but as our table was next to the open al fresco windows, it was really just two feet behind those of who were seated by the windows. Then it took 20+ min for an ambulance arrive, but they still didn't really take him away, and he was STILL two feet away from us... Yeah. One table change and 4 cocktails later, we were feeling better. Or drunker. Or both? And able to focus on the food itself. Standout items were the much hyped Suprema Burger, the Ricotta Crostini and the Burrata di Bufala. Less impressive than my first attempt at tap dancing were the flavorless Mushroom Pasta and the dry-as-cardboard Olive Oil Cake. The Crème Brulée was okay, but you don't come to an Italian restaurant for that, do you? Ethanol-wise, you're best served getting the Ananas for something strong and tropical, La Pasion if you crave smokey mezcal, or the frozen Paloma if you're melting from heat. The decor was cute, I think, but it was hard to tell because the lighting was so dark and I was facing the al fresco windows, so I was basically blinded by the lights (cue Weeknd riff). They should turn the lights on more or shutter the windows. Dark candle lighting + summer sunshine do not mix. read more

See all

Great spot for food and vibes! Started with the fallen leaves cocktail and a spagliato Negroni -- server highly recommended the spagliato based on the "famous tik tok." Both drinks were good but the fallen leaves was my fav. I hate dry burgers and this one was super juicy. The brussel sprouts were so good as well. The short rib fettuccine was good overall -- short rib was delicious as it fell off the bone but the actual pasta was only okay. Loved how it was on the corner of bleeker in WV! read more

Suprema Provisions - The Suprema Burger & Short Rib Fettuccine - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

That burger is everything they say it is. Only complaint is that I could eat another! A bit on the small side. But so good. juicy and the melted drippy sauciness. COME ON. bravo. worth the trip i made to seek it out. read more

The food was just okay and the service wasn't the best. We came here to try their restaurant week menu and it was quite underwhelming. I ordered the burrata, burger and tiramisu on their restaurant week menu and I think the best thing was the burrata. The burger was good but nothing special and the tiramisu was not sweet...I typically don't like my dessert so sweet but this barely had any sugar in it. Overall wouldn't recommend for restaurant week but maybe for their regular menu. read more

See all

This is one of the best meals I've had in all of my trips to NY and it's not even one of those crazy hyped up spots as far as I know. The vibe is rustic and lively and service is on point. We ordered a few rounds of cocktails with which you can't go wrong and went a little wild ordering a bunch of items for the table. I would call the menu modern Italian. We started out with the Ricotta Crostini, Salumi & Formaggi Board and Suprema House Salad, all excellent choices. The salad is nice and light and I recommend ordering it because a lot of the menu is on the heavier side. I believe they've won awards for their Suprema Burger made with short rib, brisket, iberico jamon bacon jam, black garlic sauce, aged cheddar and roasted tomatoes. My mouth is watering just from that description and it did not disappoint. We also ordered an assortment of their pastas which were fabulous and ended with the Olive Oil Cake. You really can't go wrong here. read more

See all

My favorite burger in town. Chef always recommends medium rare but I prefer medium: just get the burger ($29) you won't be disappointed. read more

Suprema Provisions - My preference: medium perfectly cooked $29. The standout. - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

This is a very cozy, dimly-lit, sexy spot - very popular with dates for a reason. The West Village is just full of these haunts; I sometimes wish the UWS had a bit more of this romanticism in its restaurant scene but we do have the better bagels. From a COVID standpoint, interesting strategy to pack the front bar and glass window area with people; it gets really loud as soon as you have one drunken table (and the rest just fall like dominos), which isn't helped by the windows. Not to mention the frigid temps that have just been throttling the city; there's definitely a bit of a draft that seeps through. The back area is a lot quieter and warmer. We ordered the Supreme house salad and ricotta crostini to start. The salad was a heaping portion; I loved the shaved parmagiano cheese on top, as well as the crunchy bits of fennel. Not sure if that night, they swapped in something else for the apple but overall, a fresh healthy dose of greens. The ricotta crostini was obviously the superior option though, loaded with ricotta and topped with honey, mint, and hazelnuts. I may need to make this combo for myself. I went with the black sea bass for my entree - in hindsight, I'm not sure why, it was tasty (albeit a little heavy on the oil for my preference) but there's no shortage of restaurants in this area that can make a solid piece of fish. Should have gone with one of the pastas - the spaghetti pomodoro caught my eye, as I'm a sucker for a good classic spaghetti. Need to try the meatballs and marrow and the meat/cheese boards. read more

See all

I had heard of this place before and to be honest we were going to go to Westville for brunch further north on 7th avenue but they were packed and we just kept walking. I had heard good things and was curious. I think their burger is supposed to be a top city burger and their pastas are supposed to be pretty good. But honestly have to say that their brunch food was kind of lacking and very underwhelming. I liked what I ordered but my boyfriend and his friend's dish wasn't that great. I ordered the Prosciutto, tomato, mozzarella, basil sandwich. The ingredients were heavenly. Pillows of mozz on top of super fresh tomatoes and delicious salty prosciutto. Interesting choice of bread. It was like very thin and crispy and the texture of a croissant. For the price and size (a bit small) wish there was like a side salad at least. My boyfriend got the steak and eggs. He wished they asked how he'd like his eggs cooked because he really doesn't do runny eggs but that was more his screw up. Everything was very bland though and under-seasoned and super small portions. His friend had the eggs benedict with salmon and he also said everything was under-seasoned and underwhelming. I'd come back for dinner and give it another shot because I feel like we ordered the wrong things and the egg dishes really aren't memorable or particularly worth it. read more

See all

Great service for Brunch. Had the BEC and a Bloody Mary. They were both really tasty! It was an impromptu visit and loved it! Good spot for family, friends and couples. Nice for groups too! The service was quick and very nice! read more

Suprema Provisions - Bloody Mary - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all