Fantastic ice cream and fudge store, right in the middle of Fernandina Beach Historic District on Amelia Island. They specialize in Fresh Marble Slab Fudge, Hand dipped chocolates, and great ice cream. Line was out the door on Friday night with many locals and tourists with the locals saying best ice cream on the island. We had 2 scoops each in a cup. I had the salted caramel praline and triple peanut butter and my wife had chocolate mint and birthday cake.... This ice cream is simply incredible. Fresh, creamy, flavorful and can't wait to go back before we leave. Servers are high school kids very friendly and keep the line moving. I believe it's a family owned business and has been open since 1988. Highly recommend read more

See all

I was told this was the spot to stop during my time here. I was looking forward to it the entire weekend, however, I didn't end up getting anything once I stopped in. I had a worker scan me up and down (particularly looking at my chest) once I came in, and greeted me after staring for a good 10 seconds. I'm sure this place is amazing so I feel bad giving it such a low rating, but I felt so uncomfortable I had to leave - and not for nothing, I was with my entire family. I just wish these workers were more friendly because I would've loved to try it :( read more

Small ice cream and fudge store on the main walk. We got all different flavors in the waffle cones. Ate outside as the weather was nice! Girls at the counter were polite and professional. I wish my scoop would be a little bit larger but I guess that flavor was running low?! You have to treat yourself plus they were open on Sunday so we are coming back to try their fudge ;) read more

See all

Cute storefront with great ice cream. Blueberry cheesecake was a favorite, but I don't think anyone left unsatisfied. Service was quick despite a long line, and portions/price were average for the area. read more

Nice ice and fudge shop with walk up counter service. Staff is very friendly and helped with allergen questions. We had Moosetracks and Salted caramel praline. Pricey, but both were Oh So Good! read more

Their coffee ice cream is so good. The blueberry cheesecake ice cream has actual chucks of cheesecake in it. Always a favorite for when we come and vacation every year. read more

Very fudge? No reslly, there is a lot of fudge, and white chocolate, but they also have a good selection of ice cream too. We only sampled the ice cream and something called a coconut cloud, but there were a ton of choices like: Chocolate covered pretzels Chocolate covered nutter butters Pecan Pralines Chocolate covered caramel corn. In short, you will find something you will like. read more

A great stop while shopping or walking around town. The fudge is off the chain delicious, especially the rocky road variety. They also have about ten ice cream flavors if you're in the mood, and a variety of chocolate treats. The white chocolate Oreo was tasty! Friendly folks. A few seats inside, and benches outside. read more

Fantastic Fudge - Outside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

This place is busy after dinner, shorter lines mid day. Best ice cream and fudge on the island. We had chocolate ice cream, and fudge. We will be back. read more

Abigail was a great help super kind. Lemon sorbet was great also enjoyed the chocolate peanut butter fudge

Fantastic Fudge really does have fantastic fudge among many other delicious treats. Hubby is a huge fan of fudge so naturally we had to take a look at the case while we were up in Fernandina. Their rocky road and peanut butter fudge was so good! A few other items that I think are awesome include: milk and dark chocolate pretzels, dark cashews, pecan turtles and chocolate covered Oreos. With the holidays upon us, stop in today for some tasty Christmas gifts! read more

See all

Great ice cream!! We walked in and we were greeted right away. They were friendly and will let you try the different flavors. Friendly fun cute store! read more

See all

We come just for a small treat after dinner. It's always busy and so worth the wait! We got coconut clusters and chocolate fudge...it did not disappoint! We enjoyed sitting outside for some people watching too. read more

Fantastic Fudge - Coconut Clusters - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Absolutely must visit for ice cream while on vacation! Good ice cream, great fudge, fun for all ages! Almost always a line out the door, especially on weekends! read more

Fantastic Fudge - A must for ice cream on vacation! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

My favorite place on Amelia Island to get ice cream is at Fantastic Fudge. Now there's usually a line our the door, but the staff is usually pretty efficient and it moves relatively quickly. I've also only had ice cream from here. I love the Raspberry Haze, but everyone has their own preferences. The rest of my family goes for cookies n cream, cookie dough, butter pecan - and no complaints. read more

See all

Busy busy busy. Ice cream with large topping selection. But my favorite was the pecan praline. It just melts in your mouth! The fudge and chocolate selection will leave you wondering which one(s) do I buy because I really want to try them all! Small shop but judge selection. It's always busy but they have enough folks working there to move the line pretty quick. read more

See all

Person was nice and gave samples - got my change right Amazing cookies n cream 9.5/10 Nice white theme and cool colors and ambiance read more

Fantastic Fudge - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

NOT what it claims. I understand why they don't give out samples: it's not economical in these tough times and if they did, no one would buy it! I think the ingredients are fresh (at least the marshmallows in the rocky road were), but the fudge was hard the next day! I made the mistake of assuming it looked so good, it would taste at least good. I didn't get much of a chocolate flavor and certainly not the taste of nuts. My next mistake was buying it shortly before closing on my way to dinner, so I didn't eat much more than a tiny bit on my way to restaurant...and it wasn't creamy then. The next day, it was hard, grainy, and crumbly. Perhaps that's not a popular flavor and it's been sitting around, but for $10 a slice, I expected more. So disappointing. read more

We really enjoyed the ice cream here. I had the mocha almond fudge in a waffle cone, and it's definitely high quality ice cream. The single scoops are huge too. There was a long line when we went, but they have a ticket ordering system. Make sure you grab a ticket, because that takes priority over who is ahead in line. read more

Tried the Cookie Monster icecream today! It had pieces of chocolate chip cookie dough and cookies and cream! The cone was crisp and fresh. They weren't too busy on the weekday in the afternoon, but on weekends - the line can be out the door! read more

Fantastic Fudge - Raspberry chocolate chip and mint chocolate chip - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

After enjoying a lobster roll, we took a quick walk around and found this delicious shop! All items are marked with allergens. I enjoyed a HUGE scoop of rocky road, in a cup. The smallest scoop was still huge! It tasted fresh, and delicious! Terrific way to top off a delicious meal. Smiling faces, quick service and delicious ice cream-not sure you could ask for more. read more

Really good ice cream. And very nice shop decoration! The girl at the front was very kind and friendly. Restaurant was nice and clean. read more

See all

Yummm!!! Some of the best icecream I've had!! They have so many choices of flavors or icecream, and you can get milk shakes too. They also sell fudge which I wish we had tried. I got the cookie butter icecream and my husband got the chocolate milkshake. Both were so good!! The staff are super friendly also, answering our questions and letting us try some of the icecreams. Such a cute icecream shop, I would love to have gone back again!! Next time! read more

Fantastic Fudge - Cookie Butter icecream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

After deciding to change up our dessert venue, Fantastic Fudge was the place to be. They had a raspberry chocolate chip that was top notch. The butter pecan was excellent also. Not many good places to sit inside, so we walked (in the rain) back to the car. read more

Just all sweet treats with awesome ice cream and fudge, if you come at right time you can watch the fudge being made read more

See all

Such a classic and one of my favorites in Fernandina! Although I have not tried the fudge, the ice cream is wonderful! We ordered the butter pecan, it was delicious! We'll be back! read more

Fantastic Fudge - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

A Fernandinho Beach landmark! I used to take my girls there for ice cream 28 years ago after dance lessons... Classic ice cream flavors. Superman ice cream was changed to superhero but everything else was the same. Great fudge too! read more

This place was packed but we heard it was worth it. It was cool inside so we didn't mind a wait. We both ordered the salted caramel ice cream. Best ever!! read more

Fantastic Fudge - Salted caramel ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Best Hot Chocolate, Ice Cream and Chocolates around - there are other places that have ice cream but you will notice this one always has a line *there is a reason for that* read more

Ah well the fudge passed the spouses review, both the peanut butter and the chocolate peanut butter. Not cheap mind you but what is nowadays? Especially in touristy areas. No cherry vanilla or black cherry ice cream so I had to go with strawberry, again not the best I've had and not the worst. Service was fast and efficient no problems there I am surprised by so many young workers present, and working as a team. read more

I ordered a small cup with Blueberry Cheesecake & Chocolate Fudge ice cream. I like that you can order two different flavors and there is not an up charge. I loved the blueberry cheesecake. It was very good. The chocolate fudge was okay but not my favorite. read more

Fantastic Fudge - Blueberry Cheesecake & Chocolate Fudge ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

This place is really popular so be mindful of the time you decide to come, if you go after dinner on the weekend be prepared for a line. The ice-cream is yummy and fudge is great for what it is. This place offers typical tasty ice-cream & dessert items. The only downside is they don't have really any dairy substitute options that I noticed. However, coming here after lunch on a hot day is a great way to treat the family! read more

Walking around Fernandina taking in the sights, it was refreshing to have some great ice cream on a hot day.

Busy place. Line moves quickly. Excellent ice cream. Decent selection of flavors. Fudge made live. Cool to watch. Super sweet smells in the air. read more

10/10 fudge was delicious and perfectly made. Inside is a bit crowded with people trying to order ice cream right by the front door but a great spot to grab some sweets. read more

We stopped in here after strolling around. Having just had Mayday in Jacksonville the night before, my expectations were set pretty high. I ordered strawberry and was very disappointed when i saw it was bright pink. This is usually a sign that it's not as natural and there were no chunks of strawberry inside. We did get some toffee to go to which was pretty good. This wasn't our first time here as we've gotten fudge and I believe they changed their name. They also sell fudge here too if you're up for that too! Overall it's a decent choice for the area but not the best I've had. read more

How can anyone not love his place? There's fresh fudge with samples on display and homemade ice cream! It was hot after we finished the trolley tour so we were looking for something cool to eat or drink. As we strolled along Centre Street, we passed this popular spot and stopped in. The flavors are not wildly creative here but they have the basics that we all love - strawberry, moose tracks, rainbow sherbet, orange creamsicle, berry cheesecake, cookie dough, butter pecan, chocolate, mint chip, double fudge brownie. I got two of my favorites - rocky road and cookies and cream. I wanted a single so I asked about splitting a scoop and I got something even better! Their "single" is actually a large scoop with a smaller one on top versus a double which is two large scoops. As far as I was concerned, the portions were huge! We felt like we really got our money's worth! The only disappointment for me was that despite their having a waffle iron and pieces of waffle near it, I was told that they had been too busy to make their waffle cones. I ended up skipping the packaged ones. Otherwise, the ice cream was excellent - thick, rich, and very creamy. It melts fast though so lick quickly! read more

See all

Outstanding experience Came by today on a busy Saturday afternoon Had some the best service ever by Sarah - she handled the rush and multiple customers - all with a huge smile! Give that young lady a raise and a promotion! Delicious chocolates- large variety made fresh everyday The photos do not lie!!! Had the Cherry Cordial ice cream - so fresh and delicious! read more

See all

Fantastic Fudge is too cute to pass up. You can't just walk by it and not go in. Especially if you catch the scent of fudge in the air (which you will). This place smells so amazing! It's in a little beach downtown area so you can expect lots of families and children. We honestly had to squeeze around kids and strollers and gumball machines to get to the counter to order, but that's all part of it. The line moves quickly and while you're waiting you have so many sugary confections to gaze upon and drool over. No complaints here! If you're lucky they'll be pouring out (or slicing up) freshly made, thick, velvety fudge on those big marble tables in the back. We saw a block of fudge waiting to be divvied up, but no action during our visit. Ah, well. There's plenty to peruse between the fudge, candies, chocolate-dipped everything, and the ice-cream. I left with a couple fat squares of dark-chocolate covered caramels with lots of sea salt on top. Extremely good and so rich, I could only eat half at a time. Jon ended up with a couple scoops of ice cream on a cone. Everyone left happy! Prices are for tourists, but nothing unexpected. And the quality is there so you won't be disappointed. read more

See all

Really awesome ice cream from a local creamery! We will be back. They even had homemade chocolate covered raisins, my wife's fav.