Our Treasures

4.5 (2 reviews)

ModerateAntiques, Thrift Stores, Used, Vintage & Consignment

Closed • Closed

Updated 1 month ago

Add Review

Call

Directions

Website

Our Treasures Photos

Our Treasures - Vintage Wedding Dress - Antiques Near Me - Painesville, Ohio

Our Treasures - 50 W Erie St., Painesville, Ohio - Antiques Near Me - Painesville, Ohio

Our Treasures - Sports Cards - Antiques Near Me - Painesville, Ohio

+17

Our Treasures - Our Treasures - Antiques Near Me - Painesville, Ohio

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Our Treasures

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Liz Z.

4 months ago

This is a thrift store, much like 150 shops on the lake but on a smaller scale. Would not have known since it is listed as jewelry/gift shop!!! Hidden for sure! I found out about them on fb marketplace by some girl named Lizzy. She popped up in my feed for her room Loolie B Boutique. Had it not been for her, I would have had no idea this place even existed even though I live 10 minutes down the road! I could not find much about them when I searched for them on socials. They have their own fb page, but unless you know to follow them then you wouldn't know it's here. Other than that, pretty cool hidden gem. I plan to come back here once a month to see what new treasures are in store! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jenny W.

9 years ago

I have shopped, visited this store several times... in the time frame of ober a year now I have notixed such a great class selection of antiques and collectables at such great prices... thank you read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

More info about Our Treasures

50 W Erie St
Painesville, OH 44077
Directions
(440) 856-6695
Call Now
Visit Website
https://www.ourtreasuresllc.com

Hours

What time does Our Treasures open?

Our Treasures opens at 11:00 AM on Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.

What time does Our Treasures close?

Our Treasures is closed on Monday, Tuesday and Sunday.Our Treasures closes at 5:00 PM on Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.Our Treasures closes at 3:00 PM on Saturday.

Mon-Tue, Sun ClosedWed-Fri 11:00 AM - 5:00 PMSat 11:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Our Treasures take Bitcoin?

No, Our Treasures does not take Bitcoin.

Does Our Treasures take credit cards?

Yes, Our Treasures takes credit cards.

Services

Is Our Treasures by appointment only?

No, Our Treasures is not by appointment only.

Indoor Amenities

Does Our Treasures allow dogs?

Yes, Our Treasures allows dogs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Our Treasures have bike parking?

No, Our Treasures does not have bike parking.

Does Our Treasures have parking?

Yes, Our Treasures has parking options. Private Lot Parking

Other Amenities

Is Our Treasures wheelchair accessible?

No, Our Treasures is not wheelchair accessible.

From the Business

Specialties

Our Treasures is Painesville’s destination for Thriftage — a curated blend of thrift, vintage, antiques, and unique home décor. Shoppers love our boutique-style layout, friendly atmosphere, and constantly refreshed selection of one‑of‑a‑kind pieces. We specialize in vintage décor, collectibles, glassware, seasonal décor, handmade items, and upcycled treasures that add character to any home. Every visit feels like a personalized treasure hunt. Our shop is known for high-quality, affordable finds that are thoughtfully displayed and easy to browse. Customers appreciate our eye for nostalgia, our rotating themed rooms, and our commitment to offering items with history, charm, and personality. Located in the heart of Painesville, Ohio, Our Treasures stands out for its warm customer service, curated inventory, and unique shopping experience you won’t find in big-box thrift stores. Whether you're decorating, collecting, gifting, or hunting for something special, Our Treasures is the place where meaningful pieces find their next home. Discover why locals call us their favorite thrift and vintage boutique in Lake County — there’s always something new to explore.

History

Established in 2016.

Our Treasures began as a small antique shop in Painesville, Ohio, built on a love for nostalgia, reuse, and meaningful home décor. Over time, we grew into a curated Thriftage boutique — blending thrift, vintage, antiques, handmade goods, and one‑of‑a‑kind pieces that reflect our eye for character and charm. As our community grew, so did our vision. We refreshed our layout, that make every visit feel like a treasure hunt. Today, Our Treasures is known for warm service, unique finds, and a shopping experience that celebrates creativity and history. What started as a simple idea has become Lake County’s favorite spot for discovering pieces with personality.

Meet the Manager: Cindy Q.

Steve Quick is the owner of Our Treasures and his wife Cindy, manages the location. It's a great at home feeling.

More Info

Special Hours

Ask the Community - Our Treasures

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

You might also consider

Miscellaneous Barn

I love shopping here! The staff are very nice and helpful. The prices are nice and reasonable. They…read morepack your fragile items up carefully for you to take home.

This place was worth the 30 mile trip from where I live. It popped up on my Facebook page and the…read morephotos definitely enticed me. I knew that I then had to entice my BFF to take a Sunday drive with me. It's quite a large building and what a lovely mix of things inside. Their prices are reasonable and the staff was very friendly and helpful. They have a beautiful selection of vintage furniture for every room, lamps, artwork, glass, too much to mention. They have an entire room of 50% off everything inside. That was fun! I found a melamine bowl from the 60-70's, a good find for 50 cents. Directions were easy so I highly recommend taking a ride to the Barn. If you like "picking" you'll love this place.

Photos

Beautiful vintage Mirror

Mid century furniture

See all

Here are the stunning theater seats. I'm so in love with them!

Shops by the Lake

It has a variety of vendors and it is all year around…read more Pretty close to my place and the prices are okay

The staff here is super friendly and accommodating. There is a very large selection of vintage…read moreitems and furniture here, as well as some antiques and handmade items. They are competitively priced and definitely worth the stop!

Photos

See all

So many Trump signs and stickers all over the place. He lost, it's 2021 now. How embarrassing. I won't be shopping here again.

Twice Loved

4.7

(3 reviews)

5.3 mi

Received the ring today. It's fabulous. We love it…read more Couldn't have found a more perfect ring anywhere. Service was excellent. Received it a week after ordering. It came with certs and is more beautiful than the picture. 6 stars!

Who doesn't love...Twice Loved! It's an adorable consignment/antique shop located in the heart of…read moredowntown Willoughby. An awesome selection of antiques, and home accents, at super great prices. Owner is very friendly and always running specials and making deals. Every time I'm in there, I buy something!

Photos

See all

Painesville Flea Market

3.5

(4 reviews)

2.0 mi

WHAT A DUMP! Dirt floors with absolutely NOTHING of value! You could literally plow that trash…read moreunder and nothing would be lost. There's no market for what they have there, COMPLETE WASTE OF TIME. Terrible representation of this area. DO BETTER.

Fun place to stop and look for vintage stuff and good deals.. venders indoors and weather…read morepermitting outdoors

Photos

See all

Tiffany Rose Antiques

This place is adorable! Stopped in on a Friday afternoon and spent nearly an hour looking at all…read morethe great vintage items. There was a wide range of furniture, glassware, clothing, and jewelry - no doubt, there is something for everyone. Plus, the prices are super reasonable! Kim, the owner, is really the shining star of this shop. When I walked in she greeted me pleasantly, showed me some of her favorite items, and made sure that I was finding exactly what I was looking for. I even learned a few things about vintage items! Nowadays, it's rare to find someone who is so genuinely passionate about what they do. Tiffany Rose Antiques is more of an experience than just your average shop. I encourage anyone - especially younger people like me - to spend some time inside and be transported to days we're less familiar with through these items!

Have been shopping here for years. Whenever I need a piece, I know I can contact her and she will…read morealways be in the lookout and find what I need. Great customer service, welcoming environment, always has new pieces that are fun to look through. Great family owned store that loves their community.

Photos

An inside look .

Antique and vintage furniture.

See all

So many wonderful treasures.

Transitional Design

Found table we were looking for at great price. Also found terrific couch for my office. And to…read moretop it off got a set if books we wanted at an auction that nite. Oh yes,they took our table on consignment. Overall a great experience.

Great selections of furniture, well organized clothing (by color and size) and high end brands…read more Excellent customer service too.

Photos

See all

West Side Market

So good that I came here 4 times in 3 days. Came to this vendor and tried something different every…read moretime. No regrets. Highly recommend Jacob's oasis. Divine!

Been awhile since I've been here. Parking is always a challenge. Last time I was here you had to…read moreget a ticket. Now it's a QR Code. You get 90 mins free then you pay $1.50 an hour. Pretty good. But you gotta do the work and hit the code and go thru the process. The WSM right now is under construction. So the produce side is smaller and off to the side not the main hall. Then you go out and walk around the sidewalk off Lorain to get to the meat side. Produce side is to the left. Smaller space but they have it organized better. Everyone is selling the same stuff and prices are fairly similar for each stall. But it is brighter and well laid out. I guess you can go by who looks the most trustworthy to who you buy from. Just keep an eye out to what you buy and make sure it's what you get. That was the old market. Hopefully it's better now. TBH I did not buy any veggies or fruit. Meat side is abundant with meat, fish, pastry, sauces, cheese and other vendors. You can find a deal. We got 3 pounds of ground meat for $18. Sunday is an off day some vendors are off so not all the stalls are filled. But more than enough. We also went to Christopher the bread guy for our favorite bread. So good! We got the rustic Italian small loaf and they sliced it. Good sandwiches this week for lunch. But they have a million other options too. This is a nice little treasure and it's worth the time and effort to go here. Grab lunch and hang out on W25th it's fun and worth the visit.

Photos

Sausage roll

2 for $6 buckeyes and $1 mochi

See all

Produce Vendors

Madison Avenue Greenhouse

5.0

(4 reviews)

1.4 mi

What a wonderful hometown family owned and operated Nursery and greenhouse! They have come such a…read morelong way since they bought it just a couple of years ago and had little experience! I must say as a small business owner myself it's hell to make it go in this day and age so kudos to Lisa and her husband and family! And congratulations on the beautiful new greenhouses! It's so exciting to see the growth and I hope people get out and buy their plants and garden needs with you this spring season!

Good experience with this local greenhouse. Very friendly people willing to answer your gardening…read morequestions. Nice supply of flowers, plants, shrubs, and trees. They have wagons if you need them for your shopping. If you are looking to support a local business, this is a great place to visit.

Photos

Sales Flyer

See all

Bremec Garden Center of Concord

3.8

(5 reviews)

5.0 mi

can't find prices on many items and flats of plants are either dead or dying. Pottery is a mess…read morewith no organizational concept. Half the fountains don't work and the ones that do are filthy.

Bremec has the healthiest plants and a great selection. I have used their soil and mulch and have…read morehad it delivered to my home. The customer service is exceptional. The boutique has unique gift items, clothing, and jewelry. With Mother's Day coming up I would highly recommend going to Bremec. One stop shopping for your gifts and cards.

Photos

See all

Our Treasures - antiques - Updated July 2026

People who viewed Our Treasures also viewed

STAR POP vintage + modern

21 reviews

North Collinwood, Northeast Shores

Classic Country Consignments

2 reviews

Painesville Flea Market

4 reviews

Looks Better on You

1 review

Shops by the Lake

18 reviews

Blue Arrow Records and Books

28 reviews

North Collinwood, Northeast Shores

Toy Box Antiques

9 reviews

$$$

The Act II Shop

5 reviews

5th Street Underground

2 reviews

Gateway District

Shore Society

1 review

Ohio City

Our Treasures

Our Treasures Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Our Treasures

More info about Our Treasures

Payment methods

Services

Indoor Amenities

Outdoor Amenities

Other Amenities

Ask the Community - Our Treasures

You might also consider

Miscellaneous Barn

Shops by the Lake

Twice Loved

Painesville Flea Market

Tiffany Rose Antiques

Transitional Design

West Side Market

Madison Avenue Greenhouse

Bremec Garden Center of Concord

Our Treasures - antiques - Updated July 2026

Browse Nearby

Browse Brands

Related Cost Guides

Related Searches in Painesville, OH

Browse Articles

People found Our Treasures by searching for…

Trending Searches in Painesville, OH

People who viewed Our Treasures also viewed

Our Treasures

Our Treasures Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Our Treasures

More info about Our Treasures

Payment methods

Services

Indoor Amenities

Outdoor Amenities

Other Amenities

Ask the Community - Our Treasures

You might also consider

More businesses like Our Treasures

Miscellaneous Barn

Shops by the Lake

Twice Loved

Painesville Flea Market

Tiffany Rose Antiques

Transitional Design

Trending businesses in Our Treasures's area

West Side Market

Madison Avenue Greenhouse

Bremec Garden Center of Concord

Our Treasures - antiques - Updated July 2026

Browse Nearby

Browse Brands

Related Cost Guides

Related Searches in Painesville, OH

Browse Articles

People found Our Treasures by searching for…

Trending Searches in Painesville, OH

People who viewed Our Treasures also viewed