Great store, great people, great dog - what else is there?…read more Spacious and well laid out store, lots of high quality items that you don't expect to see in a hardware store. People are always helpful and friendly. Don't feed Gunner the free popcorn (he will follow you if you get a bag just in case!).

I rarely give reviews but I have to give 2 thumbs up to Beartooth. A person who shall remain…read morenameless dumped their dirty cleaning water down the toilet (my wife) along with the cleaning rag and plugged the toilet for the guest bathroom right before our guests were due to arrive on Sunday afternoon. I drove to Beartooth True Value shortly before they closed. Brian (the owner) helped us with selecting the right snake (less money). Mike who checked us out (an actual plumber) helped us select all the right parts if we needed to pull the toilet in order clear the plug. Brian gave us his cell number in case we needed to come back for a different snake or additional parts after hours. Repairs were a successful. Service way above and beyond. thank you, thank you, thank you, Brian and Mike!!!

Best grocery store we found in our area with a hardware store attached and tons of fishing gear and…read morebait. This place had it all. Friendly helpful staff.

These guys sold me some boots on ebay in Nov of 2022. 4 months later they fell apart, I sent them…read moreback on my nickel. On March 19, 2022 they contacted me and agreed they were defective and they sent me another pair which arrived after March 19th 2022. Now less than a year later I wrote them that the replacement pair has the same issues - cracked rubber on the uppers, cracked all the way through and no longer water proof. Today March 11, 2023 they told me the boots have a one year warranty. I am within the one year warranty but they do not want to honor the warranty saying the warranty started on my original purchase. I feel the warranty should start when the replacements arrived for the defective original pair. They were very sarcastic and belittling in their correspondence with me. The boots are Frog Toggs and junk. The Godfrey's True Value Hardware store is junk too. Beware as they do not stand by what they sell or the warranties they claim to give. Steve

I fell off my bike because the handlebars were really loose and the hardware really close friend…read morebiked over there and we told happened and they repaired my bike for free. They are very nice and professional. every place needs a sore like this. and it is amazing because right as you walk in the store they say how can I help you? It's not just that you walk in and go get what you want, but you go in and very friendly and right to what you need

From the owner: Locally owned and operated with over 30 years experience in the hardware business. We have a…read morefriendly, knowledgeable staff willing to help you with any projects, keys, window repair, plumbing, lawn and garden, rental, sharpening, housewares, paint, plus a lot more

The first week of April, we ordered composite decking to replace our old deck boards. The product…read morecolor was Forest Brown made by Fiberon. The order was delivered two weeks later. The entire bundle was the wrong color, even though the wrapping said Forest Brown. I called the guy we worked with at Home Depot and sent him the picture of what we received. He agreed it was wrong and handled getting it returned to the store. Apparently before the product would be returned, a Fiberon Representative needed to come out and see the problem. One week later, he showed up. Saw the color was wrong (told us incorrectly the product had been discontinued 7 years ago) One more week later the boards and hardware were finally picked up and returned to the Baxter Home Depot. The total we had paid them for this product was 3,279.49. We received a partial refund two weeks later for 1,712.33. We called the store a number of times, at some point we were told they held off a total refund because they thought we were going to reorder. This is late May. We already lost our contractor due to this long delay. We were told we would not receive a full refund until Home Depot was refunded the money from Fiberon. There was no way we were going to pay another large amount of money to order another product from them, then pay interest on a credit card on a refund we should have gotten since they had picked up the product. We decided to just go ahead and finish the old deck since now its full outdoor season and we needed to get things ready and enjoy our space. after several weeks and no additional refund we finally talked to the store manager. They seemed concerned about how this had been handled. Ha guess they thought a refund of 443 should placate us. Today, June 16, the supervisor from Home Depot left a message that the final payment was paid. That was for a whopping 351.00. We have a problem here. They still owe us , 1,223.00!!!!!! We will never ever step foot into another Home Depot store again. What kind of rinky dink kind of place would have such terrible customer service. No apology, no action no nothing except to drag getting us refunded for this long.

Top notch service from a knowledgeable and friendly staff…read more Multiple associates working and all asked "can I help you?" Everything we searched for was in a stock, and the associates recommendations we're spot on.

Replacement Key prices are highway Robbery. Two years ago I had keys made here for $2-$3 dollars a…read morekey. I was just charged $6 dollars a key. Unfortunately I had 12 keys made for a total of $72 dollars. That price is ridicules for keys. I believe Home Depot is still $2.50 a key. I understand they are under new ownership, buyer beware!!

Large selection of hardware supplies and friendly staff. Different sections of products.read more

Sometimes you need a bag of chips and a carton of eggs when you are in the middle of nowhere. Your…read morechoices: Drive 20-30 minutes to a grocery store or head to Bear Trax which is only 5 minutes away. Further proving the desolation of the area are the Christmas decorations; the tree outside was decorated with ornaments and a "dead deer" hanging by its back legs in the tree. (OK maybe I am being slightly dramatic - its not that far out of civilization). Any way. They have every little random thing you might need in a pinch, but it is definitely not a place to do your main shopping. It was $7 for a bag of chips and carton of eggs but it saved a bunch of gas and time, so I think it evens out. I am sure we will be back, frequently, as someone in the family is at the cabin every weekend. Its good to know a place run by nice people exists conveniently nearby.

Was new to the Platte Lake area this summer and anytime we needed something little for repairs they…read morehad it... super convenient for gas and snacks also!! My #1 favorite to find out is they stock many flavors of Schwan's ice cream

Such a wonderful small-town hardware store! The team is always so helpful and thoughtful, and you…read morecan really tell it's a family-run business that cares about its customers. They always seem to have everything you need, and if not, they'll go out of their way to help you find it. A true gem in the community!

Great hardware store every time I've been there for the past 20 years! It's what hardware stores…read moreused to be/should be! Very friendly, helpful folks and they have what you need. Never been stumped