I was not expecting much from this place in a small town, but I was truly amazed. The staff is very…read morewelcoming, our server spoke English. I got chicken which was ok. The pizza was amazing though. We had different pizzas and the best one was what the server recommended- margarita pizza with fresh buffalo mozzarella. The prices were very affordable. Definitely recommend.

This was by far the best pizza I had our entire trip. Service was wonderful and very welcoming…read more Very clean and would definitely eat here again if we were near!!!

Pizzeria that looks small on the outside but with plenty of seating on the inside, located across…read morefrom the water. Top 40s music is playing in the background. We were early so there were only a few people there. The waiter speaks English but I still practiced my Italian (and he said I was doing good with it ) We ordered a couple of beers and the fried seafood. There was plenty of it, having a nice crunchy breading. The calamari was tender and not chewy at all - it really was a large order in size! We had a Forte and Margherita pizza. Oh!! And yeah!!! Flavorful thin crust with the outside crust like soft pillows!!! Enjoyed relaxing and talking about what we did today, the amazing time we have had here and eating local handmade pizza with the simplest of ingredients

Very cute pizzeria in Gaeta with perfect Italian charm inside and out, and the staff was extra nice…read moreand the waiter could speak enough English to help us butcher our Italian attempts. We really enjoyed the fried seafood before the pizzas arrived hot and fresh from the wood burning oven. Perfection on the pizzas, wife had a Margherita and I had a Forte.

The best pizza I have ever had! Had 4 different kinds and the multi tomato pizza was the best! Wish…read morewe could go again before heading back to Texas!

It's often hard to live up to the hype and expectations of being the prior and current year number…read more1 pizza place in the world. People come in with lofty expectations of being blown away by the pizza, and while most if the pizza we tried was well above average, nerveless a gap existed to my expectations. The staff were great given the massive number of people that make pilgrimage to this place and the months in advance needed to get a booking during prime season. The Capriccisita pizza as described in my attached photo was mind blowing which overpowered the other pizzas we ordered. Friendly efficient staff. Figuring out the registration of your reservation prior to entry was a little tricky and chaotic but it eventually worked out fine. Tonight though, in my opinion the crust was not best in class. I found it to be excessively doughy around the edges and soggy in the bottom. Without a great crust as a base any great pizza is doomed to underperform. I will try the world nbr 2 ranked pizza place in the world, Una Pizza Neopolitana,, also owned by the same group, when I'm back in New York to see how their crust performs. Regardless, it was a worthwhile visit.

Out of all the pizzas I've had in the world, this is by far number one. I know that may not be…read moresaying much since it's in Italy, but I've had my fair share of pizzas while I was there and this is still the top choice. The wait to get in may be long, but I've never ordered 5 of the same pizza (Scarpetta) anywhere else.

Continues to be the go-to pizza lover spot. Can't say enough of the memories created here.read more

We enjoyed the variety of pizza here at Pizzeria Rustica. Quick service. Tasty toppings and all…read morearound good flavor!

My favorite pizza place in Gaeta!! First had it 10 years ago and loved it! Went back again last…read moremonth, and still great!!! Now they have an outdoor eating area. They have a vast variety of pizza for a really good price. My favorite is the mushroom and pepperoni pizza. It's the perfect place to go when you're not sure exactly what you're craving because you can get some of everything and they'll heat up for you to enjoy immediately.

The best pizza in the world. Waited around 1.5 hours but 100% worth it. I recommend trying each one…read moreon the menu as they were only €5 each.

Yelp Review #25 (2026)…read more Visited in June 2026. There are two lines when arriving. There is a to go line that's pretty short, an a dine in ticket line that you receive from the employee by the entrance. If you visit their museum to learn about the history of Antica, then your indoor seating is expedited. After the museum, we sat down and ordered our delicious pizza. They offer four different types of pizza.

We found this walking through the town. If you want great pizza, pizza is all they do and have…read moremany options personal or full size. The crust is amazing and everything was so fresh. A winner! The tomato and buffalo mozzarella with the Parma ham was delicious!!!

The food was fantastic Service was good, serving team was…read morevery considerate. Some of the best pizza in town.

This is a great place with a great family atmosphere. There's plenty of room outside and inside for…read moreseating. The menu is very reasonably priced and the menu is in both Italian and English. They have a very reasonable and delicious house white wine. The pizza is great. This is a week night restaurant good for when you're feeling lazy and don't want to cook or break the bank.

Yummmm. Some of the best pizza we had on our trip. I ate slices of artichoke/ham/pepperoni/black…read moreolive and kale sausage. The fried calamari is also great, as is the penne with red sauce.

I am more than pleased to be the first to review this little gem. We were spending a few days…read moretraveling by car between Naples and Rome and we're driving up to the Abbey at Monte Cassino and gave this a shot and sure happy we did. We ordered a few pizzas and pastas and a few sides and they were all really great. I had just had maybe 3-4 Melenzane Parmigiana's over the past few days but they had theirs on an antipasto table that looked great so I had to have it - it was as good as any in Naples. So, literally not a word of English spoken but it was fine. I think the vino rosso there was my least favorite of the trip but everyone else had beer or soda so I took one for the team. I hope they don't hate me for introducing the Yelp community to this place - maybe the locals will, but hey it's 2019...

They pizza is amazing!!! Coming in from New Jersey and was looking for a quick family meal. You…read morewill not be disappointed. Very nice place.

Omg. Excellent in every way, best pizza in the area, another local spot! Even the flight attendants…read morecame for a pickup.. must try!!