Yes! That's exactly what I had in mind when I think of a Jersey Pizza. Crust was just right, toppings had amazing flavor and the red sauce, WOW. We ordered the Kitchen Sink pizza and we also had the garlic knots which were incredible. Service was great. Food was amazing, just go. Traffic will probably suck, but do it anyway! read more

See all

Maybe there's a difference between New York and New Jersey pizza but this one was a disappointment. I ordered a Sicilian and it was like a two-parter. I can't explain it. I didn't take the picture because it was weird. It was good just different and I didn't want different. I wanted a traditional Sicilian read more

Lies!!! Just ordered one for pickup, the pie does not look like picture, in the picture the pepperoni is arranged nice around the shApe of the pie, when i asked the rude ass girl behind the counter why was the pepperoni thrown all over pizza instead of like in the picture,she said they don't make it like that, so showed them there instagram post and she replies " oh thats just for the picture " smh. Ps nothing in there is brick oven and it looks dirty as hell in there Lies!!! Just ordered one for pickup, the pie does not look like picture, in the picture the pepperoni is arranged nice around the shApe of the pie, when i asked the rude ass girl behind the counter why was the pepperoni thrown all over pizza instead of like in the picture,she said they don't make it like that, so showed them there instagram post and she replies " oh thats just for the picture " smh. Ps nothing in there is brick oven and it looks dirty as hell in there read more

The margarita pizza is EXCELLENT!! I love the crust and how fresh the ingredients are. I also liked the mozzarella sticks but the chicken tenders and fries weren't as good as I expected. Overall, for the price- the food was good. I will definitely order from here again. read more

I really enjoy the pasta dishes here, but the pizza tends to miss the mark for me. The service is always great from everyone who works here, whether I order take out or sit in for a quick slice. Good value as well for price/ quantity. read more

Overall positive experience but I think food is hit or miss. Depends on what you get. Service is good. Staff are very friendly. There's not a lot of seating but worked for us. I think this place is sort of a local favorite. The setting is very casual and fits the local favorite theme. The starter bread and marinara sauce was delicious. For meals, I had the aglio y olio but found it lacked flavor. But I did enjoy the chunks of cooked garlic. My wife had the pepperoni pizza, which had plenty of pepperoni but not a stand-out pizza. My daughter had the chicken parmigiana which was pretty good. My son the rigatoni which was decent. And oldest son the chicken Murphy, which was very good. So overall not bad. Sort of depends on what you get. read more

See all

Stopped in after landing at Newark- had a pepperoni and sausage slice. Great pizza, great service. read more

Eli's Pizza Pasta - Slice of sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

If you're staying in EWR area this is the spot to get good pizza. High quality ingredients. Loved it read more

Eli's Pizza Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

Got a slice of kitchen sink and Buffalo chicken. Didn't expect to like the Buffalo chicken, but it was very good. With all the various ingredients on the kitchen sink pizza I expected it to be better. The price was very reasonable and the staff was very helpful. Overall it was a good experience and I'll try them again, probably even try the kitchen sink pizza again. If you want a reasonable priced slice served quick, Eli's is a good choice. read more

Eli's Pizza Pasta - Slice of Buffalo and Kitchen Sink pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

The food was ok, but a $4 delivery (less the mile away) is pretty ridiculous- no app, called directly read more

Eli's Pizza Pasta - Receipt - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

What a lovely find! Pizza: excellent, pasta dish : to die for. Meat pies: not to miss!!! The staff is amazing and very helpful.

This was our only option due to being snowed in at a nearby hotel. Spent $65 for 2 glorified gas station pizzas. If you have another choice I would go elsewhere. read more

Not a bad place but a tiny area. Service was decent besides some kid that tried to charge me 7 bucks more for a pasta when it was just 14 on the menu. So beware of the cashier charging you more for food read more

Total liars. Placed an order on Uber Eats. Ordered based on the price offered. Immediately after ordering I received a notice the restaurant made an adjustment to the price. They added $4. Called Uber and they said the restaurant charged extra for my "special request" to leave the order at the hotel front desk. Called the restaurant and they blamed Uber because they didn't charge the mandatory delivery fee. No one would help. Uber blamed the restaurant, the restaurant blamed Uber. This restaurant is a total scam. read more

Was at the Newark airport and needed a quick bite to eat. Eli's was recommended. Driving there was quick and easy. I was lucky and found parking right away. I wanted some good NY Pizza and this place has some. Their menu is large, and they have plenty of dishes. I almost ordered something different than pizza because everything looked and sounded really good. I did order a pie with sausage and pepperoni. Between two of us, we destroyed the pie and left one slice. When I come back, I will try so of the other plates. But for now, pizza was what I wanted and what I got. Pizza was good. Service was great. I will be back. read more

We ordered chicken francese, and eggplant parmigiana for delivery to our hotel and were very pleasantly surprised. Dish portion was very generous and sauces tasted just right (not too tangy or salty) and also not too cheesy. Definitely worth a try! read more

Eli's Pizza Pasta - Chicken francese (small) and eggplant parmigiana (with angle hair pasta). The meals included side salad and bread - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

Have done many too good to go orders! Their vodka pasta is amazing!!! Definitely add the chicken.

It Was Cooking ""Outside That Day! Too Darn Hot To See A Stove Top & Miss Me With Turning On That Oven. I Simply Made Up My Mind It Was Gonna Be (DELIVERY) To Hell With That K.I.T.C.H.E.N. Tallied Up The Gang Orders In The House.. Then Placed An Order For Delivery! Great Taking Food Orders. No Complaints There! Food Took Maybe 30-35 Minutes To Deliver. The Delivery Driver Handed Us A Box. With All The Food Packed So Well & The Food Was HOT! Absolutely Loved The Food. I DIDNOT Enjoy The Calamari! Calamari Was Part Of The Frozen Bag Club Everything Else Was Great! Please Keep Up The Great Work Coming Out This Establishment. Quite Often It's Hard To Find A Great Pasta/Pizzeria! HARD WORK NEVER GO UNNOTICED! Eli's Pizza & Pasta...Thank You For Saving Dinner! read more

See all

This is my favorite local pizza place near my apartment. They have very good pies. However, the pricing isn't consistent. I once paid $42, yes, $42 for a large Hawaiian pie. Then two weeks later, $27. Also, the pizza size varies. I consistently order largest and sometimes they are massive and other times regular large, other times they have 9 slices instead of 8. Either way, be careful what you're charged, since depending on if you order online or over the phone or on the slice app the prices change for the same thing. read more

It was INCREDIBLE!! We had the garlic knots which was super yummy as well as the meatball pizza - and the best part...the penne alla vodka with chicken. I don't know what they put in it but the family recipe cookout needs to be dropped TODAY. Also the people who worked there were lovely and the woman who helped serve us was so wonderful and kind. I'd recommend to anyone. Best spot in town. The atmosphere was also very nice with a nice family feel and ambiance. read more

Got a few slices, sat in the restaurant and ate. Delicious, quick, and fairly priced.

The guy here told me the secret to his sauce. I can't guarantee he was being forthright (better than coming fourth, right?), but why would Eli to me? Seriously though. This Pizza in Elizabeth is not bad at all. The guys were friendly and their pizza was tasty. They got the impression they do quite a lot of business in the area and so they should. Slices are pretty cheap and it's easy to find in a residential ish area in the very underrated Jersey city of Elizabeth. read more

Eli's Pizza Pasta - Don't ask because I have no idea. I'm not a fan of bush, regardless. Although I do like "Chemicals Between Us" & "Letting The Cables Sleep" - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

See all

Good food and friendly service within walking distance off the main drive. The folks are seem to be eager to please you food is great and add a fair price. read more

If you are in the area, go here!!! We were in the area for graduation at Stevens Institute and scooped up diner from here. We got the grandma pizza, garlic knots, and salad. All were delicious and we got our NJ pizza fix!! read more

Eli's Pizza Pasta - 4. Grandma Pie - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

See all

We were doing a park and fly and needed something to eat for delivery to our hotel. Eli's was close and had good ratings so we ordered pizza for delivery. It did not disappoint. We really don't eat pizza too often Because it's not the healthiest food in the world but it was very good. The delivery was quick too. Definitely will order here again next time we park and fly. read more

We ordered from a local hotel and were quoted 45 minutes. We called twice and it finally showed up 1 hour and 30 minutes later, ice cold and soggy. $35 plus tip for three chicken tenders and a chicken wrap. Don't waste your money. It was terrible. read more

Pizza is decent but very cheesy. The price is ok as well. I really can't complain much, I just prefer a little more ola or on my slices. The slices are big enough but something is...missing (can't put my finger in it... ) I can also "taste" the flour, if that ma'am es any sense I'd come again if I'm ever in the area. DO NOT EAT THE CRUST! :( read more

Eli's Pizza Pasta - Cheese Slice - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

Just arrived from a long flight and found Eli's on yelp. Gabriel was awesome. It was a family feel atmosphere and the food was delicious.

Great tasting pizza and meatballs. Very nice staff. I will be back to enjoy the great food again when in town.

We always Yelp search our restaurants. From time to time you find a place that really is far better than the ratings would lead you to believe. We were pleasantly surprised to find Jimmy's clean and large storefront windows that opened up the small yet inviting restaurant. There are limited tables and despite the constant flow of customers there is rarely a wait for a table. We ordered a calzone, chicken alfredo and hotwings. We also ordered a beef patty while we waited. All were excellent, literally 5 stars. The chicken also came with a crisp succulent FRESH salad with what appeared to be in house made caesar dressing. Here's what my husband had to say, "I have missed real italian food since i left the tri-state 5 years ago and the quality of flavor here is mind blowing. The alfredo sauce, calzone and wings were to out of this world. " Eli's surpasses most if not all the Itallian I've had this year. read more

Eli's has been my personal favorite in Elizabeth having worked at the local hospital since 2009 (I remember when they were on east jersey) . Last week, we had a celebration for crisis workers and when we took a vote, Eli's won . The quantity, quality , packaging and delivery is superb- the food is extra delicious. The best penne vodka, eggplant parm and chicken Marsala around and to boot the staff is always friendly and helpful!! Trinitas Behavioral health workers loves our Eli's ! read more

See all

I had the food delivered to my hotel - Angel hair pasta with meatballs and a side of sausage - also Caesar salad I will order this again - am sure everything is awesome from them - big menu! read more

See all

The food is magnificent. I ordered chicken parm, pasta and salad. Not only was the portion huge, but it was cooked to perfection. The cutlet was tender. The sauce is homemade - thick, tangy, and flavorful just like grandma used to make. I grew up in Italian Canarsie in Brooklyn and Eli's food is better! Don't stop at the pizza. Order a meal from this gem. I live on the west coast now and there is no comparable food. read more

Fast, friendly service! Ordered takeout on consecutive nights because it was sooo good! Pizzas were fantastic and the stuffed mushrooms were even better! I highly recommend Eli's if you're in the area. read more

The pizza was amazing! I will definitely eat there again when I'm back in Jersey! The meatballs were very delicious. I wish I had ordered a meatball sandwich as well. I would definitely recommend Eli's. read more

Best margarita pizza in town. The chicken francese is delicious. So many options to chose from you won't be disappointed.

We order the margarita pizza and it was delicious, def will try other items in the menu next time

I end up at one of the Newark Airport hotels a couple times a month. And Eli's is my go to for great food. Pizza is really good as are salads. Delivery service is timely always. But their Meat Lasagna is outstanding!!! Very flavorful and plenty for two (although easy enough for one to finish it is so good). Love it. Highly recommend. read more

Great Pizza and very friendly employees. Order pizza to go and it was very fast, it had cooled off by the time I got to my hotel but it was still delicious! This will definitely be a stop o have to make again when I'm in Newark! read more

On the way home from our Cruise needed a NJ PIZZA fix. ELI's Pizza In Elizabeth NJ - You can't get ANY better than Jimmy and his team at Eli's Pizza read more

Eli's Pizza Pasta - ELI's Pizza - JIMMY is the best !! Excellent Pizza - Excellent Team !! We had a great time ! - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

See all