I refer to Joe Schafer, owner of Schafer Brothers Remodeling, as my "Obi Wan Kenobi" - as in "help me Obi Wan Kenobi, you're my only hope". I have called upon this company many times for home repairs and home remodeling and have always been highly satisfied with the end results. Most recently one of the pipes in an upstairs bathroom in my home froze and split - leaking down to the bottom floor den destroying walls, ceiling and laminate flooring. When I noticed the damage I knew Joe and Schafer Brothers Remodeling were the ones I could trust to put the room back together again. Joe was very thorough as he assessed all the damage and offered suggestions on how to repair the damage. Since the paint on the walls was no longer manufactured, he suggested an alternative finish which looks just as good as the rest of the walls that did not sustain any damage. Joe and his crew took care of everything, from laying down protection as they entered the home to cleaning up after themselves each evening as they finished for the day. They were prompt and courteous and after each day of work they let me know what had been completed - and what the next steps would be. Joe handled the estimate with my homeowner's insurance company making sure that they considered all the damage that was done - not just the visible damage but also the work that would need to be done to put the room back together again. When the original estimate from the insurance company came back and Joe saw that they had not considered some of the work - he went to bat for me and explained to the company all the items that they had not considered, resulting in a higher estimate of damage on what they would cover. I would not hesitate to recommend Schafer Brothers Remodeling. They have always done a complete and thorough job on everything I have hired them for - from just installing a kitchen sink faucet to replacing ceiling, walls and flooring. read more

Completed a full master bathroom design, complete bathroom tearout, changed plumbing and heating, built custom vanity cabinets using quartz tops, glass shower wall used for shower wall, all used for rebuilding the master bathroom. Entire process flow of the project from design to completion was well organized. Project management involved in very early stage of construction project. Able to choose my own choice of bathroom materials from other suppliers or materials directly from catalogs from Schafer remodeling. Communicated with Schafer Remodeling team via email and during design phase at their Virginia Street office and my home. I paid directly for the project (no financing) although I understand financing is available. Construction crews cleaned up after a days work. Tiling crew was exact in leveling each tile to preciseness. Discussed with carpenter assigned to project on regular basis to make sure bathroom design was being implemented properly. Discussed with plumber and heating technicians to understand correct placement of pipes and changes in ductwork. Construction debris was removed from my home and discarded in their pickup truck dumptruck during the demolition phase (no need for the ugly dumpster in your driveway). Communicated often with Project team via email and provided weblinks of products to order for bathroom. Orders purchased by Schafer remodeling. Schafer Remodeling handled obtaining the permit from the city and provided necessary design updates to city. read more

I had Schafer Brothers Remodeling Inc. remodel my much outdated master bathroom in August of 2023.  They had previously remodeled my kitchen and did an amazing job with that job. Aside from personnel issues Schafer Brothers was experiencing, they did complete my master bathroom and it looks amazing!  They really want the best completed product and when their personnel cant keep up to their standard, they remove that personnel and replace them with those that fulfil the Schafer Brothers quality that the owners and customers expect.  Johnny, Paul, Chad and more all did a great job once Jeff Anderson became to be the project manager.  Jeff had an impeccable eye for detail and would not allow the quality to fall to les than perfect.  He demonstrated that he understands that the name of Schafer Brothers is on the line and that's what sells to the next customer so if I wasn't happy, the world would know.  At the end of the project, it was amazing thanks to Jeff Anderson.  Joe Schafer even came out to the house after the project was complete to review the work and what a good guy he is!  No matter how much the job may cost him, he will make sure the job is done right and that the customer is happy.  I'm here to say, trust Schafer Brothers with any of your remodeling needs.  At the end, you will not be disappointed!     A special thank you to Jeff Anderson for a job well done!  Thanks Jeff read more

Through the years my spouse and I have observed the high-end quality of Schafer's workmanship throughout McHenry County. When we recently purchased our 50+ year old house, we decided to call upon Schafer to improve our investment. We are happy we did. They took the time to talk with us, and were conscientious about the quality of the products they used, took care in their work, and each day cleaned up the area. As for the details of the project: Our entryway only had the original frosted, single pane, side-lite windows on both sides of a drafty door where we could see the sun shine between the hinges. Schafer replaced our entry door with a custom Therma-Tru door to fit the era of our house and stained it to our preferred color choice. They also installed double pane, customized side-lite windows to the exterior of the original frosted side-lites, and to further protect the glass they stripped and repainted our decorative wrought iron panels and installed them over our new side-lite windows. They removed the clunky old storm door and replaced it with a Larson's full view door and brass lock. The entire exterior door frame was also given a fresh coat of paint. Our entryway work was completed in August and now that we are approaching November and have experienced a variety of weather, we can honestly say that our house is more energy efficient since Schafer made these improvements. read more

After having our first floor completely remodeled we had Schafer come back out and freshen up our master bedroom with new flooring, repair and paint walls and install a ceiling fan. We of course request Erik, one of their lead carpenters, as he did such a phenomenal job with the 1st floor. And let's just say phenomenal is an understatement for Erik's level of skill and level of meticulousness. He again amazed us with his work in our master bedroom. We have a vaulted ceiling in which the tape and mud was all cracked and instead of redoing it so that years later it happens again Erik custom built a beam to match the beam he custom built on the 1st floor. We will continue to use Schafer Brothers for anymore indoor or outdoor work that we need done, which one for sure is to redeck our deck and replace the rails. For Erik's bosses, do whatever needs to be done to keep him at Schafer for he is definitely indispensable. He has the same work ethics and pride as I do when I do plumbing and in my experience people like us are hard to come by. Lastly I have to mention Jeff, Schafer job superintendent, he is very personable and anal, but anal in a good way. Any flaws that catch his eye, no matter how small, he will make his guys or the subs correct it no matter what. He has always done a final walk through to sign off on the job. read more

We had Schafer Brothers remodel our master bath 5 years ago and it was obvious that they were the place to go when it was time to remodel the kitchen recently. From start to finish, they made the process as painless as possible. Our thoughts, concerns and ideas were heard and addressed. I felt like the way we use the kitchen was taken into account as we planned cabinet layout and made our selections for counters, cabinets and back splashes. A kitchen designer was available to us which gave us confidence in making our choices. Before construction, we had a meeting to go over all the steps of the project. Everyone's expectations and concerns were discussed. We were all in agreement before we started, so there were no problems. Every day, the contractor would tell me what the day's work would be and who would be in the house. He also told me at the end of the day what had been done and what the next day's plan was. I appreciate knowing what is going to be happening and who's going to be around. Every one I came in contact with was very polite and considerate. Clean up was done every day. The time frame we were given at the beginning was right on target. Probably one of the most important things is they show up when they say they will and do what they say they will. read more

Sorry this post is a long time coming due to personnel issue. We had Dave Bray from Schafer Brothers remodeling out again, (they did my kitchen,2bathrooms, fireplace wall & more) cause we wanted to hear his ideas for a screen room we wanted to add. Wow Dave never disappoints! He has the ability to see things and put it to paper I swear he has a special talent. Next step is Lee taking from the paper and making it amazing!! Another guy (Lee)who has amazing talents!! He is the best all around carpenter We've ever had the pleasure to work with honestly!!! Lee walks you thru every step of the process and asks for your input. Lee is really amazing! But Lee also has help. There's Brandon who is also a great carpenter & Nate and John others on the crew. All the are awesome. But getting back to my screen room it turn FANTASTIC!! We love it!! If your ever in the market for any kind of improvements to your home I highly recommend Schafer Brothers Remodeling!! I'll add pictures of the finished room. I just want to send A Great Big THANK YOU to the team at Schafer Brother's Dave Bray, Lee, Brandon, Nate, Daniel, Kevin the Electrician, Chanel& Kelsey and many more, It was a pleasure to work with all of you. Mary S read more

Schafer Brothers Remodeling is professional and wonderful to work with. From the initial consultation to the end of the work being done they stayed in contact and kept me informed. I had my garage trim replaced and wrapped in aluminum due to a large hole that had developed. Since SBR was completely booked in the Fall and knew they wouldn't be able to take care of the issue until this Spring, they told me what we could use to patch the hole to protect the wood frame from rotting during the winter from the rain, snow & ice. Mark called every couple of weeks to let me know that I hadn't been forgotten and that they would get me on the schedule just as soon as possible. When Lee came out to replace the trim he was very courteous and professional and completed the job in a timely manner. He also explained what he did and why they install the way they do. I'm totally pleased with the finished job and the quality of the work that Lee, and SBR, provided, and will definitely call them for future repairs/remodeling if the need arises. They can be trusted to do the work right the first time! read more

From the first contact by phone and after the initial meeting for window consultation, we knew this was the company we would have doing our remodeling work. We were impressed by their professionalism, quality of product, excellent warranty, and the detailed written proposal. You could certainly tell these guys were not your fly-by-night contractor. The job was started on time, the prep work proved to be exceptional. All of my floors and furniture were covered and the crew were courteous and friendly. From the start of the job to the finish, a supervisor was at the house every day to make sure all details of the job were to their and my expectation and satisfaction. At the end of every work day a truck arrived at the house to take away all the debris. Due to the excellent workmanship and quality of product, the curb appeal of my home has people commenting on what a beautiful job was done. I have recommended this company to many neighbors and friends. I would not hesitate to hire this company for future remodeling projects. read more

It's such a pleasure to recommend a company that is excellent in every way! We have had Schaffer Brothers assist us with several projects, the latest of which was a remodel of our master bathroom. Everything from the beginning to the end of the project spelled excellence! From Joe Schaffer's assessment of the need, his guidance in design and materials, to the project's implementation and completion by Matt, truly a master builder and craftsman. The project site was kept clean, great care was taken to keep the dust and debris at a minimum and vacuumed up each day, and the project was completed ahead of schedule! Really, we can't say enough about the Schaffer Brothers organization . . . they all are truly professional in all they do, from initial contact with Joe or Bill, anyone who answers the phone at their office, and those who work on the job. Their excellence is consistent! What more could a customer ask for? If we have another project come up, we would definitely go with this company again! read more

I am so glad I chose Schafer Brothers Remodeling, Inc. My husband and I decided it was time to update our 1980's kitchen - it was literally falling apart. I called for an estimate from Dave. Throughout the process Dave was friendly and professional. He even tolerated me sending him Pinterest pictures at 5 a.m. asking his opinion. LOL! At the meeting before the project began, we met Lee. Lee would be the guy who handled the entire kitchen remodel from demolition to final touches. Lee was friendly and payed close attention to detail. I was very comfortable having Lee in my home, even when I wasn't there. Lee was highly professional. He ensured the process went smoothly. We are so pleased with his workmanship! My kitchen is so beautiful! I already have more projects for Schafer to do around my house. read more

We recently had a bathroom and kitchen remodeled. The Schafer Brothers team made it a positive experience from beginning to end. Avery was fantastic with explaining everything each step of the way. Every staff member was professional, knowledgeable, and respectful. I expected to come home each day to cleaning for hours and my home was clean and organized after each day on the job. Austin, the electrician was very professional and had excellent communication. His expertise was impeccable. It was so helpful to have a company that recognized busy schedules with families and were honest and communicative throughout the process. Thank you to all staff members for making this as smooth as possible. I give Schafer Brothers the highest rating! read more

Schafer Brothers remodeled our kitchen. The time they took to plan our project assured us that details were going to be correct and the work would be done in a timely fashion. This job was a remodel "down to the studs" and reworking of the floor plan including the addition of a first floor laundry room. Their crew was at our home on a daily basis and progress was always on time. The remodel was scheduled for 4 weeks at the maximum and it was finished in 3 1/2. They even mounted , wired and connected the new TV. Professional planning and execution. There were a couple of minor issues but they took care of them immediately. Their crew of contractors were all outstanding! If you want it planned and done right, call Schafer Brothers. read more

We recently had Schafer Brothers Remodeling remodel our kitchen. They tool dark kitchen, opened it up and made a beautiful kitchen dining area. With the help of their designer, we picked out cabinets, tile, faucets, sink, and colors. They gutted the kitchen replacing cabinets with beautiful Amish cabinets going all the way to the ceiling. Recessed all lighting in the kitchen and dinette, as well as LED lighting under the cabinets, all of which are on dimmers. The installed a tile flooring and backsplash. All of this was drawn together with a Cambria quartz counter. The workers were prompt, friendly, efficient, and cleaned up well everyday. We have used Schafer for 3 major projects and will use them again when needed. read more

We recently had our master bath remodeled. Schafer had done some windows for us several years ago, so we called them back. The work they did was wonderful. From our first meeting with Dave, we could tell that he really listened to what we wanted. The team that came out was fantastic - extremely professional and they communicated really well with us. Matt would leave a note each day saying what had been done, and what to expect for the next day or rest of the week. Any issues that came up were taken care of immediately. Not only is our new bathroom beautiful, the quality of the work is great. We would definitely recommend Schafer for any home projects! read more

As first time homeowners we weren't sure where to go regarding the renovation of our second floor. After speaking with Dave during the initial walk through we knew we were in great hands. The home is almost a hundred years old and displayed some obstacles, however Dave and his team were quick to overcome them. Any detail or idea we brought to the table was received with a can do attitude. The end result really showed me the difference between the house we had bought and the home we plan on living in for years. We couldn't be happier with the work performed. We are already recommending Schafer brothers to anyone in need. Thanks again! Nick & Becky, read more

We had our kitchen remodeled from a dark cramped space to a modern light-filled kitchen with much more room. Schafer Brothers Remodeling did a great job through the whole process. During the design phase our wants were taken into account as we went through different layouts and cabinet and material choices. The actual remodel went as well as we could have hoped for. The dust was contained to the area being remodeled and we didn't notice any in any other areas of the house. It went fast considering how extensive a change was being made to our kitchen. All of the workers were very friendly and professional. We are very happy with the final result. read more

Can't say enough about this Company. Just had a medium sized job done (painting and some Siding replacement) and it was outstanding! It is the fourth time they have done work over the last 12 years. They are not the cheapest but they are the best. I have never had a problem. Joe and Bill (owners) are as caring and good as they come. Their guys never leave a mess (which happened often when I have used others), they were polite and also started and finished on time- another rarity! Oh, and any time I had a concern the phone was answered or I received a call back in a timely manner, even on a weekend. Just a great experience! Thanks Schafer. read more

We have used Schafer Brothers Remodeling twice and have been pleased with their work both times. The last time was to remodel our master bathroom. We started with their sales person, Dave who stayed on top of our process all the way. We had a terrific contractor, Daniel, who was punctual, and kept the work area clean after each day. He took the time to listen to any concerns I had and answered my questions promptly. All of the individuals at Schafer Brothers Remodeling were great to work with. The end result is beautiful. We couldn't be happier. I believe there will be a third engagement with SBR in the near future. read more