Went today for the first time to meet up with friends. We were warmly greeted when we entered and…read morewere given an introduction and explanation of the business. There is a small retail section in front for those who wish to purchase games, but there is a massive selection of games to use while you're there, we were told over 950 games! There is an adequately sized menu to cover standard gaming fare, as well as beverage options to cover most tastes and ingredient intolerances Our group ordered a sugar free vanilla latte, unsweetened ice tea, bottled water, and a pizza. The pizza is made in-house and is pretty good. A soft hand-tossed crust topped with a tasty sauce, and we added slightly spicy sausage and pepperoni. I would definitely order it again! The service was excellent despite being a busy with one person handling the guest check-ins, order taking, order delivery, and checking guests out. There is currently a $7 cover charge, which I will assume covers the use of the 950+ games, and is a bargain. You are allowed to bring in your own games, but I assume you can't bring in your own food or drink, but I didn't ask because why would I? We want to support a small business, so buying drinks and food is the least I can do, since they let us have access to all of their games. Overall, we had a great experience, and we will be back! Highly recommend!

Tastes great. By looks, I thought it was overpriced. Then I tasted the all meat offered, and man…read morewas it tasty and filling. We were happy with our purchase.

This store I have to say is my home away from home. After walking in 6 years ago just to look…read morearound I've made friends and have been able to play a lot of really cool games. I stop in every week to pick up my comic books and I'm always greeted with a smile and a hello from the owners. Together they have both created an atmosphere of awesome for anyone who wants to learn a new game, join and ongoing game league or just to buy a few comics. I've never found a better store to get my geek on.

I'm new and an outsider to the world of comics and gaming, but I'd never know it from the way Carla…read moreand Don treated me. My boyfriend has been a regular at the store for years, and I went with him to pick up his pull list this past weekend. There were people chatting at the counter when we came in, so Carla didn't see that I was with anyone when I entered the store. She was sure to ask me if I needed help with anything, which is a first in the slew of comic and game shops I've been to recently. The shop is set up with different rooms devoted to your interest, with comics in one wing and games in another, and more general books and collectibles merchandise in the main room where you enter. If you head to the back, you'll find space for game playing and where Don is organizing his back stock of comics. The shop on the whole is bright and colorful, and I felt totally welcome to browse. Don and Carla had a nice word for everyone who came in the store, and it was pretty clear that they have a small army of loyal customers. The outside of the store isn't much to look at - it's situated in an industrial-looking strip mall - but don't let that deter you from the checking out their cozy shop. Even if you're not a full-on geek, there are still things for you here - several of their games are great for a game night with friends.

This is a super fun locally owned small business for both young and old! The shop owner is a gem…read morewho thoroughly enjoys their business and it shows! They are friendly and extremely helpful. I've come here several times now for neat gifts and creative projects, as well as fun little things for my own office. Each time I've been here I have found it well organized, easy to shop, and affordable. They have everything from silly putty and books to puzzles and craft kits. If you like supporting small businesses then give them a whirl while you enjoy the shops of Cedarburg!

A charming local toy store with great service, unique finds, and a warm neighborhood vibe.read more

Legitimately my favorite spot to find dice, minis, maps, paint, board games, and tons more! I…read morestopped in twice last week and happily purchased SO MUCH. I would have spent more, but the last time I was in, there was an unpleasant young lady behind the counter who I apparently inconvenienced by grabbing more items when I didn't get what I was hoping for from the Ravenloft blind box. She wasn't afraid to tell me so. Outside of that individual, The Sanctum is like Shangri-La for TTRPG fans.

(Originally posted mid2022) We stopped by The Sanctum last…read moreweek--three times! We first went to get a copy of the Star Wars Outer Rim expansion. We weren't certain if they'd have it since the game was only released that day. They did! We were so impressed, we stopped by later with our son and checked the store out. Their inventory was quite impressive. They had games of all types as well as other items like dice, card protectors, and puzzles. They also had an impressive selection of games to rent--we're not sure what game to rent first! Also, their collection of used games is diverse and well-priced. Finally, their gaming area is attractive. It's well-lit with comfortable seating. Each time we came in, we were greeted by a friendly staff. In fact, when I was pondering a game they had open and on display, an employee came over to explain the game to me. Very helpful. We'll definitely be spending more time (and money) at the Sanctum. What a great place!! (Update, Six months later: As we expected, six Sanctum has successfully prompted us to spend more money on games and game-adjacent items. The owners are wonderful--we've taken several of their recommendations and no regrets. The space has matured and morphed, and we love the changes. We've rented games, tried a game night, joined their frequent buyers program, bought and sold used games, and purchased numerous gifts for gamers and non-gamers. Sometimes we stop in just because we love the vibe of the place. We did that last night and bought the early release of the Wingspan expansion. Couldn't be happier to have them in the neighborhood!)

This store has an excellent community and friendly, welcoming, and knowledgeable staff…read more Everytime I've walked into this store I've come out happier then when I went in. I got my younger brothers into magic after I returned from a deployment one of them started playing games here regularly. This was his first time venturing out into an unknown environment of people and almost instantly he felt welcomed and at home. If your nervous about starting to get into games or don't have a community or a place to play I highly recommend this store.

Lake Geneva Games is an Awesome game store with an excellent selection of Magic the Gathering…read morecards!!

Great store with a dedicated owner and open space for gaming. They are very responsive with…read morerequests and have events going on all the time. Highly recommended!