What a great place for dessert! Located in a strip mall with plenty of parking off the torturous SR60 in Brandon, I wish I lived closer so I could be a regular. Inside was bright and clean and pink, with cute signs and decorations on all walls. We were immediately greeted and given the spiel since we had never been: cookies with or without frosting, cookie ice cream sandwich with flavors of your choosing, boxes of cookies, or just ice cream. I went with a sprinkle cookie with icing, and it was perfect. I love icing so sweet it makes me shudder, and makes my teeth feel like they are about to fall out, and this hit all those benchmarks. We were told that while the cookies are made in house, the ice cream is not; however, it is made by a local dairy (ice creamery?) and brought in fresh. Go here eat cookies be happy! read more

See all

I thought the $3.49 brownie with fudge was better than all of the dozen cookies that I tried. Next time, I'll ask if they can heat mine up or get a fresh one out of the oven and it would be perfect. In my photos I numbered the $25.99 12 mini cookies with 1 being the best and 10 being the worst. I couldn't label the 11th cookie, but just look at the photo. I did order 2 chcolate chip cookies on the left side. I didn't try all of the cookies, but here is my ranking from best to worst: (Best) 1. Red Velvet - the icing is actually delicious 2. Birthday Cake 3. Peanut Butter 4. Pink Strawberry 5. Stuffed Oreo white chocolate 6. Stuffed Oreo milk chocolate 7. Turtle caramel chocolate 8. M&M 9. Sprinkle 10. Chocolate Chip (I ordered 2) 11. Snickerdoodle Overall, if I came back for cookies, only the top 2 were worth ordering. The brownie you should absolutely get. For any other style cookie, Bake N babes (especially chocolate chip) or Indy's cookies are the best you can get around Tampa Bay. read more

See all

The stuffed cookie left me speechless - and stuffed. What a treat! They are decadent to say the least. The banana pudding cookie was unbelievable. These are special occasion worthy! If you have a sweet tooth, this is a must try. read more

The Stuffed Cookie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brandon, Florida

Got a sweet tooth? The Stuffed Cookie in Brandon has got you covered. I stopped here on a weeknight and was pleasantly surprised with the selection and the quality! My wife and I were having a busy evening of running errands. From Brandon to Plant City and back. It was a late-night take-out dinner kind of night and our 8-month-old wasn't having it. Normally, we eat somewhat healthy during the week but after picking up pizza, I said, to heck with it and walked in to The Stuffed Cookie. This was my first visit in. The smell of fresh baked goods and smiling employees welcomes you in. I've been in similar places like this before. Simple but creative dessert shops that bake up a wide range of flavor profiles with ornate decorations. The Stuffed Cookie's forte is taking their cookies and slabbing down a thick layer of locally sourced ice cream between them. For this trip though, I stuck with a 4-pack of their cookies for $11.49 plus tax. The kind girl behind the counter grabbed a box and I had the hard part, picking out cookies. I started with my go-to favorite cookie of all time, the chocolate chip. I also got a caramel apple, cinnamon roll and a banana pudding. Here's my take on each cookie: The Chocolate Chip: This cookie was good! Soft and a little bit under-baked. Plenty of chocolate chips. The dough was sweet and it was an all-around solid chocolate chip cookie. Caramel Apple: This cookie was our favorite out of the selection. It was one of those really nice looking one with icing and toppings. The icing was creamy and sweet and topped with a thick caramel drizzle. I was expecting more of an apple taste but this cookie is the epitome of what you expect from a place like this. Cinnamon Roll: A cinnamon roll flavored cookie that had bits of cinnamon in it like a roll would. The icing wound on top was cream cheese and reminded me of a bakery treat you can get at Publix. We liked this one but it wasn't our favorite. Banana Pudding: This cookie turned out to be a stand-out for us. I got it because my wife prefers baked goods and pastries and figured she would like this one a lot. The banana flavor was prominent and the cookie itself was almost like a piece of banana bread. The icing on top rounded it out. Imagine digging a spoon into a big bowl of banana pudding and taking a bite. That sums up this cookie and it was our favorite. All in all, The Stuffed Cookie is a solid spot. If you want gourmet cookies in the East Brandon/Valrico area, check this place out. Cookie ice cream sandwiches are their forte and I'll be sure to try that next time! read more

The Stuffed Cookie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brandon, Florida

See all

The Cookies were beautiful decorated, display is clean, variety of choices. Service was nice, provide my family with some suggestions and the turn out was fantastic!! Atmosphere was dainty, clean and comfortable. Positive energy all around. read more

I had a coupon for a free cookie. I figured why not give them a shot. The service was great and the cookie was pretty good. It's thicker than normal cookies. As the name suggests, there's a lot of "stuffing" in their cookies. read more

If you have a sweet tooth, this is the place for you. We did the 6 pack of cookies to have some variety. The classic banana pudding one is by far my favorite. It tastes just like the original dessert. The place has a cute little vibe & was extremely clean. Staff was really sweet & helpful with recommendations. Definitely will be back to try other cookies. Price in my opinion wasn't too bad, cheaper than some of the other places. Quality makes it worth it. Paid about $20 for 6 cookies read more

See all

Where do I go when I have a sweet tooth craving? Stuffed cookie always top the list. The option to choose from cookies with a tasty topping on it, or amazing tasting ice cream to go with the cookie. Either or I choose from... I love the cookies, vibes, and friendly staff. The establishment is beautiful and I have zero complaints. I recommend going to Stuffed Cookie over Crumbl. Personal preference. read more

The Stuffed Cookie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brandon, Florida

See all

This is a great place to get sweet treats in east Brandon. My husband is a cookie lover, and my kids love ice cream. So this place was a match made in heaven for us as we were in Brandon for dinner. Right now, they're in their soft opening stage, but they had 8-10 distinct flavors of cookies available when we visited as well as 8 ice cream flavors. I saw stuffed donuts on the menu but didn't see any on display. My husband loved the ice cream he tried as well as the cookies. My son was thrilled to see they have Superman ice cream on the menu (why he likes dyed vanilla ice cream is beyond me). My daughter loved having mint chip ice cream with gummy bears. I tried the frosted strawberry cookie and the NY cheesecake with raspberry cookie. Both were quite good. The NY cheesecake flavors were a bit overwhelmed with the raspberry drizzle on top, but I did like the raspberry. Both cookies were sweeter than I'd prefer but on-par with most of the other cookie places in the area. The setting is very cute, especially if you love everything pink (like my daughter). The place is very new and very clean, which is great. The bathrooms were also spotless. We look forward to many future visits. read more

The Stuffed Cookie - Frosted strawberry, NY raspberry cheesecake, m&m and chocolate chip cookies - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brandon, Florida

This is a cute little dessert stop with a few spots for an instagram photo. If you enjoy Crumbl cookies, this may be a place to check out as their cookies remind me of that style but with lots more variety. You can build an ice cream sandwich using a variety of cookies, a donut, or brownies. If you arent quite that daring, you can get a cookie sundae with your favorite scoop and cookie wedge. I got a strawberry cookie and strawberry ice cream but found both to be far to sweet for me. My family also felt the cookies and ice cream choices they had were too sweet. I'd even venture to say there there a little frost bite icey texture to the ice cream that I wasn't a fan of. I would have liked a list of suggested creations as they really leave it open to make it as you want but some combination guidance would be appreciated. Will I be back, probably not. The cookies itself are not my style...too soft and cake-like. I'm more of a slighty thinner, crispy edge with and soft center kind of cookie lover. Check it out anyway, my sweet tooth just isn't that sweet. read more

See all

Amazing taste! I can't wait to get back to try other flavors! I had the biscoff ice cream and biscoff cookie. So sweet and yummy. It didn't need the icing, though it was a nice touch! Hidden secret in the plaza down Brandon Blvd. read more

The Stuffed Cookie - Biscoff Ice Cream and Biscoff Cookie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brandon, Florida

Now I really wanted to make this a 4 but after seeing 2 bugs flying in the cookie case and even mentioning it to the young girl working she said "there's no way to keep them out." It went down to a three. These cookies I remember being fantastic!and I've had friends come in since and tell me they are delicious but for some reason this visit just didn't live up to it. I'll start with the good stuff which was the two cookie butter cookies. Those were a hit in our group I really liked the filled more than in just being on top. I do wish I could say more but the other cookies were very dry even the ones that had frosting on top the cookie itself was lacking that freshly baked feel. The M&M had to be the worst it crumbled before we could even take a bite. I love stuffed cookies I feel like it's usually so much better but like I said this visit was a just wasn't it. Now with this being said I'll give it a couple weeks and try it again because I know they put out a better product than this. read more

See all

Everything about this shop is cute, the appearance, the homemade feeling of the cookies that are so fresh and good, the unique ice cream flavors. I'm grateful this shop is in Brandon. I was a fan of seeing brownies for sale. Also tried some of the festive cookies & enjoyed how fresh they were. Recommend anyone to drop in and discover this delightful shop. read more

I found this hidden gem, which reminds me of a similar concept in Miami. I was excited to try it all, but I started with the Snookie(good minus the buttercream center) with Maple walnut(very tasty, smooth) and coffee ice cream(not much coffee flavor). The caramel cheesecake cookie(best option; frosting was delicious) with dulce Leche(very good) was a good combo. The decor has a lot of thought put into it. The server was very polite and welcoming. Look forward to trying more options. read more

See all

My new addiction!! I'm loving grabbing a mix of cookies and cutting in fourths for a cookie tasting. My family swarms me when I get home to grab a slice. read more

See all

These cookies are awesome! I've been wanting to go back to try more cookie flavors before writing this review, but I just haven't gotten around to it. They have some really great cookies and brownies. They have sundaes, ice cream stuffed cookies or donuts, ice cream, and lots of yummy toppings. I didn't see any donuts the day I visited so you may want to call ahead to see if they have them. The store is decorated with fun colors and there is lots of indoor seating. It was very clean, and the service was super friendly. I must have looked like a kid in a candy store. I was overwhelmed with all the choices. The cookies are decorated and frosted so beautifully. I couldn't pass up the peanut butter chocolate cookie and the strawberry cookie. Before I knew it, I already had 3 items in the box. I couldn't pass up that brownie either. Well, everything was delicious. It took me 3 days of nibbling on these treats, but I finally got to taste them all. If you think this is another Crumbl, then guess again. It's nothing like it. They have more of a variety of flavors. They didn't have any that I saw that are served warm but that didn't take anything away from the homemade freshness of the cookies. Besides, I think you want your cookie cooled off, and especially if you're making an ice cream sandwich out of it. It's just cool that they have so many different combinations. I have to try a stuffed cookie one day. The pictures look amazing! The pricing seems about right for these large cookies. It's around the same price as Crumbl, and it's closer to me. I also love the picture walls. The sign that says "Feed me and tell me I'm pretty" is just awesome. Support this locally owned business if you happen to be in the area. It's next door to BubbaQues on Brandon Blvd in Brandon. You can't miss it as you're driving out to Dover to get your strawberry fix. read more

See all

Cookies were so good, inside is really cute with instagramable photo opportunities. Plenty of options and flavors. Service was good, nothing spectacular but nothing bad either. I'd totally come back for my sweet craving. I had the raspberry cheesecake cookie- ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS. I forgot to take a pic. read more

The Stuffed Cookie - Inside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brandon, Florida

We needed a sweet treat and as soon as we walked in we were greeted and there was no line. I ordered one scoop and one cookie with sprinkles. The store was very pink with neon signs and cute decor throughout! We loved it and will definitely be returning! read more

The Stuffed Cookie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brandon, Florida

We have been going since the yummy place opened- 5 words- strawberry cookies & coffee ice cream But truly everything Cynee makes is really good - we could literally go there everyday! read more

The Stuffed Cookie - Getting crazy & letting my son enjoy a real sugar Coca-cola - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brandon, Florida

Cookies were pretty good. The red velvet with cream cheese and raspberry cheesecake were my favorite. The other 2 were Oreo cheesecake and a lemon cookie read more

The Stuffed Cookie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brandon, Florida

See all

Great customer service and clean establishment! Not as much product on display as usual but a good experience overall

I ordered my cookies for delivery and had never eaten here before. When it arrived it was exactly what I ordered. They were Beautiful. Caramel Cheesecake, Oreo Cheesecake and Cookie butter filled Snickerdoodles. When I opened the lid they had even written the names of the flavors on the inside. No need to guess. The cookies were soft but not too soft as they had to support the rich and creamy topping/filling. I do wish they had the Oreo cookie with more of an Oreo cream filling but it was all delicious. I can't wait to try some other flavors. read more

The Stuffed Cookie - Caramel Cheesecake, Oreo Cheesecake, Snickerdoodle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brandon, Florida

I tried it for the first time today. Nice atmosphere and they were friendly. I thought the price was a little high for 6 cookies but they are huge and taste yummy. I got the cookie/ice cream sandwich. I should have eaten it in the store by the time I got to the car it had already started to melt. It was like cookies and milk. read more

The Stuffed Cookie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brandon, Florida

See all

It is VERY PINK inside like a Barbie house. And Very clean. The staff was very friendly and answered our many questions. Cookies and ice cream were delicious. A little expensive we thought, but in today's market not too bad. Granddaughters loved it! We will go again. read more

The Stuffed Cookie - Classic Oreo Cheesecake Cookie with ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brandon, Florida

See all

What a cute little place! Thanks to the emails I get from That's so Tampa, I found out about this spot. I had it bookmarked in my Yelp right away. After going to dinner with my kiddos, I figured we would head on over since we were already in the area. It is tucked in a small shopping plaza next to an Italian restaurant. When we walked in, we were greeted by two friendly young ladies. She asked us if we had been there before and since it was our first time, she made sure to give us the run-down of how the concept works. They have good size cookies, brownies and donuts to make your ice cream sandwiches with. You can make it just the way you want! You can make a stuffed cookie, a double stuffed cookie, a stuffed donut, or just a cookie and cream sundae. I was still pretty full from dinner, so I opted with just two scoops. Nonetheless, I had a scoop of the Captain Chocolate and a scoop of their Coffee Club. Two great combos right there. My boys had their Cookie and Cream Sundae. They gobbled that down quick and actually mentioned how good the cookie tasted. This is definitely a cool concept. I hope that enough people will come and give them business, because I want to keep coming back! read more

See all

Hands down the best cookie and ice cream place in Brandon. I was welcomed with great smiles as the staff recommended fun options and stuffed combinations to try. I settled on the stuffed croissant with ice cream and a box of delicious cookies for my family. read more

See all

If you're looking for a great cookie or ice-cream, look no further! This place has the best cookies in town. They come in different flavors for everyone as well as the ice-cream! Try the stuffed cookie sandwich, it's a MUST! The store is beautifully decorated and very clean. The staff is welcoming and friendly! Definitely recommend and will be back for more! read more

The Stuffed Cookie - Variety of the cookies! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brandon, Florida

Great cookies here !!!! And good selection of ice cream. And a well kept establishment. read more

See all

Brand new cookie and ice cream place in Valrico near Nativity. Looks like a Crumbl Cookie clone but does it better by selling ice cream as well and giving you an option to make ice cream sandwiches. I haven't tried the ice cream portion so I can't comment on it, but tried out a couple of their cookies. One big thing is that there is about a dozen different cookie flavors on display and unlike Crumbl, not all of their cookies rely on heavy frosting. Their cookie dough is also good, with a nice flavor and texture (my critism of crumble is that they sell brownies masquerading as cookies). From the ones I tried, is definitely a notch above Great American and Panera cookies, but still falls short of the local Instagram delivery bakers. Definitely the better option in Brandon if you're looking for party and presentation worthy cookies. Would come back again. read more

My family and I stopped this location for the first time, and I had no clue this gem is in my neighborhood. There is a great variety in cookie and ice cream options, and you can add toppings. The desserts and customer service were spectacular. We will definitely return! read more

See all

This place is a gem and has to die for desserts! The selection of cookies, donuts, and ice cream is incredible. The owner and staff are also very friendly and attentive which makes the experience here much more amazing. I promise if you try this place at least once, it certainly will not be the last. read more

The Stuffed Cookie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brandon, Florida

See all

The owner Sinyee always makes me feel so welcomed! The cookies and customer service here are impeccable! Highly recommend!

Cute place great service - cant go wrong w cookie and ice cream ... Derek is amazing .... read more

Amazing cookie and ice cream flavors. I would definitely recommend the lemon cookie and butter pecan ice cream

If you've ever dreamt of what it would be like if Crumbl and Insomnia cookies had a baby then this is the best of both worlds! Fairly new to Brandon this cookie shop is serving up all the cookie and ice cream sweets you could ever dream of. The pink, girly vibe is perfect for all your Insta and selfie needs. Employees are friendly and ready to help you make a dessert masterpiece with a smile. Lots of unique cookie options. Some with icing and others plain... I had a hard time deciding which to make my cookie sandwich out of! They have multiples cases of ice cream too; serving up all your favorites. Don't stop there, you can also add toppings as well like marshmallows and sprinkles. read more

The Stuffed Cookie - Raspberry cheesecake cookie (top) Strawberry ice cream M&m's cookie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brandon, Florida

See all

This place was great! There were four of us and we all got something different and all loved what we tried. The employees were great at explaining each of the cookies we asked about and served us well. We ate our desserts inside. The seats/tables/floors were very clean. If you like red velvet at all, then try the red velvet cookie with cream cheese frosting. Fantastic! read more

See all

Really good, came last on a Sunday after a rush but they still had lots of delicious items to choose from. Will definitely be back. Staff was really helpful and had lots of recommendations for cookie and ice cream combos. Brownie was a must! read more

This place was so cute! Many cute photo ops all around the shop. Very similar to Crumble cookie but they added an ice cream option that you can have alone, as a sundae, or as an ice cream sandwich. The cookies were pretty decent sized and they had a great flavor variety. My favorite was the s'mores and my husband enjoyed the New York caramel. The staff was very attentive and helpful. The only thing that was not my favorite was the chocolate chip cookie. The taste was lacking and tasted as if it were under baked and the chocolate chips were not the usual milk chocolate. It tasted more bitter than I like for a chocolate chip cookie. Other than that, this was a cute place to try if you are wanting a yummy cookie. read more

See all

I had it DoorDashed, it was super good. I recommend the lemon cookie! Very heavy though I don't recommend eating more than one. read more

Great cookies and better price than crumbl cookie. Service was friendly and clean interior.