My daughter and I have been in the store probably 5 times. She wants to go every time she visits…read more The girl/lady with the short dark hair at the register is not nice. Stares. No hello. Feel like we're an inconvenience. My daughter used the sanitizer that was in FRONT of the counter. Looked like for customer use. Then the lady grabs it and puts it behind the counter. Get a grip. I know people have it tough but we are no exception. Put your friendly pants on or go work where you don't deal with the general public.

May 21, 2021 This…read morelittle store is small and (to me) has a bunch of junk. I mean...I'm not so upscale that I can't thrift...but, this stuff was icky. 2 star rating. I gave them a lot of really nice costume jewelry, some clothes, some wall decor, a pair of shoes and a big new backpack. Everything was in pristine condition unlike the stuff they had. Soo, yeah. I'm sure my stuff won't last long. I think because this business has so little quality items I will bring my donations here from now on. Glad to share!

We decided to pay this place a visit after being away for a year. The interior has been renovated…read moresince our last visit and seems to have even more clothes than before. They still feature all their hard goods, kitchen wares and glassware on shelving above the clothing. Even the bathrooms look new and you don't need a key to get in. The checkout area has a more organized cleaner look and situated next to it are their "Goodwill treasures" behind the counter. Depending on what day of the week you stop in, you can take advantage of their color tag sale. Some older and newer photos included. ***1/2

Good prices and great staff. I always find something special on each visit…read moreItems for the most part are well organized. I'm

What a great shopping experience. Nice shop packed full. Prices were great. Left with so many…read moretreasures. Lady who helped us was very nice, even delivered an item we purchased.

This was probably my favorite stop on my trip in Galveston!…read moreI've been to manyyy antique shops and this one was so well curated. You will seriously not be able to go in here and leave empty handed! Lots of beautiful jewelry at the front. I was able to buy my grandmother stunning earrings and a brooch for Christmas! She loved them!! I wish I had spent more time in here as I'm sure I missed a lot. Lucky Charms Antique Mall will be a new regular stop when I visit Galveston. *check the photos for a feature from their sweeeet shop cat*

It's been a couple of years since I set foot back in this place and it's still basically everything…read moreI said it was before. So the former review still stands and I added a few more photos. Only street parking here, but at least you won't be feeding the parking kiosk. Insightful photographs included.

Interesting shop with vendor booths. Mostly coastal decor but jewelry, vintage items and some…read morefurniture. Shop is merchandised well and easy to navigate

This is an interesting tourist shop where 30 vendors have gathered under one roof with their wares…read more As far as peanut butter is concerned about this place, they do have some fudge when you walk in, but that's about it. You can find over priced local honey here as well. At one point, the upstairs used to be opened, but that's not the case anymore. This is just another one of those businesses near the strand where you look around and usually leave with nothing.

I am extremely disappointed in my experience with Peanut Butter Warehouse, specifically due to the…read morelack of professionalism, poor communication, and unacceptable customer service. My wedding was planned for January 2027, and we toured the venue in November 2025. We loved the space and were excited about the possibility of hosting our wedding here. After the tour, I attempted multiple times to get in touch to officially book our date. I sent emails and made phone calls, but received no response for a couple of weeks, turns out a family emergency had happened so I told him to take his time and be with his family. We finally heard back on December 2. A contract was then sent on December 5, but it contained incorrect names and incorrect information, which understandably needed to be corrected before moving forward. On December 22, I received a follow-up email stating: "Hi Kim, I didn't receive an email that had your requested changes to the contract. Just send it and we will do our best to make requested changes and accommodate your concerns. Thanks." At this point, communication again went silent, which I initially attributed to the holidays. Wanting to move things forward, I reached out again on January 3. What happened during that phone call was shocking and completely uncalled for. Jonathon Starkey was incredibly rude, raised his voice at me, and hung up on me twice. This behavior was completely different from our earlier interactions, which had all been pleasant and professional. During the call, he accused me of being argumentative and rude -- accusations that were entirely unfounded. I remained calm and simply tried to clarify the situation and move forward. Without warning, he then stated that our wedding date had been cancelled. This came as a complete shock. At no point prior to this had there been any hostility, conflict, or indication that our date was in jeopardy. In fact, we had expressed multiple times how excited we were to work with Peanut Butter Warehouse and looked forward to hosting our wedding there. To make matters worse, I later spoke with the owner -- his father, Jerry Starkey -- and unfortunately the unprofessionalism continued. He repeatedly interrupted me, showed no interest in hearing my concerns, and made it clear that he did not care that his son had treated a potential customer in this manner. There was no apology, no accountability, and no attempt to resolve the situation. This confirmed that the issue is not just with one individual, but with how this business is run as a whole. The way this situation was handled was deeply unprofessional and extremely stressful. Weddings are once-in-a-lifetime events, and venues should understand the importance of clear communication, respect, and professionalism -- especially when couples are planning years in advance. Based on my experience, I cannot recommend Peanut Butter Warehouse to anyone planning an important event. Poor communication, incorrect contracts, and aggressive behavior are not things any couple should have to deal with while planning their wedding.

So much stuff here to wander through. Well organized and clean. Excellent prices. If you like…read morelooking through nice random stuff you'll love it. Clothes, decor, books... one of my new must hit shops when on the island.

The store is located inside a larger building. It has been at this location for a little over a…read moreyear, and before that it was actually located a block or two away from its current position. The shop has a great deal of clothing and accessories. It is not a large shop but it does have a lot of interesting items to see. It is also pretty much in keeping with much of the antique store pricing in the area which is definitely on the high side. It was definitely worth stepping into, but I did not see anything that really grabbed my attention. The photos below should give you some idea of what to expect.

From the owner: We offer a selection of vintage clothing, costume pieces and accessories, antique furniture,…read morevintage pyrex, fireking, restaurantware, knives, jewelry, vintage Christmas, and much more.

This thrift store has an okay selection of clothes and other things but mainly you should check out…read moretheir boutique. In the small selection of random coats, shoes, and handbags in the boutique there is some amazing finds! There is easily designer goods hidden in between the random goods. They have a wide variety of China and home decor that looks fresh out of a garage sale but some of it's cute. It can be s hit or miss depending on whose volunteering.

A very reasonable & inexpensive resale shop!…read more There is lots of glassware, GLASS! It is towards the back thru an open door. There is chairs, rocking and still. Washing machines, pillows, picture frames, children toys, shaving clippers still in the box. The clippers looked as if they were donated wholesale, it is a whole plastic bin of it. The clothes are not so hot! Mostly older clothes for elderly people and it is pretty packed together. Laminator machine, for $15, vintage projector $5, playstation controller&cable $3. The books are 4 for $1. A mannequin might greet you when you walk-in or the owners terrier. I didn't much of a greeting or talk from the owners themselves. The parking is on the side of the building. It is parallel, not very wise if you want to turn around and leave the way you came in. I saw a couple of people trying to do that. Lol! If you have trouble you can always drive behind the building to leave. Fishing gear does go fast here! A very affordable resale shop in Galveston always taking donations for good cause!

very unique selection of clothes and accessories for that occasion when you really want to stand…read moreapart from the crowd. The owner is the best! she will help you as much as you want, or leave you to browse if that's your preference. everything in this store is a one of a kind piece.

On Postoffice Street in the heart of Galveston is a rare gem of a retail establishment aptly named…read moreTHE EXPERIENCE. Owners, Cayenne and Concho, (AKA Kelli Holmes and Don Hendrickson), have created an eclectic mix of Art, Apparel, Accents, and Accessories, all made by Texas Artisans and presented in a cool vibe slightly reminiscent of a retailer in in the Village of NYC during the 60's and 70's. Cayenne and Concho have sold my art for the past 5 years here and at a former location in ETX. This place is very unusual and lots of fun to explore, especially if you are looking for an eclectic experience outside of the similarities most retailers offer in most stores today. Cayenne, a creative powerhouse, makes a lot of the offerings herself, including a line of clothing called Filly Pepper. The clothing line is recycled form vintage and current pieces on which she paints, tie dyes and sews into one of a kind wearable art. She also creates decorated hats and jewelry as well as very unique 3 dimensional assemblage pieces filled with humor and complete originality. If you are in Galveston, don't miss this rare establishment. I guarantee it will be an EXPERIENCE.