Same exact experience as the reviewer from May of 2018.
This awful little shack went down the list of dishonest car rental scams within a matter of 10 or so minutes. It was truly unbelievable how dishonest they were.
I was able to book a Fiat 500 (or similar) for a surprisingly low price. I thought it seemed too good to be true, but the reviews were pretty good.
Well, As soon as we got to the counter it was clear there would be trouble. The woman at the desk first went on and on about how we need to get their insurance. We had done our research beforehand, including confirming In writing with our insurance agent that our insurance would cover all damages but ONLY if we refuse the car rental company's insurance. She asked to see our insurance card and clicked at her keyboard for 15 seconds then tried to tell us that our insurance does not cover damages in Italy. As if she knows better about the fine print of our American auto insurance policy than our own insurance agent.
After we made it clear through over 5 minutes of back and forth that she wasn't going to talk us into the insurance, she went on to the bait and switch portion of the exchange in which she insisted they had no vehicle similar to a fiat 500, just a van, a BMW or an Audi. Of course as I suspected, these were considered upgrades and would significantly change the price of our rental...
I told her I wanted a "Fiat 500 or similar" as we had booked online, and she claimed with our luggage (one large and one small bag on wheels and two small backpacks) was too big for the vehicle. We explained we had looked at videos of a Fiat and we were certain we would fit our bags, even if the smaller one had to sit in the backseat. She claimed we are not allowed to put our bags on the backseat. When has any car company ever dictated how you use their vehicle to that extent as long as you get it back in the same condition? She was clearly lying to convince us to upgrade and pay at least 2x the price we had booked.
Mind you, we made an online reservation weeks in advance so they would have a car reserved for us. What is the meaning of the word "reservation" if they do not reserve a car for you on the date and time specified? We had taken a Metra and bus from central Rome to get the car we had reserved, and they knew we weren't going to leave without a car. She claimed since we had not paid in advance, the car was not guaranteed, but the Sixt website (As well as Priceline) literally did not give that option for this location.
An ethical business would have reached out to us in advance to warn us our reservation would not be ready (managing reservations was literally this woman's only job..) or at the very least apologetically insist on providing an upgrade at the price we had reserved online. (I was told by an Italian friend that they are pretty sure this is actually the law in Italy. Maybe they get around this by not allowing you to pay in advance?) This is in February, which is considered the off-season for travel to Italy, but they only have 3 cars!? Of course the entire lot behind the shack is full of cars including many smaller cars, but she claimed those were not their vehicles. We just wanted a small car from a company that wasn't going to play games with us.
So we went to Hertz and got one.
I don't buy the positive reviews here giving Giulia such adoring praise. I don't know who the reviewers are or what dream world they are living in, but my experience was as bad and as shady as possible.
What a bad representation of Italy. read more