My husband found this shop a few miles from our house when he made a wrong turn and, after seeing…read morethe old signs displayed outside, knew I would love it. Sure enough, the shop is straight out of American Pickers, full of rust and patina--everything lovingly used. I had been desperately searching for a dark wooden cabinet with glass doors for the six months I've lived in Fayetteville, browsing craigslist every day and flea marketing on the weekends. I found one within 10 seconds of walking in the door of Back-N-The Day. For $40! I was ecstatic. The owner, who was friendly from the moment we walked through the door, gave me a good deal on a porcelain pitcher that I bought along with it by taking $5 off both items, and he helped us carry the cabinet to our car, even measuring to make sure it would fit for us. The shop houses stacks of furniture, old Pepsi and Coke machines and paraphernalia, gasoline collectibles, vintage art and frames, old tools and cookware, and bits of everything imaginable. It's quite a maze, and really invites those in search of a discovery.

I've been a loyal shopper for years. Love the guys! I can always find something I need or want at…read moretheir store! Stop in and say hi, they would love to see ya!

Very quaint. Smelled so good in there too. Nice people. Cute Christmas gifts that are unique.read more

VERY EXPENSIVE NOT A THRIFT as one might think! Good for the RICH Nice atmosphere, helpful staff!…read morePrices a bit too much and no bargain room for prices!

Walking back from breakfast we walked past this place. Smelled so good we had to stop in. Some…read moreunique items. Grabbed some hot sauces. Would have grabbed some pickles if they were dill. It was nice to be an able to try everything before buying.

The girlfriends and I turned up at Turner Lane while browsing downtown Fayetteville. What a gem!…read more + The muscadine drink is amazing. I was so impressed by the sample the host offered us I bought my own bottle to make smoothies with at home. The brain freeze while drinking this is real, though. + Five pepper chili. The best chili salsa thing I've ever had ever. I am usually crying and dry heaving by the third bite but it's the kind of spicy that makes you come back for more. It goes well on everything, mostly because it tastes good on its own. I deal well with spicy, so others may be more cautious. + The soaps here smell awesome and retains its smell until the last itty bitty bit. My favorites are the almond and cucumber melon. Then I spent enough money and got to choose from a goodie basket. I chose to get the bear jam. The above three things are what I would be coming back for!

Store is very neat and well layout to navigate throughout the store. Owner is helpful and…read morepleasant. Lots to select from, fair, and competitively priced for this type of market. If you don't see anything, it's because you weren't looking.

One more spot for the Fayetteville antique circuit. I remember when this was a very specifically…read moreChristmas-themed store and a slot car hobby shop with a track was in the large space below it. For years after, I neglected checking out the antique store here now. This one is expansive and observes the vendor booth set-up so common for antique stores these days. The selection is mostly what I'll call "home goods". Furniture, kitchen items, decor, lots of framed paintings and pictures, dishes, displays, wall hangings. Of course there's a large assortment checking almost every box, but the above are the ones that stood out most to me. I wasn't blown away by the quality of most items in here nor the selection. This store didn't appeal to me quite as much as others nearby. Prices definitely varied, but seemed mostly reasonable. I will definitely pay another visit in the future.

I LOVE this thrift shop. I try to go in there at least once a week. This store carries a variety…read moreof items some new and some used. The prices are reasonable. When I Shop at this store I find the best stuff at great prices. If you want to find hidden treasures this is the place to shop. You may even find some real collectibles. You will be surprised by the variety of selections that this store has to offer. I like the proprietor, she is very helpful when it comes to locating what you're looking for, also if need be she will sometimes deliver the merchandise.

Great place to get gently used items at a good price. At the same time, you are helping Cora's…read morefund their free programs to those in need. Cora's has a pregnant program to help parents learn about their newborn baby at the same time earning points towards new items for the infant. Also, Cora's has a mentoring program for teens. Your money is well spent here!

They have so much stuff but the place is tiny. And full with people. Maybe it was a busy day or…read moremaybe it is always like this. I assume you'd be able to find some great finds for great prices but you'd need to plan a decent amount of time to look around. There is stuff everywhere. It is fairly organized, it's just a lot to take in. I didn't see any staff other than the check out lady and she had a line so she wasn't able to help anyone.

Honesty a good play and they definitely support a cause and do not mark up prices like most thrift…read morestores! Excellent and helpful staff!

amazing prices, the best selection and the staff are amazing, and super friendly! store is great…read morewith great selection

A lot of things to choose from, and the price is right. The workers were super super nice. 10/10…read morewould recommend frfr

Love love love this place. Great selection for men and women!!! You don't often find a diamond that…read moreshines so bright but this little shop deserves all of the traffic it can get !! Open on Sundays too !!!!

Amazing selection, wonderful owners, and stellar service!…read moreSome truly great pieces to be had!

When I say I despise Plato's Closet as a company, I genuinely mean it. I wasn't even planning to…read moreleave a review, but after attempting twice to sell clothes and being told both times they were "at full capacity," I've completely lost interest in ever coming back. The first time was around 4 PM, and the second was before 2 PM. Even after being told to come at 10 AM instead, I have no desire to make a third trip just to get lowballed and have them mark them up in a mysterious price. If you've ever tried selling to Plato's Closet before, you already know this is the infamous reality. They have one of the worst business models I've experienced for a resale store, and it's frustrating that nearly every location seems to provide the exact same disappointing experience. The employees often come across as snobby, like they work on commission at a luxury department store and see themselves as fashion authorities. Mind you, I brought in genuinely good pieces that people in Fayetteville would absolutely buy. I had Coach bags, Marc Jacobs, Anthropologie, Lululemon, and more. So for them to advertise that they buy clothes all day, only for the rules and capacity to keep change depending on the day or time, is ridiculous. They lost out, not me. If I could leave 0 stars for every Plato's Closet location, I would. Nothing would convince me to return. I only decided to swallow my pride this time because I'm in town trying to sell my remaining clothes before donating them. I don't have personal ill will toward the employees themselves, but honestly, they deserve better than working under such a poorly run system. Seeing the "This Store Is For Sale" sign out front was honestly the cherry on top. No one should consider investing in this company unless they genuinely plan to change its practices and policies, because the current system clearly does not work.

I'm here every week such good clothes! I always get…read morewhatever I'm looking for and good deals on brands

So glad this rip off joint went out of business, they were ripping off their own citizens out of…read moremoney they didn't have, people just wanted a little bit of furniture to put in their homes instead they were sold used furniture for ridiculous prices and even paying more than if they bought it new, Ashley Thompson was the worst ripoff there the daughter...

I had the pleasure of working with Ashley, she's so informative. I bought my dinning room table,…read moreand brand-new sofa from her. The sofa was ordered from Carolina Furniture Co. I wasn't impressed with the cushion foam they used, it's more like memory foam, it leaves as impression of your butt. Other than that, it has some cool stuff in there. Not sure if Ashley is still there, last we talked she was moving. Not to crazy about the wheelchair guy, seems a bit shady