Let me be clear, there was nothing wrong with the service, food, or ambiance. The turkey slices were thick and tasty. The 8-grain bread is healthy. It's just that I remember the days of the Neapolitan pizza and white bread and a fuller menue. The sandwiches are served without sides--no chips, even for sale separately. The decor has been updated, thankfully, since the new management. It just seems like there is less now. Fewer options in the bakery case, fewer menu options. I hope they will continue to do what they do well and then add to the menu. read more

See all

Counter service only; coffee house music, popular with the SUNY Fredonia students, and town families. Really great looking chocolate chip cookies for sale, with smoothies, coffee and teas read more

Great spot for quality food! We came here after a local couple recommended it. Gluten free and vegetarian options available. The tomato mushroom soup was creamy and full of flavor. Bread served with it was thick and delicious. Nice variety of smoothies, pizza, paninis and salads. read more

New owners took over. Quality has gone down. We are not patronizing until they get their act together.

When I don't have the time or energy to make farm to table meals, The Upper Crust has been my go to for Bread, Lemon Loaf, cookies, soup and sandwiches, since High School & then as an Ambassador/Tour Guide for SUNY at Fredonia. Powering PoliSci/Blue Devil Diplomat Barbie, since 2007! Thank you for my blueberry lemon loaf, peanutbutter hotchocolate and PEACE! love the team at Upper Crust! Make sure you pop by, whether you're here for a tour, hockey otrclass! read more

Upper Crust Bake House - Upper Crust reusable Lemon Loaf Box! - Bakeries Near Me - Fredonia, New York

See all

Great coffee and tea drink options. This is a great local establishment. Very cozy inside too. Recommend.

Cute little coffee shop right in he middle of things on Main Street. We stopped in after having lunch down the street and were pleased with everything. The decor is minimal, but inviting. The whole front wall is a window with a seating nook on each end. I absolutley love places with these books as they are such great places to people watch! We sat outside at one of the few tables they had because it was just too nice of a day to sit inside. There were a good selection of pastries and a delicious looking food menu, but as we had just finished lunch we stuck to coffee. My husband had a cappuccino and I ordered the iced lavender latte off of the seasonal menu. Just a note, I love all things lavender flavored, but it is a flavor a lot of people don't care for in coffee. So bear this in mind if you decide to try it. It's probably the flavor you don't like, not the drink that was made for you. We were both happy with our drinks and would recommend stopping in here if you are in town! read more

See all

Stopped here for lunch on a drive from Niagara Falls to Pittsburgh. Very small and was packed. Menu was small but plenty of options ranging from soup to salad to sandwiches, and a nice selection of beer and wine. Ordered two half sandwiches and a bowl of soup. Was told there would be a 20 minute wait but ended up being closer to 40. There was a sign advertising that the place is short staffed so I have sympathy in this current environment, but it was hard to deal with while my 7 year old was hangry and I likely would have gone elsewhere if the wait time listed was accurate. Also thought the counter staff was very unfriendly but I'm sure this also has to do with being short staffed. Food was delicious and that's why I'm giving it 4 stars. We had the turkey vegetable soup, ham and Swiss panini, and turkey sandwich. I would inhale a loaf of the bread it came on as well. Maybe it's just because we were starving from waiting for so long... but the food was worth the wait. Staff should do what they can to get wait times more accurately listed though. read more

Good sandwich and very large. A half sandwich was more than enough for lunch. Added a cup of soup but couple only finish half. Good value and quality. read more

Superb soups, sandwiches and baked goods. A little on the busy side so expect to wait a bit on your order. At some times of day you won't get a seat. I guess that is a sign of how well regarded they are. read more

I've been here several times - before and after covid. The espresso drinks are always reliably good. The tomato mushroom soup is delicious. The bread served with the soup is delicious too. The atmosphere is minimal and I like it better since their redo - less college grungy - a new, nicer look after their renovations. The tables are often not wiped off which is something they could improve upon. The staff is usually impolite. It feels like it's an imposition to come in for lunch. This was the situation before covid as well. The staff also literally YELLS out when an order is ready. This place could be managed better. Also, it's time to get back to real dishes and silverware. It's a good place to go if you want espresso in the area, and I do love their soup. One of those spots where you know what you're going to get - good drinks and food but nothing warm or welcoming past that. read more

Friendly atmosphere, adorable place with just good food. Save some room for dessert and or coffee or tea . Large portions. Yum!

Glad to see they are offering gluten-free bread, but why would you put scrambled eggs on avocado toast? I've always had avocado toast served with a fried egg. It's definitely not as good with a scrambled egg. read more

Upper Crust Bake House - Vegan breakfast burrito - Bakeries Near Me - Fredonia, New York

Upper Crust used to be a five-star joint, but ownership recently changed hands a few things need to change to get back to that rating. Generally, I order the crust special (side salad, bowl of soup and a piece of bread). The tomato mushroom soup is absolutely out of this world. If you are going to start with something, that should be it!! The apple-cider vinaigrette salad dressing was also absolutely delicious- so fresh and flavorful. Here's the issue...my bread was hard. It tasted like they had previously cut the bread and let it sit out in the air, thus making it hard. The bread for meals should be cut immediately before serving so that this doesn't happen. There is usually a wide-selection of baked goods-I personally like the double-chocolate "drop" cookies, but I haven't really had a bad treat here. There is water available, along with a wide-variety of coffee beverages. There is a back and a front entrance (back has more parking!). read more

Upper Crust Bake House - Crust special- Tomato mushrooms soup and side salad w apple cider vinaigrette dressing - Bakeries Near Me - Fredonia, New York

Our entire group enjoyed the meal from the Upper Crust Bake House. The choices provided were great for all parties and the size of the portions were excellent. I had the Tomato Mushroom Soup with a Ham and Cheese Panini and they were a great combination. The soup was some of the best tomato soup I have ever had. The other's in my party had the Garden Veggie soup and Tommy Club and they thought those items were wonderful as well. The sandwiches had just the right amount of ingredients and utilizing roasted turkey as opposed to lunch meat turkey was a wonderful extra. Definitely will visit the Upper Crust again on our next trip to Fredonia. read more

The staff is always very sweet and accommodating but the food is just fine. I got an egg sandwich and there was a lot of egg (overwhelming in my opinion) and not enough of anything else. It was just unseasoned egg and bread. I will always go back the Turkey panini though and the vibes in there are always nice. Cute little cafe. read more

All I can say is Yum! If you stop by Fredonia, you should definitely check out this fabulous little bakery. Everything is so fresh. I highly recommend it! read more

I was a regular customer here. My friends and I made this cafe our go-to for breakfast, and lunch. Everything is exceptional! That all changed this week, with their customer service. A friend found a piece of hair in her sandwich two weeks ago. We didn't speak up because things like this happen by mistake. We ordered again this week. Another hair, baked into a scone. I decided to reach out to Upper Crust, just in case someone wasn't following hair net protocols or management wasn't overseeing something in the kitchen. I reached out to let them know. Not for a refund, a replacement, or a gift card. Just to tell my favorite lunch spot that hair has been found multiple times. I sent them a message on Instagram, so I could send a picture of the hair hanging from the scone. (They are VERY active on Instagram, and I've personally asked them specific questions about menu items, so I knew this was a decent place to reach out.) They read it, saw the picture, and said nothing. I thought I'd give 24 hours .. people are busy, especially business owners. I "liked" all 10 story posts on their Instagram today, and they saw that too. It's now 30 hours later, and nothing. All I was looking for was an "I am so sorry this happened. I will double check our safety protocols with the kitchen staff today." That's it.. and I got nothing. It's unfortunate that my friends and I have lost our favorite lunch spot due to poor customer service. read more

Always have loved Upper Crust, especially for their soups and bakery items. The restaurant recently was sold to new owners and most of the food seems to be the same but they have "updated" a bit with fancy wood serving boards and better salad options coming soon. My favorite is the creamy potato soup and the chunks of fresh bread it comes with! We used to also love the cherry turnovers and oatmeal raisin cookies but I didn't see those being available anymore! I hope they bring them back! read more

Upper Crust Bake House - Vegetable soup and creamy potato - Bakeries Near Me - Fredonia, New York

Used to frequent this often when I was in college, but haven't been since probably 2016. What I can say from all of my experiences back then was that everything was so consistently good. Every sandwich and soup on the menu is absolutely delicious. I'm craving it now that I'm thinking about it. Amust visit if you're looking for a nice lunch. read more

The food is huge and delicious. The mornings are just so much better when you walk into Upper Crust. You walk in to a welcomed environment and the service is great. I had a half BLT sandwich and it was more than enough. read more

You'd think this was a side salad off the kid's menu, but it was $3.99 for a "small" salad... On top of that, there was hair in the salad. Outrageous. read more

Upper Crust Bake House - "Small" salad - Bakeries Near Me - Fredonia, New York

See all

I would give this place 10 Stars if I could. I love this sandwich shop. I live in Buffalo, but anytime I'm nearby I have to go there! Sometimes I'm tempted just to drive there for a sandwich. I always order the Wally (turkey sandwich with apples) because is just so good!!! I think the sandwiches are amazing because they have their own fresh homemade bread, I've taken a few people here and they love it too. I'm not even a huge sandwich person, but this place is just so good. The roasted turkey panini was also really good. I ordered the strawberry basil lemonade which was fantastic and my partner ordered the iced salted caramel latte which was fantastic as well. Highly recommend this place! Oh, and if you're lucky, they may have homemade bread you can buy! You might have to ask. Oh, I almost forgot, we ordered a chocolate brownie which was amazing! Great customer service as well. Small shop with some inside and some outdoor seating, we ended up setting up a trunk picnic with our folding chairs in the shade which was fun. read more

See all

I was headed from Jamestown to West Seneca earlier today and decided to stop at the Upper Crust in Fredonia for lunch. I accidentally closed out the online ordering sheet so when I called the restaurant back, the employee let me place my order and give my credit card information over the phone. I ordered a large (hot) mocha drink, a crazy cheese panini, and a cinnamon roll. The mocha was good. I enjoyed it. The crazy cheese panini comes in a whole or half. I ordered a whole sandwich. It came on eight grain bread. You can get it on white too. The inside of the sandwich had homemade garlic butter, Asiago cheese, American cheese, shredded cheddar, Swiss cheese, and provolone cheese. It had chopped tomatoes and purple onions. It was really great. I think next time I'll try it on white bread or try another one of their awesome offerings. I was talking to the one employee. She told me that they have new ownership and were remodeling. I loved the new decor. My sandwich was in one of those boxes that are good for the environment. The employee had wrapped my sandwich in foil before placing it in the box. I'm not sure if this is how they always do things for their takeout orders, or if she did it for me because she knew I had a long drive ahead of me. I thought it was really kind. My order came to $20.04 for the sandwich, cinnamon roll, and mocha. It was more than worth it, especially since the cinnamon roll will last me awhile. The next time I'm in Fredonia, I'll happily stop by. read more

See all

A bit pricy, but the food we've had thus far has been exceptional. Great homemade bread, and desserts. We love the double chocolate chip cookies. The potato soup is great too! read more

Whoa.... Maple. Latte. Strong coffee, mapley sweet. Super good! Blueberry Cloud! Like a soft biscuit loaded with fresh blueberries, drizzled with icing. These were both so good, & so special, that I'd bet there's lots of other amazing things to try here. read more

Forever and always a must have in Fredonia! The Waldorf skinny sandwich (turkey, green apple and special sauce) on the homemade bread has been a favorite of mine for years (don't forget to add a side of cream of potato soup!) The upper crust is such a fabulous little gem with all your bake good needs, coffee and cafe lunch spot! It's always busy, but they keep the line moving and every order is made fresh! read more

Upper Crust Bake House - Bakeries Near Me - Fredonia, New York

See all

We've been going to UC for years - before and after the recent owners took over. It's been well over a year since we've had it and today, my husband surprised us and brought it home to Orchard Park. Excited to eat my favorite sandwich (The Wally), I open the box only to find they now use your basic deli Turkey and no longer the freshly sliced thick Turkey meat. Extremely disappointed to say the least. And no more white bread? Just don't understand. read more

Upper Crust Bake House - Bakeries Near Me - Fredonia, New York

Tasty but slow. Bread dry. Baked goods so yummy - choc chip cookie with oooey gooey center and crisp edge

Ordered 3 sandwiches to go at 12:22pm. Was quoted 30 minutes. Showed up at 12:55 to pickup the sandwiches. They were not ready until 1:20pm. Completely unacceptable. Either quote the real wait time or close your business. No one has an hour to wait for 3 sandwiches. read more

The food was really food. The dining room full. I have 2 complaints. 1st my 1/2 sandwich was so big I could barley pick it up ( not sure that's really a complaint). Seriously was huge!. 4 stars because there were a lot of flies inside. I know that's a tough problem but it's really annoying. read more

WARNING TO ALL VETERANS!!! Let me please tell you what happened: I went to the Upper Crust Bake House in Fredonia this past weekend when I went to see the musicians perform at the "Rockin' at the Commons" event. The musicians were excellent!! Anyway, I waited in line at the Upper Crust Bake House while the person at the register made it a point to explain everything to the customers, quite nicely, I might add. When it was my turn to make an order, the person at the register, said, quite abruptly, "I'll be with you in a few minutes". I figured "OK, it is sort of busy and she needs to tend to other orders for a minute or two". Well, this person made it a point to avoid me for a lot more than a minute or two, even to the point to assist the Barista on duty, while ignoring me with money in my hand. Finally the Barista, who was quite nice and respectful, took my order. So guess what? As soon as my order was over, the regular person at the register returns and starts to take care of customers behind me. Why would this happen??? The only reason why I think this would happen is because I was wearing a cap that said "US Army Veteran". If I am wrong, please correct me Upper Crust Bake House! I have no idea why I would garner such disrespect from an employee (or is it the owner) of the Upper Crust Bake House. I posted a review similar to this on Google Maps and it has been removed!! So I will go to other websites to explain my experience. Well, guess what "Karen the Veteran Hater", I served so you could have the right to be an asshole to any customer you want to. I certainly hope you will not treat any other veteran the same way. Respectfully submitted. Paul Monaco Veteran of the United States Army read more

My ever-faithful comfort zone when I'm home for a visit. Love this place. Never had a bad experience, great for all ages, simple and high-quality deliciousness, pleasant setting, nice people, and they even play good music!! read more

Must try the tomato mushroom soup. Even my daughter who doesn't like mushrooms loves this soup!!

The new menu here is excellent! Plenty of vegan gluten free options. I had a make your own warm bowl. You get up to two options for your base and five toppings. All the dressings are also vegan gluten free. There are sweet treats for those with food preferences and the vegan gluten free chocolate chunk cookie did not disappoint. It wasn't overly sweet and had great texture! I can't wait to come back! read more

Upper Crust Bake House - Vegan gluten free chocolate chunk cookies. - Bakeries Near Me - Fredonia, New York

See all

Another of my favorite places! Still my favorite place for sandwiches in the world! If you're visiting, you will not be disappointed. The downtown area is beautiful and worth checking out. read more

Great lunch spot in Fredonia. Both the tomato soup and the vegetable soup are delicious. All the sandwiches are served on fresh homemade bread. The Wally is my favorite (turkey and apples). For dessert, you gotta try the Blueberry Cloud. It's like a moist scone with icing. Plenty of parking behind (there's a rear entrance). The dining area is small and can get busy during lunch hour. read more

Upper Crust Bake House - Cinnamon Roll and Italian Roast Coffee - Bakeries Near Me - Fredonia, New York

We stopped in for lunch and it is a hit. Fabulous soup and sandwiches with a roasted turkey cheddar panini where the turkey was clearly hand sliced off the bird. The Tomato Mushroom soup was sweet at first and then a hint of a burn. Then you dip the panini in the soup and you are wondering if you can just stay until you get hungry again so you can have more. Highly recommended. The coffee was good too. There is limited parking in front on the street but there is a lot in the back as well as a back entrance. read more

Upper Crust is one the of local gems in Fredonia. I have been enjoying their food and coffee since 2010 when I first came to Fredonia for college. Although they have had a change in ownership the recipes have stayed the same and the inside got a huge upgrade. When my family is in town from long island they almost always request Upper Crust for at least one meal. I suggest the tomato mushroom soup and the wally sandwich. read more

Love their potato soup!! Cookies and other baked goods are also delicious!