Went to Michelinos for an early dinner on a Saturday. I was thinking it would be a beat up old school pizzeria, but it was actually a really nice restaurant. Our waiter took our drink orders, and brought us a complimentary basket of freshly made bread. It was really good. For appetizers, we got the hot antipasto for 2 as well as an order of calamari. My favorites from the hot antipasto were the eggplant rollatini and clams oreganata, but everything tasted great. For my entree, i got the Sicilian short rib, which was served with a wild mushroom risotto. The short rib was a huge portion for the price, an entire short rib. It was tender, well seasoned, and delicious. The mushroom risotto was very savory and rich. I would definitely order this again. I'd definitely return to this spot. read more

Michelinos Pizzeria - Peterstown - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

Good pizza but on the pricier side vs nearby pizza places. The pie is on the thinner side but crispy and ingredients are generous. A loaded pizza cost $35+ but good quality dough. There are top pizza places in NYC for $35 pies. read more

The burger was good until I pulled out a long brown hair It's really to bad because the food is usually Ok. And it's close to home but, it's unacceptable to find hair in your food ‍ read more

Oh my goodness, I don't know what took me so long to come back to this place. Everything about it is five stars. My boyfriend had never been here before and was like why haven't you haven't you taken me here before. LOL. We started with the sausage crostini which was practically a meal in itself and sooo good. I asked our server for his recommendation of the pork osso bucco or the scallops and he suggested the pork. My boyfriend had the stuffed sole and he loved it. My sangria was just as I remembered it, the best I ever had. Jerry, the owner who I haven't seen in years came around to make his rounds. It was so good to see him after all these years. Like I said, everything was great and the prices are nice. My boyfriend and I will definitely be back soon. read more

Michelinos Pizzeria - Sangria - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

See all

The food was awesome. I had a pepperoni and a general tso pizza and a side salad. It was delicious and reasonably priced. I will return before I leave the area!! The service was great! The guy behind the register was knowledgeable about the food and suggested the general tso pizza. It was a hard sell as I don't generally like chicken on my pizza. I'm glad I took his advice! The ambience was very minimalist and laid back. I will definitely eat here aga read more

Everything was good from here. The chicken vodka was my favorite. The wings were good too. Delivery was as promised- time wise.

Haven't ate here in a while. And I regret doing so. The buffalo chicken had shredded chicken on it...SHREDDED. It was gross. The chicken looked dried out. The bottom of the pizza was soggy. Over all flavor was not good. Idk who's running this place now but they are definetly doing a very bad job. Will not be ordering pizza from here again. Left a horrible taste in all of our mouths. read more

Michelinos Pizzeria - Buffalo chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

See all

Always the best never disappoint outstanding service always been going there for years never a problem

We're long time customers, but had to go back this weekend as we heard about the new look. Food was excellent and the place looks great. The service was on point. You really can't beat the value of this place. Did I mention to have the cannoli zepoles for dessert? Loved it all! read more

Michelinos Pizzeria - Penne Vodka - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

See all

My work always orders from them. The onion rings are the bomb and the pizza is the best. delivery guys are nice never had any big issues

I enjoy my bacon ranch pizza I I visit every two days and will continue so I have a lot of family's that wants to go there exactly the restaurant thanks keep doing what you do good work Gracias Raul Claudio read more

The best pizza in town Good food Amazing service Fast delivery Good prices Different options available read more

Always delicious and delivery people are always polite. We order our pizza, mussels and wings from Michelino's and are extremely happy with their food and delivery service!! read more

This place is yummy! A group of us usually order here for delivery since we work at the airport. It's really good! The eggplant parm sub is delish. I ordered a salad and it was huge. Everyone had no complaints about their orders. Super tasty and worth ordering from especially in the Elizabeth area. read more

Simple pizza or fine dining all in one. The food is amazing. Parking can be challenging so avoid peak hours or Uber but definitely worth it

Where do I start our waiter was so nice and attentive, the food was everything and so much more I was so satisfied, and on our way out we met the owner who was so pleasant and appreciative I say go on a date very cute ambiance or for a girls happy hr which I will be going back for I went on a date and he enjoyed himself as well. read more

I visit Jersey once a year (moved away 10 years ago) and Michelinos is alway a must stop. I have been around the USA and hands down this is the best! read more

Michelinos Pizzeria - If you know...you know - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

Stopped by for a plain cheese slice and a Sicilian slice. Good pizza but nothing that stands out. The Sicilian had a nice crust that was crisp on the outside and soft on the inside but there was too much parm cheese on top. That's really all I tasted. I do not like parm cheese and would have preferred they left it off and allow you to add it after. Stick with the plain slice if you don't like parm cheese :) read more

Michelinos Pizzeria - Plain cheese slice and Sicilian slice - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

Awesome place for all your Italian needs. The delivery is a bit slow but worth it. This place is awesome if you want authentic go there. read more

This is a great place for a meal with friends and family. Food is great and the attention is above and beyond. Have been there many times and it has never been disappointing. The only drawback is not Much parking space. If it would not be because of lack of parking I would give it a high 5 stars read more

I'm a fair reviewer the pizza here is AMAZING ! The stuffed portabella mushrooms are really good, but this was probably one of the WORST appetizers I have gotten in while. It was half a mushroom, then a small mushroom that still had a little stump on it . The breading was 6x the size of "mushrooms". I am assuming they were probably at the bottom of barrel. Typically, it's a one plump mushroom on the bottom. Please stay consistent even on to go orders. I love that item. read more

Michelinos Pizzeria - Stuffed Portabella Mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

Love their pizza I was born and raised in Elizabeth and they are my number one place . You can dine in or carry out.

I did my son confirmation the service, food and ambiance were excellent . I would recommend for any type of events. Looking for my next event. Rosa read more

MICHELINOS FOR TAKE OUT IS EXTRAORDINARY!!! Consistent with Flavors! Cheesesteak sandwich is AMAZING. Goat Cheese Salad is delicious and always very fresh. And the Plain Pizza is Pie is the Best one I have found in NJ. Not only is it good put delivery of pie is on point, never sliding and clumped cheese like other places. Oh and I almost forgot the most important thing MODIFIERS FOR FOOD ARE OUT OF THIS WORLD! You give us the options that we wish other places did. We will continue to order. We Love Michelinos!!! read more

I order from Michelinos every 3 weeks. When I moved to NJ 10 years ago I fell in love with their pizza. They remain the restaurant my family and I order the most food from. It's disappointing to write a bad review, but here we go. I ordered a half cheesesteak. Asked for only American cheese and ketchup. It was printed on the receipt. I get a full cheesesteak with ketchup, cheese and mayo. Nope. I detest mayo. Can't stomach it. Called the restaurant, young lady says they don't usually put mayo on cheesesteaks. Welp, they did with this one. (Why invalidate your customer?) She puts me on hold. Comes back and says "I talked to the guy who made the cheesesteak - he says he didn't put mayo on the sub." Ma'am. Who is this "guy"? She said she would replace the sub. I asked for a refund. She said she won't refund me unless she got the sub back. Dude...WTF. This is the hill you're willing to die on? Take the damn sub. Waste gas to have a driver come back to my home. You f'd up. Here are the pics. I hope people see how companies can make great food and suck at customer service. Keep that same energy when I call you back tomorrow because your driver never showed up. Update: I called the following day and a different employee (presumably a manager) acknowledged that she had received complaints about this employee before and offered a credit for my food. I appreciate the quick resolution but I sincerely hope you either retrain that young lady or let her go because she's not good for business. read more

See all

Awesome ordered a Penn pasta with garlic and oil, capers, and chicken. Delivered on time still warm freshly made. Also did a spinach dip incredible combination. read more

The best Italian good in union county. I fly all over the world and compare this place with the very best The food us delicious. The drinks are over the top. It's quaint romantic place. The staff is awesome. A true gem in New Jersey Parking can be a challenge but it's worth the distance. 5 stars plus. read more

The pizza here .... is weakening !! They have these tiny creme puffs that are stuffed with a cannoli filling- OMG Our server was absolutely amazing, Ana and Steven you're the best. Both drinks and food were tendered in a timely manor. Both wings were delicious. The pene vodka pizza is my recommendation to you. The bacon cheese burger was also good, burger was served on a Kaiser roll- which was different. The raviolis were AMAZING !!!!! Restaurant is super clean and organized, it's a great spot to have a couple of drinks and chill. As far as menu pricing goes, it's very affordable. Both food and drinks! We love Michelinos! read more

See all

I got take home from here about a month ago. Presentation was nice but only 1 out of the 3 things I ordered had a good taste. The whipped mash is blah, the cheese ravioli had a thick pasta and not enough cheese. Lastly I had the spinach dip which was good. My favorite was the foundation soda. I ordered 15 minutes before going into the store and still had to wait 20 minutes. It was Friday afternoon post covid though. read more

Michelinos Pizzeria - a person holding a receipt - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

Ordered from here multiple times and they always deliver consistently good food and service.

Fantastic! Simply fantastic! The food was amazing! The ambiance was funky Elizabeth.... Nicest people working here. Highly recommend... without a doubt. Lina is an absolute gem! Thank you for amazing service! read more

Michelinos Pizzeria - Vegetarian pizza - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

See all

was my first time order from this place and I'm very disappointed my order was a personal pizza with chicken and spinach the chicken looks like shredded chicken and spinach like yes take out from the frozen spinach bag I don't think recommend or back to order from that place read more

Michelinos Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

Service is horrible nasty lady at the counter and the pizza is lacking flavor. Not the best

the pasta was very good! the waiter awkward. i saw a vape at the counter and my little girl could have grabbed that! the food was so good! but service needs a little work! read more

Was not impressed. Lasagna was ok. Pizza was ok nothing noteworthy. Seems to be popular but I wouldn't go back.

Last night i went for something more familiar and had Italian at Michelinos Pizza. There is a pizza joint in the front with a full restaurant in the back. There is a nice bar as you walk in, ample seating in that area as well as in a full dining room area. I ordered a drink and asked for bread and was told, yes, it is almost ready... Yep, it was fresh made and served with olive oil, parmesan cheese, butter, etc. I ordered the appetizer special which was asparagus wrapped in prosciutto covered in some balsamic oil dressing on top of arugula and roasted sweet peppers. It was absolutely delicious. For dinner, I was already relatively full but ordered the Penne Pasta in Vodka Sauce with a side of sausage. I was very pleased with everything. It's in the middle of a neighborhood and seems to be mostly frequented by locals. I'd imagine they will be there for a long time to come. read more

See all

Just as I thought this place couldn't get any better IT DOES. I have been a costumer for years. My family and I dine in and take out all the time the food is always delicious. The services is amazing, They are always willing to fulfill my crazy order and last night Jerry really outdid himself. I called to place my order and he was a little taken back by my request of having him write BE MY VALENTINE with pepperoni on a pizza. He made it happen and not only was the pizza delish it looked better then what I imagined. read more

Michelinos Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

We were visiting NJ and was recommended this place for pizza by someone local there. The pizza was freshly made and was very delicious and the staff was nice. This is one of these family owned Italian cuisines and give you the vibe and has home made food. Would recommend. read more

Worst cheesesteak I've ever had. Wrong bread that wasn't toasted. Cheese wasn't melted. Good portion though ...

I do frequent the restaurant side, not only for the great food but also for the relaxed atmosphere and friendly staff. This past weekend I had my father's surprise 80th birthday party there and a the crew at Michelino's couldn't so anything more for me! Even Jerry (owner/executive chef) popped out from his busy kitchen at least four times to see how everything was going. Besides the bountiful appetizers ranging from cold antipasta, perfectly fried calamari, to eggplant rollatini,I made some Italian (family style) selections and my 45 guests were blown away! The main courses were Chicken Marsala and Veal Dishes were superb, perfectly cooked and flavorful. The service was on point led by a young vibrant staff! Hats off to the fam at Michelino's and thank you for making the perfect party. read more