Really good creamy ice cream for a reasonable price. The flavor is really good. The girl working there was very nice and keep multiple samples. We definitely come back here. It's connected to Upper Crust and Borough BBQ. Indoor and outdoor seating available read more

See all

Dirty place overpriced and ice cream was melted and refroze in display case. We waited outside 10 min a sign on door said be right back then a unpleasant girl worker waited on us never apologized or smiled you lost many customers waiting. read more

Great service but the ice cream taste was not what we expected. Particularly, mint chip had an aftertaste none of us liked.

Most mediocre ice cream ever. Nothing to come back for. Service was amazing. Even store bought tastes better.

The ice cream was terrible, it had that freezer burnt taste, the cones were so stale made me question how long they sat out. Service was socially awkward, not nice and bubbly like an old ice cream shop should be. The place it self is old looking, (cool looking) rather empty though. NOT the "finest" read more

Ice cream was good but it felt like I was in a wind tunnel with all these fans blowing for no apparent reason. Also the server seems like she just had a fight with her boyfriend. Not pleasant at all. read more

This was a nice addition to the pizza place right next door. We came with a group and they all enjoyed having some ice cream after their dinner. read more

Lulu’s Finest - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

The ice cream was visibly melting, the waffle cone was under cooked and floppy, and the girl at the counter was not professional. I do not recommend. read more

The ice cream was not at all creamy. No nutty flavors. Kind of expensive. Service was just ok...efficient but not friendly (not rude but not welcoming). read more

We thought, if they make their own it must be good and bought one small scoop and two scoops for $17.56 and it wasn't very good. There's much better ice cream for much less. read more

Ice cream was terrible and overpriced for the serving. Giving it 2 stars because the girls behind the counter were so friendly and welcoming!! But would not go back read more

My ice cream looked and tasted freezer burned, with a crumbly bad texture. Most of the ice creams behind the counter looked like that too, or like it started melting and then refroze. Very disappointing ice cream experience. The mint & chip was not freezer burned, but the flavor was not great, had like an "off" mint flavor. read more

We very visiting from out of town we walked in and right of the bat it felt really nice inside looked like your typical ice cream place but the prices are crazy 5.50 dollars a scoop, which wouldn't be that bad if the ice cream was actually good. I had mango and raspberry cheesecake. There was almost no cheesecake in it and the mango... I am not kidding when I say that it tasted like pickles and mustard. It was awful I had to throw it away. Never going back. read more

Seemed like it had potential but sadly the ice cream was very icy and little flavor. The portion is a pretty small scoop. I probably recommend sampling first if they have that option before committing. The cookies were dry and hard sadly as well. read more

Lulu’s Finest - Cherry chocolate pistachio - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Unique ice cream shop with homemade artisan flavors. Love to stroll around after eating at one of the many restaurants near the square, to have our dessert elsewhere & in a cone. This is our new go to spot for frosty treats in Gettysburg. Friendly service and yummy ice cream. Free samples, too. I'm gonna keep my eye out for the green tea ice cream to show up again at some point. I saw from another review that it was really good, and yes it is very hard to come by!! They just don't have it on the menu right now. This quaint ice cream shop is right off the square, a couple doors down from Blue & Gray Bar & Grill. We have found parking spaces along the circle in the past although sometimes you have to drive around & parallel park nearby. But this is a great part of town and fun to stroll through if you have to walk a little ways to get there. read more

Lulu’s Finest - Exterior along York St. in Gettysburg - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Stopped in after lunch and shopping nearby for a quick scoop. Two girls behind the counter were kind, efficient, and generous with the scoops. There was a wide variety of flavors to choose and all three we chose were creamy and yummy. Only complaint is a lack of indoor seating. read more

Ugh. I really wanted to love it. As a new resident we wanted to compare Lulu's to Mr. G's to choose our go-to ice cream spot. I have to agree with others that our $40 dollar ice cream bill for a few scoops hurt even worse after we tasted it. It isn't yucky...just not good. I'm sorry to share that. The actual place was cute but the two kiddos working behind the counter were so cold and not welcoming at all, at least this evening, That made the tipping option even more painful. read more

We were hesitant to try this place this evening, after reading several reviews from last year. However the ice cream was wonderful, the waffle bowl was delicious and the service was great! We came in at 9:50 as they were getting ready to close at 10pm, and were still welcomed in, with a great attitude. If you're hesitant about going because of the reviews please give it a chance, it's actually worth it! read more

Lulu’s Finest - Waffle cone and waffle bowl - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

This location used to be called something else - perhaps it's a new owner? - but the ice cream is as good as I remember. Unfortunately, they don't offer any sugar-free options, so nothing I could have this visit. Lots of great ice cream options for those without sugar restrictions, though, decently priced ($3.50 for a single scoop on a cone). My daughter's cookies and cream was quickly devoured, and the hubs enjoyed his sorbet. Staff was friendly and quick. Window of options is right when you walk in. No seating inside at the moment (it's very tight in there), but there is some seating outdoors - it's close together and not cleaned between guests, but it's somewhere to sit and enjoy your cone before it melts all over ya. read more

yummy birthday cake ice cream! service was also super kind and let us sample a couple flavors

Ice cream is phenomenal, but the customer service was even better. Big love to Davis hospitality and kind words. Visiting from Tucson AZ. Will b back read more

Excellent service and a fantastic selection of ice cream! If you're in the area you definitely need to visit. There's an option for everyone! read more

See all

Really expensive for average/below average ice cream. They didn't have cake cones so we got charged $2 for waffle cones. Flavors don't taste like what they are supposed to?? read more

Not sure how they get away with calling this ice cream, let alone charging top dollar like it's something special. It tastes like it's made with water and is very unsatisfying, both my and my wife had to throw ours out after a couple bites. Go to Mr. g's instead! read more

Terrible customer service from the "owner" The blonde lady working inside was very nice and helpful.... Ice cream was decent.. The owner came over and escalated a de-escalated situation. She literally stood staring at us while we were eating pointing and talking. I highly recommended going elsewhere because of the terrible customer service displayed by the owner. She was super rude and condescending. If I could put negative stars I would! read more

The ice cream was about as tasteful as the people's attitude behind the counter. The ice cream was bland and frozen. Avoid mint chocolate chip at all cost my friends daughter got it and it taste like a weird cross over between bubble gum and mouth wash. $5.50 for the smallest portion of ice cream. Save your money and go somewhere else. read more

Stopped by while visiting Gettysburg- we tried a few flavors including the blueberry cheesecake & the chocolate. Both were very tasty! Creamy, flavorful, sweet & delicious ice cream- can't go wrong there! read more

Delicious ice cream and generous portions and right in downtown Gettysburg. Homemade waffle cones were a big hit too.

The atmosphere was amazing and welcoming. I had no issue with the service. The young blonde woman was nice and welcoming from the moment I walked in to the moment I walked out. read more

The service was outstanding! My server, Lily, was nothing but kind to me and helpful when I asked questions. She talked to me as if I was a friend and gave me all the samples in the world when I couldn't decide what flavor I wanted. Although I've had better ice cream, the experience made it all worth while and I will DEFINITELY be back again. Hope the manager sees this and knows how grateful I truly am! read more

Amazing service!!! Great ice creamery!!! I'm from WI, so I'm pretty critical of anything dairy. This was so fresh and creamy, you could taste the freshness of the milk and other ingredients. The staff is outstanding!! read more

Gross. If this is truly voted best ice cream in Gettysburg I can only imagine what the other establishments must be like. No flavor at all, icy consistency. Do not recommend. read more

Good customer service! Very friendly and nice. Ice cream is fresh and homemade and a good product they are producing.

It's filthy inside and not just old and run down. We went in 15 minutes after opening time and there were crumbs all over the floor, the payment screen was filthy and didn't even want to touch to sign for my payment and the waffle cones were stale. Not only were the two waffle cones stale, they had to put them in a cup because they had not made any new cones and these ones were broken. Have some pride in your business. read more

Excellent homemade ice cream. I had butter pecan and it was loaded with pecans. Very smooth, creamy. Highly recommend. Jaden is an absolute delight! read more

Lulu's has the most exciting flavors! I have been looking for Green Tea ice cream since the days of Ping's and I've found it. The Pistachio was delish and the Chocolate was wonderfully dark and smooth. We loved the holidays flavors and spices of the Gingerbread too! We wanted to try a few more interesting ones but I felt like four was a great start. The ice cream was so smooth and flavorful! What a great addition to the variety of ice creams that Gettysburg has to offer! We'll definitely be back! read more

Great Customer service the staff was very accommodating. service animals are welcome.