Don't bother. Arrive on a breezy evening of 64 degrees to find out it is only outside seating. Menu is online, but 5g is not great. Order waters so we could get an alcoholic drink, but told to get our own at a water station with no ice. Flatbread pizzas were only ok. Tip choices are 20%, 25%, 30%. Maybe for full-service! Not coming back. read more

Reasons to come here: nice variety of well made beers. We are In caseville! nice outdoor seating, friendly staff. Dogs allowed. Tuning needed: waitress brought our appetizer with our meal, took 30 min to deliver burgers when seating was filled but not busy (2pm on Saturday). Need to improve: The details of the food served- the description on the menu should match - burger was missing several toppings. We ordered well done burgers- not hockey pucks. We were seated at the back of the yard which seemed to have its share of flies. We will be back and hope for better. Glad they are here. read more

See all

If it is the area for the Pumpkin Festival. Great time playing cornhole sidewalk drawings xcetera. Decided to stop in and try to Brewery. Set outside of the covered patio area. Only a few tables gave customers. He waited five minutes and went inside to order our beverage cashed out and left. read more

Thumb Brewery - A sin of thum burry - Breweries Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

See all

Great spot. Pet friendly. Kid friendly. Beer is brewed on site. Solid choices. Guest taps and full bar. Food was good. Service great. Cool logo and merchandise. Check out the record collection inside. read more

Good food, beer and outdoor sitting. We really had a good experience. The staff was friendly and quick.

Their website is never updated and their hostess tells you to go elsewhere when they are busy. Doomed to fail.good

Love this place! Ashely always takes care of us and Is awesome! They always have a great assortment of beer and the pizza is awesome. It's a great small town brewery and the atmosphere is great! read more

Thumb Brewery - Hef - Breweries Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

The walleye sandwich on special was amazing. Kinde IPA was great as well. Great patio to drink on!

Brought the kids here - FANTASTIC! They had sidewalk chalk, games, hoola hoops ... SO KID FRIENDLY! We had 2 families. Kids sat at one table and adults at the other. Adults had fun, kids had fun! Lady Lavender is my new favorite of all time! Bought a growler and we brought it with us to Dark Skies! (Shhh) This is a must if you are in Port Austin/Caseville area with kids! Our server Laura was great :) Bring the kids and enjoy a night out ;) read more

Thumb Brewery - Breweries Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

I have to admit, I was a bit disappointed with the experience here, should have had more selection with beer. The menu looks decent until you read the small print that they will not do special requests like leaving mayo off a sandwich if you don't want it. I had a cheeseburger that was cooked too hot and too fast so that it was crispy black on the outside and pink in the center. I'd recommend checking other restaurants in town - this one needs to improve their operation. read more

Fun little brewery in a house. Patio outside and a lot of variety in beers. I'm not a big beer drinker so did some samples - pumpkin spice is excellent. Not too sweet. And they have a new coconut porter i really liked too. And then a nice wine selection so kept me happy while others kept going on beer tasting! And great chili read more

Hostess who seated us wasn't overly friendly but our waitress was great. We stopped here after the beach...Kind of stumbled upon this place when I went to turn around to go to a bar. Sat outside and sampled brews for awhile. It was perfect. Seems they allow your well behaved dog to sit outside on the patio too. That's always a plus for dog owners! Good selection of beer. read more

Thumb Brewery - Breweries Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

See all

Great selection of both house brewed beers and craft beers. The Bloody Mary bar is outstanding, I've never seen such a selection of items to create your own Bloody Mary, I was greatly pleased to find pickled asparagus in the choices. Great food as well, and often entertainment. When they don't have live music, the house system and selection of vinyl is fantastic. All in all a great experience not to be missed when visiting the Thumb. read more

Everything is ok, the food was fantastic but the environment not to friendly. They need to have a welcome feeling. Actually Jeff was great after all. read more

Truthfully we are bummed. We came up to Caseville from 2 hours away for a day trip and called to order some takeout...we ordered 2 salads called the thumb brewery Salad off their online menu and they told us it was now called the Michigan salad..ok, fine. We get these salads that we paid 28.00 for and it was literally wilted lettuce with a few cherries and a few walnuts. On the menu it said it came with bacon, red onion, and blue cheese in addition to these things...so gross. So bummed. read more

Thumb Brewery - Breweries Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

one of my most favorite places in caseville very friendly owners food always good and love sitting outside.

We came here with our toddler as we remembered it had outdoor seating with some room. We also remembered a better menu. Pizza, hoagies, wraps and boring appetizers. Wife ordered pepperoni pizza, I had a turkey swiss hoagie. Got a mac and cheese plate for the kid. Pizza was no better than store bought microwave. High school cafe made a better hoagie. Mac and cheese was FROZEN in the middle. Waitresses were great with crayons and bubbles. Feel sorry they have to work here. The beer menu is good with some tasty locals but it doesn't make up for the unimaginative, poor quality food. read more

Thumb Brewery - Tiny hoagie that was supposed to be toasted - Breweries Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

What a great place! The food was excellent, the beer was awesome....I can't wait to go back and try some of the other flavors. The real appeal is the service though! Tanya, our server, greeted us like old friends when we came in. She had an answer for almost every question and knew who to ask when she didn't. We don't know anything about beer, but she was patient with us and explained the process and the pairings. Because of this I was able to try the oatmeal stout, which was really good. Our server suggested the beer cheese soup and I have to admit, I wouldn't have tried it on my own. I am so glad I did though and will be coming back for more. Greet beer, great food, great service... I'd give it ten stars if I could. Thumb Brewery is my new 'Up North' spot. read more

Last year was a plesant suprise with great beer selections, enthusiastic staff and homely atmosphere. My first visit this spring was a disappointment with inattentive staff and unimaginative food. Hope things return to last year's level of excellnce. read more

Food, wine, ambiance, and music were all top notch. Definitely the best food I've had in Caseville as a vegetarian.

The front yard was very welcoming on a sunny warm day, no bugs not too hot, perfect. There was some contemplation as to which table we should sit at with out two dogs. Eventually the two hosts settled on a spot. The waitress was ...unique. The service was prompt and friendly, encouraging about trying some beer samples including her favorite which was so good that I ordered a second beer of the one she recommended. The menu is advertised as remarkable cuisine, that is just hilarious. How remarkable is a ham sandwich, how about a BLT? Ha. The waitress said that no one orders hoagies (versus wraps) and most certainly not a bean burger on one. She would see if the kitchen could do it. They managed it some how. Our sandwiches were good even if my hoagie was missing about 3 inches in length compared to my husband's. We ordered their beer and had a few samples only one was worthy of a cup (note I did not say pint or glass, they only pour 12 oz for the price we've been paying for a pint ($5-$6) in a plastic cup). Luckily, they have a very nice selection of guest beers. read more

We had a party of 6 and decided to stop in for lunch. We were seated quickly and had relatively prompt service. We all ordered beers and a had a couple of appetizers, the pretzels and the feta dip. The pretzels were good but the feta dip was outstanding. The beer wasn't anything special, I wouldn't go back for it. We all had various pizzas. The Greek and the club (a blt pizza with ham and pickles) were the favorites. The BBQ chicken was just ok. The service was also just average. read more

Do not recommend this Brewery! We were seated but that was pretty much all welcome we got. No waitress stopped by our table to ask AT LEAST if we would like to get a drink or something! Nothing. Very disappointing. No waitress came by for 20 minutes. We got up and LEFT! Thumb Brewery THANK YOU for no service. We will not come here ever again. Bye read more

The new owners have done a wonderful job bringing this place back to life. Many upgrades abs good food and beer!! Let's goooooo! Great craft beer selection. The brewer is doing an amazing job!! read more

The service is amazing, the food is fabulous and the brews are something to write home about. Nick the brewer has a great talent, always having guest taps and delicious wine too! The patio is always packed, great talent singing and Music bingo is always a riot:-). Come check it out.. you won't be disappointed!! read more

First time here and we tried the Buffalo Chicken Dip which was good! Staff is friendly, clean place, and did I mention they have Beer? Lol! Tried the Raspberry Rubaeus Ale and the Oatmeal Cream Pie! You won't be disappointed! read more

Thumb Brewery - Buffalo Chicken Dip - Breweries Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

Thumb Brewery is a Not To Miss Beer & Pizza experience! We enjoyed Greek and bbq chicken pizza!! YUM. Great waitstaff. Tonya was perfect!! read more

Nice location in an old house. Good pub food & nice environment. Would visit again if ever in Caseville area

New owners since summer of 2020. Beer is just ok. Food is processed- burgers were frozen patties and even my chicken sandwich was a pre-cooked chicken breast. The chicken was promised to be smothered in mozzarella, but this was not true at all- barely could see it. It came with pesto on a brioche bun. Very dry and tasteless. Sandwiches served with chips are all in excess of $12 which is too high for mediocre processed foods. Nice atmosphere outside, but not a "must go to" place. read more

So nice sitting on their patio enjoying a delicious flatbread and a glass of wine. The owner, Lauren, explained they were renovating the kitchen to expand their menu and adding to the wine list. They are also very committed to preventing Covid. We will be back. read more

Well, after 3 visits to Thumb Brewery in the past 7 days I feel I am now adequately familiar enough to give an accurate description! I'll say this up front, this brewery is still experiencing some growing pains; from the menu, decor and seating arrangements. PRO'S 1. Helpful and attentive staff. 2. Very Good Craft Beer Selection 3. Fair Prices for Pints & Food 4. Quick Food Service (Once you ordered) CON'S 1. Major Issues with Seating Came in tonight and our party was told it would be about a 20 minute wait time. 90 minutes later we had a table. It wasn't a huge issue since we didn't have anywhere to be but regardless no one really likes to wait for an hour over your estimated seating time. They so take reservations! Call ahead. 2. Hit & Miss On the Menu After trying 5 items on the menu there are definitely some winners and losers. The Pizza Sub Sandwich and Margarita pizza were both delicious! The pretzels, beer cheese soup, cheese and sausage platter and veggie burger are all pretty decent. The grilled chicken sandwich definitely tastes like something from the frozen food aisle of your local grocer. Not horrible but not what you would expect when someone else is preparing it and definitely was a frozen block at one point. - no grill yet. Will be revisiting once the grill is actually there. 3. Sit outside if possible. The inside is still in heavy need of work and it's definitely not the most optimum place to catch the game or enjoy any kind of atmosphere at all. 4. Overpriced Growlers, "Special Growlers" and refills. Growlers here are exactly 100% higher than in Royal Oak. $4 will get you a growler at ROB and Bastone's and refills are under $10. $8 will get you a Growler at the Thumb Brewery and most beers cost at least $20 to refill. This is Caseville not LA... Additional Notes: Seems to be struggling with identity. Can't tell if this is actually a family restaurant or brewery. From my humble experience you are eventually going to have to choose between the two. Either or is fine but you aren't really going to be able to achieve both or at least this would be a first. Only one bathroom for men and women. Smaller bar, only a 6 seater. On a closing note, I will definitely be checking out the Thumb Brewery again in the future. Just hoping they make some much needed improvements and continue to offer the best beer selection in Caseville. read more

Let's be clear here folks...the name is Thumb Brewery. The first and only pub in the Thumb dedicated to craft beers made on-site and other regional selections. They now have a solid year of experience under their belts and it's showing. There signature brew is the Oatmeal Stout. Yummy. They make batches of 50 gal. at a time. Over the winter they released their first IPA...excellent. As mentioned in the other reviews their food selection is strictly bar fare. I've stuck to the appetizers which is a perfect nibble with one of their pints. I would give 5 stars if they can expand their seating and lower the beer prices a bit. They offer a membership with includes a growler and a glass. My benchmark is Blackrocks in Marquette. read more

Thumb Brewery - Shanty Days - Breweries Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

See all

Amazing pizza and great assortment of beers on draft to try. The bartender and wait staff are friendly and helpful. If you are in Caseville or anywhere close, you should not miss this place! read more

Thumb Brewery - Breweries Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

Delicious! Even with a limited menu because of Covid, it was great! The food is great and the cocktails are awesome. We will definitely be back when we come back up. read more

We were seated outside and my wife was cold so we asked if we could be seated inside. The waiter said sure just go inside and grab any table that wasn't taken. So we did, but no one ever came to serve us. We flagged down a waiter and managed to get our order in. We ordered an appetizer and our meals, but they all came at the same time. The appetizer was wrong and our meals were already cold when they came. The beer was good, so just come and drink you'll be fine. read more

Beer was good. Food was subpar. Service was subpar. Outdoor seating only when it was 90 outside.

Stopped in on Easter Sunday, which was our first time visiting Thumb Brewery. Basic food options which suited us well. Food and service was excellent. We will visit again and utilize their large patio area. Nice meeting the owners as well. read more

Had an excellent dinner with friends last night at the thumb brewing company. We started out with horseradish cheese and warm pita wedges. The cheese was very tasty and the potassium were perfectly warm, toasty and soft. Very good. My wife had the thumb brewery salad. It was most delicious but was a salad you could definitely get at other fine establishments. I on the other hand toiled with having the PB&J burger, the combination sounds very interesting but I just wasn't digging strawberry jelly with jalapeños, maybe next time. Instead I settled on the cowboy burger. The bbq sauce was more of a sweet chili sauce than a bbq sauce but was absolutely delicious. We had our kids with us and I felt the kids meal prices were a bit high ($5 for Mac and cheese with chips), but the large fresh baked cookie to end the meal was a huge hit with the kids. From a service perspective Our waiter did an excellent job at keeping up with two families with kids going a little crazy. The restaurant was quite empty when we were there so I'm assuming that was part of why the service was so excellent, but I'll take it. Overall some unique items on the menu that was very tasty. The prices were around the right ballpark for the quality of food (maybe a little high for the thumb, but overall in line with expectations). Ironically we didn't try any of their beer, but they had a lot of other michigan breweries on tap. Service was good and we'll definitely be visiting again! read more

Ambient. Good beer selection. Almost 1/2 friendly, in a Michigan crass egotistical way. My compliments end there. I almost never dock for service but this was pretty bad. I changed my mind while ordering and the guy couldn't get past it. Went from one sandwich no mayo to a a different sandwich no cheese. I can promise I said "no cheese" 3 times because it threw him for a loop. Of course the sandwich came with cheese, he got all pissy and said no, you said no mayo. Yes, I explained, on the first sandwich I ordered, but this sandwich doesn't even come with mayo. Then he came back and said they tried to scrape the cheese off but it was baked on so they had to remake it. Uh...yeah I think so. When we got our food, none of it was good. Mine was meh, my friends chicken dish was tiny and flavorless, my husband's medium rare burger was cooked to a crisp. No thanks. Oh, and they aren't a brewery like how you'd think, they have craft beers that other people make on the menu, and two selections they make that aren't very good. read more

Our waitress was so kind and helpful. Laura was great with my kids as well. Pizza and beer were great. I even enjoyed the samples. We will be back read more

Thumb Brewery - Rogue Hazelnut Brown - Breweries Near Me - Caseville, Michigan