Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Carter Realty

    2.8 (10 reviews)
    Open 8:30 am - 5:00 pm

    Services - Carter Realty

    Buyer's agent

    Listing agent

    Property management

    Carter Realty Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Carter Realty

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Always so nice and helpful when I call to pay on my unit. Recommend carter realty for sure .

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Tina A.

    Tina A.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Carter Realty

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Real Estate Services 732 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Your Neighborhood Realty - Real Estate in Woodland Park, Teller County, and South Park Colorado

    Your Neighborhood Realty

    (5 reviews)

    AMAZING realtor! Steve Sroufe with Your Neighborhood Realty Associates, Inc., Inc. performed a…read moremiracle for us and helped us to purchase a new home in New Port Richey, Florida, while we are still living in Colombia! We just closed on the property today! Steve provided us with virtual showings of homes in which we expressed an interest. He also did an amazing job of handling all of the communications and negotiations with the seller and with making an official offer to purchase. He even attended the home inspection. When it was required for a new water heater to be installed to satisfy Florida homeowner's insurance, Steve personally took care of this for us! Steve helped us to get us set up with a Remote Online Notary (RON) so that we could handle the signings necessary to move through the home purchase process. Steve earned our trust from day one. We've developed a friendship and an earned trust to the point that we assigned Steve as our Power of Attorney and he was able to have us review all of the final signing documents and then sign for us on closing. We can't thank Steve Sroufe enough for going way above and beyond as our realty representative! The Universe definitely connected us with a gentleman we regard as a godsend!

    It pains me to write this but it is important to warn people of my experience working with Mike…read moreSlaback. I find no joy in writing this but his constant abuse has to end. Throughout my extensive experience in the real estate industry spanning several decades, I've never encountered a realtor as unprofessional and unethical as Mike Slaback. I am the legal agent and caretaker of a ranch outside Woodland Park. Seven years ago, Mike was hired to manage the rental of the ranch. Despite my role as caretaker and agent for this ranch, Mr. Slaback consistently disregards the directives of the property owners and me. He refuses to communicate with me even about the smallest issues, like proving a picture of damages. He also will not provide any copies of any damage assessments or contracts as requested. The owners of the property asked him many times not to contact them and to work through me. He totally ignored that and for a month he continued to constantly contact them and refused to work with me. Eventually the owners of the property got fed up with his constant harassment and I was asked to trespass Mike, his company, and anyone employed by him from the property. After his ignoring that directive and his continued harassment, I warned him today that the next step is a restraining order if he continues. I extended an olive branch to Mr. Slayback proposing to pursue mediation as a means to resolve our differences peacefully. I did not want to make a complaint to the board of realtors, which could damage his reputation in the community and his real estate license. Regrettably, despite explicit instructions by the property owners to refrain from contacting them, Mr. Slaback has continued to contact them and has refused to work with me. His behavior can be likened to the movie "Fatal Attraction". He just keeps going after the ranch's property owners and he shows no care for them. It is like he thinks he owns their property and will decide who is in control of it. With Mike, it's like any day he will pop up from behind a virtual door and attack us. He forgets who he is employed by, who owns the property, and has a definite detachment from the standard ethical and legal norms. Despite my role as the designated agent, caretaker, and trustee of the ranch, Mr. Slaback refuses to work with me. He refuses to hand over any pictures, damage assessments, or damage deposits made by the renters into the ranch's bank account. He won't provide repair receipts, or any financials for the property for the last seven years. Furthermore, his proposed solution to repair the $6,000 in damages from the last renter was to offer me $400 and have the property owners pay me to repair them. I was also asked to submit a false claim to Allstate to relieve Mike of his financial obligations. Submitting a false claim to an insurer in Colorado is 3 years in prison and fines of up to $100,000. Needless to say I am not going to ask the property owners to do that If any of his realtors or employees read this PLEASE ask him to comply with what the property owners tell him to do. Please ask him to hand over all the pictures, contracts, security screenings, and the bank account financials for the last seven years. Most of all PLEASE ask him to quit harassing the property owners. I feel sorry for you and do not want to hurt you or your families by writing this review of Mike's services. Please ask him to ethically comply with the simplest standard real estate practices and the law. Mike PLEASE stop abusing the ranch owners, PLEASE!!! They are trying their hardest to get away from you! In a community abundant with ethical realtors, there is no justification for engaging the services of, or working for unethical people.

    Renjoy -  Short Term Rental Management - Whitewater Villa dining room in Buena Vista. Airbnb Luxe property!

    Renjoy - Short Term Rental Management

    (13 reviews)

    The team at Renjoy always goes above and beyond. They have been managing my property for years and…read moreits always in prestine condition. I would highly recommend using them.

    We booked a VRBO in COS back in May. The unit is managed by Renjoy and we could NOT have been more…read moredisappointed. The hot tub was fully broken (one of the main reasons we picked the rental) and the house was filthy. See pix I uploaded. - The worst mattresses imaginable. Guests chose sofas and floor over the terrible beds! - Filthy carpet - Mildew in primary bath - Teensy tiny primary shower and bathroom - DIRTY kitchen cabinets, drawers and silverware - Dusty, dirty screened porch and outdoor furniture - BROKEN hottub cover - Inoperable hottub I never called or complained about the crime that was their "housekeeping," but I did call about the hottub. They do everything they can to push you to (what feels like) an AI chatbot in their app. Trying to find and connect by phone was a nightmare. And, when I did, the agent wanted me to take a million photos; flip a circuit breaker; and basically be the on-site maintenance person before she would call and send someone out. It was infuriating. On the plus side, the maintenance person was a great and was determined to get us up and running no matter what! I have stayed in dozens of short-term rentals. I own a short-term rental in Colorado. I would NEVER stay in another place managed by Renjoy or consider them as managers of my property.

    Falcon Property Company

    Falcon Property Company

    (11 reviews)

    The application process was pretty easy and smooth. Once I sent my paperwork in, Laura was quick to…read morereach out to me. She was great to work with and I really appreciate that she went above and beyond for me. I've sent a couple of friends who were looking for rentals here. I cannot recommend Falcon enough!

    I had an absolutely horrible experience with Jeff Cirkus and would recommend you stay far away from…read moreFalcon Property Company. When first starting the call, I shared that I was reaching out to multiple property managers in order to compare rates and fees of management which I was then told was allegedly "Illegal". I gave Jeff the benefit of the doubt and proceeded the conversation guaranteeing that I would not be sharing any of his figures with other managers, and simply wanted to do my part in ensuring I was getting the best deal. During the entire conversation, Jeff was unfocused and unwelcoming, constantly looking away and making degrading comments along the lines of "I was taking up multiple professionals time" all because I wanted to compare and ensure I was getting the best deal. Finally, he showed up late to our call per the email below, and came unprepared, directly ignoring my request for rental comps which every other firm I have talked to has been able to provide. I encourage you to check my profile and see that I rarely ever leave a review, but I was pushed to do so by the rude, condescending, and outright disrespectful treatment in an introductory call. Hiring a property management firm is along the lines of entrusting someone with one of the biggest purchases you are ever going to make/have made. I would not trust Jeff to even drive by my property. His position as President of the company tells me all I need to know about their values, and I would highly encourage that anyone considering a Property Manager stay away from them! (Edited response to Jeff) All of these things you see below are lies with a grain of truth. Falcon Property Company practices discriminatory policies and wastes the time of its customers. I see that Jeff has too much of an ego to realize that he was completely in the wrong, but for anyone out there reading this I would once again encourage you to stay away. Falcon Property Company wasted my time and will waste yours. My "threats" consisted of giving feedback and saying I would leave a review. As proven by his response, he doesn't want his customers getting the best price for their property management needs and encourages uncompetitive practices. STAY FAR AWAY FROM THIS CON MAN!

    Summit Group Colorado - EXP Realty - Thankful to represent these awesome sellers!

    Summit Group Colorado - EXP Realty

    (13 reviews)

    The Summit Group was amazing, and Tiffany was a spectacular realtor. We couldn't have asked for a…read morebetter person to guide us through the sale of our home. Her dedication, attentiveness, and professionalism made what could have been a stressful process feel simple and manageable. From start to finish, Tiffany was incredibly responsive, resourceful, and always willing to go above and beyond to ensure everything stayed on track. She kept us informed every step of the way, answered all of our questions promptly, and consistently looked out for our best interests. We always felt supported and confident knowing Tiffany was in our corner. Her expertise and commitment truly made a difference, and we are incredibly grateful for all of her hard work. We highly recommend Tiffany to anyone looking for a knowledgeable, caring, and top-notch realtor.

    Working with Andrew and Tonya Nielson at Summit Group was a fantastic experience from start to…read morefinish. Moving is always stressful, but they made the process of selling our current home and buying a new one feel seamless. They are incredibly attentive and responsive--no question went unanswered. Their deep knowledge of the Colorado Springs market was evident as they helped us secure our new home at a fair price and sell our existing home at full asking price (which we welcomed their guidance on). If you want a team that is professional, knowledgeable, and truly has your back, look no further!

    Timberline Property Management

    Timberline Property Management

    (15 reviews)

    Three years ago I came across Timberline Property Management and their amazing team. I leased a…read moreproperty from them for 2 1/2 years, and was sad to part ways when lease was over (kicking myself for not staying w them!). We moved down the street into an apartment complex and have been plagued with issues in the almost 7 months we have been living there. I reached back out to Timberline and Amy, Jennifer, Julia... A.k.a. the dream team... found my family a beautiful new home for the same price we were paying at the apartment. I tell you these people genuinely care about their tenants, treat them with respect, and always do right by them. I am a single mom on a limited budget, with their rental program to ownership program... I know I'm in the right hands to eventually own a home. Almost 20 years of renting and I've never had such an amazing experience with a property management company and will never rent from anyone else again. The fact that they will also help me find my family's forever home... brings me such peace of mind and makes the process so much less intimidating. I am forever grateful for this team, and would recommend them to everyone I can :-). A special thank you to Jennifer... You are one in 1 million! Julia is the realtor that everybody dreams of, and Amy is an amazing addition to an incredible team! Brad...you've built an astonishing team!

    Worked with Timberline and Brad for the first time. Great experience from the realtor that showed…read moreus the house to her and Brad communicating options with us. Bead worked to make sure our needs were met with what was fair on the business end for him and the property owner. Excited to be working with such a professional team.

    Carter Realty - realestatesvcs - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...