great store, very great value, 10/10 recommend. from pokemon to sports they don't miss. owners…read morealways 100% honest on values, and very nice to talk to outside of just cardboard.

Went in because I had two slabbed cards that weren't super valuable but would've been appreciated…read moreby some kids. I take some in and give them to multiple stores for free to have them give out to kids to try to grow the hobby. Went on WhatNot later that week and saw the owner selling both slabs instead of just giving them to kids as they said they would. Slimy move, be wary of doing business here. Outside of that poor experience and shady move, it is a nice and clean establishment so they deserve credit for that.

My favorite sports card shop in Milwaukee. Largest selection of Giannis Antetokounmpo cards I've…read moreever seen! Highly recommended.

STOP. READ THIS. SLOWLY. This is THE BEST, HANDSDOWN best cardshop in the Milwaukee/West Allis…read morearea. Point blank period. I'll die on this hill. And the crazier part? I'm a first-time customer. I walk in with my yellow binder ive had since elementary school. My guy goes straight to giving me advice on how to probably upgrade it "these stick and ruin the cards". But that's not even a sale, he's just running numbers on the cards. Gives me a nice estimate. Then I ask for the binder upgrade and he gives me exactly what I need and how to use it. He gives a compliment to my collection and tells me to KEEP them. Get it? This place is NOT looking for a sale. Instead he's insisting to hold on, and get better value later. Finally I got a Mewtwo at a bargain based off his own negotiation. Nah. This is rare air. One of a kind imo. Go there.

Huge bummer to wait in line for a new set only to see the prices at more than double retail on the…read moreday of release. I wouldn't have minded as much if they had any social media to speak of or a usable website where they could've announced it in advance, everybody's gotta keep the lights on but was pretty lame to find out after waiting in the cold. Was unfortunately a waste of time and I won't be back, had been excited to check out the space too :\ Update per response: in the post on their Facebook page which I did find after the fact they would not announce prices, instead they said "it will be above retail but lower than what we're seeing elsewhere" near the end of the post. I don't know where they're seeing higher prices that their own, they charged $125 per $49.99 retail etb and just scrolling through Facebook marketplace scalpers are selling them for less. $65 for the binder collection over double retail at $29.99.

This place is packed with old collectible games and toys! It seems a little disorganized, but the…read moreowner knows where everything is if you just ask him what you are looking for.

Floor to ceiling toys, games, and collectibles. A good place to go to find that toy line or game…read morethat has been discontinued. I'm definitely going back again....and again.....and again

amazing selection of pokemon cards at affordable prices. The people at the desk are very kind and…read moresave pokemon cards for kids

Made this account just to post this. Great service, the person behind the counter was amazing and I…read moream definitely am coming back.

This is one of the cutest variety stores in town and it's one of those places where you want to be…read morethere to shop in person. They have all kinds of candy, puzzles, knitting materials, and it's very likely you'll find something unique for you/and or loved ones.

A cute hidden gem! I've been looking for blind boxes (specifically sonny angels and smiskis) and so…read morefar this is the only place that has them in Milwaukee. They have a ton of other cute items as well (stickers, snacks, plushies, etc). The owner is super sweet and kind and will put items on hold for you if you ask. I'll definitely be back to check out their new miffy items (and other blind boxes of course!).

American Science and Surplus is an absolute family favorite. Hot summer days to cold winter…read moreevening, you can lose yourself wondering the aisles. You never know what you'll find but there is something for everyone Toys, art supplies, games, chemistry equipment and everything in between, go and check it out.

Have been long time fan of American Science & Surplus. As an amateur magician I'm always in need…read morefor various bits and bobs for new tricks and routines. Also great place for fun quirky presents for birthdays and holidays. We make it a regular stop to just go and see what new stuff they have.

What a selection of games!!! Very friendly staff and easy to talk to. They know their games!!!…read more We bought 5 board games in 2 visits. Awesome and great change of pace from Monopoly!!

Heard about this online via Tik-Tok viral video and decided to check it out. Feels like once you…read morewalk inside you are transported to a new world. It's very pleasing to the eyes and the owners (female owned!) are incredibly knowledgeable and even offered to demo a game to me right then and there so I knew how to play correctly (saved me from reading the instructions, haha!) They have the classic board games (sorry, trouble, mousetrap, monopoly, etc), dice, STEM games for kids who love to learn, unique board games (Super Natural, Chose your Own Adventure) painting miniatures, dice, Warhammer, Critical Role, and did I mention DICE? I really love their game library they have; for $5 you can come in and play nearly anything they have for the DAY! When your done the $5 you paid is then turned into store credit for a purchase. You can't lose with this. *Edit* Went back with my friend from out of state and he was like a kid in a candy shop looking at all the games and a bunch of Odd knick knacks! (Did you know they sell D&D inspired spices?!?!?!) Every time I go in there they have something new and cool to show off. We picked up a bunch of items and walked out super happy. Thanks OddWillows!! *Edit 2* I swear every time we go in here it gets better and better; we just booked my daughter's birthday party; YES! They have a private room for parties! She is so excited to be able to celebrate her 11th birthday with all of her friends while learning a bunch of new games to play.