Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Services - Spencer's

    Gift shops

    Spencer's Photos

    Recommended Reviews - Spencer's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Spencer's

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Gift Shops 4,580 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Memories of New York

    Memories of New York

    4.8(212 reviews)
    11.9 miFlatiron
    $$

    We went to many souvenir shops but this place was a clear stand out. Greeted warmly upon entering,…read morelots of items (there are a lot of things in a close space, so you to have to navigate a bit). Prices were comparable to other shops but had a good variety of items (shirts, magnets, pins,etc.). The man working also gave us two stickers with our purchase and was kind. Definitely would recommend!

    This souvenir shop was highly rated so I came here based on Yelp and Google reviews and honestly, I…read morewas kinda disappointed in the selection of clothing. It was the same stuff everyone else was selling, but like less variety. However, I can say their prices were a lot lower than other shops. For example, I bought a pair of pink I Love NY pajama pants for $19.99 in size small. It was the last one. I needed a medium but they didn't have one. I ended up getting it for myself and figured I'd find a size medium in another souvenir shop. Well, I did but the same pair of PJ pants was $29.99! So I can confirm the prices at this store is cheaper (at least for PJ pants). I also ended up getting a lighter for my brother in law last minute and all the lighters by the register were just meh. I bought a lame one anyways. And then just as we left the store, they had all these other cooler lighters in the window on display. Too bad none of those were actually out on the shelves.

    Photos
    Memories of New York
    Memories of New York
    Memories of New York - They have many I love NY officially licensed products. You name it.

    See all

    They have many I love NY officially licensed products. You name it.

    Dan’s Parents House - Tchotchkes & Then Some

    Dan’s Parents House

    4.9(11 reviews)
    2.5 miCity Island

    This store had an incredible amount of unique & unexpected nostalgic items. There wasn't really…read moreany strategic organization to the layout, which honestly made it feel like a treasure hunt. I felt like I was in a museum w/ antiques.There was so much to see that I could have easily spent hours just exploring everything. I really wish I had more time, b/c I didn't even get to rummage through the entire store. Every corner seemed to have something new, including drawers & drawers of items that looked like they dated all the way back to the 1960s & maybe even the 1950s or older. Overall, it felt like one of those places you could get lost in for hours & still keep discovering new things. My absolute fave was the 80's & 90's nostalgia (my era)! It took me back in time to when I was growing up! Prices were fairly decent.

    In terms of coolness the shop definitely gets five stars. Me and my kids had a blast here!…read more I don't know who came up with the idea for this place but it's completely awesome. As Gen X guy it was alot of fun to walk around here, total trip down memory lane. They have a little bit of everything toys, comics, music, you name it. The prices and the quality of the items are all over the place, but there's definitely potential to find something nice for your collection or home if you feel like taking the time to dig through everything. In the end I actually didn't wind up buying anything but it was great to stop by during my recent visit to City island. Five stars. Worth checking out!

    Photos
    Dan’s Parents House - Things

    Things

    Dan’s Parents House
    Dan’s Parents House - Hold It

    See all

    Hold It

    Uncharted

    Uncharted

    4.7(3 reviews)
    11.1 mi

    Wandered in to see what this place was all about and was pleasantly surprised! This shop has a…read morelittle bit of everything in an organized fashion. Perfect store for gifts. Will totally be back

    Went to the grand opening of the Uncharted store. The store is very spacious. It has a variety of…read moreclothes, kitchenware, jewelry, home and gifts to get. It is very much similar to The Paper Store, but more focused on gifts and clothes. There is also a small section of greeting cards if needed. They have two fitting rooms behind the jewelry area. You will need to grab an associate to let you in. The fitting room I went into was very nicely decorated and had a nice big cushioned bench and large mirror. There were plenty of hooks to hang clothes to try on. There is plenty of room to take in a stroller for the mom's shopping with little ones. The store is spaced very well that I had no issue pushing the stroller around. The prices of the merchandise varies depending what you buy. They have a lot of the big name merch like barefoot dreams, UGG and Pura to name a few. The staff all were very nice and welcoming. They were very attentive to greet each customer and able to tidy up areas where customers shopped to keep the store looking nice. Definitely would come back again since they have some cute stuff. For the grand opening (March 29 & 30, 2025) they have free gift cards for the first 100 customers each day and also provide a breakfast treat from Grace's Marketplace. There is also a 40% off coupon online that you can stack with your purchase.

    Photos
    Uncharted - Cute and spacious fitting room

    See all

    Cute and spacious fitting room

    Spencer's - giftshops - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...