We stopped in for some beer to replace what we had consumed at our son in law's house. Beer is stored in a refrigerator case at the back of the store, making you walk through most of the store. Checking out was quick and simple. If we lived in the area we would probably visit again. Good location on highway - easy to get in and out quickly. read more

Attempted to purchase the White Claw 0% alcohol seltzers, cashier asked for my ID. Explained there was 0.0% alcohol but he kept demanding it getting louder and louder. I went back to the car, retrieved my ID (31 years old), showed him, then he refused to sell to me saying I had an attitude. Luckily 3 other liquor stores are within a 100ft. Will never be back. Cashier barely spoke English, not sure he even knew what I was saying read more

Shay's Liquors - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Flanders, New Jersey

See all

I was looking for Andres Cold Duck. Not many places have it anymore, so I was real happy when I saw it on their website. I was almost gonna have it delivered, and it said it was in stock, but my husband said he would be able to pick it up. So this morning, 11/9/24, my husband went in. He told the man behind the counter what he was looking for. The man was not nice and insisted "no cold duck!" My husband told him that their website said that they have it. "NO Cold Duck!" So my husband went to look for himself and found Andres Cold Duck. So I don't know who owns this place, but it might be a good idea to do something about the person working behind the counter. He should not be doing customer service with an unknowledgeable and hostile attitude. I will not be shopping in this store again! read more

I am not sure this location is actually still Buy-Rite because when I was there today, the Buy-Rite sign was gone and there was a different name on the building. I don't normally shop here for liquor but it was convenient for other errands I was running today nearby. I wish I had paid attention to the new name on the building, because even the receipt for the wine I bought still says Buy-Rite. While the gentleman working behind the register was not friendly, didn't greet me or even say a single word, my issue is with a box of Bota Box Breeze Pinot Grigio that I bought. When I opened it at home hours later, I found the bottom of the box said the best by date was JUNE 2023!! Now, I am not one of those people who thinks products go bad immediately after their best by date, but I am extremely unhappy that the box of wine I bought TODAY, MARCH 2024, has a best by date from NINE MONTHS AGO! So folks please beware of what you buy from this store, and check the dates! Definitely not buying from here again, I will stick with Bottle King. read more

Shay's Liquors - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Flanders, New Jersey

I should have never spent my money here. Horrible customer service. Expect me to carry out multiple bottles of liquor in my hands

The cooler is very dirty and when I went to check out the clerk was on the phone the entire time holding a conversation in a foreign language. It was almost as if I was bothering or interrupting him. read more

Typical old school liqueur store. Sells craft beer, standards like coors, wine, sake, and liqueurs. Lots of boxes - not much for display - but this is made up for with price and selection. For a small store they have stocked right! Also great for all the byobs on the area. Lots of 4/6 packs and small bottles of wines. read more

Amazing place and newly renovated. They have a great selection of fine wines to choose from at low prices

I've stopped here numerous times and each time the person behind the counter is always talking on the phone. What's even worse is that he has it on speaker! I do not want to here your conversations (in your language). In fact, I don't want you to be on the phone! Very rude. Aside from that, no one offers to help me find anything in their shitty little store. Give your business to someone else. read more

Went in to pick up some wine and beer. Owners were in the middle of counting lottery tickets. More important to them than a customer. Said they would be with me in a minute which took way to long. I walked out and took my business elsewhere. Many other liquor stores in the area. One star is long for the location. read more