Went to their pop-up New Haven-style pizza night and ordered the pepperoni and sausage apizze. Would have preferred the custard to be a little more charred/crispy. They sliced the pizza into 12 slices so it was harder to judge the "Flop" of the slices. That being said when I took my first bite I thought it was the best bite of pizza I've had in Syracuse. I think it's significantly better than the regular wood grilled pizzas I usually get here. read more

Toss & Fire - Pepperoni and Sausage Apizze - Pizza Near Me - Camillus, New York

I've been here twice to eat in quickly while shopping and such and it works well. Although they were busy with take out orders our pizza came out quickly and delicious. Honestly I would have rather had a longer wait so it cooked for longer and didn't have a floppy center but either way delicious. I appreciate their quick service seating, tables inside and outside could be cleaner. Staff was friendly read more

Toss & Fire - The Daino Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Camillus, New York

See all

Toss n Fire is my fave wood fired pizza place out of all that I've had including those in the DMV area. Every year during the New York State Fair they put out specialty pizzas. This year I tried Toss n Fire & Ji-Woo's collab Sweet Bop Pizza. Normally I do not finish a whole pizza and I save some for home. This pizza was so good, and fresh, that I finished it in one go. I'm a huge bulgogi fan and the sweet chili sauce added to that sweet hot flavor. This is everything you want in a limited time collab pizza. When I dine-in at either the Camillus or North Syracuse location I usually get the Deanna which has spicy tomato oil, pepperoni, ricotta, and mozzarella. As you can guess, I like a little heat on my pizzas. Toss n Fire offers pizzas in various sizes and styles so you can try something new and find your new favorite style of pizza! Their food takes a bit of time to cook because each pizza is made to order, but it still comes out fairly quick. It's hot, delicious, and the staff are friendly. Give them a try! It may become your new fave pizza spot as well. read more

Toss & Fire - Close up of Sweet Bop Pizza with bulgogi, scallions, & sweet chili sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Camillus, New York

See all

Build it and they will come. Correct? That's what you can do at the toss & fire woodfired pizza. Looking at the pizza options here they offer your classic New York style, Detroit style. (I needed an explanation on this one), or wood fired. Of course you gotta go with the wood fired. They offer a variety of ready created pie options. I chose the 12." cheese with two toppings. For that I chose mushroom and red peppers. The pizza was cooked fast. It was not too thick or not too thin. There was plenty of sweet tasting sauce and plenty of gooey cheese. They didn't skimp on the mushrooms or red pepper either. Overall, an excellent pie for $16. read more

See all

Soggy wings not crispy pizza was ok. bill came out to $34 could of got better wing at BWW for less One time is enough read more

Toss & Fire - Thin not crispy cheap on the cheese ok flavor - Pizza Near Me - Camillus, New York

See all

Had a weeknight dinner at Toss & Fire at Township 5. We tried the honey pot pizza and the sweet & hot chicken tender special. The pizza was delicious and fresh as usual, and the chicken tenders were good value for the price (5 large tenders for $8.99). They were served with a generous helping of maple syrup, and I added blue cheese on the side. This is a good spot for a high-quality, casual meal. read more

Toss & Fire - Honey Pot Pizza - 12" Wood-Fired - Pizza Near Me - Camillus, New York

See all

I've always enjoyed the crispiness and char from a wood fired pizza and Toss & Fire does it so well. They have been doing pop-ups of the New Haven style "Apizza"! After hearing wonderful feedback I pre-ordered a Cheese pizza ( New Haven style of course) These pop ups, right now, are held on Mondays when they are normally closed. They currently serve approximately 6-7 varieties all New Haven style along with soda , wine and beer. They had a full crew all working hard to keep ahead of the orders as well as serve walk in customers. My pizza was ready on time and it was hot. Of course I sat down with my boxed pizza to eat one slice.... which turned into 3 slices!! Be careful because the pizza is thin with a beautiful, crispy crust so it's easy to just keep eating. The renovation inside is very nice and there is lots of comfortable seating. The employees are so nice, as always and I saw Nick slinging pies with the crew. read more

See all

Every time I eat here I'm reminded of why it's the best pie in Syracuse. So so so good. The Detroit style honey-pot is to die for. Oh and my partner and I both agree the fried pickles are the best around as well. Keep it up. read more

Toss & Fire - Pizza Near Me - Camillus, New York

See all

Pizza Maven here making a trip to one of the hottest, trendiest pizza joints in CNY, Toss n Fire. After seeing the lines at the State Fair and reading good things, I had to give this 3-store local franchise a try. I ordered a 16" plain cheese pie and a large Detroit style pie with charred pepperoni. Both were appealing to the eyes and smelled pizzeria perfect. The crust on the 16" was perfect; nice chew, bake, and finish. Truly the strength and centerpiece of the pie. The sauce was good, but a little acidic. The cheese was too much and too gooey. It became soupy on top of the slice. No stretch or snap either. Slices were way better reheated because it rendered the cheese a bit firmer. Nevertheless, TnF worked mainly because they have a killer crust. On to the major disappointment; the Detroit pie. I got it with charred pepperoni so it wouldn't be as greasy as regular pepperoni. The pie looked fantastic in the box & smelled even better. But, the second I lifted a slab/ slice out of the box, I saw there was going to be a problem; an overflow of oil on the pie and all over the box reminiscent of Pizza Hut's greasy finishes. On their menu, TnF describes this pie as "their take on a Detroit" pie. They might as well have called it a Kalamazoo pie; nothing but the look was Detroit, where the pies are baked in actual auto oil pans and topped with brick cheese. TnF Detroit has so much of the wrong cheese on a too thick of an airy focaccia-like crust. The oil that came off of this pie bordered on disgusting; it soaked right through a heavy duty pizza box. I had to wash my hands with Dawn afterwards. There was a nice char along the edges only. The bottom was soggy and greasy (see pictures.) the crust too thick and soft. But, the greasy finish makes the Detroit among the worst pizzas I have recently eaten, and that includes some pretty bad ones in Chicago. read more

See all

The food is great and all but the wait takes so long. I do recommend coming but be prepared for the wait. Also it is usually really busy and the seats will all be full so as soon as you get inside get a seat. read more

Stopped in for pizza and appetizers about an hour before closing and everything was great. Really like the new spicy and sweet tenders!

Slices (garlic and pepperoni)were good the Arancini rather bland and barely warm. Definitely won't order them again. Service was good and inside just reminds me of a fast food restaurant, the area by the register seems cramped and packed in. read more

Toss n Fire is always a treat when we don't want regular pizza. We love trying their speciality wood fire pizza. We dined in their Camillus location for lunch after attending a dance recital. They did remodeling recently and I like booths they put in better than the layout before. What we got for lunch was their garlic knots, my husband loved them. You get three in an order but they were big that three was definitely more than enough for appetizer. My husband ordered the buffalo chicken pizza which he really enjoyed. Our family members ordered the vegan cheeky monkey and Tessa's veggie with vegan cheese. They loved it and love they that offer vegan cheese option. I ordered the Detroit Hot Pot pizza. It's one of my favorite, perfect amount of heat, sweet and freshness from the basil. I also like ordering cheeky monkey pizza. I ordered regular cheese pizza and French fries for our little ones. You can't go wrong there, the fries had salt and lots of black pepper but my kids didn't mind. It was nice to dine in, we usually do takeout and both experiences have been great. read more

See all

The Detroit style pizza is delicious! Definitely a place to go before going to the movie tavern! I highly recommend!

Always receive great service and great food. My one complaint about the wings is that sometimes the sauce doesn't stick to them. With the new dining room renovation the inside is cozy and clean. I have tried many different items off the menu and always been pleased. It can be on the pricier side for pizza but these are wood fired pizzas with quality ingredients. They also make some of my favorite fried mozzarella around. read more

See all

All specialty pizzas were delicious and great staff. We enjoyed our first time to the restaurant

BEST PIZZA EVER. Especially when the manager, Craig, is working - pizza comes out 12/10! Had to post this after trying the Apizza style! read more

What a wonderful place! As we entered, we were warmly greeted and presented with menus. There is a great selection of pizzas, calzones and a number of appetizers and drinks. We decided to eat in and our order was quickly and cheerfully delivered to our table. Whomever trains the staff here does a great job! The food is fab. The Caesar salad was large enough to share for three people, or two if you eat with my husband. We also had a huge calzone, a small wood fired pizza (outrageously good), fried pickles and an order of boneless chicken wings. Everything was served piping hot and was top notch. The tables are kept clean and there is plenty of seating. This is a great place to hit after or before a movie. read more

See all

I consistently get great food here. I will continue to be a repeat customer. The availability of cauliflower crust is great too. read more

Great pizza and salad with their new menu. Also, pizza and salad was ready when they said it would be. Staff are courteous at the restaurant. Enjoy that crispy pizza and especially the pickle pizza read more

I'm not the biggest fan of thin crust wood fired pizza. In my experience, it's usually a glorified flour tortilla you can eat in one sitting at the same price of a regular pizza. I'm all about sauce wherever it applies, so I don't really gravitate toward the dry, crispy pizzas even when they're clearly made with love. I never really gave this place much thought beyond that. I know they've got a huge presence in the city, and they're big at the state fair and in the food truck scene. It was only when we saw the Mexican Street Corn pizza we decided to give it a try anyway. This was when we learned they don't just do the lightweight stuff, but you can get whatever pizza you want on a crust that wouldn't shatter if you dropped it. This was crazy, because they've got a huge list of great looking specialty pizzas, and it felt like this door just opened for us. So last week we did the Mexican Street Corn pizza and some Cheeky Monkey wings. I don't get the reference, but I see the name mentioned a lot so figured it was worth trying. I also realized I've never had Mexican Street Corn either, so I have no reference or understanding with which to compare the pizza. As expected though, the pizza was loaded up with corn, jalapenos and delicious white sauce and we absolutely loved it. It actually had a reasonable spicy kick to it and it all worked out better than I'd ever imagined it could. We did this on a New York style crust. The dough was still light, and a bit more dry and stretchy than we'd go for on our own. We were just relieved to have a NY Style vehicle for these pizzas, so we're still in. The wings themselves were great. We ordered extra crispy, and they actually made them crispy! Good size, cooked amazing and had a great taste. Even with extra sauce, they definitely felt lacking. The Cheeky Monkey sauce is thin and oily, so it mostly runs off the wings and pools. It did have a good, tangy and "politely spicy" taste to it. I'll bet it'd be good on a salad. Today was our next pizza day, and we knew we were craving specialty so it had to be here. This time we went with Detroit style crust. We've never been crazy about Detroit style, but we've been coming around to it lately. Today after some stressful deliberation, we decided on the Joey Fried Pizza. Buffalo Base with a ranch drizzle and three kinds of meat, seemed like a no-brainer after we labored over the decision for 2 hours. Their Detroit style crust is excellent. The perfect delivery for these amazing and unique specialty pizzas. Joey really came through, and it was exactly as good as it sounded. Just a pile of good meat, and we were surprised once again with a pleasant spicy kick. This time we got buff-a-que, because we figured it'd be thicker and should stick to the wings. Still got extra sauce and of course extra crispy. These guys have some of the best wings I think. The sauce was as good as it sounded and it stuck well to the meat. Having a large dippy cup with extra sauce was worth the extra dollar. This time they came in a metal tray, so we can heat them up in the oven. The prices are good, the service seems fine. I love the black dust you get on your hands eating a wood fired pizza. My only complaint is the very distinct smell. The first time I walked in I thought someone had just thrown up in there. Turns out that's all the time, and nobody else seems to mind it. That tells me there's a valid context for the smell I just don't understand. Still though, I know I couldn't eat in there because of that. That's why god invented takeout. We're definitely coming back whenever we need a good specialty pizza. There's so many amazing choices that seem like a sure thing. We might even swallow our pride and try the thin crust just to see if we can understand all the hype. read more

See all

I absolutely love Toss and fires pizza. They have the best menu options and everything is so customizable. They also make it easy to order online. This picture was from the fair but their shop in Camillus is also awesome. read more

Toss & Fire - birria pizza - Pizza Near Me - Camillus, New York

If there was an option for 0 stars I would have clicked it 1000 times this might have been the most mediocre piece of shit pizza I've ever had.went to take a bite and the whole thing was one piece then when I picked it up the cheese and sauce all slid off.Didn't feel like asking for a refund because I would never want to spend my money here again.Ive spent money on stupid shit but this might have been the worse 20 dollars I've ever spent read more

This fire wood pizzeria is conveniently located near several stores in Camillus. This place is very casual and offered what we needed for a late lunch. We ordered and everything took less than 20 min (from ordering to getting our food). The pizza was decent but I felt mine needed a bit more salty components. Next time I'll try the create your own option and see how that goes. read more

Toss & Fire - Spinach & Artichoke Pizza - 12" Small Wood-Fired - Pizza Near Me - Camillus, New York

See all

The pizza was so special. I liked that it was made to order personal pizzas. We had great service. The space was inviting and bright.

awesome food!!! great staff! Echo is awesome he always greets us with a big hello and a smile. Staff is always working hard while we are there. read more

We were headed out to eat with my granddaughter and she did not want to go where we had planned. It was a pre-birthday celebration and she wanted pizza. So we pulled over, put in directions for the closest pizza joint, and ended up at Toss & Fire Pizza. I had heard good things about their pizzas so I was excited to give it a try. She simply wanted a cheese pizza so we ordered her a personal size for her very own. She loved it. We also ordered some bone-in wings and she was a huge fan of those!! She loves her dad's smoked brisket and has fancy tastes for an almost 7 yr old! Steak, shrimp, crab legs, yeah, we got lucky when she said she only wanted pizza! We ordered the Hawaiian pizza. It was very good. Different from what I'm used to, this had a red sauce, ham, pineapple, and sweet red peppers. A nice touch. We ate almost everything but the two pieces we brought home were even delicious cold. The outside crust was pretty dry and hard the next day though and almost impossible to eat. Overall, quite pleased. There was was quite a few people there but the staff were on top of things. Everyone seemed to be very friendly, polite, and hard-working. They seemed to be a great working team. We haven't seen a lot of that when we we've been out at restaurants lately. Many places after COVID have been sparsely staffed and things have not been great. This place seems to have it together!! Kudos read more

AMAZING food! Pizza and wings are always top notch. Salt Potato Pizza is the family favorite. Great atmosphere!

We finally got to try out the pizza here and we were not disappointed! I was going to snap some pictures but we were so excited to eat our personal pizzas that I completely forgot. Oops! We tried the Tessa's veggie, Four the Love of Cheese, and two Build Your Owns. The veggie was perfect for vegetarians because it was topped full of broccoli, tomatoes and garlic. If you like gorgonzola cheese, the Four the Love of Cheese is just for you! If you want to mix things up definitely build your own. The possibilities are endless. Next time I'm definitely going to try some of the appetizers which looked so good when I saw them when passing other people's table. I also loved the rustic feel of the restaurant! If you order online, definitely double check that your order gets sent to the right location! Ours accidentally went to the wrong location but one of the lovely employees was so nice to call and get our order switched to be made in Camillus. We were so thankful for that!! read more

Really solid pizza place, we were tired of Doc's tough and bland pizzas, and this place really delivered. Fresh, good quality toppings, flavorful sauce and crust - all great. The wings are a bit soggy, even when ordered extra crispy, but still really good and very minor given the quality of everything. Very happy to have found a new regular spot. read more

I've been here a couple times and I absolutely love the pizza. I love how they have different types because I prefer a deep dish and not many places around make deep dish pizzas, but my real favorite thing is their fried pickles. I've always loved fried pickles, but I've only had fried pickle chips, these were spears, and I am obsessed. Will be going back whenever I need some guilty pleasure food. read more

Well, being from WNY we knew pizza can rarely be a let down and I know brick oven pizza never disappoints. Service was very kind - free refills is a HUGE win for me... It came out quick and was super delicious. read more

Great pizza with lots of meatza flavor and wood fired for a unique texture and added flavor. read more

Toss & Fire - Meatza pizza - Pizza Near Me - Camillus, New York

Food was excellent would definitely recommend, if you want good pizza in Syracuse, the service was a bit slow at first but picked up as more people came, the ambiance was somnolent and had vivacity at the same time. 10/10 read more

I have never had a bad meal from Toss & Fire. Everything is always cooked great and timely. Service is always friendly and helpful.

Have only tried the pizza but everything has been good. Love the salt potato pie! Salt Potato Pizzas Cheese Pizza read more

Went here Saturday night for the first time for a slight girls night. We got to try 3 of the state fair themed pizzas + the caramel apple dessert pizza and a ton of wings. Everything was amazing and will definitely be back again. I'd say my favorite is the poutine pizza and the tomato oiled wings with blue cheese. They had quite the selection of beverages as well. We kept to 1911 cider for this dinner but am interested in other drinks on the menu for another visit! read more

See all

Glad we have in Camillus. Whatever pizza I order it always comes out great. My picks are the Garlic Broccoli or the Marqherita. If you like spicy try the Cheeky Monkey. Service was fast and friendly and easy to order online. read more

Toss & Fire - My Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Camillus, New York

I've been a fan of Toss & Fire Wood-Fired Pizza for a long time. Visiting them at food truck rodeos, festivals and the NY State Fair. I've always have had a consistently well prepared and delicious pizza. They have two brick and mortar locations. The North Syracuse location is the original. They opened their second location at Township 5 in Camillus back in the fall of 2020. This review is of their Camillus location. I have been to this location numerous times and always order three wood fired pies on each visit. The wood fired pizzas come in 10 inch and 12 inch pies. For this visit the three wood fired pies all had a nice crisp crust. The Margherita had fresh mozzarella and the perfect flavor balance of basil and garlic. Tessa's Veggie had fresh vegetables such as tomato, broccoli and pecorino. You didn't miss a veggie in every slice. We also wanted to try a "novelty" type of wood fired pizza. We went with one that Toss & Fire created for the NY State Fair, the Bit of a Pickle. Garlic, Applewood bacon, Mozzarella, Cheddar, dill pickles and a ranch drizzle. Don't sell this pie short. All the flavors worked well together. I learned not to term some foods a "novelty" until I try it! Instead I will change the term to unique. They still have a couple more "unique" pies that I have not tried yet! The chicken wings were ordered extra crispy with hot Buffalo sauce. An order comes with ten wings. They were nice sized wings and glad I ordered them extra crispy because when I got home they seemed like they had a normal crisp to them. Will not knock that since it was takeout and I'm sure if I ate at the restaurant they would of been as ordered. The staff are always welcoming and able to answer any questions you may have while placing your order. Once you order they give you a vibrating beeper to let you know when your order is ready. If it's longer than 20 minutes I like to walk around Township 5 checking out the other shops. You can also order online from their website. Toss & Fire also has normal NY style pizza oven pies along with Detroit style pizza. Looking forward to trying their Detroit styles pizza in the future. read more

See all

Before movie with friends we decided on Toss N Fire. I'm not a huge pizza eater but I do love wings. I had the Buffacue wings crispy and an order of garlic Parmesan chips which were huge and amazing and the wings were perfect and tasty. My friends shared a couple pizzas and loved them as well. The customer service was outstanding and Christina took the time to touch all of the tables in the dining room as well as deliver the food and help with order taking making our experience enjoyable. We will definitely return before movie again. read more