1. Plum Creek Archery

1. Plum Creek Archery

0

Dyersville, IA

Cancel

Open app

Search

Plum Creek Archery

5.0 (1 review)
Closed • Closed

Plum Creek Archery Photos

Recommended Reviews - Plum Creek Archery

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration
Photo of G. Lue D.
130
98
50

8 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Plum Creek Archery

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Pappas Trading Post

Pappas Trading Post

3.0(4 reviews)
75.7 mi

I'm sharing my experience with Pappas because I don't want anyone to have to waste the time and…read morehave the frustration I have had with them. The bearings in my cams of my VXR blew out the day before the 2022 archery season.... I was at pappas right away the next morning when the doors opened. I had bought my last two bows from them, and figured that would be the way to go. I showed them the issues and they told me I over tightened the axle and I would have to buy the cams and it would be weeks to get them. I took my bow and left. I called around to other shops, 2 other shops said that this is an issue that they have been seeing, and that it has been covered 100% of the time. I went back into pappas and told them this due to the other shops being even further away. At that point they said they had cams but I would still need to pay $300 for the set. I did this so I could hunt. A while later I reached out to the Mathews rep, he said that that they have been warranting, out the cams, and he would talk to Randy to get me a refund. Today I went to pick up my refund and was charged a $50 service fee for them having to process the return. This is something that no other shop in this area has done. This is gone as far as a close friend of mine with the same bow had the same issue got charged for cam by Pappa's. Went to a different dealer and that dealer ripped cams off of a brand new bow, replaced his damage cams, and sent him on his way free of charge. I do not understand why the customer service at Papas has gone downhill so far. I would've gladly payed them to put new cams on my bowl the first time if they would've warranted the cams simply for there inconvenience, but instead I had to drive an hour each way twice. I don't believe I will ever return to Papas. There are better shops in the area. Oh.... And when I pulled the cams back off of my bow to swap the top hats they put back in reverse of how I had them, the axle that was "over tightened" was tighter than it was when I took it to them the first time.

Randy, JC and the crew at Pappas Trading Post are awesome. The store carries the best products in…read morearchery at very competitive prices. The on-site range is super-convenient and the team will offer advice, make adjustments, re-fletch arrows, do anything you need to get your shooting on-point. We're fortunate to have this outfit within a reasonable drive of Madison.

Plum Creek Archery - archery - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...