Mall does have a lot of items; and i've found some very nice items there in the past. BUT make sure that you really want to make your purchase as they DO NOT tell customers that they have a NO RETURN POLICY...nor do they have this posted any where in their business. Another customer wrote a Google review telling of how they will add in their credit card charge, AND NOT TELL YOU ABOUT THIS EITHER!! Beware as you stop in there. read more

I have been meaning to stop here long before now and I wish I had. I love this location!! The store is amazing and so full of vintage items..many people call crap but I call TREASURES!!! Tony and I enjoyed pilfering through the boxes, bins and shelves of items looking for treasures that we might need for some of our collections. I was able to find a Aluminum 1960s Jello mold for my daddy. I am making him lots of Jello lately and he wants it PRETTIED UP a bit...lol !!! There is two levels and there is so much to see. We were there about 3 hrs and it seemed like 1/2 hr..the parking lot was FREE and on the side of the old warehouse There is no elevator in this old warehouse so if you have issues climbing stairs beware!!! I am definitely going again to this warehouse searching for additional beauties and baubbles!!! read more

See all

Soooo much stuff! I easily could have easily spent hours upon hours looking at everything they have. They have a lot of antique/vintage items but they have new things as well. It's a consignment shop so there's a lot of different vendors. It's definitely a little overwhelming. They have 2 floors that are open to the public and a 3rd floor that I believe is only open once a month. read more

See all

A good collection of vintage items, many booths set up. We went on an antique crawl, this was among the places we stopped. Comparatively, I found this shop to be very spread out and very little organization. Not as in the booths were organized, but it was more like scavenging through your grandparents building. I would have preferred a bit more organization of the booths and a map would have been helpful. read more

This is a pretty cool place. Lots of glassware and furniture. I think it's a bit overpriced, but maybe that's just me. This old wardrobe reminded me of Narnia, the lion the witch and the wardrobe. read more

Olde Shoe Factory Antique Mall - Antiques Near Me - Lancaster, Ohio

See all

Pretty cool collection of vintage/antique/resale items. All kinds of stuff from furniture to old tools to stand fans to vintage dresses. I was on the lookout for some kind of bedside stand, and didn't need anything above $20. My mother reminded me of this warehouse, so we figured we'd take a drive and check it out. Two floors chuck full of stuff - first floor and the entire basement level also. People rent out a space to sell their stuff. James (runs the show?) was a great help in pointing me toward the general direction. I came across a sturdy end table that was short and skinny - just what I wanted. $15, $16.01 cash. ***Two important things:*** 1. Depending on the vendor, James MAY be allowed to give a 10% discount to anything over $20. 2. A 3% charge is added to your total if you pay with a credit card!!! read more

My first time browsing and shopping yet my third or fourth time inside. Many booths belonging to vendors who have varieties of items for sale. I enjoyed looking at Amish baby clothing, quilts, sporting goods, clothing and collectibles. I found a nice women's top 20% off. Many vendors put their items on sale so look for the sale signs when browsing. Pay with cash to avoid a 3% fee for using a credit/debit card. Now that I took time to browse, I plan to return again. read more

Olde Shoe Factory Antique Mall - Many items galore to look at - Antiques Near Me - Lancaster, Ohio

Wonderful place to browse all kinds of antiques. We have found many pieces for our home. Prices are great! There are two floors to explore and they are getting ready to open the third floor with more vendors. :) read more

The best antique mall in the area. Great, ever-changing selection offered by a large number of vendors. The floorspace is well organized and it is easy to see all the items and maneuver around the displays. Be sure to go on a day (one weekend per month) when the upper floor is open so that you can see the vast collection for sale by the owner. Owner is friendly and informative. read more

I have been coming in here for YEARS. Prices are good, and the antiques are on point. THE STAFF has always been nice and helpful. They do not FLOCK. Which is my favorite thing about them. They let you shop and come to them when they are needed. The rules are on the front door. I don't know how any can be upset about "NO PETS".. IF they let you and your 4lb puppy in, they gotta let that 4 lb Chihuahua in as well.. or that crazy cat lady trying to bring her Tabby in(that's me). Entitled much. read more

I throughly enjoy these revamped old buildings. Lots of glass and attractive pretties for my shelves at home. Took two hours to go from top to bottom but worth every minute of the search. read more

I haven't been here for awhile, but this place has stepped it up. They have accessed the natural light of windows which has totally changed the feel of the shop. The formerly junky booths have been neatened for a better shopping experience. The lower level has been cleaned up and organized for better access to items. It is so much more appealing to root around down there. No hint of its former creepy self. Whoever undertook the challenge of revamping this place should really pat themself on the back. I think it won't be so long until I make a return visit. read more

First of all, who bad reviews a place because they won't let your 4lb "dog" in?? Let's be honest any dog that weighs 4lbs isn't a dog... It's an obese rat, but anyways my fiancé are antique obsessed, any chance we get to go to an antique shop we jump on it and this place was a gem, the staff was sooooo sweet and welcoming and they have authentic antiques, not the thrift store hand me Downs mod places play off as antiques but real antiques. I would highly recommend this place if your in the mood for some treasure hunting read more

A very large and a bit overwhelming vintage shop. Nothing really interesting or unique.

This place is gigantic! It is very easy to get lost in a sea of antiques. I've never walked out empty handed, and there are reasonable prices. You can't visit Lancaster without stopping by the Olde Shoe Factory! read more

Nice antique mall. Nothing great, but the staff WAS very friendly to me. Decent variety & average prices. It's worth a look now & again.

we have traveled all over Ohio, Illinois, Indiana, and Kentucky antiquing. We have never experienced how we were treated when we had our 4 lb. Pomeranian. We went to the OLDE SHOE and were turned away and was talked shortly by the male employee working...stating.."NO PETS" Other places we have went they are very very very pet friendly. We want people to know that on vacation, as we were, we were not going to leave our dog in the car. We went else where and will not be going back.. We will spend our hard earned money elsewhere. read more

First time in this antique store and I can't wait to go back again! Very large space with a lot of stuff to look at and buy! The staff was very friendly and the booth owners were very nice as well. I will go back frequently and would suggest that others check it out as well! read more

They don't allow dogs which is messed up. My small puppy was just sleeping in my arms doing nothing. How does that bother them?? I decided not to buy anything because of that and I won't be back. They lost business. Also huge place but prices are not very good and not negotiable. I wanted to buy a small bench (which was damaged and smelled horrible). They refused to bring the price down at all. Every other antique store I've been to had better prices and they were willing to negotiate. read more

Lots of great vendors, and if you like to collect old postcards, there is one vendor here with an amazing collection that is organized extremely well. The basement area is full of farm primitives, and although some are priced high, you can find some good deals. They periodically have basement and sidewalk sales that are AWESOME! read more