This is an amazing store! Needed some dressier clothes for dinner so stopped in. My husband and I both found great clothes! And the service was excellent, Florita (sorry if spelling is incorrect) was very engaging and also gave us tips on places to visit. read more

Fun selection and decent pricing but they did 50% off certain colored tags so that helped! Beautiful jewelry selection but high prices. And the fur coats are amazing! read more

My Sister's Closet - Jewelry Near Me - Hilton Head Island, South Carolina

See all

We make a stop to My Sister's Closet a part of every trip to HH! I always receive the the warmest greeting from Florette, who is like having a personal shopper work with you! Love the selection, merchandising, and the pricing...but mostly love the personal and friendly service. read more

This is among my favorite used/vintage clothing stores in Hilton Head. They have a huge selection of mink coats, estate jewelry that they get from an estate lawyer in Florida, and a wide array of older items from all the retirees who move down to HHI from New York. It's not the largest or full of the highest end stuff. But, the staff tend to be unpretentious sweet older ladies who bring a certain charm to shopping here. read more

Have been to this place several times and had great experiences until today. I was browsing the shoes. Sales clerk: do you wear 7.5 shoes? Me noticing she had some cute shoes in her hand and thinking she was going to show me them: no, I wear a 9. Sales clerk: well those shoes you are looking at are not your size. Your size is over there. Me: well I guess I am not supposed to look at theses. I was done after that and had to just leave before I looked at the wrong size clothing too. read more

Consignment store located on a busy street near the golf course my husband plays on, so I decided to stop in to view their merchandise. Mostly upscale women's shoes, clothes and accessories with a very small amount of men's clothes in the rear. They have a full rack of fur jackets and coats next to a designer section. Lots of purses also were displayed, but some were obviously used and soiled, not to my liking. A jewelry display by the cashier area had their "estate jewelry" that the salesperson advised came from a Florida attorney and they had appraisals for each piece. Not exactly where I would purchase expensive jewelry but to each their own. I was able to browse easily, but it really wasn't anything worth purchasing. read more

Very pricy, I don't ever find anything there. I prefer others consignment places on the island and in Bluffton

They have a lot of high end items for reasonable prices, needed a coat for my trip to ny and left with on sale $50 which cost at the sacks for $80 coat for $22, sister got a like new dooney & Burke for $60, anyway just go you will buy something. Workers are nice n helpful. read more

My Sister's Closet - Jewelry Near Me - Hilton Head Island, South Carolina

I was on HHI for business and stumbled across this place. Glad I did! It's a little pricey, don't expect goodwill prices. This is more of a second hand boutique. I got an adorable vintage fur hat and a cute scarf. Stop by! read more

The floor plan is fantastic and I received full service. It was like shopping with a personal shopper. I had a wonderful time, found amazing close, and made some friends. The estate jewelry is to die for also. I was totally Impressed with the designer section too. I was surprised to see such a large section of Saint John's. And I would definitely go there 1st if I was looking for mother or father of the bride. read more

Great clothes at great prices! I was a little hesitant to shop here due to some of the negative reviews, but I had a wonderful experience! The Sales Associate, Flo, was welcoming and helpful to everyone who came in. Many designer brands were available and I found many items to purchase. I'll be back on my next trip to Hilton Head! read more

I love My Sister's Closet. Every year, when we are at the beach, my mom and I visit them. I always find something fantastic to bring home...last year it was a set of wine glasses and a pair of shorts, this year a few tops and a gorgeous necklace. They have so many fantastic choices and prices that I wish I was closer to them year-round. read more

Very nice shop and helpful staff. Definitely will return! Comfortable chairs for the non - shoppers , food selection and very organized by size and color. read more

What a dreadful experience. My youngest daughter wanted to go because the name caught her attention. As she said, what a bunch of old lady clothes. That's fine. There's lots of old ladies on Hilton Head Island. But why was the clerk so unfriendly? We weren't even acknowledged. There there were signs all over the store telling us "no" this and "no" that. There were so many "No" signs that I thought the store was put there in answer to the Five Man Electric Band. Jeez. Even on the bathroom door there was a sign saying "No Service". Excuse me, but don't old ladies need to go to the bathroom often and without warning, sometimes. Or was that just my grandmother. Look, I was relaxed with a thousand bucks cash in my pocket and wanting to spend a little bit of it to treat my daughter. This place kept my wallet firmly in my pants. We got out quick. read more

Not thrift store prices, but still some good values here. In the past, sales help has not been great, but recent experience a delight. This store is SO much more user friendly now. Thank you. There's a wide variety of all sorts of fur coat styles; not bargain basement but solid value. One can find many basic styles in excellent condition. Appears some items may have never been worn. read more

I absolutely loved it here, the atmosphere is great and the workers treat you like family. I was only in the area for vacation but it was an amazing experience. Although some of the prices are higher (due to their mixed in designer brands) it is truly such a deal. Each day there are different items on sales going up to 75% off. This is such a great place for shopping, chatting and exploring new styles. I highly recommend. read more

Lots to look at! Really pretty jewelry too! They carry men's and women's clothes as well as furniture. I found a dress and a cardigan and mom found a dress too! The ladies who were working there were super sweet and helpful! Everything was reasonably priced and most of the items were on sale! read more

We hesitated to go as there were negative reviews but decided to bite the bullet as my daughter has wanted to stop in on each visit to HH but we just haven't managed it. We are so very glad we went! Great selection of clothes and accessories (found a new Spartina 449 bag). All was organized and there were even men's clothes. Prices and discounts were clear. The lady there was super helpful and pleasant. A great experience! We'll be back. read more

This shop is on my "must do" list whenever I visit Hilton Head. I've bought Tocca, JCrew and other labels. My favorite summer dress from last year came from here! read more

Some higher end names mixed in w regular stuff. Nice woman in charge who is welcoming to all.

This store gives consignment shops a VERY BAD NAME!!!!!!!!!!!!! They are rude to you when you call about getting your money from them. They charge you a fee to sign up and to get your check mailed to you. I know I never got all the money they made off my cloths!!!!!! What a dreadful experience. I will never go there again!! Louise L. Bluffton,SC read more

Just called this store to find out if they had any size 14 clothes. Now, I know I am not petite, but I was insulted when the woman said " Oh yes. We have a plus size rack." Do not think they will get my business. read more

My 16 year old daughter and I passed this establishment several times during our week at Hilton Head. She loves consignment shopping so we decided to stop. The only acknowledgment we received in the store was when my daughter was trying on a coat and the clerk looked at me and said "the owner is getting ready to come in and she won't like that your daughter has that on." I responded saying "she certainly isn't hurting anything." So many other ways to address us... Like " may I help you with that?" So rude. We hung the coat up and left immediately. So rude. read more

Rude owner Tracy Redmond threw $26 at me when, the night before, she told me to come in early to pick up the cash because she "forgot" to send my check. She is rude and very disrespectful. I'd rather donate my items to charity than deal with her. read more

My sister and I rushed over at 4:30 to see this shop before it closed at 5:00. At about 4:50, I heard some older woman whisper " time to go" from across the room in the employee area. She kept saying "time to go"or " get out" softly, I assumed she was talking to the other woman working there since we still had 10 minutes. Then when my sister was going to try on clothes, this same older woman ( from the way she was acting, I thought perhaps she was senile or handicapped, could not imagine anyone acting like this otherwise) said " for God's sake, get out". The other saleswoman never said anything, had her back to us. SO WE GOT OUT AND WILL NEVER GO BACK AGAIN!!!. read more

not very good selection. I had high hopes for this place but was unfortunately disappointed because the prices were way too high for a consignment shop. I understand that they're cheaper than what the in store price would be for the items but they are still not cheap. $98 for a lily Pulitzer dress that at another consignment shop would be $25 at most. Strange place--I don't recommend it, especially for anyone under the age of 65. read more

I stopped in this store in April and loved it- the clerks were friendly and I couldn't wait to go back on this trip! However this experience was less than friendly! Some lady keep telling us to get out- "we open at 10, you can come back then". I had several things to try on, but felt that I didn't have time to finish looking let alone try anything on. . . So I pretty much dropped everything and left. When we got in the car it wasn't even 5! What kind of business rushes out customers who want to spend their money there? SO Disappointed!!!!!! read more