Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Main Street Realtors

    3.9 (17 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Services - Main Street Realtors

    Commercial real estate

    Property management

    Buyer's agent

    1 More Service

    Listing agent

    Main Street Realtors Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Main Street Realtors

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Brandon B.
    405
    35
    18

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Eric B.
    104
    27
    1

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Maureen R.
    211
    12
    13

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Rachel U.
    63
    161
    25

    10 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Mike A.
    177
    24
    14

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Adam S.
    502
    84
    4

    14 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Melanie S.
    381
    71
    21

    15 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    16 years ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Main Street Realtors

    Review Highlights - Main Street Realtors

    I think Elizabeth Hefner is a great property manager and she's not even working for me because I'm the tenant.

    Mentioned in 3 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Property Management 387 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Anderson Christie Real Estate

    Anderson Christie Real Estate

    (29 reviews)

    I thought selling a house would be stressful. It was not. Dave, Marvin, and all of Anderson…read moreChristie made my two recent house sales easy and seamless. They'd call or email if I had to make a decision, e.g., the amount of pre-sale work. The rest was well in their hands and I didn't have to think about it. When offers came in, they negotiated to obtain and to preserve the highest price possible. I look forward to working with them again. SHOUT OUT to Fantasia Bailey, who is managing my rentals. Again, it is seamless for me. Other than major decisions, I leave everything to Fantasia. There are no worries, with Fantasia.

    My wife and I can't speak highly enough about Fantasia Bailey at Anderson Christie. She found us…read morewhat we considered to be the "perfect" applicant for our Condo. We are conservative business people who require the utmost in professionalism,..Fantasia Bailey is exactly that! Good communication, everything in a timely manner, courteous, professional and kind is Fantasia's way. We tried to compensate Fantasia for worked performed when she was in the process of helping us find our second tenant, my wife's mother had an emergency health issue and was forced to return to the Condo. This left Fantasia unpaid for a months worth of work trying to fill our vacancy,....she refused to be compensated for this. Professionalism and kindness,..it still exists. Rest assured that you've hired the best if it's Fantasia Bailey. Sincerely - Aaron D. ,.... Naseem N.

    Vista Properties - Dana Rasmussen 
 Property Manager 
 Broker Associate
 DRE#01102286

    Vista Properties

    (33 reviews)

    Hands down, Dana Rasmussen is the best property manager in the market…read more After working with other property management companies in the past, I can honestly say that nothing compares to the level of excellence, integrity, and care Dana brings to her work. She is in a league of her own. From the very beginning, Dana impressed me with her professionalism and her heart. She is personable, attentive, and deeply committed to doing things the right way. When she took on my property, she handled every detail--from cleaning and repairs to thoughtful recommendations that would help the home stand out in the rental market. Her eye for detail is unmatched, and the transformation of my property showed it. One of the things I appreciate most is Dana's ability to balance everything with grace. She communicates clearly, responds quickly, and makes sure both the homeowner and the tenant feel supported and respected. Her accounting is meticulous, and her spreadsheets are incredibly organized and transparent--something that gave me tremendous peace of mind. What sets Dana apart is not just her skill, but her character. She is honest, proactive, hardworking, and genuinely cares about the people she serves. I trust her completely with my home. If you are looking for a property manager who will take exceptional care of your investment, look no further. Dana is truly the very best--professional, reliable, and absolutely outstanding in every way. I cannot recommend her highly enough.

    Had an unfortunate experience during my move-out process after my landlord changed property…read moremanagement companies and Rasmussen took over handling the transition. During a disagreement regarding move-out expectations, I did not feel the communication was handled in a calm or professional manner. Due to the interaction, I felt it was necessary to contact the landlord directly and have a third party involved to help complete the process. I was surprised by the difference in communication style, as previous interactions in other settings had been more composed and professional. I understand move-out situations can involve differing expectations and interests. My hope is simply that all residents are treated with professionalism, respect, and calm communication throughout the process, especially in a small community.

    Allen Property Group

    Allen Property Group

    (6 reviews)

    Do NOT DO BUSINESS WITH I tried for sometime to rent a…read morewarehouse at 54 Old Pueblo Rd from them. I noticed the place has been available for over 6 months with no movement. I contacted Allen property and Taylor Cohan. Taylor is the most lethargic, unmotivated property agent I have ever met. After playing phone tag and him approving the use I needed it for, we agreed to a time to view the warehouse. The guy showed up late looking like he just came off a bender and didn't bring the keys, genius. So I chased him down to meet the next day and he was late again but called. I viewed the warehouse and we decided to move forward. I had told Taylor my credit score was low but I could provide stellar rental references and pay the first year in advance. Taylor said that would work and he would present this to the owner and see what we could work out. So my rental reference sent a reference to Taylor. I also sent a profit loss statement, a personal letter describing my situation. This is the first time using Taylor's email so I was looking for confirmation that he received my personal information? I send him a text on a Friday to see if he received. Most professional managers will acknowledge your very personal emails with a response, not him. So my text went ignored. On Monday I texted again to see if he received, once again crickets no response, very amateur. Then I called Allen Properties and asked for Steve Allen the owner, I left him a voicemail about Taylor's incompetence. A woman named Felicia called me back and apologized for Taylor's incompetence, almost like its a regular thing. I told Felicia I had sent personal document to Taylor and he hasn't told me he received them. Felicia then told me that she would present my info and that I'd pay a year in advance for the warehouse to the owner to the owner. Taylor and Felicia called me back together and told me the owner denied rent for the warehouse a year in advance and denied my references that were excellent. I get screwed because Taylor sucks at his job and the owner of the warehouse gets screwed because Taylor sucks at his job, and Allen properties gets this bad review because Taylor sucks at his job. Steve Allen I was told was in the loop the whole way on this? Nice work Steve good company ethics.

    Allen Property Group runs a handful of small coastal hotels, including the Venetian in Capitola and…read morethe Rio Sands in Aptos. We travel to that area about once a month, sometimes more. Our long term plan is to actually purchase a home in Aptos when our kids graduate high school, so we make a point to try to be involved in the community we plan on relocating to. That said we recently had a very awful stay at the Rio Sands and it led to a pretty unpleasant and unprofessional interaction with Steve Allen. I brought my family to one of his hotels and we ended up with no heat or plumbing. The staff at the hotel was entirely unhelpful so we reached out to Steve. He ignored all calls and emails and was unresponsive. Apparently he thinks it's perfectly fine for families to stay at his hotels and not provide them with plumbing or heat in the winter. Interesting way to do business but ok. While most of our interactions in the area have been wonderful, and we've met some really wonderful and kind community leaders and business owners, there is always a random "bad apple" that preys on tourists and it seems like the hospitality branch of Allen Property Group does just that. We obviously won't be spending our money at any of their hotels and will be sure to steer clear of their real estate side when we purchase our home in Aptos.

    Kaelin Wagnermarsh - Santa Cruz County Real Estate - Two years in a row!

    Kaelin Wagnermarsh - Santa Cruz County Real Estate

    (42 reviews)

    Kaelin is an outstanding real estate agent. She knows the market and can guide you in what to do…read moreand what not to do in preparing your house for sale. I can't speak highly enough of her integrity and doing whatever needs to be done to sell your home. In our case, we were not able to do the upgrades, as we had left the area. Kaelin jumped in and lined up contractors, supervised their work, and beautifully staged out home. She was always present at the Open Houses, followed up on leads, regularly communicated, and kept our best interests foremost in her thought and actions. I highly recommend her and her team. They kept us appraised the dates for the work, Open Houses, and any bills. Simply a wonderful, warm, and engaging agent with a dynamic team who will work with and for you!

    In June 2025, my sister and I made the decision to sell the rental property we jointly owned. Since…read morewe had never sold a home before, we were on unfamiliar territory. We interviewed four different realtors, and honestly, they all appeared to be trustworthy and knowledgeable individuals who could guide us through the sales process. After narrowing down our choices to two realtors, we requested proposals for selling our house from each of them. These proposals included information about the costs of necessary repairs and upgrades as well as estimated selling prices. During the interviews, it became evident that we were entering a buyers' market, which may limit our ability to achieve the desired selling price. In the end we chose Kaelin. Her proposal kept us within our budget for repairs and upgrades, and she was confident that she could sell the home for its fair market value. Our other 'finalist' was not so positive on achieving those goals. One of the daunting aspects of preparing to sell a home is finding reliable and trustworthy contractors to undertake the necessary work to prepare the property. Once you have these contractors, you need to ensure they begin work as soon as possible. Additionally, you must closely monitor the progress of the work to ensure it is completed on time and in the manner you desire. This becomes particularly difficult for owners selling a home that is located far from their primary residence, making it challenging to meet with contractors and monitor the progress. Kaelin truly shines in this role. She already knew the contractors we needed and managed to get them to provide us with quotes. Once approved, she swiftly put them on the job and ensured timely completion of the work. Initially, the ambitious goals we set together at the project's beginning seemed a bit too demanding, but we managed to meet them. When a buyer wanted to make an offer before the house went on the market, she made sure it was a strong and compelling offer that aligned with the high end of the sales price range she had specified in her original proposal. She also didn't hesitate to incur the cost of staging the property (she pays for this), as this demonstrated our readiness to proceed with other offers if theirs wasn't satisfactory. Long story short, she made it happen. We ended up putting in less money than we planned in repairs and upgrades and sold the property right at the high end of what she said she could do. We found Kaelin very easy (even fun) to work with over the 2.5-3 month timeframe as we went from planning and starting repairs & upgrades to closing escrow.

    DeLaveaga Properties Real Estate - www.delaveagaproperties.com

    DeLaveaga Properties Real Estate

    (11 reviews)

    Chris Somple is an extremely experienced real estate agent. He not only worked as a selling agent…read morefor me, but also acted as a general contractor in the process of preparing my home for sale. Chris provided a great team of local workers including landscapers, haulers, plumbers, electricians, painters, cleaners, etc. that absolutely transformed my house. He has keen perspectives in the business and marketing and was smart in every way in selling my house. I only needed to follow his advice and every single improvement he suggested provided me a 200 - 300% return on my cost. We ended up selling my house for $300K higher than the asking price. Chris is an honest, passionate, friendly person, and I enjoyed every process we went through together. I have already recommended him to my friends who plan to sell their house. I am certain he will give them the best advice and service. I am so happy that Chris was my agent and would recommend him to anybody with 100% confidence.

    Our situation was a relatively complex one (we needed to sell our parents' unique Soquel house, had…read morenever sold a house before, and didn't live in the area). Mark Szychowski was exactly the right person for the job. He has extensive experience and knowledge of Santa Cruz County real estate, deep roots in Soquel, and connections with all the tradespeople and agencies that need to be involved in getting a house on the market. He supported us in every way possible, from our first meeting to last phone call once the house sold (it was on the market only 2 days thanks to great planning and presentation by DeLaveaga Properties). He provided honest, clear, and well-informed guidance, and we felt fortunate to have such a trustworthy partner to navigate the process with us. Choosing DeLaveaga Properties was the best decision and we heartily recommend Mark and team to anyone buying or selling a property.

    Real Estate Eight Three One

    Real Estate Eight Three One

    (25 reviews)

    Please let this be a WARNING to all future tenants. I know it's hard to find housing in this town,…read morebut please do not rent from RE 831! The owner Suzie does not think of you as a person you are just a pocketbook to her. I lived in my apartment for five years and it was so sad to see neighbors come and go so frequently due to the yearly 10% rent increase. I have plenty of stories about Suzie and her employee Lisa acting as though they are beyond superior to me and my other neighbors. Stories Including the owners coming onto my property and going inside without asking, I know a few past tenants that have had to take her to small claims. But here is my doozy of a story. Buckle up because it's a good one, I have attached screenshots of emails of proof of this happening. When I moved in one of my neighbors that I had shared a wall with were sadly using drugs heavily, and there was a lot of domestic violence going on. They eventually moved out. About a week later after them moving out , I heard and saw one of the old tenants coming and going showering and bringing people over in the middle of the night while the house was empty. I called the police and emailed Suzie about this multiple times and in her emails she states that she DOUBTS I am hearing and seeing this man coming and going in the middle of the night to an empty house and squatting. Let me tell you, I spoke to him one of the mornings when he was leaving, I have video of him coming and going, and yes, I had made two police reports about this. She still "doubted" that I was seeing and hearing him. I was concerned for my neighbors safety and myself. I was shocked at the carelessness and heartless manner that Suzie was handling the situation. I'm just beyond words that people like her even exist on this planet, so please , if you want to be treated like a human being and that your concerns and money mattertake my story as a warning and do not rent from RE 831. Edit : After posting my original review above, I decided I wanted to add the screenshots of Susie and Lisa trying to cover their steps after admitting that the owners had come into my apartment with no prior communication. Mind you, they came into my apartment while I was moving out. The screenshots for this incident are from my email with the little moon symbol so you don't get confused of the two events. Sorry if they are posting out of order! Also, my building was falling apart! The termites are running rampant in this building, and Susie was notified of this matter multiple times and nothing has been done. You can hear rodents running through the walls, my light fixture stopped working because I believe rats probably ate through the wiring in my ceiling. The only time you'll ever see Susie is when she zooms up the driveway in her Porsche Cayenne to collect change from the washer and dryer that barely even works.

    They were within your guided hours. Opinions have nothing to do with your company's poor service…read moreand experience. Happy to never do business from you. lol I see you still haven't rented out the place either they must read the reviews and how you seem to always have an excuse and a reason for your terrible service. The place still vacant speaks for its self. Suite yourself if you want to keep going.

    Main Street Realtors - propertymgmt - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...