I will say I am blown away with how SPECTACULAR this place is. Emily made my daughters wishes come true with the squishy mystery box! We will be using the toy chest for all our toy purchases moving forward! read more

The Toy Chest will make you feel like a kid again no matter what your age! I swung by Nashville after a day spent at Brown County State Park and luckily got to drop into the Toy Chest before their 6pm closing. I had so much fun shopping for books for my niece, and even picked up some Smiskis for myself. They are the only authorized Smiski seller in the state of Indiana, so I'm happy I got to drop in. The prices are great and the staff are super friendly. It's definitely worth checking out! read more

Warning: Don't take your grandchildren, or you will come out broke! This is a cute little independent toy store located in an old house in Nashville. The rooms are packed with higher quality toys for toddlers up to teenagers. There was an interesting assortment of books including early readers. They carry many Melissa and Doug toys. Expect premium pricing. The Toy Chest is an excellent place to pick up quality gifts while supporting a locally owned business. There is limited (free) street parking, so get there early or plan on walking. read more

See all

This is such a wonderful local toy store. It's definitely reminiscent of the dreamy ones you see in the movies. We had a blast visiting twice during our visit to Nashville with our two year old and ended up purchasing a bathtub play set. The staff was both friendly and attentive. The store is located in a charming Victorian home with whimsical and fun wallpaper throughout. Prices seemed fair and I was impressed by their selection of European/simple toys. Highly recommend popping in to check this place out! read more

The Toy Chest - Toy Stores Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

I made a trip to Indianapolis and decided to go out of my way to this store on my trip back to Tennessee to look for Sonny Angels since they are the only authorized retailer in the state of Indiana. Unfortunately, their hours are wrong on Google and as an out of towner that is very disheartening to make this drive and for the store to be closed. I dont want to leave a bad review due to the unfortunate situation and looking at other reviews but I wanted to bring awareness to the situation because if it can happen to me it can happen to someone else. Please keep your hours up to date for those that dont get the luxury to just try again during business hours! read more

This is awesome place that we checked out while we were in Nashville Indiana. We had a good time. Check it out. Nostalgia is a thing and it is real and it is awesome. We like seeing all the old toys new toys everything they have this is a great spot. read more

See all

I have been visiting this toy store since I was a child. This was my first visit to their new location just across the street from their old shop. The new location is bigger which is fantastic. They have a large variety of toys, ranging from toys that you would find in a typical toy store, to toys that you don't necessarily see. As a Montessori teacher, I saw a large range of toys that were developmentally appropriate for a wide range of ages. My husband and I picked out two new games to buy. We played "Fluxx" a card game, and it is an awesome game. Every time we come to Nashville, this shop is one that we definitely visit! read more

This is such a great place! I enjoyed the mall location in Bloomington when it was open, but this one's much cuter (and still in business). They've adapted beautifully to our newfound digital era and are willing to deliver things to a huge radius. They emphasize diversity where they can (they have a new box called "diversify my bookshelf," which is a bundle of books with BIPOC people as the main character, for example, or you can order Hearts for Hearts dolls from a variety of countries). They offer all kinds of packaging options from individual items to kits (like for birthdays or holidays), and I really like that they take the time to curate things for your kids based on their interests. The age range is wide. I think it's actually as wide as it can get, from babes - adults. Additionally, they support worthy causes (like BLM, for example), and show it by contributing to various related charities. This is really a neat toy store. Check it out! read more

Reasonable prices and toys that you don't find most other places. Cool Russian nesting dolls, lots of interesting art and craft sets, dress up clothes, figurines, and pretty much anything else you can imagine. Make sure to check into Yelp for 5% off one item! read more

My kiddo cannot enter without coming home with a present. We love the business and the owners try their best to appease the locals, as well as tourists. They offer so many educational toys and merchandise to support children's growing minds. I hold great nostalgia recalling my son's favorite baby toys before he could even sit up on his own. He loved his high-contrast baby mobile, the light-up Noggin Seek rattle, and a high-contrast board book(i don't recall title) that he loved so young, months before he'd look at anything else. Now we are mostly buying cars, but i still hold a special place in my heart for the Toy CheSt. The prices are comparable to Amazon but you are supporting one family valued by the community. Tune into their fb page for special deals and in-store activities for your children. This business is a treasure. read more

See all

GREAT fun shop for kids to play! Great selection of "good" toys - games and puzzles, learning fun, Mellisa & Doug and Usborne and more! Wooden toys. Educational and science type. Books and more... Space to play and discover Try out the toys that are out Service was kind and helpful. This is a must stop shop for kids shopping among the stops in down town NAshville! Great fun for them! Nearly a five star... but I kind of wish there were a few more toys (hard to say that, as it was full of them! - although I am glad it's not all the typical toys you can find in most box stores)... and I thought a couple items may have been priced a little high, but most prices were very competitive. read more

This shop is another of our Nashville staples. When our grandkids were small, there was always a variety of educational toys, books, and stuffed animals. As the kids grew older, there were magic tricks, collectible dolls, and a little bit of everything that a child might want (and just enough nostalgic pieces that made me want to get some for myself). If you have a kid or want to feel like one, stop in here! Review #168 read more

Love Love Love this place! I can only imagine how neat this place must look through a child's eyes. I cannot wait for our little girl to be big enough to remember this place. My husband visited here as a child and wanted to show me on our most recent trip. I fell in love with this store. The most unique gifts are here, along with a neat book selection and toy ideas for older children. We will definitely be back here more than once! If you check in you get a discount too! It will say at the register, I think? read more

I got a squirrel mask here. I don't really think I need to say anything else. OK, I will say a couple more things. This place basically rules. I don't have kids, but I don't need them to enjoy The Toy Chest. Don't miss this place if you're bumping around Nashville, whether you have a couple of munchkins in your life or not. Besides the mask, I bought an Edward Gorey puzzle and a build-your-own light up race car for my nephew. I wanted to buy a deck of cards imprinted with 3-D cats but restrained myself. Games, puppets, bicycle bells, figurines, books, science sets, matryoshka dolls, costumes ... the Chest has it all! This might be controversial, but in a face-off between Mass Ave Toys and The Toy Chest, I'd put my money on this place. read more

This store has quite the selection! I usually find that small toy stores are usually missing some genre of toy. That is not the case for this store. I was pleasantly surprised when I walked through the store. They had puzzles, musical toy instruments, ball guns, puppets, traditional toys, building sets, etc. We thought we were going to be in and out of this store in 10 minutes but I think we spent an upwards of 45 minutes in here trying everything out and browsing around. I was with a wild bunch of boys and women and the store staff was very tolerable with us. At the end I walked away with a puppet on strings, a hacky sack, and a little action figure. I had my android phone with me and did some price checking and the prices were about right. Maybe 3-5 dollars more than what you can find in Indianapolis, so it is reasonable considering its remote location in Brown County. I recommend this store for all your child-like needs! :) read more

What a fantastic toy store. It had every toy you could possibly want. I bought a Berenstain Bear book and it was one I didn't have. It was in a fantastic location. I highly recommend this place. read more

Really cute place. Way bigger than it looks from the outside. Lots of interesting toys for all ages and helpful nice sales people

Great little place. Lots of toys you don't see much anymore. They sell nesting dolls, little figurines, as well as stuffed animals. They also have your run of the mill toys you'd expect to find in a toy store geared towards tourists. My kid got a pen shaped like a ninja sword. Don't skip this place. read more

This toy store has been here for years ! You will find all sorts of things from small to large gifts. Books, dolls , and replica of vintage toys. Such a great thing to have in this village. read more

For the best selection of Russian nesting dolls (Matryoshka dolls) in the United States, go to the Toy Chest in Nashville, Indiana. We have these types of dolls from all over the world, but the quality and selection at this little gem of a shop is unparalleled. Don't have time to go to Russia?.....go to Nashville, Indiana! (The Bloomington location does not have Matryoshka dolls) 3/26/16 read more

It's like a little Mass Ave toys! Only downside...extremely narrow and cramped,as tourists are packed in here.

This store is great. It is a must for our family when we visit Nashville. We spent about an hour in the store playing and making our selections. I can't think of any toy store that has the selection as vast as this one. As I was following my kids around the store I realized how many of our frineds and family would love something from this store. I have read the last review and agree with the previous reviewer. They have everything that you would want. I just don't understand why the previous reviewer only gave the Toy Chest three stars. If you are going to Nashville, you should plan to spend a lot of time and money in this store. If you are not in Nashville, you should think about making a trip to the town just to visit this store. You will love the selection and you will be able to take care of almost everyone on you list in this one store. read more

Great find for kids! Has lots of toys to choose from and very reasonably priced. My kids (ages 2, 4 and 6) absolutely love going here. As my six year old says "Mommy this is the BEST toy store EVER!" It's always our first stop in Nashville and we definitely recommend it. read more