state farm was charging me double the price I got from Weimer Over. Great savings and super nice…read morepeople.

From the owner: If you are looking for a local Lancaster, NY insurance agent to take care of your insurance needs,…read moreyou have come to the right place! Weimer Over Agency has been serving the Lancaster, NY area for over 50 years and has built a reputation for client satisfaction through hard work, dedicated employees, and the best customer service in the business. We Offer Complete Insurance Programs Personal Coverage * Auto * Home * Condominiums * Umbrella * Watercraft, Motorcycles, Recreational Vehicles * Flood * Personal Property Floaters for Jewelry, Fine Arts & Collections * Renters * Snowmobile * Landlord Business Coverage * Business Owners Policies * General Liability * Contractors Liability * Property * Automobile * Workers' Compensation * Disability * Umbrella * Garage Liability * Inland Marine/Equipment * Boiler & Machinery * Professional Liability

My wife and I bought home insurance through WNY Consulting Group and we had a great experience. Our…read moreagent was Brett, and he did a fantastic job of answering all of our questions and helping us to find the right insurance policy. He was patient and thorough, and we'll definitely use WNY Consulting Group for future insurance policies.

From the owner: Tired of feeling like just another policy number? We work for YOU, not the insurance companies…read more Contact us today!

Very Professional and friendly office. Responsive and someone answers the phone!…read moreThey know what they're doing and do it well. They helped us find good and less expensive insurance for our cars and home. Very highly recommend. Thanks so much!

We love Tony! He has done our taxes for years now! We always bring him a cup of coffee for all of…read morehis hard work and catch up! He also handles our IRA and will be taking care of our business insurance as well! He is a busy guy at tax season and we truly appreciate him!

I was very happy with Ashton's review of my upcoming auto & home policies. He made it very easy to…read moreunderstand what the difference is from year to year & if I had to increase coverage to protect myself & my home & auto. Thank you Ashton, Pat G

Very knowledgeable, very reasonable, approachable and relatable. No pushy sales, keeps it…read morerealistic. And now at a new location.

Very nice man. Receptionist is very sweet. They are there to help. I very much so recommend this…read moreagent

We had my insurance with the agent for many years; when Paul Sr retired and Paul Jr took over the…read moreagency services went downhill. We notified them when we moved several months ago, gave them new address, phone, etc. But just now got a new policy for this up coming year with OLD info!! The address we no longer live at, the phone is disconnected, and I HAD NOTIFIED Paul Jr ofour new information several MONTHS AGO. This is unprofessional and incompetent. Any future correspondence would have gone to wrong address, etc. Called Erie Insurance main agency to let them know, switching local agents ASAP.

I'm a new customer and I'm leaving because I had a special situation which I explained in detail in…read moreadvance and he said he could help me. Instead he lead me on a three month nightmare. If your child no longer lives with you, you cannot insure one of your cars in their name without transferring ownership first. This was difficult for me because the car was wrecked and restored and NY state requires a salvage inspection and new title in order to transfer ownership. The process takes a couple months and this agency either didn't know or said whatever they needed to say to get my money, knowing I would be stuck with them until it got straightened-out. Either way they failed miserably. When Travelers underwriting dep't rejected my daughter's new policy my agent put her on my policy with NY Central and said problem solved. They rejected it too and cancelled my entire policy. Until I got an unexpected refund check in the mail I did not know I had no insurance on ANY of my vehicles for three weeks. For this alone New York Central and Nickel City Insurance gets a failing grade. They are fully aware how anal NY state is about car insurance yet they don't seem to understand NY insurance law. I was an innocent victim of that who got put through the wringer. They made no apology, just excuses, blaming the state when they were at fault, nor did they offer in any small way to make it up to me which is what prompted this review. I waited a few months to calm down and write this as objectively as I can. If you have a straightforward situation they're probably ok, but for us it couldn't have gone worse.