Really great pizza! Made exactly as we requested. The ingredients were super fresh. Very nice person took our order we called in and picked up, super friendly. Give them a try! read more

The Colorful Cookery - Pepperoni and mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Berlin , Ohio

See all

Don't sleep on this hidden gem in the heart of Berlin. The Colorful Cookery has amazing pizza. We ordered their House Pizza this time and it was absolutely delicious. Fantastic customer service and reasonable prices. read more

The Colorful Cookery - The House Pizza - BBQ base, mozzarella, pulled pork, topped with cilantro coleslaw & sriracha ranch. - Pizza Near Me - Berlin , Ohio

On our trip the first place we stopped was The Colorful Cookery. We had one slice to see if we all would like it. Definitely order a whole pizza! We also had a side salad that was delicious. The service was quick and the crust on the pizza was delicious. read more

See all

You have to be looking for this place to find it! It does not sit on the main drag but rather sits in a walkway between buildings. There is signage on sidewalk that will direct folks to the door. It is basically a counter to place your order and a drink fridge. There are 2 tables right outside the door. The menu consists of mainly pizza with specialty pizzas as well as lots of toppings to design your own. We had a specialty pizza that was basically a deluxe. It was delicious with lots of toppings. Nice airy crust with flavorful sauce. Great place to grab something other than Amish style food. read more

The Colorful Cookery - Entrance - Pizza Near Me - Berlin , Ohio

See all

Gluten free pizza was good , gluten-free cheese bread was OK. Plenty of cheese toppings were good. We also ordered a regular four topping pizza it was good. read more

See all

Amazing pizza! Very nice small place. Great service! Cannolis were sooooooo good!!!!! 100% recommended! read more

The Colorful Cookery - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Berlin , Ohio

See all

All I can say is that this pizza is delicious. I come up once a year to Amish country to shop and stay. I have gotten their pizza each time, and it has been delicious every time. Lots of great flavor, and I definitely recommend picking up a pizza from here if you're in the area. I make it a point. There is no dine in, but we always take it back to wherever we are staying and have it for dinner. I'm so happy I stumbled upon this little spot. read more

See all

This was our first time trying The Colorful Cookery and it exceeded our expectations! The best BBQ Chicken Pizza I have ever had. My husband had the Italian sub and not only was it delicious it was huge! We also got the cannolis for dessert! This is a must try place when you are in Berlin. read more

Wonderful friendly service by Heather! We got the Stromboli and The House. Amazing flavors. The Stromboli was my wife's favorite. The House is spicy. Pizza by the slice for lunch or order a pie. The bubble waffle was amazing! This is definitely going to be our favorite treat this summer. read more

See all

This place is so tasty! The sausage was delicious and the vegan cheese tasted like real cheese. I loved all of their allergy friendly options. The place was cute and the workers were super nice. Definitely make sure you try their garlic sauce. This is the best place to stop for a quick bite after shopping nearby. read more

Thanks to The Shopper paper that gets delivered every Friday in Holmes County Ohio, I discovered The Colorful Cookery! There is a Facebook page with offers. Today's and tomorrow's offer includes the house specialty pizza 10" for $2 off! She has pizza by the slice, and bubble waffles with ice cream and many toppings! She also makes Stromboli! Her gourmet pizza delighted my hubby and I earlier tonight! The house specialty pizza has some heat but the favorite part for my 73 year old hubby was the sauce which is a mixture of sriracha and ranch dressing. We can't wait to get more! You can see photos of her menu on Google and some photos of her foods! She makes it easy to grab something and keep waking while you eat! This tiny shop is in the rear of Berlin's oldest building built in 1817!! It feels great to support local businesses and I can't wait to see this busines read more

See all

Huge shout out to your establishment!!!! We ordered delivery to our campground, less than an hour prior to closing (sorry). Ordered a pepperoni pizza; kids devoured it! The cheese was amazing, the sauce was ample but not over powering. Daughter had the S'mores Bubble waffle, supper yummy and I believe the pic speaks for itself. Ordered delivered directly to our camper, arrived even a bit early. Next time we camp at Scenic Hills, you will be getting another order! Thank you and Happy Easter. read more

The Colorful Cookery - Phenomenal pepperoni pizza via delivery. - Pizza Near Me - Berlin , Ohio

See all

We stopped here in hope for some pizza but sadly they were ill outs Dough. I couldn't leave empty handed so I did get a waffle. It was delicious. I hope to come back someday to try the pizza. read more

The Colorful Cookery - Peanut butter!! - Pizza Near Me - Berlin , Ohio

Love this place!! The servers were very friendly and full of energy. The sausage and jalapeño pizza was delicious and a fantastic price. We also got three different bubble waffles ( breakfast club, peanut butter chocolate, and berries) all were delicious and great sizes. 100/10 would come back. read more

The Colorful Cookery - Peanut butter chocolate bubble waffle. - Pizza Near Me - Berlin , Ohio

Great addition to Berlin Ohio. The hand tossed crust is delicious and you must get a cannoli or two!

Great pizza and cute spot! We enjoyed the pizza by the slice for a quick lunch and it was delicious. The outdoor seating was nice & we grabbed a couple of drinks from the cooler. Service was excellent! Now, I just want to go back for the whole pizza and the bubble waffles. read more

This small shop is very good. The staff was so nice! The pizza was very good. It was fresh and fast.

We had "The House" pizza. It was delicious. It has pulled pork and coleslaw on it. The slaw added a perfect crunch. The sriracha sauce had a good kick. Delicious. Also got a bubble waffle. It was good. They made the waffle on the spot. The crispy freshness was appreciated. The side salad is good too. Lots of yummy fresh grated parmesan cheese. read more

The Colorful Cookery - The House pizza - Pizza Near Me - Berlin , Ohio

See all

Passed through Berlin, OH and stopped at the Colorful Cookery. Good food with very friendly staff. Didn't think there'd be many options in Berlin as a vegetarian with a wheat allergy (lmao) but this place fixed us right up with very good pizza. Recommended. read more

Off the beaten path in Berlin but wow! The service was fantastic, the bubble waffle was also good and the Stromboli was Stellar. So glad we found this place and it has now been added to our favorites list in the area. read more

What a find in Amish country. I was looking for a bite for lunch with my family and did not want Amish home cooking. We walked into this tiny establishment (no seating) and ordered a pizza that we could eat outside. What a great surprise! Just a good pizza. I am suspecting it had a blend of cheeses. I had ham and mushroom- which was perfect. The bottom of the pizza was nice and brown and not undercooked. Me and my family were quite pleased. read more

Top notch pizza. The House special with pulled pork and jalapeño slaw was a delight. Wonderful service, too. Definitely worth a stop if you are in the area read more

I have been a die hard colorful cookery patron since my first experience a year ago and haven't ordered pizza anywhere else since. For one, I love supporting small businesses- the level of customer service is something I wish every establishment would take notes on. Heather and her employees are such kind people that I enjoy paying them for their great work. Now for the food.... The pizza flavor is something I've been longing for my whole life as an avid pizza connoisseur and I could eat it every day if I let myself. I was intimidated with all of the options for the fancy bubble waffles but was intrigued and wanted to try. Heather was kind enough to surprise me with a random flavor since I couldn't make up my mind. Without many convenient take out options in the area, or restaurants with personable employees for that matter; needless to say this is a diamond in the rough. read more

Wow! This is a hidden gem. My Italian family owned a pizza shop for decades, so we know a thing or two about pizza. The delicious pepperoni pizza from this shop did not disappoint. This is a MUST stop when going to Berlin. Not only for the pizza but for their Bubble waffles! The waffles come in delightful flavors (I enjoyed the mixed berry). My husband enjoyed the pina colada. Neither of us were willing to share...super yummy! The owner was warm and friendly, and we look forward to trying other menu items. read more

Very cute small spot in the alley. Their meat is great and pizza are baked perfect! Was a great choice for the family after a long day to dine. read more