Called around and this store was offering the best prices on silver - by far. Went in and they honored the price they gave me on the phone. They were courteous, fast and gave an overall legitimate and trustworthy vibe. Will be prioritizing their services in the future. Thank you. read more

I have been collecting coins for a while now. Learning the individual history of not just the coins but, the very interesting information of the history of our country and ita leaders and more. Long story short, collecting is not a get rich quick hobby. There's a lot of intricate levels of analysis, research, and time put into it. I didn't want to sell anything I had but because of current economy inflation in every aspect of life, i thought I'd be able to at least pay a bill with the collection I've had in my family for 30 hrs. I understand I'm not a coin expert or numerist and wanted to get an idea of where I was in my research. Unfortunately after leaving old world coin, I found myself no longer interested the hobby as a whole. The employee that " assisted" me seemed immediately dismissive and annoyed at my approach. He took time to take a glimpse at what I had with a quick snobbish dismissal, almost as tho he was saying I should be embarrassed for bringing them. He handed me most of my collection back saying the were nothing, that " if it were him he'd just give them to a young beginning collector" and that all the foreign coins I had were no longerbin production so they were worthless as well. Which confused me. The entire cyber research on the many apps, books, videos, platforms, according to him are completely inaccurate and lie about price and value. Soviet walked out with 32.00$ having currency of many denominations, key dates, sets uncirculated, etc. In conclusion i found that the reputation and rating of this business was just as misleading as the enticing ruse of the hobby. And as much as im against ai taking our jobs, and handling customer service, the service members at this establishment can probsbly take refresher courses in that area of business ethics. Perhaps a few common courtesy and pr classes ​ read more

Absolutely amazing, just bought the 1930 smthn - 1998 dansco album, a thing of AU/MS quarters 1964-74 I think, and a 2009 penny proof set, it was amazing and gave me the penny proofs I had been scouring stores for. The guys there were super helpful. read more

Old world coin is amazing! They were so nice and they offered to answer any questions I had. They also provide a good price for everything and have suck a wide variety oof coins and paper cash it was so hard to choose what I wanted. Overall I give Old world coin 5 star rating if I could give more stars I would. read more

See all

Where do I even start with this horrible experience? I had two transactions here, and both were terrible.Transaction 1: I brought in a couple of 1oz Canadian Maples. The person I originally talked to said, "George handles the gold." Meanwhile, I stood there watching George talk away with his buddy without a care in the (old) world. A lady finally approached me, took the coins to George, and came back with a 97% offer. I mentioned they were Maples because I thought there was a premium on them--and even if I was wrong, I was met with a snippy, "I know what they are and George knows what they are." Gee, thanks for the explanation. Transaction 2: I brought in a large bin my girlfriend inherited from her grandmother. I had emailed them ahead of time(granted a while back) and was told that if we were selling, there was no fee for an evaluation and offer. After my first lovely transaction, the first guy started flying through the bins. He brushed off everything other than silver coins, implying nothing else was worth any attention. only looking for silver coins, he gave zero consideration to type or age--he just based it on weight and spot. He pulled a few aside for George to evaluate, but by that point, I didn't feel confident about or getting any sort of fair deal. so I kept those. Like other reviewers have noted, he claimed all our out-of-production foreign coins and commemorative stuff were worthless, suggesting I just "give them to kids." and they would only give me a couple of bucks here and there for this pile or that, I said no thanks I'm not a crackhead in need of 2 dollars. It was also mentioned a couple of times "we don't like sifting through peoples collections" - one time I quipped "Well, we don't have to". The entire experience felt insulting and dishonest. read more

This is a great shop where the people give you honest advice and pricing. These are people you can trust. The variety of gold , silver and other precious metals is endless. If you go here once I guarantee you will be back for more! read more

DO NOT Trust them at All ! They will screw you over BAD if you let them! If you must deal with them, Know Exactly what you are doing OR YOU WILL GET SCREWED OVER BIG TIME!!! ESPECIALLY WITH JEWELRY! OR SCRAP GOLD AND SILVER! I'm regretting at least 90 % of my dealing with them, You been warned, Use extreme caution and don't expect Honesty from Them, God Bless you and be CAREFUL read more

Great selections and prices. Knowledgeable and friendly personal when buying or selling!!

I have been going to Old World Coin for years. They have the lowest premiums for your bullion purchases. They will always offer to have a person buy a 5 ounce bar then buying 5 single bars because it's cheaper to buy in bulk. when it comes to there coins, they use the grey sheet for pricing or paper currency as well. Trisha, Gary, Carl, or Dave are all wonderful to work with and they are always helpful with any questions you might have on bullion or coin. read more

Absolutely horrible to do business with. Will do anything to make a quick buck. Sold a coin I paid for to another buyer for basically no reason. Please steer clear of this place at all costs. read more

Stopped in here to have some old coins authenticated and appraised which they were happy to do. I learned a lot speaking to the experts here. Was very impressed at their knowledge and no pressure to sell or buy. I will go back in the future. Highly recommended. read more

I am a financial advisor and I am still finding questions to ask and learning every time I go in. Gary is the best to deal with most personable and knowledgeable of the staff. He has always been able to answer every question I could throw at him. This is my preferred gold and silver dealer. read more

Best coin dealer in Northern ILL! Great selection for these crazy China Flu times. Very knowledgeable staff, friendly, and easy to work with. If you are eloping to buy coins or trade in estate metals, give them a try! read more

I've done business for a few years with OWC. The parking is easy. There is no sales pressure, as they do not work on commission. I'm primarily interested in bullion and collectible / graded (or "slabbed") coins. They have both. They also have weekly auctions (Saturday, I believe, but call and confirm) and close the counters during that those couple of hours. They have collectible currency (paper, coin), some medals and, of course, bullion. This isn't a baseball card kind of place. If you have jewelry, they will refer you next door to their jewelry shop. If you like precious metals in "round", "bar" or similar format, this shop is for you I've shopped at a number of places, and am happy to both go back to OWC. I also put orders in over the phone. I cut a check and they mail me my goodies. If you are looking to sell your coins or bullion, you should be familiar with State of Illinois law. The State wants to track sales from people to dealers. Dealers want to keep their licenses and stay in business, so don't be surprised if EVERY coin shop asks you about receipts for your gold / silver / coins. It isn't that they are suspicious, it's the law. Call a few dealers and ask them about selling to them. read more

See all

Carl took the time to look over my collection and educate me on what I actually had. His experience and knowledge was greatly appreciated. Thanks for your time! read more

I inherited gold coins, and needed to understand what i had and how to handle it. I went to 4 coin/gold dealers and the difference in attention and information I received was vastly different from location to location. Choosing Old World was easy. They were professional, informative and very low key. I did not feel at all pressured to make an immediate decision. Their pricing was better than the other 3 places I visited. I recently inherited more coins and will be making a trip to McHenry again. read more

I stopped in there TODAY for the 1st time ever. Amazing Place.... Lots of interesting and cool merchandise to see. The staff is very knowledgeable and friendly. They even offer a weekly auction that has all kinds of stuff included for you to bid on. MUST STOP IN WHEN IN THE AREA.... read more

Sent a request for an appointment on Old World Coin website specifically set up for correspondence. On their door is a sign that says they close at 1:00pm and no one is seen without making an appointment. My answer from Trisha was to call on Saturday morning to see if they are taking appointments. Wow....seems if you are in a business that requires the public to come to you, one would be more than happy to make that appointment. Your business must be very lucrative to pick and choose "if you schedule an appointment". Very disrespectful. Personally I would never support any shop that expects me to chase them. Shame on you Old World Coin. read more

I can't say enough good things about Old World Coin and their staff. My ten year old son recently became interested in coins and he begs to go there almost daily. Every time we walk in the door, we learn something new. The staff are very kind and patient with him and answer all his questions. They show him new things and share the history and stories behind the coins. They have a great selection of old and new coins and bills from around the world. We have also begun attending their Saturday auctions and once again, the staff have helped him learn how to participate and bid. He loves the atmosphere and being surrounded by lots of other coin collectors who all want to share their expertise with him. Old World Coin is definitely a top notch establishment. read more

My sisters and I inherited many old coins and jewelry after the passing of both parents (6 months apart from one another) and we found Old World Coin to help us. The staff there was fantastic and they spent hours going through the coins and jewelry and even found a rare dime that was worth quite a bit of money. Everyone in the entire shop was kind, nice and thoughtful. They were all an absolute pleasure to work with. I would recommend them in a heartbeat to anyone in the local area that needs to sell their coins and/or old jewelry. My sisters and I were pleased with their service and the amount we made on our inheritance. read more

I recently visited this establishment as I had several old coins as well as foreign money that I had no idea of the worth. Not only did they accept what I had, I also learned a lot of history about coins from Carl. He was patient, understanding, and willing to assist me. I will return there in the future and recommend it to my friends!! Thanks for all your help! read more

I highly recommend Old World Coin in McHenry because of my experience with them yesterday (7/29/2017). I took in my deceased father's coin collection in to have them evaluate it. I did organize all of the coins in like denominations as best I could. Even so, it took nearly a couple of hours to go through everything. Carl did an awesome job going through the collection and explaining not only interesting historical facts on certain coins and WWll paper money, but explaining the differences in the conditions of the coins that help determine their value. This was not an easy project for me to do because it was my dad's collection and I wanted to do the best I could for him. Carl made the whole experience very easy and I felt he was very honest with his evaluations and explanations. It was a relief to be able to finally get this done and feel like they took good care of my dad. Thank you Carl. read more

Today, 3/28/19, I stopped by Old World Coin to see about selling 5 NIB Little Rock Central High School Desegregation Silver Dollars. Just asked the guy what he'll give me for them. He unboxed one and checked it out. Then tapped on a calculator briefly, and said $11.50 apiece. With a surprised look on my face I said that was less than the silver value. The sales guy looked annoyed and retorted that the coins were only 70% silver. I thanked him, twice, and left soon after. So you decide. The coins are actually typical coin silver, 90% silver content. Did he lie to me to gain $15. Or is he that bad at his job. That was my last visit to Old World Coin. read more

Horrible service... Disrespectful... I'll never bring any coins to sell them ever again... Do not recommend this place to anyone. Horrible experience. They talked to me like I didn't know anything about coins... An that the first time I was there an now the last! #&*% old world coin!!!!! read more

This is a great place. Bigger then most. But most importantly they are honest. I've gone here several times when I've had to sell some coins in the bad times & their assessment is better then most. read more

TERRIBLY terribly RUDE salesperson here. I came in to buy silver bullion and junk silver coins and although I've been collecting silver for several years I had some questions and the sales person was extremely condescending in his answers. I figured maybe hes having a bad day, do I let it pass. I picked out four silver rounds and asked for $100 face value in junk silver, which was over $2000 at that time. I was prepared to spend that much in his store, despite his bad attitude. This rude salesperson went to the back and came back and said no they were all sold out. I understand that, but by this time I was tired of dealing with this person who was so terrible at his job, which is supposed to be customer service. I bought the 4 toz silver only to find when I got home that one of them is marked "COPY" and did not have any mint name, nor weight, nor purity marked on it. M so I went back and this same Rude person was clear lady not happy to see me but he very rudely pointed out that there is a marking on the edge of the coin and that I should not question them because they dont make mistakes there. NOW HERES THE KICKER: he said, "THERES THE DOOR, ILL BUZZ YOU OUT NOW". Throughout both encounters I was very polite and patient, even pausing after each rude thing that he said because I was surprised at how UNPROFESSIONAL he was. I've spent about $10k on silver in the last 2 weeks. I will never go here again. If you're desperate and you go here, bring your own Sigma Metalytics Analyzer and test everything. WORST CUSTOMER SERVICE EVER read more

Where to begin.. I have no idea how these employees were not fired yet. I inherited a large amount of coins. I came in to sell and have never been this disrespected before. They treated me as I was a nobody. I admit I do not have great knowledge of coins. When I would ask a question they would get all protective and lash back at me with rude remarks. Totally uncalled for. It is my merchandise and I had some questions from whom I thought were professionals. Then he thru an offer at me thinking I was stupid. It was a lowball. I know it was a lowball because another coin shop had offered me a good amount more. I took my items and left as quick as possible. I will tell everyone I know not to deal with them here. read more

Very nice and helpful gentlemen. I was very pleased with the value they gave me on my old coins. Carl was very informative. The shop was very clean and organized. I would recommend them to anyone. Also I used the jewelry store next door to sell gold jewelry. read more

This is the largest & the most honest coin shop around. Go on Saturday for their bid board coin auction! Have been a customer there for almost ten years! They even allow me to promote The McHenry County Coin Club there. read more

Every time I visit Old World Coin, they provide the best service and advice I could possibly hope for. For beginner collectors or for more advanced, they always do a great job at educating and providing guidance. Their pricing in my opinion is better than other shops I have visited. read more

The selection on coins is pretty good. The customer service is just horrible. They are always in like a bad mood and are very condescending. There is no excuse for how they treat the customers. I have found another coin shop near by that has a lot better customer service. read more

I served in the military for a few years and saved some money. I invested some of it by having my brother in law buy me gold and silver coins, since I knew nothing of them. I went to Old World Coins today to get an estimate on some of the coins. I told the worker what I was there for and he asked me where the coins came from in an accusatory tone. I told him I didn't know, because I didn't, and I didn't feel the need to explain further with the way he was talking. He talked with another worker and then told me he wasn't interested because I did not know anything about the coins. I explained I had had someone else buy them for me, but he would not listen...continuing to state that having the coins meant I should know about them and implying if I didn't, then I must have stolen them. So, if you want to deal with a prick who makes snap judgements, go ahead and head to Old World Coins! Maybe you're a coin expert and he'll be more accepting of you. read more

Sadly my father passed away. He had a coin collection but we needed to get an idea what something were worth. I have 2 sisters and we wanted to split it up evenly. I called on a Monday and talked to a gentleman and he was very nice. I asked him some questions and he answered as best as he could over the phone. I asked if they did appraisals and how much they charge. He told me $50 an hour but if we are just looking for an idea of what things are worth and it was only about 15 minutes they would go through it for free. My sister and I went the next Monday. When I first went in and asked if they could do it and the one guy behind the counter said sure bring it in. I got my sister and the coins. Now when we went back in a different guy helped us ( think his name was Carl ) very rude! Told us it was $50 an hour. I explained that the guy I talked to said it would be free if it was quick and not in detail. Carl had a fit. The other guy behind the counter told Carl it's ok you don't have to charge them. He was very nice about it. Carl at that time wanted nothing to do with us and couldn't get us out of the store fast enough. He didn't even really look at what we had. Took maybe 2 or 3 things out of one bag and looked at them and nothing else. He say the coin sets but never looked at the coins from the 1800 that was also in that same bag. All I can say is that my sister and I both said we would never set foot back in that place. Very said that we got treated that way. read more