Firstly just to clarify, I am reviewing The Black Horse at Askwith, situated in a small attractive…read morevillage about 4 miles form Otley and 5 miles from Ilkley.
It is not to be confused with a pub of the same name in Otley town. It seems the prvious reviewers have referred to the town pub , and only awarded one star. This has had the effect of reducing the average rating of this pub, of which I believe I am the frist reviewer
This place is a little gem. It comprises a pub with an added conservatory style dining room with a pleasant ambience.
I got off to a good start with a pint of Taylors Landlord, one of the best bitters around, even though I may be biased, having been brought up 200yds from Taylors Brewery in the nearby town of Keighley. Black Sheep Bitter is also an excellent bitter, if weaker than Landlord, and also available here.
I called without booking at 7.30 on a Wednesday evening, and shown to the table , my beer and menu placed there whilst I had a comfort visit. The menu comprised 6 or so starters, and 10 Mains with additions of Steak and Burgers as other options. I went for a starter of Tempura Prawns, beautifully presented with a sweet chilli relish and some well prepared salad. Prawns were crisp and delicious. It was at this stage that I saw that there were a number of specials on a blackboard, slightly behind of me. This would have changed my choice (I am a sucker for a tender Lamb Shank), and I dont remember the young lady or her colleague mentioning the board to me (unless it went in one ear and out of the other). But it mattered not, as the Sea Bass main, served on a bed of crushed potato and with the sweetest of vine tomatoes , with seasonal vegetables also came beautifully presented and was equally delicious. Indeed it was as good a Sea Bass as I have had, and its something I choose a lot.
Other readers of my reviews will know I stay regularly at the Chevin Lodge Hotel, Otley. The food there is excellent, but for a what is essentially a village pub like the Black Horse to be serving food of similar quality and presentation is excellent. It deserves to be better patronised.
My two courses and a pint came to £22, but the Sea Bass was one of the more expensive options. Pies as a main were £9.95, and a choice of three.
There is also an early bird system with two courses for £10.95 before 7 pm weekdays.
The two young ladies serving were charming, efficient, and attentive and service was prompt.
There was only one other table of four running at the time, so I cant judge whether the same level of service could be maintained say on Saturday evening or Sunday lunch when it would doubtless be busier.
I will be back here (hoping to see the Lamb Shank on the blackboard again). No hesitation in awarding five stars Edit 17th Jan 2012. Well it took me along time to get back here. Had a meal here this evening, just as good as before. And nice attention from the two young ladies! Lamb Shank not available ! I will try again .
Garlic Mushrooms in cream sauce were well executed, and was the chicken in bacon (back not streaky), served on a bed of mash with veg, and a cream sauce. Place very quiet, but pleasant and cosy by the fire , to which I had been directed. No reason to alter my five star rating. Further edit 14th February.
Visited again , still very quiet despite it being Valentines Day. Lovely pint of Taylors Landlord again. Had the prawns in filo pastry delicious, but on my first visit they were 'tempura' style , not the same . For the third time there were no lamb shanks. I am told they have stopped doing them but it still appears on the menu!
Specials board had a 28day matured Aberdeen Angus Sirloin. Tasty and cooked as requested , with excellent chips and quite the best onion rings I have ever had. The whole thing spoilt rather by a mushroom sauce, which just seemed like pouring single cream on your steak, little evidence of mushrooms. I am going to reduce my rating by a star now because of this, and lack of atmosphere probably better when its fuller Further edit , Called last night, 28th March 2012 at 6pm and found the restaurant closed. I am not sure whether this is permanent or some temporary problem . A big pity if its closed down