The students at the middle school were raving about this place so I decided to check it out. Definitely worth the trip. I had the white pizza - so good and breadsticks / so good and a hard cider. They have an impressive beer menu featuring a large selection of Indiana beer. The breadsticks are definitely worth mentioning twice because they weren't at all greasy. Nice and crunchy on the outside and light and fluffy inside. Not high cuisine but excellent for a pizza joint. The best part - the prices are super reasonable! I would definitely eat here again! read more

We were so excited to try The Red Pepperoni for the first time. The food was good but unfortunately the rudeness we experienced from the server, and then the manager over a mistake on their part, will keep us from ever coming back. read more

Generally service is great and food is good, but it's annoying when the price The menu and the price on the check don't match. Usually to the restaurant's favor read more

The Red Pepperoni - Bells 2 hearted on the menu for 3.25 on the bill for 4.00 Happens all over Madison - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Indiana

See all

This was the first time that I had eaten here. The staff was very friendly and helpful. I ordered the Teriyaki chicken Pizza and it was good. I would've liked the crust to have been alittle thicker and the chicken chunks were just a bit big for a topping. But I may probably visit here again. read more

I drive here about once a month during the summer. I love they have personal size pies and always hey great service.

Very clean,polite employees but most of all delicious food. We highly recommend this place.

I came here with my nephews and we all loved it. The pizza was perfectly cooked, and tasted delicious. The bread sticks were fluffy, which I thought was excellent. The best part was that for five of us to eat, it cost $26. I couldn't believe it. The wait staff were also extremely friendly. Would recommend! read more

I had the absolute best experience with April. Thank you so much for making our first experience a lasting experience. April went above and beyond and made us feel so welcomed. Thank you April and the food was delicious also. read more

We really enjoyed our first visit to the red pepperoni. We had cheesy bread and the Sicilian pizza. Both were delicious and authentic. Good service and atmosphere. We definitely recommend this place! We will return read more

Pretty good homey place in Madison Indiana. They have pretty good salads that are big and fresh (perfect for the price) and pizza is simple but tasty. Everything is reasonably priced for everyone! A great place to go for lunch and dinner and wait is not that long. read more

Always good pizza! Good daily specials too. Parking is a little sketchy, but it's worth it.

Great lil find while in Madison for a high school football game. Pizza had excellent flavor. Wings were great. Everything, from the dough to the salad dressings, all had a fresh homemade and unique taste! Service was quick and attentive. We'll definitely be back next time we're in the area. read more

Stopped here for the first time over the weekend driving through town. Pizza was great. We had the Hawaiian Pig (I believe it was called) and the Greek...actually did the half and half. Both were delicious. They don't use a ton of sauce on their pizzas and I think that makes it taste so much better. They had a lot of good beer but we had a long drive at night so we'll have to come back and try the beer. Hope to come back to Madison and visit again soon. read more

Excellent pizza and Buffalo chicken salad. Chicken was not breaded which made it even better. The place was packed and we were warned it would be half an hour for food. Sat back and enjoyed a great craft beer. The pizza was well worth the wait. read more

I'm surprised no one has mentioned the lasagna! 2 words.... Life changing. It is the only place we order lasagna at. The RPD pizza is also delicious. The waitresses are always friendly, and the place is clean. This is one of our "go to" establishments in Madison. read more

This place has a bow Thai pasta that I could founder myself on.....very good ! Sandwiches r good too ;)

Stopped in for lunch before visiting Clifty Falls. The selection of specialty pizzas was outstanding, had a problem deciding. The pizza was hot and fresh and had great flavor. I will certainly be returning for the pizza. read more

Don't know why we haven't been here sooner but I'm so glad we did. Their pizza was awesome and they had a large variety to choose from. Even the side salad with the house dressing was delicious. Some craft beer available as well as domestic and wine too. We will definitely be back. read more

Great fresh made pizza and sides along side the best craft beer selection in Madison. The atmosphere sets the whole dining experience off perfectly. Servers are always prompt and friendly. read more

Friendly staff, really solid pizza, and a fantastic selection of beers. I'll be back!

Service was horrid we came in and waited over 30 mins and never had drinks or the order taken

Very rude server named Delta. Husband asked for a beer was looking for suggestions and she told him she'd bring a water. He said I don't want a water I'll have a... and she was gone. Barely spoke to us and when she did it was rude. Food was okay but won't be back. Not worth it. read more

Every time we eat here the food is delicious. The fried ravioli as an appetizer is amazing and they always carry an awesome variety of beers! 6 foot blonde is my alk time favorite. Friendly small town casual atmosphere. They also have a few outside picnic tables. read more

the calzones and personal pies are bomb. the larger ones aren't as good (mine were always wet), and are more expensive. avoid them and be rewarded for being greedy. read more

Staying at the Clifty Falls Inn and wanted something decent / quick after a long day hiking. Popped in to get takeout, while waiting chatted with the staff and enjoyed one of the many beers they have. When the pizza came all I can say is 'top notch'! I will certainly be eating here again read more

Just ate at this quaint little pizza spot in Historic Madison. It was So Good! Both of my picky eaters said it was the best pizza they have had and the best meal that we had on our mini-trip. My husband and I really enjoyed it too. Price was reasonable too. I highly recommend a stop here if you get a chance. read more

Fantastic spot for family pizza night! The extensive beer list with descriptions was impressive. The breadsticks arrived super hot and fluffy. Everyone loved the garlic dipping sauce. We split a large pizza...which fed 2 adults and 2 teens. The White Pizza was so flavorful. Our son wanted the Spuds McKenzie, so that was our other 1/2. It was a HIT!!! My husband said it didn't really taste like pizza...more like bar food. I thought it tasted like bar food ON pizza. How awesome is that!?! Overall a very positive experience. We will be back during our next trip to Madison. read more

What a great find. We got into Madison too early to check into Cliffty Falls Inn and had lunch here. Food was great, service was great, cute place. We had a full restaurant at the Inn (where food was not the greatest) and Friday night passed up the buffet at the Inn and ordered Pizza from here, and it was just as good at lunch the day before. Will be a stop anytime we get to Madison, wish there was one in Goshen. read more

Loved it!! Stopped here with the family on a day trip to Hanover College and Clifty. We loved the toasted ravioli and breadsticks. Specialty pizza was great - quick service, reasonably priced, and delicious! Will be back... read more

We love pizza so we are usually pretty critical of pizzerias, but we would definitely recommend TRP! Pizza and salad were both great!

I was really looking forward to eating here after seeing some of the reviews but it turned out to be just a so so pizza place.

Decent food, but nothing to wait too long for. Service is pitiful. I'll only come here if I'm really craving the beer or a calzone (because it's the only place in town to get one), but the ridiculous wait for service makes me want to walk out. 15 minutes to have my order taken when there are only 3 other couples here and at least 4 servers working is outrageous. The servers stood and stared at us while playing on their phones instead of taking our order. If you don't want to go to Hanover for good pizza then this place is a decent substitute, so long as you can handle the pitiful service. read more

We stopped at The Red Pepperoni on our last trip to Madison. It will not be our last visit. The breadsticks are alone are worth trip. The waitress was attentive and very nice. I would highly recommend this place if you are wanting pizza! read more

Great pizza. Lots of choices in toppings and good service. Try the Hawaiian pizza or the artichoke.

Supposed to be good pizza but never got waited on. Left when we got upset. Go to a place that wants your business.

Best pizza in town! They have great speciality pizzas but you also have the option to be creative too. They have the best craft beer selection around so enjoy while you wait for your delicious handmade pizza. read more

The Deli that is across the street owned by the same people is delicious but tonight I ordered a white pizza with Alfredo sauce and the sauce was almost none existent. It was dry and basically bread and cheese. This was the first date night I've had with my fiance in months and needless to say it was horribly disappointing. I brought the pizza home in a box and my 21 year old former pizza delivery driver son said "Is there supposed to be alfredo sauce on this?" He threw it away as well. So having had pizza in Chicago, New York and St. Louis my advice is skip the overpriced pie at the Red Pepperoni.. order a "specialty" pizza from a chain store and pick up a six pack of micro-brew from the local liquor stores.. will save yourself some headache.. but if you like "dry" pizza then this is the place for you. read more

My husband and I just ordered carryout and we ordered their house Pizza RPD special and their spinach and artichoke dip, I've lived in Madison 5 years and just now got around to order from Red Pepperroni and now it's my new favorite place, the pizza was delicious and so was the spinach artichoke dip. read more