Let me start by saying I'm new to the community and have only visited this parish once. However, the abuses I saw make it very difficult to recommend anyone visit this parish until these are fixed. Bottom line: I'm very concerned about this parish.
It's not all bad... There are great aspects of the parish: they are obviously well funded, appear to be active in helping the community, parishioners sing(!), people appear happy, and (for the first time ever -for me- on at a Sunday Mass) EVERYONE (that I could hear) said, "and with your spirit". The last one alone is medal worthy! ;)
There are likely many other positives, but for now, that's what I saw. And I wish I could stop there and give this parish 5 stars and move on. Unfortunately not.
I just moved to this community and fully expected to get involved in this parish but I'm not sure I can do that now. Last Sunday was First Communion. This is a great time to see how the community ticks, and get a glimpse how children are catechized. However, when the priest invited the children to say the words of consecration with him and then later said the blessing "in the name of Creator, Redeemer, and Sanctifier," I was shocked. I stopped mid-sign of the cross. I didn't know what to say. I looked around expecting to see gasps but instead this might just be standard protocol here. I hope not!
I can already picture my non-Catholic friends rolling their eyes... This may not sound like a big deal, but to a Catholic, the Holy Trinity is, well, GOD. Replacing the Father, Son and Holy Spirit with anything else is not cool, at all. (Can I get an "earth, wind, and fire" anyone? How about a "Mother, child, and womb"?) The basic problem is that each Person of the Holy Trinity is a Person, not a function. Calling each Person by their function removes the relationship out of it. Kind of like my friends calling me "the person who brings me coffee" instead of Cara.
To my seminary friends... Look, I'm not saying this priest is a modalist heretic or worse (I don't know the man, so I'd hate to presume). For all I know, he is a well meaning priest that truly believes he is leading his flock to become saints. But he needs our prayer. My hope is that he is inadvertently introducing these abuses into the liturgy, as opposed to willful rebellion from God in an effort to promote some progressive, but very ancient, heresies.
In fact, the Catholic Church (Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith) has communicated that if this phrase was used during a baptism it would not be valid. So I'm not making this stuff up.
Source: http://www.catholic.or...
And asking laypeople (anyone really) to repeat the words of consecration with you? Also not cool. That's a role explicitly for the priest. I repeat this prayer in my head as well, along with the rest of the parishioners. But the role of the sacrificial priesthood is reserved for, well, priests.
I'm currently writing a letter to the priest. And I will pray that he has the best intentions and is inadvertently introducing these and other more minor abuses into the liturgy (holding hands during the Our Father, dictating posture during the prayer -- strange hand gestures).
Okay, liturgical abuses out of the way... Next up architecture... It's actually a well built parish. However, the tabernacle is in the old / unused sanctuary. So when you walk in to the large, um, "hall?", I'm not sure if I'm supposed to genuflect. They have what appear to be unconsecrated hosts behind a covering, behind the altar, but I'm not sure. There's no red light to communicate otherwise. Then when I was walking out I saw the Precious Blood on the purificators being walked past the busy crowd on their way to the cars. I've never
Also, the parishioners sit facing one another with the altar in the middle. I'm not sure what you call this. It's not ad orientem and it's not populum. It's something else entirely. If it were a Protestant building I'd say, it looks great. As a Catholic parish, I'm still figuring it out. Candles? Nope. Stations of the Cross? Not that I could find.
I'll be back this week with more. I'm bummed because I work near by and would love to make this parish my home, but I don't think I can do it with the abuse I saw yesterday. I'm really hoping this is all a big misunderstanding and the priest didn't know to say the black and do the red, not improvise his own tradition.
I will say that the kids here are surprisingly well behaved. And smiling, and singing. So I'll give them that. I would also say that more folks were singing the modern "hymns" than at most parishes I've been to. Another plus... EVERYONE I heard said, "and with your spirit." That's a first for me at a Sunday Mass! There's always a handful of stragglers throwing out the "and also with you" at my old parish. ;) So it's not all bad! Just in some serious, but fixable parts. read more