Good store, decent prices and tons of stock. The owner is friendly and helpful…read more I picked up a few items in the clearance section and was floored at all the other great collectibles they have as well. Any toy/collectible fan should give this place a whirl!

All things considered, Chosen One is a fantastic toy and collectible store. The store is clean,…read morewell stocked, and the employees are very friendly and helpful. In addition to just being generally excellent, there's one fun detail that sets Chosen One aside from its competition: All of their "blind boxes" have already been opened and identified. Traditionally, every "blind box" series has an unknown toy inside of an opaque box, so the person buying one doesn't know what they'll get. Instead of following the traditional narrative, Chosen One opens each blind box, and then labels what they are. If you are looking for a specific piece within a blind box line, this is the place to go to get that exact one. Outside of their great blind box selection, Chosen One has a fantastic (and very diverse!) inventory of all sorts of toys and collectibles, new and old. I am positive that there's something for every toy enthusiast here.

Owner is very nice and always knowledgeable! Threat guy and live his Star Wars collectionread more

I'm so surprised this hidden gem of a store has so few reviews. The staff is friendly and helpful,…read moreand very knowledgeable as to what is in the store. The selection is a high point: they have a huge amount of back issues and other comics, including some really fairly priced key Marvels. This store also has some toys from various collections and decades, and I was surprised to see things like Willow merchandise. It's worth a look and a drive.

Took advantage of a first time seller. And wouldn't negotiate at all. Should be comping prices near…read morecustomers.

Terrific "LCS" - local card shop. They carry lots of singles and packs. They also carry a full…read moresuite of supplies at reasonable prices. The folks behind the counter are very cordial and knowledgeable. I'd certainly come back here as I get back into sports card collecting.

The staff are amazing. They are very helpful , large collection of comics at a reasonable price.read more

Very helpful employee who had a lot of patience with my 9 year-young grandson. Try to do your…read moreresearch about prices before coming.

Pretty cool store, very nice selection of comics (new and back issues) and toys (from vintage loose…read morefigures to newer lines like Super7). Great customer service. the owner PJ is a friendly unpretentious guy who greets you as soon as you enter the store. He gave me a good deal in a nice vintage Toy Biz X-men action figure set and a few loose figures. I'm definitely going back. If you are looking for comics or toys, this is the place.

Went to look for some comics, didn't find what I wanted, but a pleasant experience overall and the…read morestore has a decent selection of more modern books.

Best comic book shop in Suffolk County by far. Very helpful and knowledgeable staff. Nice place to…read morego nerd out for a few hours. Amazing selection of fairly priced slabs. Parking is horrible; be careful crossing that road; the drivers are all speeding badly.

Best comic shop on long Island in my opinion. Jason is the owner is awesome…read more A legitimate comic store - tons of keys CGC slabs, magic cards, Pokémon cards, toys, funko, statues. Magic the gathering game night on Sunday's. Can't go wrong in here -- I highly recommend

Brought my Pokémon psycho son in, and the GREAT guy there both knew Everything about Pokémon packs…read moreetc, but when we bought one of them special $11 packs and pulled something which is apparently a great card, the guy (Nathan? I'm sorry I'm bad with names but you're the man!) and my son celebrated TOGETHER. Like, this guy was TRULY happy for my kid, and exciting him even more about it. So much so, my kid asked to take a pic with him and the "awesome pull"

Great selection. Lots of sports cards. Staff is really helpful. Answered all our questions and let…read moreus take our time checking out all the cards. They were very knowledgeable and were super nice. We had a great experience shopping here.

The best shop in the area. The staff are all really knowledgeable and ready to help find what you…read moreneed. They have a good stock of recent back issues and a great selection of board games.

Amazing store filled with tons of new and old comics. Great place to try and fill runs or pick up…read morea run.