My friend and I went here for the first time yesterday. Their cheesecake is outstanding! We got the lemon blueberry and salted caramel. Seriously if you love cheesecake, you need to go! They had a variety of flavors. I'd like to see a low carb version if possible, like what I've had at the Cheesecake Factory. I definitely will be back. read more

Everything Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Martinsburg, West Virginia

Let me just say that I'm not a fan of cheesecake but this place has made me an avid lover of theirs. Pepperoni rolls are also amazing. You're missing out of you don't at least try this place! read more

Good variety. Excellent cheesecake. No better place around. There is always something new to try. The traditional sells out quickly.

Great cheesecakes! Very tasty! I just wonder if $5.00 a slice is going to price some out of the restaurant. Martinsburg just isn't known for high quality "mom and pop" restaurants. Personally I think it's well worth the money. read more

Perhaps there is better cheesecake in the world. Perhaps that slice of light, creamy goodness is sold just across town. Or, just maybe, the salted caramel, turtle and lemon-blueberry cheesecake, among many other awesome flavors that rotate in and (quickly sold) out of this specialty bakery's display case, can't be topped by anyone, anywhere. Doubt me? Try it. You absolutely will not be disappointed. Baked daily, there are regular flavors like the aforementioned salted caramel, New York-style and peanut butter, and then there are unbelievable creations that border on heresy (to our benefit) such as the pecan pie cheesecake in which a whole pecan pie is combined with cheesecake baked on top. I could ramble on and on about the cheesecake made at this bakery (as well as the great drip coffee sold there and the inviting atmosphere) when only two words are necessary - Simply amazing. read more

Everything about this cheesecake is excellent! The flavor, consistency, the crust, the creative flavors! It's a quiet, pretty shop where you can sit and have a cafe and dessert. I tried the pumpkin and reeses. Both were excellent, the reeses-- a touch too sweet for me personally, but I certainly enjoyed it and spread the slice out over a couple days. I know my mom called and told you that I said this already, but she told me I should post it to you myself. Cheesecake Factory, here in DC has nothing on your Pumpkin cheesecake! Honestly! It's so good and just perfect. Also customer service was amazing as well. Can't wait to get back to Martinsburg for a piece! read more

Phenomenal cheesecake. A little treasure that makes Martinsburg better just by its presence. The menu is super limited, of course, serving only variations of cheesecake, drip coffee (from Black Dog in Ranson), and bottled drinks, but I don't think I've had better cheesecake anywhere else and it's quite charming inside. I do hope they expand their coffee and tea options in the future, as I think it would be even more of a destination. read more

Probably the best cheesecake I've ever had! I've tried about 10 of the flavors so far and they're all delicious (especially salted caramel and lemon). They usually have scones which are also amazing but sell out fast. read more

Amazing cheesecakes. Plenty of variety and they will even make a request a couple days out. Anyone looking to fulfill that sweet tooth definitely should stop here. Full flavor and reasonably priced options read more

The best cheesecake around town! This place puts the Cheesecake factory to shame the owner so great, multiple options of cheesecake to choose from. Everyone is so friendly and welcoming. My wife and i will be returning..... weekly haha read more

Everything Cheesecake - The best cheesecake around here Amazing experience! - Bakeries Near Me - Martinsburg, West Virginia

A must stop if you anywhere nearby. The blueberry cheesecake is amazing! Very friendly. Nice and quaint.

My wife and I came here for the first time the other day and we're extremely impressed. The shop is very nice and the staff was extremely polite. The cheesecake was amazing. We checked their FB page and their menu changes everyday with a large variety. Couldn't ask for more! read more

My wife and I love this place. Great cheesecake and friendly service. They have a nice variety of cheesecakes and daily specials.

My husband and I Found this place while traveling through town and OH MY GOSH! Definitely a must go place for anyone with a sweet tooth! My husband doesn't even like cheesecake and he loved the Peanut Butter Cup. I decided on the strawberry and both were so DELICIOUS! (Of course I tried his as well) read more

Had a slice of heaven when I tried their cheesecake. A friend of mine picked up some made to order cakes for a holiday dinner and it's the best cheesecake I've ever eaten! So Yummy!!! read more

Awesome place, great food!! Great place for a group, a fun date night or just an afternoon snack! Good prices and wonderful cheesecake!!! Don't let the directions fool you, it's worth finding. Off Raleigh St, right across from the judicial center (old BR outlets) in Martinsburg. read more

A hidden gem in Martinsburg. Very friendly staff, excellent pastries and a generally relaxed and cool atmosphere.

Best dessert place in town. My wife is a cheesecake lover. We used to go to Cheesecake Factory once a month to satisfy her craving. Now we don't even need to travel out of town. She told me these cheesecakes are better than anything she's ever had at Cheesecake Factory. I believe the sugar cookie is her favorite. read more

This is the best place to eat cheesecake .. is from the crash and is the mush authentic cheesecake in West Virginia plus the owner is the most sweet person in this area and makeup feel home ... read more

Wow!!!!! What a find! Cutest place ever and cheesecake is delicious. Impressed with the friendly staff. I highly recommend. Simply WONDERFUL!!!!! read more

The cheesecake is amazing!!!! but the slices keep getting smaller and smaller each time i go and price is the same as good as it is it not worth 5 bucks a slice for a few bites of cheesecake read more