Their rates are great but their customer service is beyond any expectation…read more We can't help but shop a little every other year so and even if there maybe a few dollars to save it has never been enough to move because their service level is amazing and normally their rate is still the best. Just recently even... After the tornado's came thru last year and Pat was double checking what the roofer's did and he saw something, made the call and got them back up there to secure the tarps better. We would have never known, and then during the pandemic, making it over to help with an insurance claim and being prepared to keep our family safe and we have been with them for over a decade now. They insure 5 homes and 3 vehicles. We are blessed to have found them.

I am giving 3 stars because the company did not do right by me as a long time customer of over 15…read moreyears. Their customer service used to be phenomenal, the past few years not so much. After my son got his license, They added him to our policy without my authorization and without discussing the option of another company, Erie now wants me to pay over $1200 for a couple month policy. (This is due to Renz adding without taking to me or my husband first). I was misinformed on what would have to be done when my son got his temporary and then Renz added him and is blaming Erie for telling them to do it. I've asked Renz to make this good by me since I have been a long time customer and it was ultimately their error for not contacting me. I would be willing to pay half but Renz says there is nothing they can do. I normally don't write reviews like this but other people need to know what they might be getting themselves into. The company used to be great and I've referred many people. This is truly sad and I cannot believe I am even writing this review.

Kim, at Mike's office, has been nothing but helpful and communicative with me at every step of the…read moreway whenever I have had a question or concern involving my insurance policies.

These people are trying to rip me off. I deal with a agent name Kim. When she went set of my home…read moreowners she said she would take it out my escrow account. I never had my homeowners taken out of my escrow, but I thought she new what she was doing. A month later I get a letter from the bank saying I don't have coverage. Called Kim I'll send another memo. One month later the same thing. A month later same thing, but this time the bank said they woul give their insurance. I called the bank and the found the memo. Now this went on since September 24. All this time I thought my insurance was being paid, but last week she hits me up for 500 bucks. I don't think I should own this. Her assistant Tristan told me we would start the policy over in January. Don't deal with these people.

Just recently worked with this agency and they saved me a ton of money. They'll quote you with…read morevarious providers so you can see the spectrum of the market in terms of pricing. Renee was our agent and she's fantastic.

From the owner: The Best Insurance Agency in Medina, Ohio! Voted Medina Gazette Best Agency 2022, 2023, 2024, and…read more2025! We offer personal insurance, business insurance, benefits, risk management, and more!

I've had my personal lines insurance with McManus for 13 years. Ryan can sound abrupt if you don't…read moreknow him, but Amy at the agency is fabulous! She's kind, personable, and extremely responsive and professional.

I worked for an insurance company for years and know how insurance works. This knowledge helps me…read morerealize how well taken care of I am at the McManus Agency. Ryan always asks the right questions to determine what I need in the way of coverage for my home and car. I had an auto claim and it was handled quickly and efficiently with one phone call. My daughter has had an auto claim and was also very pleased with the way it was handled. While I feel it may be prudent to shop around for insurance coverage I'll be staying where I'm very comfortable. John F