Wife ordered fish and chips, it was cold and raw. I ordered a grouper sandwich tasted like catfish. Paid $90 for what I consider garbage.

They have very nice lobster tails, fresh fish and crab cakes. They are at the farmers market. It is a little pricey, but what do you expect on a island read more

Amazing communication! Best fish I ever had! My hubby even loved the Crab cakes and he usually doesn't like them. Totally buy from her! Went to farmers market day before and made suppers from our cabin. Saved money and was better then going out. read more

Molly Malone Seafood - Some of the best fish I've ever had! Grouper and snapper Amazing crab cakes! - Seafood Markets Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

There's something nostalgic about being able to buy fresh seafood out of a cooler, in walking distance of where you're staying. Brings me back to my childhood, I guess. The prices are typical for Captiva, which means higher than elsewhere in the area, but the seafood is fresh, and good, and Molly is both enthusiastic and proud of her product. Purchased several days worth of seafood here for our dinners - filets of yellow wedge grouper and hog snapper, and crabcakes made by Molly herself. Really one of the highlights of our trip, and the best food we ate on Captiva. read more

See all

I picked up Molly's ultimate lobster salad for dinner tonight ... simply DIVINE!!! Cannot wait to try her crab cakes and fresh grouper

The crab cakes were so delicious that words fail me. No filler. Crab, crab, crab‼ It is well worth the drive from Fort Myers! We also had wonderful lobster salad. Come here if you have a chance. read more

This is not a restaurant. It's better. It's super fresh seafood sold on the back porch behind the general store in Captiva. We had an incredible piece of grouper, the freshest stone crab you can get, and some really awesome lump crab cakes. Seafood at restaurants in the area can be really hit or miss. If you are up for cooking, this is the best way to experience incredible local seafood caught by local fishermen. read more

Best crab cakes in the area! They freeze well too. A wonderful treat! They are large so one per person is adequate.

Awesome crab cakes and shrimp! Other options too but we didn't get a chance to try them. But you can't beat the freshness and quality of the product. Absolutely the best option in Captiva and Sanibel when you want to eat in. read more

This seafood place is only open Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and I highly suggest you buy more than one crab cake. 90% crab meat and oh so amazingly delicious. The lady is really sweet and if you aren't going to be there till the weekend she may make you some and leave it at the food store. Get the bada Bing roumalade sauce for that extra kick, if you like spicy. Best crab cakes you will ever have. read more

We got 2 pounds of scallops and they were probably the best scallops we have ever had. The best bet here is to go see them the day before you want your seafood and pre-order. We didn't realize this, so we pre-ordered that day. read more

We decided to buy some fresh seafood and prepare it ourselves after walking past the sign for Molly Malones. Red snapper season had just began and we were lucky enough to get some because it goes fast. The fish was fantastic, they were very helpful with preparation tips. We also bought the crab cakes, also incredible. It was the best meal we had on Captiva, highly recommend doing this if you have access to a kitchen, and some basic seasoning. read more

Fresh, fresh, fresh! Outstanding crabcakes, fresh grouper. Excellent food safety; Molly keeps all of her seafood cold inside a walk-in refrigerator. This is a delicious find with competitive prices. Don't miss Molly if you're on island and have some way to cook! read more

Fabulous fresh seafood. The Red Snapper was the best I have ever had. Coconut Shrimp is also excellent. If you are staying on Captiva you must pick up some seafood here. Better than any restaurant. read more

Why go elsewhere? If you are staying where you have the facilities to cook and you want fresh, native seafood, Mollie Malones's is the place to go. We had the coconut shrimp, crab cakes, and red snapper. The shrimp was delectable. We only had the essentials. Just pan fried with a bit of olive oil. OMG! The crab cakes were to die for. The red snapper was cooked on the grill on a piece of foil over a bed of sliced onions, topped with tomatoes, finished with fresh basil (also purchased at Molly's ) I am not going out to eat while staying on Captiva, I will purchase the ingredients for an awesome dinner at Mollie Malone's read more

Fresh grouper was the only selection available last Thursday but it was good. Not open everyday just Tuesday Wednesday Thursday for us so we only could go once and it was late on Thursday so maybe they had more on other days. Not cheap but it's close to South Seas and reachable by golf cart from the resort. read more

Excellent food!!!! Bought the crab cakes and I'm so picky! 90% crabmeat. The BEST I've ever eaten!!!!!

Popular spot for fresh seafood. I bought grouper that tasted about as fresh as you can get. The seafood is already cut and weighed (at least the grouper was) so service is quick. read more

My daughter discovered this place last time we were on Captiva, and we really liked the crabcakes, and hogfish snapper,grouper, and shrimp. We will probably go there again. Having fresh seafood here really spiced up our stay! read more

Had scallops, coconut shrimp, and crab cakes . What a fabulous meal and all the seafood so fresh. I will always go there when I'm on the island! read more