Everything about this pizzeria screams excellent! The food selection, quality and flavor is top…read morenotch. The service is outstanding. Great friendly feel and atmosphere. This is an instant "Can't wait to come back" experience

We stumbled upon this place by accident and I can't believe we haven't been here sooner! The…read moreselection is HUGE! It was honestly overwhelming how many different slices they offer but if you can't find a slice for you there's a problem! The staff was so friendly and really helped us choose exactly what to get and the vibe is very old school but not worn down. This place is must try!

Yesterday was the first time my family and I tried Matteo's. We ordered two large cheese pizzas…read morefrom their Tuesday special ($17.99 for 2 large cheese pizzas which is a good deal). We ordered for pickup and we noticed how the pie looked a bit small for a large. I mean I guess since it's lower prices than most places in this area, it makes sense. Personally I do not like a lot of sauce on my pizza and this place does go a little heavy on the sauce, but they also add a lot of cheese which I do like and it helped balance everything out, plus the sauce is nicely seasoned. If you like a thin crust that is doughy and not like a crunchy cracker, you would like this pizza. Overall I'm very satisfied with Matteo's so far and so Is my family. I would definitely come back, I'd like to try more of their menu items!

I had a really disrespectful and extremely poor experience. My husband calls in at 6pm. They said…read more45 minutes. Great. 645 comes. 7pm comes. I understand sometimes things run behind. 715 comes, my husband calls and they say the driver just left. No apologies about the inconvenience or anything. We get the food at 720pm. Irritating yes, but okay. Then they don't have any change to give you (this has happened the past two times, not to mentioned the delivery driver looked like he was on something). So my husband comes in to ask if I have any smaller bills and we are scrambling around trying to find something smaller and then for the check book. I go out with the check and ask why they don't carry any change and he made an excuse about having to stop for gas. I call Matteo's and told the guy who answered the phone my experience... a bunch of excuses, no apologies. So I ask to talk to the manager (which I should have done in the first place). I am put on hold again, and while on hold I realized that my order was wrong and didn't have anything but lettuce and cheese on it. When he answers I ask if he was the manager and he replies, "yeah, what's up girl?" I told him first, lets change this real quick and not call me girl. (not sure what kind of manager answers the phone this way). And then as I went to start explaining my issues I was hung up on. I call back. Ask for the manager again. I was put on hold. The delivery driver just got back because I could hear him in the background saying, "The bitch was asking why I didn't have any change. I told her I had to get gas." When the manager comes on AGAIN he listens to my issues. Finally he says, "how about this... how about I rip up the check and the order is on the house." I told him that sounds great and hung up. Now to see if they really do. I am just astonished at the lack of customer service and disrespect. 9/8/2023 Update - I called the shop this morning. The man that answers his phones wants to know why I want to speak to the owner and asks a few times. As soon as I tell him the first issue with the manager, he starts making all kinds of excuses for him and says he is a really good guy and I must have taken it wrong. Tells me to call back after 4pm to speak with Felix or Matteo. It sounds like these are just a bunch of people covering for each other or maybe it was the same "manager" from last night that answered this morning. Idk. This place is a mess and I would steer clear. It would have been nice to have one delivery place nearby, but this place CLEARLY doesn't appreciate our business.

Our group of 11 ran the Phunt 25 and 50k trail races through the snow and ice. Some wise person in…read moreour group ordered a ton of pizzas, fries, wings, etc. accommodating all our dietary needs of gluten free/dairy free etc. Delivered to our house by an amazing pizza God and we scarfed it all down. Everything correct and delicious!!!!

I ordered a X-Large pizza with 2 toppings for delivery, has to be the worst pizza We ever had no…read moreflavor and was cold and on top of that they charge a $10 delivery fee which brought the Total for. 1. Pizza to $38 never again we don't recommend unless you want to be disappointed and waste your money

Dave and his team are great, always friendly whenever I walk in and he takes the time to get to the…read morehis regulars. Makes a mean chicken bacon ranch pizza, best around. Cheesesteaks got even better after switching to Cooper Sharp and wings are tasty. Highly recommend

First time ordering here. Ordered a couple of pizzas and wings. Everything was terrific. Will…read moredefinitely go back again.

The Creamy Seafood Spaghetti is the Best!…read more I ordered this dish for delivery and I have to tell you it's one of the best pastas I've had in a long time, you have to try it!!!

We had an amazing lunch and great service today the cheesesteak eggrolls were delicious and the…read moreWally salad was fresh and tasty highly recommended

I don't go often because they're out of my way but when I do drive by I do stop my wife enjoys…read moretheir lasagna, which I always make a point to buy, and I really like their pizza. I find them to be very friendly though I have never sat down and ate a meal there because I'm either traveling to a point or on returning home, but I've never had a complaint about their food

I need to try more things, but I always judge a place by their buffalo wings. And I have found my…read morenew favorite wing. These remind me of my favorite joint where i first became obsessed with wings - they were so dang good. These wings took me right back to that place. It's all about the sauce. The sauce is just the right hit of acid, fat, and heat and it stands out. Haven't gone in to eat yet, but now it's on the list

We had a Family gathering and ordered a bit of everything. Food was fresh and delicious. We got…read moreburritos,a tray of taco's, quesadillas, nachos, pizza and chicken strips.

Absolutely horrible customer service over the phone. We called to ask about pizzas and what…read moredifferent options they offered. The Hispanic man on the phone answered back very rudely saying they had over 50 options and refused to say what they had. This was the first time we were going to try this place out but never again will we give this place a try. Very disappointed.