$16.98 for a western omelette with cheese, ham, peppers, and onions because I asked for a roll instead of a bagel is ridiculous. And they didn't even give me the bagel. I don't mind paying fair prices, but this felt like getting overcharged for a basic bagel shop order. Bad value, bad experience, and definitely not something I'd recommend. read more

The Everything Bagel of Commack - $16.98 worth of food - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

So I've come back over the last couple of years and things have improved as far as the person taking your order from behind the counter. The girls are very sweet for the most part. The bathroom needs to be cleaned better. I asked a question about Fox News being on the television and the girl helping me said "I know. It's uncomfortable and I try to ignore it. It makes us all feel so weird." I told her I agreed and I'd like to ask someone about why they choose to have it on. Well. Ms. 'Manager' came out very aggressively yelling, "who has the complaint?!!!l" in front of a line of people. I didn't want to make a scene so I chose not to respond to her aggression. I said I don't have a complaint, just a question: why Fox News? "WHY NOT??!!!! Our owner is a VETERAN and THATS WHY!!!!" Turned around and walked away. Her response is trying to imply that only that news source supports veterans and not about the bias. This person is completely lacking professionalism when asked something simple. She was defensive and looking for an altercation WITH A CUSTOMER. I felt bad for the girl who took my order so not to make a scene or to make it more uncomfortable for her I paid, I waited for my food and I walked out. Never will I return again. 4/10/26 read more

With the cost of everything these days, it's often tough to get me to want to spend money on breakfast, the easiest meal of the day. But Vicky and the team at Everything Bagel in Commack make it worth your while. Creative. Helpful. Delicious. That's my TLDR synopsis for you. They are always trying creative stuff here - just check their social media pages. French toast croissant BEC - check. But what I came for was the once viral chopped cream cheese. The only place I knew that did it was in Nassau and I couldn't get myself to drink 30 minutes for a bagel. Luckily someone tipped me off that this place could! Vicky got back to me immediately on Instagram to let me know she'd love to make me one, so I was there the next day! And boy did it deliver. For the one I got, you have to like a bagel with lox and all the fixins. But they can make it with any ingredients you want. Just think of it has having your own special blend of cream cheese made. Can't wait to head back and try another one of their fun breakfast ideas! read more

The Everything Bagel of Commack - Chopped cream cheese - lox, bacon, capers, red onion, tomato, lettuce - on an egg everything bagel - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

What a cute neighborhood spot! Whenever I'm visiting family in Long Island, I like to grab some bagels (they're way better than in Boston). This place did the job. The bagels were fresh and the lox hit the spot. The vibes were very towny, in a charming way. It seemed like there were lots of regulars. I'd be happy to come back for some more bagels! read more

See all

I ordered the Philly stuffed bagel and, while I ended up with jalapeño cream cheese instead of the regular, it turned out to be a delicious surprise. The bagel itself was perfectly soft with a nice bite, and the stuffed cream cheese combined with the Philly-style toppings made for an absolutely amazing flavor combo. It was rich, satisfying, and had just the right kick from the jalapeño. And yes I added my own scorpion Tabasco to it lol. Be prepared for a line--it's long, but it moves quickly. The staff are super friendly and keep things running smoothly. Definitely worth the wait. I'll be back to try more! read more

The Everything Bagel of Commack - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

The Everything Bagel has come up with one of the best ways to eat a bagel in my opinion. Slicing them open and making it so the goodness get all inside.... Not only are they perfectly crunchy but look at all the good toppings it gets smothered in. I got the: - PBJ on a seasame bagel. (This one was deff my favorite. The brown sugar combo. INSANE.) - BEC on an everything. (The garlic butter + cream cheese. I'm dreaming of this still.) - The Foodie Princess (shout out to my girl Mel - she knew what was up with this one. @yourfoodieprincess) Definitely recommend adding them to your list of places to try on LI. It has the cutest mural on the wall inside. Check out my reel on instagram to see and hear more about my experience: @phone_munchies read more

See all

Stuffed bagels. Enough said. I mean this is great. Garlic butter on top just adds everything you could possibly want. Looks like a small mom and pop shop with a friendly spot. Line builds up fats but goes quickly. read more

I started going to this place some months ago all the way from Bayshore. One day I asked the girl if there any refills and the older woman came out with the attitude said no there's no refills God you could at least be nice for someone that traveled all the way from Bayshore to come to your establishment! After reading these comments I knew all the while it wasn't me and I will not be returned anymore yes the work is all rude and some do have attitude problems I'll spend my money elsewhere and save myself the time and gas thanks anyway I'll go somewhere in my own area. What's the cost to be nice to a customer in my case x customer. I see a lot of complaints here you're going to lose a lot more customers if you keep up your crap read more

Bagels are GREAT and that is usually an indicator that everything else is. The staff are attentive and will repeat your order and write it down if it is more than one or two items. My one complaint is the ambiance-- regardless of the time of day, the TV is on and only on Fox. The volume is on very loudly and everyone is subject to the annoying and sometimes harmful comments that are being made. It would help if when it gets that busy and people are fighting to be heard so their orders are correct that the volume be turned down a bit. read more

I've had this place on my list for awhile. But once I saw the pickle cream cheese on Instagram and had to try it. In the comments they commented it was made to order when asked, which is perfect since I don't like raw onions. But when I went to order the employee told me it was pre-made so I wouldn't be able to get it without onions. Since I already waited in line and was hungry. I ordered 2 different stuffed bagels for my husband and me. The cinnamon one was good, but not worth the trip. read more

Outstanding breakfast empanadas! Only $3 and they're stuffed with bacon, egg and cheese or sausage egg and cheese or Ham egg and cheese. They're a must try! Everything looks so fresh and the service is great. Ambiance is very welcoming and clean ! Highly recommend read more

I recently saw the new trending "Stuffed Bagel" was available at this bagel shop and I immediately had to try one. This place was clean, had some seating, and ample parking early in the morning. Everyone who was working seemed friendly and knowledgeable. There was a good amount of customers filtering in and out which was a good sign to me. They have a number of cold drink cases and a full brewed coffee bar. They also have "homemade" iced tea and lemonade that can be purchased in a big party bag to go. The stuffed Bagels come in salty or sweet. It is basically any bagel with any cream cheese and for the salty version the brush a garlic butter on it before broiling it. I'm not sure about the sweet, but I will be back to try it. The stuffed bagel was very good and different. I would highly recommend visiting and trying one or two. read more

The Everything Bagel of Commack - Counter - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Delicious! Would get this again. Busy in a Saturday morning, but they are quick! Be sure to check the specials. read more

The Everything Bagel of Commack - Special with lox cream cheese, garlic sauce and eggs - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

Myself and my family love the everything bagel! We've been coming here for probably over 15 years.. they make the best everything bagel because they are the only bagel place that actually puts salt on their everything bagel. I love when Jean helps me as she make sure everything is always perfect no matter how big or small my order is.. She takes pride in making sure she knows her customers names and their usual orders. And has a memory like no other!!! The entire staff is very friendly too. I recommend this bagel store to everyone who asks. My extended family comes here as well. Whether you live near or far the everything bagel in Commack is the best. Thanks to Anna today for helping me with my order. read more

Pickle sandwich has done it for me. I don't know where else you can get one but 10/10. 8/10 messy but it's a pickle sandwich. You can get whatever you want in your pickle sandwich, it comes with a small side, and my favorite part is they give you another crunchy pickle on the side. I've never been happier, was not a long wait at all. They have other sandwiches and a breakfast empanada that I would go back and try. You'll want to try it out! read more

The Everything Bagel of Commack - Pickle Sandwich with turkey, lettuce, and tomato - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

The food is good, but the people are not very nice, nasty as a matter of fact! You ask them questions they roll their eyes. It's too bad because the food is very good. read more

Unsanitary - dirty they all wear gloves to make it look sanitary, but then handle cash , register, knives cream cheese, and then touch bagels and food without changing gloves or using bakery / deli paper. Highly unsanitary. I wouldn't be surprised if they use the same gloves for most of the day! When I mentioned this to one of the workers they just moved on the next customer - without a response. The owners should wake up ! read more

amazing food, but absolutely terrible customer service. not even calling your order in ahead of time will save you a headache after interacting with their rude staff read more

Bagels were good - chewy as we like them, however our order got messed up (we were concerned and should have checked it before we left, but it was hectic). Also, no tofu cream cheese? All the other bagels places we visited had at least plain tofu and many have vegetable tofu read more

This place makes the best ham, egg and cheese on roll with ketchup, salt and pepper. I usually place my order with Jean! She is the most realest hard working woman I've met at the store. Not everyone is going to be your cup of tea and that's okay, not all the staff is as authentic as she is! Food is great and Jean is as great! Looking forward to coming back here again! read more

They gave me an avocado toast instead of French toast and then they told me I can't exchange or get a refund. Worst customer service.

If you're going to be off keto, you're going to do it right. Bagels are part of that. I stopped here and got breakfast. Lox, eggs and onions on a pumpernickel bagel. Made to order, it took a couple of minutes during which I drank most of a cup of coffee that got refilled before departure. In addition to bagels, they have all the usual deli stuff for sandwiches and salads and other breads. Good stuff! [Review 15333 overall, 835 of 2021, number 218 in New York.] read more

See all

Love the bagels, love the food! Jean is the nicest and most welcoming person there. Makes you feel good!! Lucky to have her

They will not honor theior own coupon. Waited 15 minutes on line just to be told they would not honor their coupon on it's last day.

Food looks and tastes great, but the service was beyond disappointing. It was my first time here so we asked where we could find the stuffed bagel menu. Ed smirked and laughed. We asked if we could swap out different flavors of cream cheese and he smirked and laughed again. This went on, and when it came time to pay I said I'd pay first. He laughed and because at this point I was fed up I asked why he was laughing, he responded "because i need to write this down first". I don't see why it was appropriate to laugh at a customer on several occasions, especially considering my friend and I had been nothing but friendly. At one point, we asked if we could get the BEC and he murmured something inaudibly so we asked him to repeat himself several times. During this, he kept laughing to himself and someone else had to let us know that the grill was not on (reasonable since we came later in the day). Maybe some customer service/social etiquette training is needed, or someone more socially capable at the register would be nice. read more

The Everything Bagel of Commack - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

This is our favorite spot for bagels but recently on the internet we saw different menu items and decided we had to try them. They didn't disappoint. The breakfast empanadas with Bacon, Egg and Cheese provided a great kick and was delicious. This would be the perfect hangover food. The stuffed bagel is very unique but absolutely perfect. The staff is always friendly and helpful. This place is the best! read more

The Everything Bagel of Commack - Breakfast Empanada (Bacon, Egg and Cheese) - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Never going back here. They make your sandwiches with the same dirty hands that they use to take your money. Disgusting!! Pick another bagel spot. read more

This place is the worst customer service.....I have experienced. And the staff never looks clean....the only reason I go there is because my kids like this place but I myself will not be going back again. Ask the girl for light colored bagels she gave me all dark. She should've let me know that they don't have any light color bagels and let me decide what I want to do. Then the women comes out of the kitchen with fresh bagels she gets the bagels from there now but starts throwing them on the counter....disgusting!!!! Don't like dealing with customers find another job! read more

This place is great. Always very clean , the food delish bagels delish everything delish. Apparently they are veterans which makes me respect even more. read more

The Everything Bagel of Commack - On their wall. - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

It's a busy shop with good food. Got a sesame bagel with salmon cream cheese here. The staff was helpful and friendly. Good selection. Made to order. read more

Bagels were great but more importantly was the service! We ordered from someone new and the order took a long time and was incorrect. When I brought this to their attention Lynne corrected my order and then came by with free bagels apologizing for the mishap. She explained this person was new and it was thier first job. That's the kind of establishment I want to recognize! Supporting the community and these experiences while showing appreciation for the customer. Well deserved high rating! read more

Here's what I don't understand. How can you order 4 sandwiches the exact same way. And each one comes out different? Can someone please respond and explain that? Would love to hear your reasoning. Why not just put raw bacon from the fridge on the sandwiches? It's already not cooked and this way I don't want to wait 15 minutes more after seeing person after person order after me leave before me. Get your act together. read more

Great experience at the everything bagel. Walked in and noticed everything was clean. Food was presented we in the coolers. Was pleased with the service and the sandwitch. Had tuna on a roll, the macaroni salad had great flavor. So for $9.99 I got tuna +LTM on a roll! With a side of macaroni salad and a pickle, + a large poland spring water. Will return to explore the menu, especially the paninis and heros read more

See all

It is right near my home, so you know what they say - location location location!!! Bagels are good too!

Terrific bacon, egg, and cheese on a roll. Coffee "regular". Man, I miss LI sometimes. Staff was very engaging and helpful.

I went in this morning to buy some rolls and unfortunately, the amount of rolls that I wanted to buy was not available however they were very accommodating and very nice and I truly appreciate their customer service. read more

I wanted to try this place for a long time. I couldn't wait to try a fresh toasted bagel with a egg. I saw 3 men standing to the side, I asked were they next in line. They said they were already helped. I stand in front of the register to get a closer look at the menu. I notice 1 young lady just stares at me, no acknowledgement. She starts calling the men over to pickup there orders. So now, no one is inside the place. This same lady starts talking to her co workers. I wasn't trying to interrupt, so I waited. Now I have been at the counter longer than 5 mins. I just walked out the door. This place might have great food, But customer service is horrible. If your a new customer the treatment felt different. I can tell regular customers were treated differently. read more

The Everything Bagel of Commack - Front view of the store - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

Absolutely my favorite bagel store! I come here almost every day--it's amazing. They have the best bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich. I highly recommend it! read more

We have tried every bagel place in Commack and this is by far the best place to go! The staff is so kind and the food is amazing

No coffee machine, just drip machine & latte/cappuccino "ewwr" machine. Bagels are pretty tasty. In general, all right place read more

The Everything Bagel of Commack - Stuffed croissant French toast... #sugarcoma - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York