It is hard to truly find a property manager that makes you feel that they are trustworthy and…read morehonest and really care. Well... Rich and his team truly go above and beyond for their homeowners, as well as tenants. They provide great service and can handle any challenge that may arise. You can trust them and that says A LOT. I will use them for all our properties.

We currently lease a Siesta Key residence managed by Bay Area Property Management at nearly $6,000…read moreper month since Sept 2025. During our tenancy, we have documented ongoing concerns relating to property condition, maintenance response, and access coordination that we believe implicate statutory landlord obligations under Florida Statutes Chapter 83, including: * §83.51 - Obligation to maintain premises in compliance with applicable building, housing, and health codes * §83.53 - Notice and limitations regarding landlord access * §83.56 - Failure to cure noncompliance * §83.67 - Prohibited practices and interference with quiet enjoyment * Applicable provisions of the Federal Fair Housing Act (under review) Concerns raised during tenancy have included: - Reported HVAC conditions involving possible mold concerns - Incomplete or unsafe stair access affecting safe ingress and egress - Second-story railing deficiencies presenting safety concerns for minor children - Delayed installation of represented safety features and window protections - Non-functioning appliances, including microwave and dryer - Front gate security not operational as represented at lease commencement - Repeated access disputes and contractor arrivals outside expected notice protocols - Installation and operation of surveillance equipment raising privacy concerns Deborah Coolidge, who operates in a principal leadership role within the company, has been directly involved in management decisions concerning this tenancy. These matters are being formally documented and reported to appropriate oversight and regulatory bodies for review, including: * Florida Department of Business & Professional Regulation (DBPR) * The Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC), if applicable * The National Association of Realtors (ethics review, if applicable) * The Better Business Bureau * Local building and code enforcement authorities We are long-standing professionals and active members of the local community who entered this lease in good faith. Our expectation is straightforward: contractual performance, statutory compliance, and safe conditions for our family. Prospective tenants are strongly advised to carefully review lease terms, confirm maintenance and entry procedures in advance, and document all communications in writing. If other tenants have experienced similar concerns, we encourage them to seek independent legal counsel and document their experiences appropriately.

I would not recommend using this company . If you do have no choice but to rent from them. Take…read morephotos of the entire house and yard before and after you move in/move out. I would recommend an attorney on standby to fight them for your security deposit. This company awful

We had an excellent experience working with Rebecca Kelly and Michelle Gailey at Eaton Realty. As…read morefirst-time homebuyers, we had a lot of questions and wanted to be thoughtful and thorough throughout the process. Rebecca and Michelle were incredibly helpful from start to finish. Rebecca brought a tremendous amount of experience, practical guidance, and market insight. She helped us think through offer strategy, negotiation, inspection concerns, contract terms, and the many details that come up between going under contract and closing. Her advice was direct, knowledgeable, and valuable at each step, especially when we needed to make decisions quickly but still wanted to feel confident. Michelle was also wonderful to work with. She was kind, responsive, patient, and consistently helpful throughout the process. She made communication easy and helped keep things moving smoothly, which made a stressful process feel much more manageable. Together, Rebecca and Michelle made a great team. They helped us find a home we love, guided us through the moving pieces of the transaction, and made sure we felt supported all the way to closing. We always felt like they were looking out for us and helping us make informed decisions rather than pushing us in any particular direction. We are now moved in and very happy with the home. We are grateful for all of their work and would absolutely recommend Rebecca and Michelle to anyone looking to buy a home in the area.

Rebecca (Becky) with Eaton Realty is exactly what you want in your corner when selling a…read morehome--action-oriented, detail-focused, communicative, transparent, and highly market-savvy. We went from listing to sale in about 5 months--faster than many comparable homes in Fishhawk Ranch. Becky understands that it's you vs. the market, and she knows how to position you to win. I always recommend meeting multiple agents for a decision this important--but Rebecca should absolutely be one of them. This comes from someone who has both sold homes and trained real estate agents. We've also worked with Eaton on the property management side, and the experience has been just as strong. They maintained the home to a high standard through every phase--residence, rental, and eventual sale--over a 4-year period. Communication was consistent (same or next day), and work orders were handled quickly and professionally. Their fees may be slightly higher than some competitors, but the value is clear--you get what you pay for in this business. Eaton Realty is the complete package. Highly recommend.

I greatly appreciate their professionalism, knowledge of the market, commitment to prompt…read morecommunication and responses to emergencies. Having done this myself in 4 different states, their speed of communication and attention to detail is so refreshing! I wish I could duplicate them in other states!

I was helping my parents find a place in Tampa while still in Chicago. We had an impossible…read moretimeline and some difficult criteria. I contacted Roland about a property. From there on out he was responsive, courteous, and beyond helpful - the exact opposite of every other property manager I encountered during that search. He was a breath of fresh air and I highly recommend using his services.

Latonia has been a fantastic agent to work with. She listened to our needs and acted quickly to…read morehelp us find our forever home in retirement. She was hands on throughout the contract /loan process to help remove any roadblocks and ensure a quick closing.

From the owner: Luxury properties and luxury property management Relocation…read moreSpecialist Investment Property