This deli definitely lives up to the hype! The staff were excellent, friendly, and efficient, even…read morewith a line of customers out the door. My sandwich was phenomenal--fresh, delicious, and made to perfection. The potato salad was incredibly fresh and the perfect side. They're also the creators of the viral Italian meatball ice cream cone that was featured on the news, making this spot a true local gem. Whether you're stopping in for one of their famous creations or a classic sandwich, you won't be disappointed. I can't wait to come back! Metered parking only!

Yes. It was about that time after saving a Reel of the Italian Ice Cream Cone - I tried it…read more It completely lived up to all the hype on IG. First, let's start with the bread. Fresh semolina hero hollowed out. The bread was so fresh and not soggy whatsoever. Then placed inside delicious, homemade meatballs, baked deli in the deli itself. I ate the sandwich in two settings. It was just as good the second time if not better. You can tell the sauce is homemade, not too wheat, but typical homemade sauce, a.k.a. gravy. The meatballs were tender, seasoned to perfection and did not fall apart. I just loved the whole presentation and the hero itself. Inside the deli, there are many Italian delicacies and hot food available for takeout. They also have so many good cold cuts in the case by the pound. I sat out in front. There is a couple of seats and a table.. Great service and experience!

I stopped in before heading to the Bronx Zoo as I heard they had the best chopped cheese. Thats…read moreexactly what I ordered! The guys working there were very friendly and made my sandwich exactly how I wanted. I will definitely be back as it was the best chopped cheese Ive ever had!

This place was once a great spot to go to.. however, I feel like the quality has gone way down. Big…read moreass bread, they don't even give you enough protein on their sandwiches anymore and they drenched that shit in mayo. Not only that but how about cleaning the grill before you make different sandwiches. You can see the burnt stuff from other meats on your sandwich. Cmo'n get it together guys clean the damn grill for god sakes.

Amazingly delicious food! Our go-to sandwich place when in the Bronx!!! We had the DSNY (chicken…read morecutlet, fried eggplant, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, delicious bread, balsamic vinaigrette. The best!

The mozzarella here is very fresh. I got sandwiches and they are huge and heavy with a lot of…read morefillings. I had DSNY: chicken cutlets with eggplants, mozzarella, and roasted red peppers. I wish they put more roasted peppers to give more flavor. There are several cutlets in that sandwich. Maybe trade one cutlet with more red peppers to add sweetness to the sandwich. I didn't taste any vinaigrette as described on the menu. I also had Con Ed: prosciutto, eggplant, arugula, mozzarella , sun dried tomatoes. This sandwich is tastier than DSNY. I recommend this one. The guy who helped me in my opinion was a bit pushy. He gave me a sample of cheese. It was really good. It reminded me of L'amuse Gouda. It's sweet, savory, like butterscotch. He tried to sell me a big piece. I asked for a small piece. He cut me almost a pound. I recommend to be more specific about the weight.

Incredible fresh mozzarella. It has some of the water. I can eat it like that as snacks…read more I got casa sandwich on a roll. You can have it on ciabatta. Fresh mozzarella with prosciutto and I believe Sun dried tomato. Very good. I have been visiting Bronx Little Italy for a couple of times but always saw a long line that made me hesitant to go in. This time I came early around 8:30 Am. I was the third person in line. The store is super small especially at the ordering area. There's only small space for one person to stand so it's very difficult to exit while there are people behind you. I highly recommend coming here early before the crowd.

I came here to try their iconic sandwiches, and I am glad I gave it a go! When we got there, there…read morewas already a line outside. However, it was probably about 20-30 minutes before we took our order, so service is definitely fast! Inside is super small, but there are lots of Italian goods around to see. There are also blocks/rounds of cheese you can purchase too. We got The Casa, and ate it outside. Service was so kind and we even got to see them make mozzarella in the back! I don't think this sandwich was my favorite unfortunately. The bread had a funky smell(?) to it, and I feel like it fell a little flat on flavors and textures. Regardless, I am glad I tried and met the incredible team!

Bruh! Omg this food is so dang good. I had onion rings and a Mexican burger. The bun was so good it…read moretasted like a real potato bun not that fake stuff. The meat was quality meat. I can't even believe I just paid $6 for it. The onion rings needed seasoning though. Overall the food was worth it and I will be ordering from here again. My sis said her fruit salad is bomb... always sweet and fresh. She ordered the yankee special sandwich and thought it was delicious. I didn't take a pic because we demolished the food before that thought came to mind lol.

From the owner: Great your perfect salad today.read more

I've tried finding mozz and mortadella as good as what they sell here in Italy, and I failed. No…read moreone beats Mike's when it beats to purveying the very best salumeria and cheese, among other provisions. The prepared dishes also hit different. The famous eggplant parm is phenomenal. I don't even like eggplant and I'm in love with this dish. All of the sandwiches hit too. The Italian sushi is interesting, but eat it fresh as the arugula doesn't stand up to refrigeration too well. My perfect foodie day is going to Mike's, buying some mortadella and a ball of homemade mozzarella, then popping into Madonia's next door to get a loaf and some fresh hand-filled cannoli.

A sandwich and soda should not cost $70 for two people. Tax and tip I can understand but a $4 fee…read morefor the privilege of splitting the tab plus the obligatory credit charge fee is a bit much. Rose was a delight but we won't be back anytime soon.

The absolute best sandwich place you can ever go to in your life five stars without a doubt I have…read morebeen coming here since I was a child the morning guys who make breakfast are amazing. The afternoon guys are amazing and you cannot forget about smiley in the nighttime who is also amazing if you ever want an amazing sandwich go to S&J - Julianna

Very very rude owners/workers. I walk to order food and they see me but just walk away they don't…read moreeven take my order. Always on the phone and ignores customers

Ordered egg sandwiches of different varieties. The bread was fresh and delivery was quick.read more

New Riverdale Deli - A disturbing experience…read more I ordered the chicken over rice, and let me tell you, this was a unique experience. The chicken was stale, old, and tasted putrid, giving you the vicarious experience of what it would be like if you were reincarnated as a vulture. The rice was okay, and the vegetables they added were pitiful. The only reason you should ever consider coming to this place for food or drink is if you are trying to do some quick grocery shopping.