I stopped in Catfish Annie's for the first time totally unplanned. So when I checked-in on my phone and saw the 1.5 star rating I was a little worried. And while my experience didn't warrant a request to speak to the manager it also won't be getting top awards. We were a party of 2 and our order consisted of fried calamari appetizer, fisherman's platter - 2 baked clams, 4 scallops, 3 shrimp, filet of sole with a double order of steamed broccoli (I opted for double veggies instead of potato). The other entree was filet of sole stuffed with crab, french fries and veggies. The entrees came with soup or salad and we both picked soup - seafood bisque and Long Island clam chowder. The clam chowder was better than the seafood bisque and the stuffed filet of sole was better than the fisherman's platter. On the platter the scallops and shrimp were a wee bit over cooked for my liking and were a little dry. Calamari appetizer was ok, clean oil and not too greasy, just would have preferred more legs - lots of rings. For dessert we shared the Spumoni Truffle which was pretty good. All and all the experience was ok - from food to service everything was ok. Nothing stood out and nothing to really call me back for more. If I could give them a 2.5 star rating that would be more accurate but because Yelp only allows us to rate in 1 star increments, I'll be positive and give them 3. read more