Pick up/Carry out/call ahead Pizza only. Loved the swanky jazz music playing while I waited. Looks like it was formerly or connected to Angilo's Pizza but still has that passed down through generations feel. The small pizza is a nice size for one person but there will be leftovers me. Let me tell you, it smells wonderful- you get the hint of garlic and oregano in the sauce. And as for the taste...excellent! The crust is both crispy yet satisfyingly doughy. Wow. As a NYC girlie practically raised on pizza I'm impressed. The flavor is wonderful. Definitely recommend! read more

Village Pizza - Personal Plain Pizza Big on flavor! - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

10/10 pizza super nice customer service Small pizza joint made fresh to order I am a Uber Eats driver and delivered food to the pizza shop and the owner offered me a free pizza and a drink! Pizza was absolutely delicious flat bread and I will definitely be going back for more read more

The inferno wings are oh oh oh so good. Garlic bread is some of the best. The staff is super friendly. Steak hoagies are one of top steak hoagies in the city. read more

I was in town for a convention, and was looking for some local pizza. Im glad I gave this spot a shot. The pizza was great!!! I love the new york thin style pizza. And the sauce was sweet and delicious. Can't wait for the next convention to have their pizza again. Only complaint is they didn't have a extra large pizza. Guess next time, we'll have to get 2. read more

Seriously the best! We love this hometown fish sandwich, steak hoagies and pizza! Don't forget the fries with cheese and the fried mushrooms. read more

Wow. Great Dough. Great Sauce. I felt like I was back in NY. I ordered a large pepperoni and mushroom pizza extra crispy. Awesome. read more

Great service! Awesome pizza and hoagie! Sauce was outstanding and crust incredible! Just the right amount of everything! THANK YOU AND WE WILL BE BACK! GLAD you are here in Sharonville! read more

One star for the super friendly fella who took our order! Zero stars for the tasteless, undercooked, terrible crust pizza. We couldn't even eat it. We are at a hotel and didn't have an oven to cook it longer and we didn't have any seasonings to give it some taste. Complete waste of $20 and going to bed hungry. read more

Pizza dropped off at front desk. Was notified went down. Driver gone. Pizza cold. Thanks

Wowwww amazing food amazing service. Truly a hidden gem. Owner is straight up a gift to the human race.

The pizza hoagie was the truth! Service was great don't let bad reviews fool ya! Angilo's pizza is and will always be Cincinnati staple!

Amazingly good food and such a friendly staff! A local favorite. And so close to Sharon Woods that you can dine au natural but with clothes lol read more

The pizza arrived sloppy, cold and with undercooked dough. I had been looking forward to trying this place as I pass by it often. Not much else to say about it really. Speechless read more

Village Pizza - The pizza arrived cold, sloppy and with no toppings. The taste was of cold, thin, undercooked dough. Very disappointing. - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

I had the pizza for the very first time, son and husband had the meatball hoagies. They said the sandwiches were delicious. I loved my pizza as it had just the right amount of sauce and loads of cheese. Definitely going to be a repeat customer read more

We were in town for a conference and some baseball games. Due to horrible construction everywhere we decided to order a pizza to the hotel one night. I was leery of the 2 star rating but ordered anyway as the comments mentioned there was new ownership. Great choice. The pizza was excellent, I couldn't believe it was delivery - Seriously! It was the best meal of the trip. I highly recommend this pizza. read more

Worse than domino's pizza Steak sandwich was a Salisbury steak on a bun. Not worth it at all

Oh Angilo's... you're pizza is so amazingness! Seriously... I don't think I've ever had fresher bigger veggies on a pizza and no skimping of anything! Plenty of cheese, plenty of sauce, plenty of toppings. It's virtually almost the perfect pizza! Their delivery is speedy at lunch time, or even quicker if I stop in and pick it up, which is really all you can do at this location. I don't even think there are chairs in the tiny little lobby area. They have coupons all the time for free hoagies or 3 topping large pizza's for $10.95 that is worth every penny or more. And the mushrooms... oh the mushrooms. are ginormous juicy so fresh so delicious. Not the jar kind not the dry "fresh" kind. but just... nom.... I haven't tried any other locations, but this one is tops. And I'm pretty sure the reason I haven't stuck to my New Years diet... read more

Village Pizza - a truck driving down a street - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Would have been two stars for bland, unseasoned food, but I'm going with one star because of the long blonde hair I found in my meatball sub. read more

Great service and food. Love their pizzas and hoagies. Food is always hot. I order weekly.

Writing this review in July 2019. Around 5 months ago, Joe, the current owner bought this business. Apparently I heard BEFORE he bought it, it wasn't that good. That's not true anymore. So I don't recommend reading any of the reviews before spring 2019. I DO recommend this place without a doubt. Really good food. My wife and daughter love the pizza. I like the pizza bread. Their steak hoagies are great. And my mom swears it's the best spaghetti in town. I encourage you to give this place a chance. Joe is a really good guy. He remembered when I brought in my 4 year old with me to eat there and asks how she's doing. He seems to have really taken that place forward. You can order online. Place is clean, employees are nice. Has some really good combo deals. It's a small place, like all Angilo's. Only 2 sit down tables so keep that in mind. I highly recommend. read more

Called in an order for pickup. Hoagie was hot and very good. It was enough for 2 people. The man working (might've been the owner) was so friendly & called me to let me know I left my debit card. I picked it up after work & he had it sealed in an envelope with my name. Very good food & very honest. Will return for sure! read more

This place is under new ownership. I just had the steak hoagie and crinkle cut fries. Absolutely delicious. I'll be back for pizza here very soon. I see that they serve breakfast now so I'll likely try that in the very near future. Very convenient for carryout. read more

Pizza was good! Also ordered fried mushrooms and they were extremely greasy. Employees were nice over the phone while taking the order and when I picked it up. read more

Pizza is satisfying but I feel it does have any oil drip just from am pepperoni pizza I've never had use paper towel so my shirt doesn't grease on it. read more

Great pizza, good hoagies, and delicious breakfast sandwiches! Quick delivery and awesome customer service. Highly recommend

Love their Steak Hoagies, and the Fish Hoagie!! Cannot get Hoagies in Columbus...Soooo missing Angilo's!!

This pizza tastes like lunchables and that is not to be mean. My 6 friends and I ordered this pizza while opening a bunch of pokemon cards and it was some of the worst pizza we ever had. Along the way however, we made many memories and were very entertained by the difference in the reviews and our experience. We will definitely be dining here again. I am really not kidding though, this pizza is awful. I wish angilos the best tho read more

Decent pizza. Good value for the price. Generous portions of pepperoni. My wife compared it to a Tombstone pizza (she meant it as a compliment) read more

We have visited this place multiple times and have never been disappointed. Their pizza and hoagies are well prepared and staff is friendly. The online app is easy to navigate and a nice alternative to calling in your order. Give them a try and I hope your experience is equal to ours. read more

Ordered a pizza for pick up. Simple plain cheese pizza... it was awful. The cheese wasn't even melted and the pizza was barely room temperature by time I got it home. This was my 2nd bad experience with this restaurant... doubt I'll give them a 3rd chance. read more

Delicious!! We watched Joe cook and prepare our take out order of a steak hoagie, royal hoagie, fish and hot wings!! The best!! Can't wait to try his breakfast pizza read more

If you want to be told they didn't get your order only to have them show up 1-1/2 hours later with an order then claim they can't help you you have to get your money through someone else (paid online with a credit card) then order through them otherwise STAY AWAY and order Donatos read more

Great delivery Pizza loved the Angilo's Deluxe, wings were good as well, delivery was very fast about 15 minutes I do recommend if you're stuck at a hotel Near Cincinnati. read more

Crappy cheese on this pizza which was delivered cold. Will skip on to the next pizza place next time. I ordered a cheese, sausage, jalapeno, and onion pizza, and there was a lot of toppings, including lots of cheese, it's just that lots of crappy cheese doesn't = good taste. The crust was pretty low quality too. I guess you get what you pay for sometimes -- and next time I'll go somewhere a little more expensive (this large pizza was $15, including delivery charges) and actually enjoy my pizza! read more

My husband and I had a craving for pizza Saturday. We decided on finding an Angilo's Pizza near by that had seating so we could relax and enjoy our food. We call and Joe said he had outdoor seating. Our food was good and enjoyed seating outside. The owner Joe and Dawn was friendly and catered to our needs. Thanks both of you. Upon arriving I discovered this was the same Angilo's our team orders from. Told them it was obvious a new owner had taken over. Phone ordering was handled professionally by being patient and confirming order. Great job Joe and Dawn, it was nice meeting you both. Deb & Ed. read more

First off, got their deep fried jalapeño poppers (j bombs)... These were nothing more than store bought frozen jalapeño poppers anyone can get. Second I got the cheese steak sandwich. While it was good, I had one SIMPLE request in the whole order, no onions on the sandwich. This very easy task was not met.. Maybe their pizza is better? read more

I don't care for the pizza but the cheese fries are pretty good. I just wish they would use the tin pans instead of the paper. The cheese always sticks to the paper. read more

Excellent meatball sub and pizza is great! Sauce is great. Definitely will come back to try other menu items!

We ordered delivery to the hotel, everything was great on the order and delivery was fast. Prices not bad ,pizza was just ok had plenty of sauce and cheese and toppings but did not excite our taste buds read more

Think twice about this place. Ordered steak hogie and breaded mushrooms. Mushroom gravy was con-gelled mushroom imitation and breaded mushrooms consisted of 4 mushrooms for a ridiculous price. Dine is service advertised was a big joke read more