Pizza Boy Pizza

Very kind staff! Casual inside but clean and well kept. I think I'll give it another shot and try…read morethe pizza next time-- which the other guests seemed to really enjoyed. I think the menu was a little large and they may want to refine a bit. My baked ziti came out on a room temp plate which is a strong sign to me that it probably wasn't baked. The taste was wonderful but I couldn't get past how watery it was. I DO intend on coming back for the pizza. I don't want this to be a bad review for the restaurant but I wouldn't get the ziti.

Italian Pizzeria & Restaurant (not the most inventive name, but I guess it gets the point across)…read moreis a good enough pizzeria in Lake City, Florida. It is not too far off of Interstate 75. I came in and ordered two slices to-go. The woman taking my order was friendly enough, though it took a bit of time for the pizza to be handed to me. There is also a price difference between paying cash or using a credit card. The pizza was okay. Not great, but good. I mean, I wouldn't go out of my way to go here, but it was good enough all in all. I also have to give them credit for selling pizza by the slice during lunch hours. I don't understand why they (and all pizzerias) don't sell slices all day long), but it is what it is. The cost of two slices (including the almost four percent credit card surcharge) was around seven dollars. I would give it between three and four stars, but I will grade up and go with four stars.

Inside

Pizza

See all

Outside

Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - Lake City

4.2(89 reviews)

2.0 mi

We were traveling home on I-75 from Valdosta heading back to Jacksonville and decided to pull into…read morePiesanos Stone Fire Pizza. We've been to other locations and have loved their pizza. Today we ordered the Large Meat Eater Pizza. It was delicious and it was cooked just right. I love all the flavors and the ingredients they use on their pizza's. Everyone is always so nice and especially this location. Definitely recommend Piesanos Stone Fire Pizza's!

Awesome thin crust!! Good quality pizza! Thank you so much!!…read morePassing through Lake City and tried Piesanos. I would say this is probably one of the best pizzas I have ever had..

Pizza rolls

See all

Fresh salads

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

4.3(80 reviews)

2.7 mi

Had a GREAT lunch and the Service was AMAZING!!!! Carla went above and beyond 10/10 service !read more

Food is always consistent, hot and good! Staff is friendly!…read moreReasonable lunch prices and you get plenty to eat! Those breadsticks and Alfredo dip is the best!

Fettuccine Alfredo: Our signature alfredo made fresh in-house every day, served over fettuccine.

Minestrone: Fresh vegetables, beans and pasta in a light tomato broth.

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant - Five Cheese Ziti al Forno: Oven baked blend of Italian cheeses, pasta and our signature homemade five cheese marinara.

See all

Five Cheese Ziti al Forno: Oven baked blend of Italian cheeses, pasta and our signature homemade five cheese marinara.

Sal's Italian Deli

4.6(261 reviews)

4.1 mi

Completely addicted to the Godfather sandwhich and the pizzas are great too. Service is always…read moregood. Highly recommend

I always pass this place on my way to work and decided to Stop in here for a quick lunch. I ordered…read morethe chicken Parm sandwich and some garlic knots. The sandwich tasted very fresh and I loved the bread. They had a texture of a baguette and focaccia bread. The chicken was a nice size inside with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese. The chicken would have been even better if it was crispy on the outside. It was really soft. I noticed that they have lunch specials and to follow them on Facebook for dinner specials too! They sell pizza and other cold and hot sandwiches. I ordered my sandwich over the phone and it was ready within 15 minutes! The inside is very basic with a few tables to eat they even have an outside area too. But overall nice place for a quick lunch.

Inside

Eggplant Rolletini

See all

Inside

Papa Johns Pizza

1.9(8 reviews)

2.4 mi

My family and I are visiting Lake City from south Florida and our visit to Papa John's was…read morehorrible! We walk in the door and no one greeted us (there were 4 people working) we stood there for 5 minutes without anyone coming to wait on us. When someone finally did she acted like we were bothering her and as if she didn't want to take our order. We ended up walking out and not ordering anything because we refuse to treated like that. We DO NOT recommend this place at all!!

I have ordered from papa johns many times but they really outdid themselves last night. I ordered a…read morestuffed crust pepperoni and had it delivered and it tasted amazing!

See all

Domino's Pizza

2.8(13 reviews)

2.0 mi

Jason at this location is a real American hero. Full stop…read more My grandfather has been a loyal Domino's customer since this store first opened. These days he can't drive, but Jason has gone above and beyond for over a decade to make sure he still gets his absolute favorite pizza, pan crust chicken Alfredo, delivered to him. Even though he's technically outside the delivery area and the order can't be placed through the app, Jason has consistently made it happen. That kind of dedication isn't just good service, it's rare. He's made my grandfather's day more times than I can count, and that means everything to our family. Thank you, Jason, for taking care of your longtime customers and showing what real customer service looks like.

I received wrong order ordering online so I went to the store to place oder & verify I would…read morereceive correct order. I am a disabled veteran, a healthcare provider, & mystery shopper. I had difficulty entering the store because the entrance/door is not ADA compliant for mobility issues/wheelchairs or assisting devices. I had my Service dog & SIT with me. Once in the door, I was ordered to leave the building because I had my Service dogs with me. I was told because they were not vested & they were dogs to get out of his restaurant. I advised him of my rights but he challenged me to call the police. This is not only illegal but disrespectful causing moral injury to an already disabled veteran. Please support our disabled veterans & their needs. Thank you!

Parmesan bites

Sorry for the missing piece lol garlic Parmesan sauce with ham and Italian sausage

See all

Cinnamon twists

Hungry Howie's Pizza & Subs

2.3(3 reviews)

0.3 mi

Edit: I'm changing this to a below average rating. Last week my antipasto salad had no salami…read more Out of the last 10 pizzas I ordered. Half didnt have the extra cheese I ordered. Y'all wanna be stingy fine! I will go some place else. And I also don't like feeling pressured to tip if the order is wrong. I will pay 4 dollars plus tip to get extra cheese and it's like your workers think that mean two extra fairy dust sprinkles. There was a guy with glasses who did my pizzas right. I'm not ordering from here anymore for a long while. I keep giving chances and its been a gamble here for 8 years. I stopped coming here for years,and Now its time to again say bye. I will be going to other pizza places. Life is short and pizza is my favorite food to be getting this upset and disappointed randomly. Then you have sometimes girls at the register acting like they dont get tipped enough.

Not the best pizza in the world, but not the worse. It is your typical chain restaurant pizza…read more Delivery was fast, pizza was hot. Was hoping for something more, but you get what you pay for and it was cheap.

See all

Little Caesars Pizza

2.8(4 reviews)

2.0 mi

Was served a near raw pizza on more than one occasion. Sometimes the staff is rude. Long blonde…read morehair in my pizza once. Quality really went downhill. Will never go back.

I always get the regular thin crust pizza. Always good. This time I got the deep dish , gross , it…read morewasn't cooked all the way. Gooey center sauce not hot and toppings looked like they were tossed on as an after thought. Not sure what was happening there but not pleased with the deep dish. I'll stick with the regular pizzas that they're famous for.

Pp

See all

Pizza Hut

1.0(1 review)

0.1 mi

Terrible service! I ordered a pepperoni, ham, and bacon large pizza. I picked it up from the store…read moreand noticed when I got home that it was a bbq pulled pork pizza. I called and spoke with the manger who said that they will make me another one and have it delivered to me in 30-45 minutes. Well an hour an a half goes by and still no pizza. So I called again and the "manger" answered the phone and said she never spoke with me but the pizza was ready for pickup. She said since the order was originally for pickup she couldn't deliver it, even though she specifically took my address down and said they would deliver it. Save yourself the hassle and go to Pizza Boy Pizza.

From the owner: When there's pizza, good times follow. That's why we're serving up classics like Meat Lovers® and…read moreOriginal Stuffed Crust®. Check out our offers on meals for the whole family, plus sides like breadsticks and cheese sticks, signature wings, pastas and desserts at many of our locations. Order online or on the mobile app for carryout, curbside, or delivery. Pizza Hut - Feed Good Times.

Little Caesars Pizza

4.1(16 reviews)

4.7 mi

Employees are polite. Good is ok but definitely better than the one on 247. Wish it was still $5 a…read morepizza. ‍

The Pizza here is the best in town. I really like that I can stop by anytime and get the Mostest…read morePizza under the Hot-N-Ready.

Under baked pizza

Pepperoni & Sausage Pizza

See all

Over cooked pizza

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Teddy P.

0

1

0

6 years ago

I usually eat Pizza Hut exclusively and have never liked pizza from any other place. But i had the Bianca pizza at Pizza Boy and its now my go-to pizza. Im getting one right now! Incredible! And the dinners like eggplant parm are big enough to share. Nice little place, quite a secret. read more

Jack B.

0

1

0

13 years ago

Stopped in for a sandwich in the afternoon, the lady in there gave me a few garlic knots to sample, went back and got a pizza & knots. All was great, including the sandwich. Probably the best and freshest pizza in Lake City! The crust is definitely the best. read more

Nicole C.

0

2

0

1 year ago

This is the best pizza place in town! We go here all the time we love it. The staff is so friendly

willie b.

11

5

0

16 years ago

the pizza is ok

Pizza Boy Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Pizza Boy Pizza also viewed

Italian Pizzeria

4.2

(65 reviews)

Very kind staff! Casual inside but clean and well kept. I think I'll give it another shot and try…read morethe pizza next time-- which the other guests seemed to really enjoyed. I think the menu was a little large and they may want to refine a bit. My baked ziti came out on a room temp plate which is a strong sign to me that it probably wasn't baked. The taste was wonderful but I couldn't get past how watery it was. I DO intend on coming back for the pizza. I don't want this to be a bad review for the restaurant but I wouldn't get the ziti.

Italian Pizzeria & Restaurant (not the most inventive name, but I guess it gets the point across)…read moreis a good enough pizzeria in Lake City, Florida. It is not too far off of Interstate 75. I came in and ordered two slices to-go. The woman taking my order was friendly enough, though it took a bit of time for the pizza to be handed to me. There is also a price difference between paying cash or using a credit card. The pizza was okay. Not great, but good. I mean, I wouldn't go out of my way to go here, but it was good enough all in all. I also have to give them credit for selling pizza by the slice during lunch hours. I don't understand why they (and all pizzerias) don't sell slices all day long), but it is what it is. The cost of two slices (including the almost four percent credit card surcharge) was around seven dollars. I would give it between three and four stars, but I will grade up and go with four stars.

Italian Pizzeria

4.0

(42 reviews)

Pasta dishes pizza and home made desserts. Are always yummy wish they made Zeppelin's…read moreFried dough powdered sugar Menu is large there's something for everyone

They don't care liquor licence we got some orange juice Beth our waitresses offer us also battle or…read morefountain soda or tea. So we are looking the menu now. Got the appetizers and did not get disappointed it was delicious all fried in fresh oil or at least noticed. We both got the Seafood pasta served with a side toasted bread. I ask to mine to be in a pink sauce with a touch of cooking white wine and extra garlic. The garlic were processed in very tini cubics . Of course they charge extra. Chef came from Long Island New York. Originally from El Salvador. I asked because my husband being a Executive Chef for Italian Cuisine got curios about the taste. TV on all the time a bit noise by the cleaning station. In my opinion they should upsize their tiramisu portion and use fresh chocolate powder on top also it could use some decoration around the dish. Was told they run out of wipe cream.

The Pizza Stone

5.0

(6 reviews)

We a local here and its our first timer can't tell how exited we are to try it. We order with the…read moreowner Cherylyn from Philippines very friendly and polite. We got the food in 20 m after just like she said. They take order by phone but do not deliver for now. We have our meal delivered to our table wile waiting. I suggest to ask for plain sweet teriaky wings sauce on the side. It's not as sweet as I usually have in other places. Pizza is to the thin crust side a little oily for my taste. I asked why and they told me it was because they drizzled some garlic butter on top. It's a small town even seeing costumers arriving in ATV. Desabilite ramp is on the other end of the porch.

Really good pizza. A gem for the locals. The owners are also very welcoming and accommodating…read more Highly recommend.

Sal's Italian Deli

4.6

(261 reviews)

Completely addicted to the Godfather sandwhich and the pizzas are great too. Service is always…read moregood. Highly recommend

I always pass this place on my way to work and decided to Stop in here for a quick lunch. I ordered…read morethe chicken Parm sandwich and some garlic knots. The sandwich tasted very fresh and I loved the bread. They had a texture of a baguette and focaccia bread. The chicken was a nice size inside with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese. The chicken would have been even better if it was crispy on the outside. It was really soft. I noticed that they have lunch specials and to follow them on Facebook for dinner specials too! They sell pizza and other cold and hot sandwiches. I ordered my sandwich over the phone and it was ready within 15 minutes! The inside is very basic with a few tables to eat they even have an outside area too. But overall nice place for a quick lunch.

Our Place Pizzeria and Italian Ristorante

3.9

(15 reviews)

Order a pizza for my husband to be delivered since he's in Lake City doing some training for work…read moreand order it through DoorDash and the DoorDash driver stole my order in the process of finding this out. I called the restaurant and talk to the floor manager who is the sweetest person ever and I wish I could remember her name, but she assured me that my order was picked up by the DoorDash driver had to contact DoorDash for a refund and I re-ordered it and in the process of re-ordering she was contacting me to make sure I was re-ordering the pizza she went above and beyond, and I wish all the best for this young lady because she did not have to take the time and be respectful to me because I was a little irritated. I know it was not her fault it was DoorDash, but DoorDash didn't hear about that and I hope her manager sees this and gives her a praise for me because she deserves one.

Amazing house special Pizza. Fresh vegs, fresh meats. Even great as a reheated lunch. Highly…read morerecommend, I asked for extra crunchy crust and it was perfect. NOT PRICEY AT ALL. 10 +++

Skip's Delicatessen & Specialty Shoppe

4.1

(19 reviews)

Skip's is always amazing. I've been eating there for over 20 years and have never had a bad…read moreexperience. The sandwiches are always fresh and tasty and the salads are as well. My only complaint is that I've often had a long wait at lunchtime if eating in, but it's always been worth it.

We ventured off the freeway to find Skip's for lunch. I'm glad we did…read more We split a Godfather sandwich which is an Italian sun. The bread was fresh and warmed up for the sandwich. Little poppyseed sprinkles were a nice added touch. The sandwich was full of meat and fresh veggies. No skimping here. Since we split the sandwich, we were charged an extra $1.50 but it was worth it as we each got our own side of chips and a pickle. The restaurant was clean. It was constantly busy as we sat inside and ate so it must be a local fav. Great stop.

Marion Street Bistro and Brew House

4.2

(383 reviews)

As regular patrons of Marion Street, I want to say that this place is fantastic! The food is great…read moreand the ambiance is perfect! But what makes us keep coming back time again is the famous Brittany "Boots!" She is an awesome bartender who really knows how to entertain the bar guest and treat us with passion and enthusiasm. In addition, she is very veteran friendly and always has a smile on her face and always takes care of her customers. We'd highly recommend giving Marion Street a try, and tell Brittany we sent you! Paul and Anita

Love the bartenders at this local establishment!!! Mrs. Brittany always makes sure to take extra…read morecare of me...she says its cause im a veteran, but I think she's just a good person.

Shirley's Restaurant

4.2

(99 reviews)

This has been a staple since I was a child. I love this restaurant from the breakfast menu and on…read more This place has one of the best Hamburgers you can get and I love the pork chops both fried and grilled. From the owners and their employees they are so wonderful very nice and home town people.

Our Road Trip 2026 got off to a great start when we stopped by Shirley's for breakfast! There were…read morea group of locals who meet here on Saturdays. Very nice group. I had the sausage and cheese omelet with the fried potatoes. Husband had the fried pork chops which were not on the menu but available if you ask. Both were yummy. Sausage gravy was good too. Service and atmosphere were Great. We'll be back.

Two Fat Guys Burgers & Fries

4.3

(72 reviews)

Just had dinner here on a Sunday night on way home from Disney back to Nashville after plane got…read morecanceled. Looking for a place off the freeway we decided to give this a try. Omg I would eat here all the time if I was local. The burger and seasoned fries are very similar to that other place with a similar sounding name. Their input on the menu for a first timer was spot on. Super friendly staff. Plenty of places to sit and eat, and they have a drive through as well.

Wow the burger was fantastic! I got the bacon cheeseburger with grilled onions, mushrooms, mustard…read moreand mayo. I also had the garlic parm fries. These guys nailed the flavor perfectly

The Brown Lantern

3.9

(112 reviews)