Buckeye gave us an incredibly reasonable estimate on the new roof for the house, TWO flat roof…read morereworks, plus gutters AND they repaired the shady fascia board between the first and second floors, under one of the (no longer) flat roofs. Everything looks so good! We chose the same shingles for the house that we had put on the carriage house/garage, and although it's hard to see up top, they do look amazing. And the drainage around the house is SO MUCH BETTER. At the time the crew was out, we were having other repairs inside the house, and everyone did the trades shuffle with grace and humor. You haven't seen a crew work like these guys did until you realize they roofed a 7,200 sq ft historic house in just 3 days--including the flat roof rebuilds. So much attention and care was paid to the fabric of the home, and each flat roof got its own plan and treatment. They did our carriage house in early spring 2026, and the same attention to detail means we now own two very spiffy historic structures. Call Buckeye, you can't go wrong.

Salesperson was late for initial consultation for a bathroom remodel. When he arrived, he first…read moreasked me if my husband was available. He then went on to ask a myriad of questions unrelated to our bathroom project, in addition to again asking if my husband could join us. I told him he was busy and could not join us and that I was the point person for this project. He asked a third time if my husband could join us, citing that I might not be able to remember all the information I was given. I told him if he was not going to provide a consultation/estimate for me, the project owner, unless a man was with me then we can cancel. I led him out of the house 30 seconds later.

Kyle , Bob and his guys did a amazing job ! Amazing quality for the price ! Very impressive! They…read morewere all very nice and did a amazing job cleaning up afterwards. Couldn't recommend them enough! Great job guys!

I highly recommend this family owned business. Blacketer gave us an honest, reasonable, no nonsense…read moreestimate and timeline for the job. Their work ethic is excellent. They care about keeping their work area clean both inside and outside of the house. We've had some extremely windy days and didn't feel the slightest draft through or around any of the windows that they replaced. The personal service and communication that you get from them is far better than the big business companies! Watch out for those big companies that try to sell you something you don't need. We are 100% happy with the windows and workmanship from Blacketer.

Great experience from start to finish! I have used them twice - once for a rental house, and now…read morefor my primary residence. Ron came out and measured everything, and gave me the various window options. He wasn't overselling anything, and let me make my own decision. Ron also had some really helpful information about lead paint, as we are remodeling an old house. Then, for the install, Keith helped us. He was better than we could have hoped for. He really knew his stuff. We had weird storm windows on the house before, so when he took them off there was an open section that needed to be covered. He cut the new vinyl trim on-site, and fit it all together with our totally-not-level 100 year old house. It makes a world of difference. Keith also showed us how to operate our new windows, because I had never used the tilt-in type of window before. So again, a great experience from start to finish. This is the second time I have used them, but I'm sure it won't be the last!

Fooled twice by this business. This is actually an update…read more Michelle, the same receptionist that ignored my message pertaining to renovations as they were discussed by the in home consultant (will update with name after I find the card), messaged me asking to remove my review as I had confused the business with Window Depot USA. I had not. This, in fact, is the very dishonest and, evidently, disrespectful company that I will never approach for another window again. Thank you.

EDIT: We decided to have Schaefer and Co. come out to fix the roof. They were right on time and…read morespent maybe 30min discussing the issue with me and were very eager to get started. They have been working for 3 days now and seem to be replacing probably ¼ of my roof. We'll see how it goes, but so far I'm happy with the way things are going. Adjusting my rating. NOT happy so far. We got a new roof by Schaefer in 2021 because of leaks and we have had 3 leaks so far since our new roof. We just now discovered our 3rd. We're going to get a 3rd party inspection done and then possibly explore legal options. They were the highest bid, but we went with them because we thought they would do a good job (from past experience).

I asked Schaefer to repair my roof. The flashing at my chimney has corroded through and it began to…read moreleak. They came the day I called and began the repair the next day. They did a quality job that when done it looked great! I also asked them to quote building a new shed over our pool pump area. They came back with a quote that was twice what others quoted. They did a great job on our roof, they didn't build our shed.

Bottom line up font: STAY AWAY!!!…read more My wife and I have been shopping around for someone to repair or replace our shower. ImproveIt was one of the top search results for bathroom repair/remodeling work. My wife trusts me to handle an appointment for an estimate, but they insisted that my wife and I must both be present for the appointment. No other contractor I've worked with has such a requirement. I didn't have the best feeling about them after the phone call, but I went ahead with the appointment, which they said would take 60-90 minutes. The representative they sent seemed very nice. He complimented our home, and asked questions about the smoker I have on our back porch. He inspected our shower and decided that the tile work was shoddy and would need to be completely replaced. This didn't seem totally unreasonable since the grout in the floor was crumbling. In retrospect, he would have come to the same conclusion no matter what he saw. Following the inspection, we sat down at the kitchen table for his presentation/sales pitch. He talked up the company and went over all of the awards they've received. He then talked through various options for redoing our shower. As it turns out every option is terrible except one. The one that isn't terrible is the product he's trying to sell. His product was a very sciency miracle materiel material, aka plastic. What he didn't know is that my wife and I both have advanced degrees in materials engineering, so we saw right through his B.S. There's nothing wrong with plastic, and it may be a good product, but it's hardly unique. At this point in the process, I hadn't quite figured out that he was going for the hard sell, used car salesman style. He had an affable demeanor and continued to pepper in compliments of our very ugly kitchen. He was very patient with our toddler disrupting the conversation and playing with his material samples. After we selected materials and options, he finally gave us a cost quote. The quote: $16,617!!! Over $16,000 to replace a 3'x3' shower that might not even need to be replaced! The quote was good for a year, but if we signed a contract for the work in the next 30 days, we would get about a $1,000 discount. But wait, he had a letter from the owner of the company. It was a very official looking letter, and it gave him permission to give an extra $1500 off if we signed a contract right then and there. My wife and I had not consulted any other contractors for the work, so we weren't about to sign a contract for over $13,000 on the spot without a better feel for the market. We hadn't ruled them out, but we needed more information. When we explained this to the salesman, he tried to convince us that it was a foolish waste of time to get more quotes. He said we wouldn't want to sit through yet another 3 hour (yes, he was at our house for 3 hours) presentation. He continued to push, but we held firm. As he packed up his things, my wife thanked him for his time. His response: "I just don't understand why you wouldn't sign the contract now and save $1,500, but whatever." He was suddenly quite rude. In retrospect, the sales tactics are quite clear. First he buttered us up. Then he "inspected" our shower and found that yes, indeed, it needed to be fully replaced. Then he talked up his company and product while disparaging any competitors. Then he hit us with the hard sell. I don't appreciate such tactics. I don't care how good the product is. I won't give my business to someone who treats me that way.

I have been trying to get our installation done for over a year and a half!…read moreI was sold a remodel that they tell they can't do. I am currently waiting on Shower doors. I call but no one returns my calls.